That's correct otto---one of the fastest ways to break TOS is to sleuth an innocent bystander.
As for the mental illness debate. We do have vetted and professional posters here that work in the psychiatric field.
I do not. However, my two cents is this: We can speculate all day what diagnosis we think this young man may have all day. But at the end of the day it's speculation because we do not have access to his complete history and we do not have access to speak with him directly and unless we are qualified professionals then it's just a guessing game. (I am referring
only to Personality disorders or schizophrenia subtypes which I am not suggesting he has but he is at the age when those symptoms first manifest...however, as I say I'm not stating he has that or a subtype).
Here's a point I would like to make this is just a personal observation and it is subjective to just me having the hobby of "crimes".
That point is: He does not have suffer from Antisocial Personality Disorder in order to have commited this murder or consequent dismemberment. He just doesn't.
Many of the Axis II personality disorders have symptoms that overlap and unless a psychiatrist eval's him completely (not just looking at the crime commited) it's impossible for us to know if he suffers from one or more or any at all.
I am by no means qualified as I said however, subjective experience (I am the daughter of a now deceased man that was diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia and have 2 family members on my Husband's side of the family that have official diagnosis of PD's).
We just can't say well if it walks like a duck, quacks like a duck...etc. and conclude that there is a mental illness and/or personality disorder in play. JMHO.
It's fine to speculate or give an opinion according to WS rules (except where a mod says it's not to do so such as Beach did on this thread about a specific illness)
But make sure you indicate that it is speculation or JMHO. It helps the threads move along without issues JMHO.
Just chatting. Not giving direction as to posting on the thread. I'm not a mod and I really really don't want to be one haha they work too hard!
