FL - Anastasia Gilley, 19, 4-months pregnant, last seen at home, found deceased, Jackson County, 3 May 2023 *arrest*

  • #81
not a boyfriend. not the co worker


Houston County Sheriff Donald Valenza did confirm that the suspect, 33-year-old Marquis Devon McCloud was an acquaintance of Gilley but he said McCloud was not a boyfriend or co-worker.
 
  • #82
not a boyfriend. not the co worker


Houston County Sheriff Donald Valenza did confirm that the suspect, 33-year-old Marquis Devon McCloud was an acquaintance of Gilley but he said McCloud was not a boyfriend or co-worker.
As an acquaintance, why/how did he know where her house was? Did he stalk her or did she know him a little more than they're insinuating? Ugh. You have to be so careful nowadays. She must have been so scared.
 
  • #83
  • #84
JCSO said Marquis Devan McCloud, 33, of Alabama, was arrested on a charge of capital murder during a first-degree kidnapping. McCloud had been in custody since earlier in the week.

“The suspect has been uncooperative throughout this entire investigation," the Sheriff's Office said.
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
From the video presser with LE: (perhaps not paraphrased perfectly)

- AG and the suspect were acquaintances and that is all (does not sound like an ex-colleague).
- she was dead for approximately 5 days, based on the Sheriff's opinion, (yet was missing for 7) and LE believes she was held against her will.
- they had leads that took them to the area where she was found. They had been looking in the general area for several days but finally got closer to the right spot.
- there may be further charges as the investigation moves forward. They don't know if they will/can charge the suspect with the death of the unborn child. It depends on the age of the fetus and the specific laws surrounding that.
- her body was highly decomposed and she was identified by the clothing and costume jewellry. Final confirmation of her identity will be made through autopsy, but they sound pretty confident.
- they believe she was killed in the spot that she was found, not just dumped there
- question: there have been reports that she was shot a couple of times. Answer: there were things at the scene that might imply that she was shot, but it is not certain and they don't want to comment further until they receive the autopsy results.
- when asked about the emotional impact on LE regarding this case: while some of the investigators are fathers and this is no doubt tough, the team are professionals and they are able to hold back emotions and go about their investifgation in a professional manner. The Houston County LE have put 600 hours into the case so far, so this has been a very active investigation.
- there are lots of false rumors on social media. Please don't add to them or spread them.
 
  • #85
The grandmother of Anastasia Gilley knew something was horribly wrong after her granddaughter, four months pregnant, vanished.

“I knew she was in trouble, and I knew she would not run away,” Sandra Steele told WCTV, a Tallahassee television station on Friday.

Investigators believe Gilley was shot multiple times by Marquis McCloud, a 31-year-old Henry County man described as her acquaintance.

Friends last saw the 19-year-old in Greenwood, a small Jackson County, Florida town where she moved from Tallahassee about 18 months ago.

Houston County Sheriff Donald Valenza believes Gilley went with McCloud willingly but, after they crossed into Alabama, he would not allow her to return home.

“I was scared, I was angry, and I wanted to get her. I wanted to find her, and it just didn’t happen that way, but she’s been found now and we’re going to put her to rest,” Steele said.

McCloud, who is charged with a count of Capital Murder and has a history of violent crimes arrests, faces the death penalty if convicted.

“Just the sheer nature of knowing somebody could do that to somebody that was so good, she never did anything to harm anybody,” Steele said.
 
  • #86
I’m not sure why they think she went with him willingly. I’ve read from an article upthread that she left her phone and purse at home - most wouldn’t leave those at home even if just going for a drive, or a walk to a corner store, etc. Additionally, neighbors heard a scream the night she was last seen, which could have been unrelated but … likely was related. imo

Idk, maybe that’s just what they’re saying for now, I just can’t see that she went willingly.
 
  • #87
I’m not sure why they think she went with him willingly. I’ve read from an article upthread that she left her phone and purse at home - most wouldn’t leave those at home even if just going for a drive, or a walk to a corner store, etc. Additionally, neighbors heard a scream the night she was last seen, which could have been unrelated but … likely was related. imo

Idk, maybe that’s just what they’re saying for now, I just can’t see that she went willingly.
Whispering Pines Circle (her street address, named in a few stories) in Greenwood is quite remote. Most of the houses are isolated with one driveway on the road linking to them. Based on neighbors being close enough to hear a scream, there is only one area where there are houses side-by-side. IMO.

Anastasia Gilley.jpg
I've marked the area in red.

Google Map directions from that point to Headland, AL, is quite far (46 miles).

IMO it's definitely the kind of housing area where you'd always have your wallet and phone.
 
  • #88
  • #89
Sheriff Donald Valenza will reveal those charges Wednesday in a news conference that News4 will stream live at 9:00 a.m.

From @killarney rose link above.
 
  • #90
  • #91
  • #92
  • #93
Good. I’m so glad they are getting justice for the baby, too. God what an awful man. She must have been so terrified. So sad.
 
  • #94
“The last call (Gilley) made was to McCloud, but he denied knowing her whereabouts when we called him,” he told Judge Lewis.
A Houston county judge has order 33-year-old Marquis Devon McCloud capital murder case, for the...

A cell phone search indicates the duo traveled together to Dothan, but Gilley had wanted him to drive her to Sneads, Florida where her male friend resides, Herring testified.

He believes that McCloud killed Gilley within a few hours of her abduction, likely because she refused to have sex with him.

McCloud conducted multiple searches on his electronic devices about how to eradicate fingerprints from guns, he said during the two-hour hearing.

He also asked about the credibility of witnesses, some of them felons, and insisted that he be provided with all the evidence that investigators amassed.

Wadsworth also questioned if Gilley had been kidnapped or had gone with McCloud voluntary and, indicating he hopes a grand jury will indict on Felony Murder—not Capital Murder---charges.

However, Wadsworth and co-counsel Amy Cobb Smith had no other expectation of the hearing’s outcome, planning a more vigorous defense during the trial that prosecutors don’t anticipate until at least 2025.

Houston County District Attorney Russ Goodman is confident McCloud, 33, will ultimately be convicted and, if that happens, plans to seek the death penalty.

According to records, McCloud has a 15-year adult criminal record that includes other sex arrests and accusations that, as a registered sex offender, he resided too close to an Abbeville, Alabama, school.

McCloud faces two counts of Capital Murder, one based upon allegations that he kidnapped Gilley and the other because he is accused of killing two people---that includes the unborn child—during a single criminal act.
 
  • #95
From Oct. 2023. BBM.
DOTHAN, Ala. (WTVY) - Houston County grand jurors indicted a man this week on charges that he murdered a Florida panhandle teen and her unborn baby.

Marquis McCloud, 33 of Newville, is facing capital charges in the shooting of Anastasia Gilley.

[...]

A January trial will likely be rescheduled based on timetables for other capital cases.
 
  • #96
Praying for justice for Anastasia and her baby. When I read the story some time ago, I believed he took her by force. She trusted him and he betrayed her trust. I hope he rots.
 
  • #97
Screenshot-2025-01-03-113541.jpg
Marquis McCloud being escorted into the Houston County Courthouse by HCSO deputies
Marquis McCloud was arrested in May 2023 and charged with one count of Capital Murder-Kidnapping and one count of Capital Murder-Two or More Persons in the murder of 19-year-old Anastasia Gilley and her 4-month-old fetus.

He was initially set to stand before Judge Christopher Richardson and a jury of his peers in July 2024, but after several setbacks, his trial was pushed over nine times until finally landing on March 17, 2025.

It is currently unknown if McCloud’d trial will be pushed again. McCloud pled not guilty to his charges, claiming he has a “mental disease or defect.”

Gilley’s “badly decomposed body” was found in a Houston County field in early May 2023 after she went missing from her Jackson County home.

According to Houston County Sheriff Donald Valenza, Gilley may have wilfully met McCoud in person after speaking with him through social media.

The sheriff says at some point after meeting in person, McCloud began holding Gilley against her will and then shot her to death in the field off Headland Avenue. An indictment claims Gilley was shot several times
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
89
Guests online
2,339
Total visitors
2,428

Forum statistics

Threads
633,074
Messages
18,635,864
Members
243,397
Latest member
Gaz00
Back
Top