I think the voting records showed another adult female living in the SP household, but I don't have the link.
If Susan was accidentally killed, Josh has pretty much removed all possibility of leniency by refusing to help at any point in this case. It is true that sometimes the cover-up is worse than the crime, but that's because people think they can get away with it. He's also forfeited any claim to insanity, I think, by calculating a big move, renting the place and so many other things that show he can think just fine.
AFAIK, if his attorney tells him not to talk, that pretty much means he's guilty, too, and refusing to talk about it is just damage control.
If Susan was accidentally killed, Josh has pretty much removed all possibility of leniency by refusing to help at any point in this case. It is true that sometimes the cover-up is worse than the crime, but that's because people think they can get away with it. He's also forfeited any claim to insanity, I think, by calculating a big move, renting the place and so many other things that show he can think just fine.
AFAIK, if his attorney tells him not to talk, that pretty much means he's guilty, too, and refusing to talk about it is just damage control.