Casey Anthony attorney: Judge Perry has 'clear bias'

[strawberry]

I must admit when I first read the order, the office part struck me...I was confused about him saying they used a conference room that she said was her office. But then I gave him the benefit of the doubt that he meant it was in the building where she said her office was. FYI here is Yuri's notes:

http://www.docstoc.com/docs/5404318/Casey-Anthony-Investigative-report-July-Aug

Universal starts page 13

 

[strawberry]

I had those same thoughts when I read the Order for the first time. I worried that the inaccuracy about the conference room, in particular, might be a problem. I realize it is a technicality, but doesn't it have to be corrected? I'm not suggesting that JBP is wrong in his overall ruling -- not at all. I'd hate to see something bad happen because of a technicality. There is no way they need a new hearing - Judge Perry got the relevant facts perfectly straight.

BBM Exactly, he could just rewatch it or read the transcript. Ridiculous. Can you imagine going through that again?

 

[lowens1975]

And how do we know that Casey did not literally answer the door that evening and say "come on in!"? (I know, I know. No one has ever testified to that.) But still, it could have happened that way.

I'm sure something could be said for the fact that she may have not been physically staying at her parents home, but she was probably still getting mail there, most, if not all, of her and Caylee's clothes, shoes, etc., were still in their respective closets, so for all intense purposes, that was still her primary residence. All she had to do was open her mouth and ask the officer's to leave. Or go to her room or bathroom and close the door. There was a hundred of ways she could have not cooperated and given the officers a 'clue' that she didn't want to talk with them. Instead she wrote statements and went on walks with them.

I don't think it was the 6' 3" burly armed police officers that was intimidating her... I think it was her mother. No telling how many time Casey was non-verbally threatened with just a look or by her being in close proximity of her mother.

 

[whiteangora]

I must admit when I first read the order, the office part struck me...I was confused about him saying they used a conference room that she said was her office. But then I gave him the benefit of the doubt that he meant it was in the building where she said her office was. FYI here is Yuri's notes:

http://www.docstoc.com/docs/5404318/Casey-Anthony-Investigative-report-July-Aug

Universal starts page 13

Thank you, and also ty to my2sense for noticing what Mason is calling inaccuracies.
I would think that all Judge Perry needs to do is have his order rewritten and that should be the end of it.
This shows how desperate the defense is, having to pour over each word and phrase looking for something to complain about. As far as the biased accusation, I think JP will have a chuckle when he reads it.

 

[strawberry]

Thank you, and also ty to my2sense for noticing what Mason is calling inaccuracies.
I would think that all Judge Perry needs to do is have his order rewritten and that should be the end of it.
This shows how desperate the defense is, having to pour over each word and phrase looking for something to complain about. As far as the biased accusation, I think JP will have a chuckle when he reads it.

I was thinking that too. Just amend the order. And I was also thinking "Yoo hoo, DT! Your Desperation is Showing!!"

 

[Aedrys]

What kills me is that they put on a shoddy attempt at getting this thrown out, and then it's HHJP's nonexistent bias at fault? You bring crap to the table, all you're going to get is crap. What nonsense this motion is. Had they done a better job of arguing, they might have gotten something thrown out. Instead, they put on a circus and blame it on HHJP when they don't get what they want. Logic is definitely NOT the DT's strong point at all.

 

[strawberry]

Let's see:

Yuri wouldn't let ICA finish.
They only gave ICA not even 24 hours before the "put her there" in jail
The State is trying to railroad ICA
There was NO ODOR
Someone else put a body in the trunk in the tow yard
HHJS is a self-aggrandizing media hound
They only looked at ICA from day one
They tried to get her to take a plea for something she Did Not Do
They should have done an Amber Alert
YM dared to go on vacation during the case
HHJP is biased
Dr. Vass has a financial interest (but the Angel of Death didn't with her book)

And that is just off the top of my head. ANd on and on and on. It's a vast conspiracy.

 

[MissJames]

AF strikes me as a very good attorney.I would love to know what she is thinking about this DT.

 

[LCoastMom]

Let's see:

Yuri wouldn't let ICA finish.
They only gave ICA not even 24 hours before the "put her there" in jail
The State is trying to railroad ICA
There was NO ODOR
Someone else put a body in the trunk in the tow yard
HHJS is a self-aggrandizing media hound
They only looked at ICA from day one
They tried to get her to take a plea for something she Did Not Do
They should have done an Amber Alert
YM dared to go on vacation during the case
HHJP is biased
Dr. Vass has a financial interest (but the Angel of Death didn't with her book)

And that is just off the top of my head. ANd on and on and on. It's a vast conspiracy.

One thing I wish Yuri could have told them (as they were putting this out there) - KC was obviously enjoying her time trying to charm these men! The photo is evidence of that, as is her primping and preening.

Mother of a missing child? Not! She acted like her biggest trouble was her misplaced phone! You know the one that was missing from her office, the one that had all her outcry witnesses contact information! BLAH! This whole debacle is sickening!

 

[strawberry]

AF strikes me as a very good attorney.I would love to know what she is thinking about this DT.

I like her too. She exactly resembles a nun from my church, especially when she wears that blue suit. She seems to have a good, pofessional head on her shoulders.

 

[LambChop]

Let's see:

Yuri wouldn't let ICA finish.
They only gave ICA not even 24 hours before the "put her there" in jail
The State is trying to railroad ICA
There was NO ODOR
Someone else put a body in the trunk in the tow yard
HHJS is a self-aggrandizing media hound
They only looked at ICA from day one
They tried to get her to take a plea for something she Did Not Do
They should have done an Amber Alert
YM dared to go on vacation during the case
HHJP is biased
Dr. Vass has a financial interest (but the Angel of Death didn't with her book)And that is just off the top of my head. ANd on and on and on. It's a vast conspiracy.

And the thought came into my head when JB brought this up, "What in the world were you thinking of when you brokered the picture deal for your client? And who was the primary beneficiary of that money????" I think the average American citizen understands how science contributes to everyone as a whole and it does not come cheap. Now if JB could prove that the State promised to give the good doctor bill bucks for his testimony that would interest me. For what the doctor was paid to endure JB's questioning yesterday, it was not enough. jmo

 

[21merc7]

AF strikes me as a very good attorney.I would love to know what she is thinking about this DT.

Haha, the truth, but she can never say it out loud! :crazy:

 

[LambChop]

I like her too. She exactly resembles a nun from my church, especially when she wears that blue suit. She seems to have a good, pofessional head on her shoulders.

You know, she does. I like her. She is very professional and appears to be concerned with seeing KC gets a fair trial but also is not that emotionally involved so she is able to make clear decisions. JB is just dangerously emotionally involved with his client. He is unable to think clearly and he is taking everything that is said too personally. While I understand you do get to know your client on a personal level his is way over and is causing him to over react personally when he should be concerned with legal issues and address them not "you're attacking my girl" attitude. It's just what I see. jmo

 

[hannahsnana]

I'm sure something could be said for the fact that she may have not been physically staying at her parents home, but she was probably still getting mail there, most, if not all, of her and Caylee's clothes, shoes, etc., were still in their respective closets, so for all intense purposes, that was still her primary residence. All she had to do was open her mouth and ask the officer's to leave. Or go to her room or bathroom and close the door. There was a hundred of ways she could have not cooperated and given the officers a 'clue' that she didn't want to talk with them. Instead she wrote statements and went on walks with them.

I don't think it was the 6' 3" burly armed police officers that was intimidating her... I think it was her mother. No telling how many time Casey was non-verbally threatened with just a look or by her being in close proximity of her mother.

Plus the fact that we have seen documents in the past that this was certainly not the first time that cops had been called to the Anthony house. I wish one of our links people could find that and put it up. In other words, this was not the Anthonys' first rodeo with LE, so Casey wasn't unduly afraid of these 'big burly men' IMO.

 

[jharres]

I like her too. She exactly resembles a nun from my church, especially when she wears that blue suit. She seems to have a good, pofessional head on her shoulders.

I think I commented on this in the afternoon hearing thread as well, but it was interesting to note the change in HHJPs demeanor when addressing/discussing things with Baez vs. Finnel. To me it spoke volumes against any kind of bias for the state. The judge isn't biased against the DT (as evidenced by his dealing with Finnel), he has a problem with Baez's antics and behavior in his court room.

Maybe OT, but, I've wondered many times why the judge doesn't put a stop to it, or be a bit more forceful with Baez and I really think he is being lenient in order to give him enough rope to hang himself. He's not stupid and Baez certainly isn't getting one up on HHJP, rather, he is digging himself a hole and HHJP is letting him do it. I kinda see it like tough love with your kids, sometimes I let them dig themselves a nice deep hole, because the experience will teach them more than any of my lecturing ever will.

 

[strawberry]

I think I commented on this in the afternoon hearing thread as well, but it was interesting to note the change in HHJPs demeanor when addressing/discussing things with Baez vs. Finnel. To me it spoke volumes against any kind of bias for the state. The judge isn't biased against the DT (as evidenced by his dealing with Finnel), he has a problem with Baez's antics and behavior in his court room.

Maybe OT, but, I've wondered many times why the judge doesn't put a stop to it, or be a bit more forceful with Baez and I really think he is being lenient in order to give him enough rope to hang himself. He's not stupid and Baez certainly isn't getting one up on HHJP, rather, he is digging himself a hole and HHJP is letting him do it. I kinda see it like tough love with your kids, sometimes I let them dig themselves a nice deep hole, because the experience will teach them more than any of my lecturing ever will.

I also wonder why the State doesn't object more with "asked and answered" when he repeats himself. Probably for the same reason...give him the rope.

 

[LiveLaughLuv]

Let's see:

Yuri wouldn't let ICA finish.
They only gave ICA not even 24 hours before the "put her there" in jail
The State is trying to railroad ICA
There was NO ODOR
Someone else put a body in the trunk in the tow yard
HHJS is a self-aggrandizing media hound
They only looked at ICA from day one
They tried to get her to take a plea for something she Did Not Do
They should have done an Amber Alert
YM dared to go on vacation during the case
HHJP is biased
Dr. Vass has a financial interest (but the Angel of Death didn't with her book)

And that is just off the top of my head. ANd on and on and on. It's a vast conspiracy.

Because this is all they've got..huge conspiracy to blame the mother of an allegedly missing child who gave not one piece of credible information on the whereabouts of Caylee Marie...Hypocrits is what I see...you do as I say and not as I do...as Baez has shown with the sale of photos/videos of Caylee Marie...

Dr. Vass is in it for profit??

The canine officer gave a false positive? Since the officer was leading the K9 officer to falsely show he smelt a decomposing body...all huge conspiracy surrounding ICA...I believe if the jury is able to get all the information on how this case unfolded from an allegedly missing child to a deceased child, they will see for themselves who is reponsible for Caylee's demise. It sits on the prosecution to prove this and I do beleive they can and will...beyond a shadow of a doubt...she will be found guilty..JMHO

Her detached demeanor in court until she hears something that sparks an interest will not go over well with a jury. If Baez continues his accusatory tones, he condescending words to these fine officials who did their very best to get Caylee's remains in tact, will be seen for what it is..

As Judge Judy would say, if it doesn't make sense, it's not true...You tell the truth once you never have to remember what you've stated..

Baez should take a hint from Judge Milian...if ICA's tongue came notorized she still wouldn't believe...I feel he's too emotionally involved with ICA to see the forest thru the trees....JMHO

Justice for Caylee

 

[watergirl]

Nine pages of spin and desperation...and nary a "thwart" to be found. Meh.

:violin:

 

[denjet]

I don't think the Judge will be at all "insulted" by Mason having written and filed this motion. I would think he expected it.

As for Mason, he better get a whole lot better in HIS research. Because I'd suspect HHJP not only expected this very motion, he likely could guess what arguements it would contain, and already has researched the case law to refute those arguements.

I don't think he'll be insulted but I do think the part insinuating bias is going to raise his BP a tad ... it's one thing to disagree with a judge's rulings but to accuse him of bias in making his decision is, I would think, a big no-no unless you can back it up ... it comes across as a veiled threat
Judge Perry has already warned Mason and Baez about using the threat of appeal continuously ... (paraphrasing) Judge Perry said he doesn't want to try this case more than once, but he WILL if need be ...
As I see it, it's the second attack on Judge Perry ... the first one was about having to turn over witness reports and sanctions against Baez ...
Mason most definitely knows better ... he's just a bully ... JMO

 

[cindysnow3]

Since it's too late to edit, I need to clarify that I am in no way endorsing Mason's motion. I was just trying to see what he was claiming to be "inaccuracies". If anyone has been inaccurate about the chain of events in this case it is Cheney Mason. moo

Also wanted to bounce this off yours.. Mason's excuse for that is... "I only just came on this case.....( insert however many months )" He hasn't a clue even how long he's been on the case. I feel he needs to get better informed before trial.