Australia Australia - Leisl Smith, 23, Wallarah, NSW, 19 Aug 2012 *arrest in 2019, died during trial*

Inquest to start this week

1749446723515.webp


 

Alleged killer's verdict could remain sealed forever​

Rachel Jackson
Wed 11 June 2025 at 3:19 pm AEST

The only person who can say definitively whether Leisl Smith was murdered has been sworn to secrecy by Australian law.

Legal proceedings must be terminated if the accused person dies, according to laws of abatement.

The legislation means Ms Smith's family still do not know if she was murdered, almost 13 years after she went missing.

The lead detective in her case on Wednesday used the woman's inquest to call for law reform.

Her family deserved to know Justice Elizabeth Fullerton's sealed verdict, Detective Sergeant Michael Jones told the court.

"I believe in our investigation, I know in my heart what the result was going to be in trial," he told the NSW Coroner's Court.

"That decision would have helped (Ms Smith's family) to reconcile and move forward."

"It's something that I think about all the time," he said, before addressing Ms Smith's mother Sandi Harvey in the courtroom.

"I'm sorry I couldn't give you the ultimate answers that you really wanted ... you deserve them.

"I've done my best and I'm sorry."

Deputy State Coroner Harriet Grahame praised the quality of his investigation and said hope remained something could be found.

"It is very clear to me that you went above and beyond," she said.
 
What a sad conclusion, 13 years later.

Leisl still missing, presumed murdered
James Church dead, one day before the court verdict, never to be an official verdict in his murder trial
Craig Elkin (Leisl's ex) dead in a river in 2015, in non-suspicious circumstances

I am guessing that Harriet Grahame will, in her findings, conclude that 'someone known to Leisl' murdered her. Unless she is allowed to actually name James Church.

imo

 
What a sad conclusion, 13 years later.

Leisl still missing, presumed murdered
James Church dead, one day before the court verdict, never to be an official verdict in his murder trial
Craig Elkin (Leisl's ex) dead in a river in 2015, in non-suspicious circumstances

I am guessing that Harriet Grahame will, in her findings, conclude that 'someone known to Leisl' murdered her. Unless she is allowed to actually name James Church.

imo

The decision will be handed down toward the end of August. I will let you all know the result then
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
100
Guests online
629
Total visitors
729

Forum statistics

Threads
625,465
Messages
18,504,353
Members
240,808
Latest member
zoeep
Back
Top