Found Deceased CO - Suzanne Morphew, 49, Chaffee County, 10 May 2020 #70 *ARREST*

Status
Not open for further replies.
  • #141
That’s not what circumstantial means. DNA and fingerprints are circumstantial. There is no category called “definitive proof”. The other category is called direct proof. It needs no interpretation to explain it. Circumstantial evidence does. You have to interpret the DNA evidence. And the fingerprints. You need experts to explain what is there.
boy am i glad to see you here @gitana1 - we need your expertise..
IMO
 
  • #142
Last edited:
  • #143
How was it ineptitud by the prosecution?
That is a different case, one that is in the history books. Let's discuss this one.
 
  • #144
@LaurenScharfTV
Exhibit 60 is being showed. It is a google map of where the helmet and bike was found vs. where the home is on Puma Path. #SuzanneMorphew helmet was 50 feet from the road. Libler advised Suzanne to have contact info in the helmet in case of crash.

4:06 PM · Aug 10, 2021·Twitter Web App
 
  • #145

Lauren Scharf
@LaurenScharfTV

·
Aug 10
Replying to
@LaurenScharfTV
On May 9, Text messages: 9:50 BM: Wanna go on a hike? 9:52 SM: where? (no response) Later on, asking about summer tires on range rover? 10:36 SM: Wanna meet to hike? 12 minutes later 10:48 BM:No, coming home SM: Get Hottub stuff

So while on the jobsite with MG, Barry was indeed texting with Suzanne. This has been speculated on before so now we know it's fact.
 
  • #146
On May 9, Text messages:
9:50 BM: Wanna go on a hike?
9:52 SM: where? (no response) Later on, asking about summer tires on range rover?
10:36 SM: Wanna meet to hike? 12 minutes later
10:48 BM:No, coming home
SM: Get Hottub stuff

Ok, so this is where MG and her comment that Barry quit work early "to go home and make the wife happy, go hiking or biking".

Is this also where the Chlorine purchase and him being seen in town comes in?
 
  • #147
Another question answered:

On May 8 at 9:28, Suzanne texted her sister saying, He has been "abusive emotionally and physically."

This was two days before she disappeared
https://twitter.com/marcsallinger/status/1425183182278709257?s=21

Unfortunately, most victims of Domestic Violence keep the "secret" to themselves, not believing anyone could help, out of fear or unwarranted shame.

This could have possibly been the first time that Suzanne told her sister. Deeply saddening
 
Last edited:
  • #148
So... trash runs which included a 'tree container' ?
Maybe some of our speculation wasn't far off the mark ?

I'll keep my thoughts to myself about BM's saying he shot about 85 chipmunks around their home. :mad:

While growing up my siblings and I fed a chipmunk that was almost tame and would bravely eat some bits of birdseed we scattered by the fence.
Charming little creatures. :(
Yes. Children just love watching Alvin and his brothers get shot.
 
  • #149
@CarolAMcKinley
WOW
On Saturday night before Suzanne was reported missing, her Facebook codes were reset and her account friended 23 of her old friends, 20 of them male. investigators asked Barry if he did this and he denied it.

3:59 PM · Aug 10, 2021·Twitter Web App
Of course the JERK did. He’s a Murdering liar! He’s garbage! How did she stay with him this long? Moo
 
Last edited:
  • #150
His statement about shooting chipmunks from 2:44- 2 whatever makes me think he shot her.
He used a dart that required a .22 blank and needed to explain why (he might) have gunshot residue around, or why someone heard a shot... speculation
 
  • #151
Can someone post a link to the very helpful list of Twitter accounts reporting on the case? I lost it
 
  • #152
So, did he plan to hike with her to the place he had pre-prepared to dump her? But she wasn't having it, so he tranquilized her and drove her there?

I'm confused about when exactly he wiped the truck's motherboard.
I think he caught her with the messaging to JL and the picture of her sunbathing. I was thinking the truck thing happened sometime early Sunday morning? Have to go back to @Niner synopsis to verify
 
  • #153
  • #154
So... trash runs which included a 'tree container' ?
Maybe some of our speculation wasn't far off the mark ?

I'll keep my thoughts to myself about BM's saying he shot about 85 chipmunks around their home. :mad:

While growing up my siblings and I fed a chipmunk that was almost tame and would bravely eat some bits of birdseed we scattered by the fence.
Charming little creatures. :(

Aww. Off topic but they play with my cat in the backyard. They chase each other back and forth and then the chipmunks come to me with little hands outstretched for nuts. As the cat watches!
 
  • #155
Unfortunately, most victims of D.V. keep the "secret" to themselves, not believing anyone could help, out of fear or unwarranted shame.

This could have possibly been the first time that Suzanne told her sister. Deeply saddening
MOO She was on the trail to escape and still just trusted him too much.
 
  • #156
It's so painful to think that a devoted mother whose children have seen her be abused would be in any danger of having their affections alienated. At the same time, it makes sense, because abusers are scary, and when they are also a parent, it warps your thinking.
 
  • #157
Unfortunately, most victims of D.V. keep the "secret" to themselves, not believing anyone could help, out of fear or unwarranted shame.

This could have possibly been the first time that Suzanne told her sister. Deeply saddening
Absolutely
 
  • #158

Lauren Scharf
@LaurenScharfTV

·
Aug 10
On May 9, #BarryMorphews phone is pinged near the river behind his home. Investigators asked why this was, his response was, "I was looking for a turkey that MM had shot some time ago." 11:50 a.m. - 12:50 a.m.
 
  • #159
Not to me. With what we have so far, if I were a juror, I'm not sure I would convict at this point. That may change as more is presented.
This isn't the trial.
This is about whether he should go to trial.

Would you rule he should not go to trial?
 
  • #160
https://twitter.com/LaurenScharfTV/status/1425185309285928966?s=20

This tweet is intriguing as it starts to point towards BM accessing SM’s Facebook account.

Also intriguing are the text messages Saturday morning between BM and SM. Wanna go for a hike… Go get hot tub stuff

I wonder if BM had figured out a way to create that whole conversation himself and this make it look like SM wanted Chlorine to be purchased but the whole time BM was trying to set up an alibi for why he purchased the chlorine.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Staff online

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
134
Guests online
2,528
Total visitors
2,662

Forum statistics

Threads
632,144
Messages
18,622,669
Members
243,034
Latest member
RepresentingTheLBC
Back
Top