Where do you think she was killed? Do you have a theory?? You're not alone in your thinking, i've always believed it was in the house or on the property. Interested in your theory, they are always well considered
Well, if someone truly didn't act impulsively but instead deliberated how to do it, suffocation would be one theory. If the murderer chose drowning instead, he'd obviously want to get the body hidden well. No coroner could mistake hot tub or bath tub drowning for creek or lake drowning. Anyway, if it happened in the house, there was no large amount of blood or else charges would have been filed sooner. IMO.
Strangulation (which is one of the most common ways for a spouse to kill their partner) generally leaves lots of forensic evidence.
In watching this case, I thought it was fascinating that Barry found it "too soon" to talk about Suzanne's disappearance until about 10 days after she was gone. He was clearly still nervous about the situation.
But after about a month, he starts to think about filing court paperwork, does some travel, may even resume seeing the girlfriend (IMO). To me that indicates that he had a date in mind past which the body, if found, would tell medical examiners much less.
So if he put her in water, after a month, a lot of evidence of strangulation would be gone, as well as any bruises or defensive marks on her body. If he put her in a grave or a mine shaft, there would probably still be evidence of bruises and defensive marks on her body, as well as easily recovered evidence about the state of her lungs (which would tell a lot about manner of death - and perhaps place of the murder).
Barry just kept getting more and more confident. I find it strange that he brandished a weapon to keep Andy Moorman and company off his property, that he allowed friends to mobilize to scare off AWP. In the first 2-3 months he really didn't want that body to be found.
By the time he moved out of Puma Path, he may have been convinced that both his story about what happened and the forensic evidence of the body might dovetail.
OTOH, my gut tells me that he put her body someplace off the property (so that when found much later, disarticulated, it might look like a "mountain lion got her"). Or that she "went into the water." Whatever Barry did, he was confident that the crucial period of finding forensic evidence that was truly damning was over.
So, I think strangulation (perhaps with his arm against her windpipe with consistent pressure rather than a grab and strangle scenario) or suffocation or perhaps drowning are the most likely possibilities.
Sometimes I think he simply took her on a walk to a predetermined place, with that short rifle. If he shot her, though, he has to be very worried that the body will be located. Very hard to shoot a person without leaving clear forensic evidence. If he actually thought he had managed to do that (shoot without leaving evidence in the bones), he's both really stupid and really arrogant. Entirely possible.
Now, if 10-20 years passes before she is found, it'll be hard to prove conclusively which gun killed her. But his behavior for the past year shows me a man who is not particularly worried about forensic evidence and has already spun stories to cover what might be found. A stranger could have strangled her (we'd most likely have no evidence of defensive wounds on her body). A stranger could have drowned her. Or she could have just fallen in the water after her bike accident.
So...the prosecution needs to show that there was never a bike ride, for starters.
If Barry believed his body itself smelled of cadaverine after moving Suzanne, and that he might be leaving evidence around his own house/kitchen and therefore, he bleached areas in house - that, to me, says he disposed of a body. If no bike ride and Barry Morphew had to disinfect his house, his tool box, his own body, etc., well...you see where I'm going.