Canada- Christopher Smith, 22, fatally stabbed, Portage Bridge between Gatineau & Ottawa, Ont., 12 April, '96, Dna, arrest- Lawrence Diehl, 73, 2024.

You could be right, but IMO the wording is ambiguous and neither article clarifies whether he called for himself or for Christopher. I think we'll have to wait to see if there is some clarification.
However, we do know that an ambulance eventually arrived at the bridge where Christopher Smith was, but no ambulance was said to have arrived at the payphone the police traced the call to and found the suspect's blood in.
 
I won't make any definitive statements on my theory, but I will summarize what I know that led me to that theory:

-A 40ish guy from another city goes to a location that is in a notorious gay pickup area and is also a place where young delinquent men have been known to go to beat, kill and rob gays.

-The guy finds himself in a confrontation of an unknown nature with two young men on the bridge. The conflict escalates until the guy and one of the young men suffer knife wounds.

-The guy runs away bleeding and calls for an ambulance to save the young man he stabbed on the bridge.

-The guy then disappears back to his life in British Columbia for 30 years until he is exposed by DNA.
Does that mean that the suspect might have initially been a victim?
 
That's an interesting possibility. If the suspect, from Vancouver, was more comfortable exploring his sexuality in another city, and was then victimized by two younger men - maybe it's just as well that this is made public through the courts.
 
That's an interesting possibility. If the suspect, from Vancouver, was more comfortable exploring his sexuality in another city, and was then victimized by two younger men - maybe it's just as well that this is made public through the courts.
I am not going to dox the suspect, but if you google a diminutive of his first name plus his surname and Vancouver, you find info on a man of the same age who seems to have had a respectable professional career and also involvement in a youth-oriented organization. Plenty of reasons not to want that sort of sexual activity exposed.

Of course, Diehl might have simply been crossing the bridge to get to the nightlife in Quebec instead of looking for a gay hookup.

There was also a murder in that location in 1989 of a Chateau Laurier waiter who was not gay, but was mistaken for a homosexual by a gang of youths who then threw him off the bridge to drown.
 
Last edited:
I am not going to dox the suspect, but if you google a diminutive of his first name plus his surname and Vancouver, you find info on a man of the same age who seems to have had a respectable professional career and also involvement in a youth-oriented organization. Plenty of reasons not to want that sort of sexual activity exposed.

Of course, Diehl might have simply been crossing the bridge to get to the nightlife in Quebec instead of looking for a gay hookup.

There was also a murder in that location in 1989 of a Chateau Laurier waiter who was not gay, but was mistaken for a homosexual by a gang of youths who then threw him off the bridge to drown.
The culture towards homosexuality (not sure whether that is the correct word today) in the 1990s was quite different. There were no rights, and no one to argue for rights. I'm looking forward to hearing facts about what happened that night.
 
I am not going to dox the suspect, but if you google a diminutive of his first name plus his surname and Vancouver, you find info on a man of the same age who seems to have had a respectable professional career and also involvement in a youth-oriented organization. Plenty of reasons not to want that sort of sexual activity exposed.
I would add, if I've found the same person, they are the correct age, but would never be expected to be associated with this crime. So, maybe it's not him...not sure how media will confirm or deny. I guess someone in the know would have to make a statement, eg 'that's someone else'.

JMO
 
I would add, that person is the correct age, but would never be expected to be associated with this crime. So, maybe it's not him...not sure how media will confirm or deny. I guess someone in the know would have to make a statement, eg 'that's someone else'.

JMO
Sometimes, crime associates itself with someone, rather than that person associating themself with crime, if you get my drift.
 
Sometimes, crime associates itself with someone, rather than that person associating themself with crime, if you get my drift.
I agree. I'm thinking more about the years it often takes before a trial. The person is likely out on bail already, and it might turn out no one will officially say anything until the trial.

It requires endless patience to follow Canadian cases, we often have nothing to speculate about, the way people do with American ones.

JMO
 
I agree. I'm thinking more about the years it often takes before a trial. The person is likely out on bail already, and it might turn out no one will officially say anything until the trial.

It requires endless patience to follow Canadian cases, we often have nothing to speculate about, the way people do with American ones.

JMO
If this case plays out the way I think it will, it will probably get a lot of publicity and generate controversy.
 
Yes, I can see that.

I wonder about the cousin/witness, what was/is his story? There's less often direct witnesses in these cold cases.

JMO
I don't recall much about the cousin except I think he was a teenager at the time and that he flagged down passing cars after his cousin was stabbed. I wish I had a Newspapers.Com membership. I remember this case got a lot of coverage back in 1996 in the Ottawa Citizen.
 
It would be interesting to read Christopher'cousin' deposition with the Police at the time of the crime.
Wonder if they found the knife.
I guess if they went on looking fo the perpertrator for that long they knew Christopher was the victim and the fact the perpertrator disappeared without making a claim is a red flag.
Wonder how Diehl' DNA landed in the data bank ?
IMO.
 
Last edited:
It would be interesting to read Christopher'cousin' deposition with the Police at the time of the crime.
Wonder if they found the knife.
I guess if they went on looking fo the perpertrator for that long they knew Christopher was the victim and the fact the perpertrator disapeard without making a claim is a red flag.
Wonder how Diehl' DNA landed in the data bank ?
IMO.
There is a recording of the 911 call as well. I don't know about the knife. I would imagine there were two knives, as both Smith and Diehl were stabbed or cut. I'm guessing that Smith's knife was still there when cops arrived and Diehl probably took his knife away and disposed of it later.

Due to social attitudes at the time, it's understandable why the suspect would not wish to contact authorities about his involvement in a stabbing at a gay pickup site, even if there were possible extenuating circumstances.

I think LEOs used DNA ancestry services to match relatives of Diehl to the phone booth blood, and then they narrowed it down to him through various criteria..
 
Wonder how Diehl' DNA landed in the data bank ?
IMO.
These days, it's usually distant relatives who submit their DNA into genealogy sites. So a descendent of one's great-great-grandmother and a grandchild of your grandfather's 4th cousin once removed come up as having some of the same DNA as was found at the crime scene.

Genealogy used to be a quaint pastime for retired people wanting to trace their ancestors back to some village in Europe (or maybe, if lucky, a Duke). But now it's about finding criminals by tracking through old records of births and deaths, census, etc, in huge extended families, to find a particular person today.

JMO
 
Just to add, anyone who thought they'd gotten away with a killing in 1996, has probably been aware for several years that they could be arrested at any moment. At least since 2017 when the Golden State killer was nabbed. In Vancouver, the mystery of the boys killed decades ago in Stanley Park was solved 3 years ago with genetic genealogy.

Now it's: you may have run, but you can no longer hide.

JMO
 
I would add, if I've found the same person, they are the correct age, but would never be expected to be associated with this crime. So, maybe it's not him...not sure how media will confirm or deny. I guess someone in the know would have to make a statement, eg 'that's someone else'.

JMO
OK. By the photographic evidence, it is safe to say now that the man I found online actually is the suspect in the crime. This video confirms his identity.

The video says the suspect has a wife, which would be another strong reason he would have had to choose not to turn himself in to authorities regarding a killing with homosexual overtones.
 

Attachments

  • suspect.png
    suspect.png
    707.1 KB · Views: 21
Last edited:
OK. By the photographic evidence, it is safe to say now that the man I found online actually is the suspect in the crime. This video confirms his identity.

The video says the suspect has a wife, which would be another strong reason he would have had to choose not to turn himself in to authorities regarding a killing with homosexual overtones.
"I wouldn’t consider him the most friendly neighbour to say the least"...hmmm.

ETA: As well, any kind of arrest around violence and stabbing someone, I think would sink a career in sport.

JMO
 
Last edited:
"I wouldn’t consider him the most friendly neighbour to say the least"...hmmm.
That doesn't necessarily mean he's another Gilgo Beach Murderer or EARONS, though. Maybe they just had a beef over some neighborly issue, or the suspect just wanted privacy. My neighbours would probably say the same thing about me, as I just grunt and nod at them whenever I see them.

Based on the details we now have about the suspect's life, (Government Meteorologist, Soccer Hall of Famer, millionaire) I am even more convinced that this was a once-in-a-lifetime horrible event that arose from him making stupid decisions and being in the wrong place at the wrong time with the wrong people.
 
I have access to old newspapers through my library membership (on Proquest). I'm cutting and pasting, hence wonky formatting

Police probe tips in fatal Portage Bridge stabbing: [FINAL Edition]​

The Ottawa Citizen

; Ottawa, Ont.. 17 Apr 1996: C.6

....investigators released a brief recording of a 911 call made early Friday morning, shortly after Smith, 23, was fatally stabbed on the Portage Bridge. So far the anonymous caller is the prime suspect in the slaying....

....On the tape, the caller says only: ``Yes, an ambulance, please. There's been an attack on the Pont du Portage Bridge.''....​

------‐----‐----------‐--------------------------------------------

Police believe bridge stabbing death result of fight: [FINAL Edition]​

The Ottawa Citizen
; Ottawa, Ont.. 08 June 1996: C.1.

....Ottawa-Carleton police say Christopher Smith started a fight that led to his death on the Portage Bridge in April....
it [is] our understanding that whatever took place on the bridge that night was initiated by the victim, Christopher Smith,'' Wisker said Friday night.....

....Smith, 23, was walking back to Ottawa with his cousin in the early hours of April 12 before the fight began. He died of stab wounds at the scene....

....Police still hope the man Smith was fighting with will come forward to tell his side of what happened....

....About 30 minutes after the stabbing, an unidentified caller placed a 911 call from a telephone booth on Gloucester Street....

‐------
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
185
Guests online
540
Total visitors
725

Forum statistics

Threads
625,593
Messages
18,506,777
Members
240,819
Latest member
Berloni75
Back
Top