Australia Australia - Marion Barter, 51, missing after trip to UK, June 1997 #9

Status
Not open for further replies.
  • #521
  • #522
I was looking at Ilona Kinczel's immigration file in the NAA,they have a better photo of her.

View digital copy
 
  • #523
Yes, when I heard RB describe Marion, blood drained from my head.

He kept repeating her whole look was 'old-fashioned'. It sounded exactly like what GE said in the podcast, "Marion was... imagine someone coming straight out of Little House on the Prairie". GE meant naive and sweet, not that she dressed in prairie/pioneer fashion.

We've previously been told that Marion loved fashion. And there are photos to prove it. Marion as a newlywed in capri pants! In 70s sunnies and high waisted jeans! On the stairs dressed in white (closer to the time she went missing) – she's spunky and not old fashioned at all!

So to me, it sounded like RB was ONLY describing the photos of Marion circulating online from the 80s. Particularly the one from her Missing Person's ad. They seem old fashioned now (and do look prairie/pioneer), but it was fashionable at the time. Yet he didn't know Marion in the 80s. So why refer to that 'old fashioned' 80s look only? It's so weird.

That's when I went numb... It seems like he DID know she was missing as he perfectly described the missing person poster, which was taken many years before she left Aus. Did he forget what Marion looked like? Are there that many victims? Did he know Marion at all? :eek::eek::eek:

Totally agree - it feels like he is trying to prove he knew Marion better than he actually did, which is odd because a straight forward criminal would try and distance themselves, where as this guy is trying to confuse the situation by adding in things that didn't happen, and over familiarizing himself with Marion, which would be a typical tactic from a scammer when trapped, just confuse your target and keep talking s**t, telling tall tales and talking their head off is their trade.
 
Last edited:
  • #524

yes there are so many of them!
pages and pages
 
  • #525
  • #526
  • #527
Chusan is the name of an island in China (and the ship is named after the island). Could it be the ship is a diversion from the real sentimental link to the island? Just spitballing here.
EDIT: Zhoushan is the Chinese name for the island and Chusan the (anglisised?) name. In this context Zhou means “leaf shaped Boat” and Shan means “mountain/hill”.


I also found this last night....
The Chusan Ball
"In honour of the Chusan Ball, a second was organized in 1972 for The Australian Museum Society".

Some great photos in it too!

Edit - old RB was in prison in 1972 though right @Peralta ? My brain is spinning!
 
Last edited:
  • #528
This articles says about $300,000 was siphoned from Marion's bank account. That's a major jackpot for a scammer. Not sure what their source is, but it's $100k more than I thought:

25 April 1997
Sells home for $165,000

Before 22 June 1997
$20k transferred to Barclays UK through CBA

Aug - Sept 1997
$5k withdrawn daily for 3.5 weeks at CBA Byron (and 3 days in middle at Burleigh Heads, Gold Coast), totalling between $85k to $120k

15 Oct 1997
$80,000 withdrawn from Colonial Ashmore (Marion's regular branch)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #529
I agree that Nymboida would be a good place to bury a body and that Marion could have met her fate 3-10 August.

Another theory I've had is if they arrived in Heathrow at the same time, his tactic is to ask the female to store her other bag with the documents in a shared locker at the airport to which both parties have the keys. Another idea is did they arrive at Amsterdam airport and share the locker there? then travel by ferry to the UK then hire a car as he did with JO? So did RB make up the excuse that he had to return to Australia urgently or did he lie and say he was in a hospital somewhere and Marion phoned the hospital and he wasn't there? My point is where was Marion's other case? Did RB take it home with him? Or was it left for Marion to take home? Did she actually know that RB returned home to Australia? How did they get Marion's passport from her if an impersonator used it? Did RB steal her passport and get the photo changed on Marion's passport or get a faked one?

If the point of the trip home was just for Marion get money to take back to Europe, why did both of them need to go home and waste money on a return trip? Did Marion actually know where RB was?

If the second transfer was done electronically, why wasn't the first amount done the same way?

I have so many questions.
Good questions, and I guess we'll never know some of the answers. Of course RB always intended to fly home but Marion did not, which is why she took so much luggage. I wouldn't be surprised to learn that one of her cases, containing only clothes, ended up as unclaimed baggage. Marion would have carried all valuables and documents with her. Did Marion know RB returned on 31st July? I think she did; to believe otherwise would suggest his plan was murder all along and that just doesn't seem to fit. He is a con-man, a forger, a swindler, a man who relies solely on what he believes, is his superior ability to out-wit his victims, not a cold-blooded murderer. The EFT transaction would explain the many questions asked to DdH and RB about bank accounts in the UK and if they were closed when they left in 1986 but who made that EFT transaction is ??. Perhaps, if it wasn't Marion, it presented too much risk to continue that route so cash withdrawals was the only other option. If it was Marion, why wait so long after she returned to do it? As you say ... so many questions.
 
  • #530
  • #531
This is really interesting. When it refers to 'employees' stealing, who do they mean? That employees steal, generally speaking? Or employees of a certain sector such as banking or accounting maybe?

Because I did some work for a bank once, and couldn't believe how much employees stole! And yes, many of the stealing was motivated by out-of-control gambling. Just a little bit each day being shifted around accounts and ledgers, but it all added up to astronomical amounts! I just had now idea! And it was often bank managers!

Yes, I know, this experience is also the reason I am suspicious about Marion's banks :p
 
  • #532
  • #533
Phew. Finally got the the end of catch ups. Interesting reading all the theories.
I think I need a RB free afternoon now:cool:
 
  • #534
@Estelle

I'm using your timeline here for reference (thanks to everyone who puts these timelines together!!) Because I'm still trying to get my head around RB & DdeH, when they were married & where (I can't remember if there are records for these events - I thought I did see someone post them) Their relationship timeline is so off to me! Could he of been married at the same time to two different women, under different names?

This is the timeline:

1970-02-15
Ilona left Australia on UT2506 from Sydney to Belgium?

1970-02-15 Willy Wouters departed Australia without a re-entry visa on UT2506 to Belgium, status Divorced (2)

More convictions in Belgium and France, for fraud, attempted fraud, breach of trust, impersonation. Various short prison sentences in France, the longest 4 years, most to be served concurrently.

1970 Ilona married in Budapest Hungary to MJR (Reid?)

1971 Ilona first child born (daughter ER)

1971-6-23 WW.Arrested Rouen, Discharged 21/5/1974

1971-12-09 Willy Wouters Rouen France, sentenced to 4 years prison for fraud, forgery, confidence tricks, giving false identity

1972-01-11 WW sentenced to one month for unsecured cheques in absentia in France.

1972-11-16 Willy Wouters Lille France, 1 years prison (concurrent with previous sentence)

1973-01-23 Willy Waitress Fraud 1 years prison (concurrent with previous sentences)

1973 Ilona second child born (son CR)

1974-01 Willy Wouters App Dousai "checks without cover" 1 years prison

1974-05-21 Willy Wouters discharged from prison. He may have then joined Ilona in Hungary but where he was is unaccounted for.

1976?? Willy Wouters must have returned to Australia but no records can be found say immigration dept. Did he actually return with or before Ilona in 1976 as M J Reid? Did they just separate or divorce or were never really married?


CONTINUED >>>

1977 We know they (he & DdeH) are listed in census docs living in 1/303 Old South West Road, Bondi and he has listed himself as an artist and D as a secretary. (Note D name is spelt here with 1 'N')

and then in

1980 Are listed in living in Military Road, he's listed as a photographer and DdeH is listed as hd = (is this the abbreviation for hand?)

My question and mind keep circling around: How & when did he meet DdeH?! How does she fit in?

I think he really also could be MJ Reid.

IMO In brief, RB met DdH in 1975 but it could have been 1974 as there is no record of his returning to Australia.

Sorry about the length of this but I have updated it and will put my comments in bold to explain how I understand this:

This is the timeline with my interpretations:

WW could not have met DdH on the Chusan in early 1970 (or in 1971) here as he was in Sydney with Ilona who gave birth to their first child in January, 1970. "You cannot be in two places at once" said Casselden.

1970-01 Ilona gives birth to Evelyn Wouters who later became Evelyn Reid

1970-02-15
Ilona left Australia on UT2506 from Sydney to Belgium?
1970-02-15 Willy Wouters departed Australia without a re-entry visa on UT2506 to Belgium, status Divorced (2)

Note that WW and IW left on the same flight for Belgium even though he states he is divorced. How could they get divorced so quickly if they only married in 1968? Why leave on the same flight as the wife you are divorced from? IMO WW states this as he intends to get rid of the WW name while he is in Europe as WW has a criminal record attached to it which will deny him of re-entry and come back in another name. IMO he faked the first Marriage Certificate to Ilona to get Australian residency then once they got to Europe, maybe Ilona insisted they get married as they were now parents and before they did, he pretended he lost his passport and got another one in the name of Michael J Reid - a name which would be more acceptable in Australia.

More convictions in Belgium and France, for fraud, attempted fraud, breach of trust, impersonation. Various short prison sentences in France, the longest 4 years, most to be served concurrently.

1970 Ilona married in Budapest Hungary to MJR (Reid?)

How could Ilona who has a newborn baby meet and marry someone with an English sounding name the same year that she arrived in Europe to stay with her parents because there was not enough time to get a divorce? IMO WW changed his name to Michael J Reid when he married Ilona in 1970 overseas so that Australian govt would not know when he returned.

1971 Ilona first child born (daughter ER) should be Jan 1970

This is incorrect. Daughter was born in 1970. I have corrected this since as Casselden brought this up at inquest.

RB goes to prison 1971 in France as WW.

1971-6-23 WW.Arrested Rouen, Discharged 21/5/1974
1971-12-09 Willy Wouters Rouen France, sentenced to 4 years prison for fraud, forgery, confidence tricks, giving false identity
1972-01-11 WW sentenced to one month for unsecured cheques in absentia in France.
1972-11-16 Willy Wouters Lille France, 1 years prison (concurrent with previous sentence)
1973-01-23 Willy Waitress Fraud 1 years prison (concurrent with previous sentences)

I think there is enough time here for Michal J Reid (WW) and Ilona to conceive their second child?

1973 Ilona second child born (son C Reid) - exact date of his birth is unknown

1974-01 Willy Wouters App Dousai "checks without cover" 1 years prison
1974-05-21 Willy Wouters discharged from prison. He may have then joined Ilona again in Belgium after leaving prison but where he was, is unaccounted for.
I predict that Ilona has been living with her parents in Belgium (not Hungary) while WW has been in prison. Not sure if she ever knew he went to prison. Maybe he concocted a story or that led to their separation as she returned to Australia alone with her two children and went to live in Melbourne. No record to say he and Ilona ever divorced and she died of a heart attack (not in a car crash as RB claimed) in Melbourne.

Between 1974 and 1975 IMO, Willy Wouters using a passport in the name of Michael J Reid must have returned to Australia but no records can be found say immigration dept (this file is not public) as they were unable to link the name WW to Michael J Reid IMO.
Did MJR enter Australia again on his WW Australian passport changed to the name of MJReid so he could enter easily as he had Australian residency on that attached or did MJR get a fake Belgian passport in the name of M J Reid in which case, he would have entered on a Holiday Visa for three months? If he arrived on a Holiday visa, he could not officially work so IMO he could have worked for cash in 1975 at the cafe owned by DdH parents as DdH said he worked for her parents there. IMO this is where they first met.He also lived with her parents at Vaucluse. Did he overstay his Holiday visa or had he used a faked Australian passport and arrived earlier in 1974?

If RB did not get a divorce from Ilona, he could have been married to Ilona and DdH at the same time for one year and thought he could get away with it by changing names. RB married DdH in 1976. Ilona died in 1977-07-13. Bigamy? Or were none of Ilona and RB's marriages registered officially? Perhaps the one in Belgium was to Michael J Reid.

CONTINUED >>>

1977 We know they (he & DdeH) are listed in census docs living in 1/303 Old South West Road, Bondi and he has listed himself as an artist and D as a secretary. (Note D name is spelt here with 1 'N') He told her he was a Wedding Photographer

and then in

1980 Are listed in living in Military Road, he's listed as a photographer and DdeH is listed as hd = (is this the abbreviation for hand?) Home Duties

My question and mind keep circling around: How & when did he meet DdeH?! How does she fit in?

I think he really also could be MJ Reid.[/QUOTE]

12 Feb 1976 – WW changes name to FDdH
IMO This is because his M J Reid name is a fake, he has not been divorced from Ilona and WW has a criminal record so he claims he lost his passport.

20 Feb 1976 – FDdH marries DW

23 Feb 1976 – FDdH applies for Aus citizenship

25 Mar 1976 – FDdH Aus citizenship granted and AU passport issued

28 July 1976 – FDdH and DdH depart Aus. DdH claims in the next few years they lived in Belgium,
3 years in Luxembourg, a few months in Bordeaux, France, back to Belgium, UK for 3 years then Aus

1977 We know they (he & DdeH) are listed in census docs living in 1/303 Old South West Road, Bondi and he has listed himself as an artist and D as a secretary. (Note D name is spelt here with 1 'N') He told her he was a Wedding Photographer

Oct 76 - Feb 77 – FDdH arrested in Luxembourg as Roger Lauzoney from Morocco born 1945

1977-07-13 Ilona died, age 31yo, St Kilda, Victoria of Myocardial ischaemia (heart), The Coroner at Melbourne Mr H.W. Pascoe ordered burial of the body without inquest. What happened to her two children? Was WW/MJR the father?

13 Aug 1978 – FDdH and DdH return to Aus

2 Apr 1979 – FDdH DdH son born in Sydney

1980 Are listed in living in Military Road, he's listed as a photographer and DdeH is listed as hd = (is this the abbreviation for hand?) Home Duties

6 Feb 1980 – FDdH departs Aus

23 Apr 1980 – DdH and son depart Aus

21 Jan 1980 – DdH and son return to Aus

2 Apr 1981 – FDdH issued Aus passport issued Germany

17 Apr 1981 – FDdH DW daughter born in Luxembourg

18 Nov 1981 – FDdH returns to Aus

4 Dec 1981 – FDdH departs Aus, no apparent re-entry into Aus for 6 years
 
  • #535
  • #536
Episode 24 of The Inquest Part 5 now seems very interesting in light of the new developments. This was Bronwen referring back to May 1997 I believe, at 8.09 - "She remembered Marion being very upset about resigning from TSS." "When we were up at dad's birthday we went for a walk on the beach and she was terribly, terribly upset. She told me she'd been betrayed at that school. She didn't tell me any details. I did ask her but she wouldn't tell me. She just was terribly upset. She was crying. And it left her with no option but to tender her resignation." There was never any evidence from the school indicating any betrayal or incident ... food for thought!

I am sure RB made the complaints to the school in another name (or DdH did) to ruin Marion's reputation and motivate her to start a fresh life with him in Luxembourg by resigning and selling her house - even changing her name. This is what he did with Ginette as well.
 
  • #537
There's a Diane Walker in Woonona in 1972. Could she have been visiting her family uncle and auntie in Vaucluse in early 70's

Interesting you say this because I found a passenger card with that address for a Diane Walker... but the birth dates don't match up..
Diane walker.jpg
 
Last edited:
  • #538
My notes from the inquest, there is a name change from WW to FDH on 12Feb1976, 8 days before marriage to DDH on 20Feb1976.

Yes I have added to the timeline since and added my interpretations of it as well just now.
 
  • #539
I was looking at Ilona Kinczel's immigration file in the NAA,they have a better photo of her.

View digital copy
Great find F.Knab, absolutely fascinating, just looking through it now .... wait, it looks like two different people, having trouble reconciling the other photo of IK with this one of IK. H'mm. What do you think?
 
  • #540
Status
Not open for further replies.

Staff online

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
95
Guests online
1,237
Total visitors
1,332

Forum statistics

Threads
632,389
Messages
18,625,618
Members
243,132
Latest member
Welshsleuth
Back
Top