FL FL - Seffner, WhtFem UP212/423UFFL, 35-50, skeletal remains in orange grove, Dec'82

GJKJR

Well-Known Member
Joined
Feb 10, 2019
Messages
299
Reaction score
993
  • #1
Looked up several keywords and couldn't seem to find this case listed.

423UFFL5_LARGE.jpg
423UFFL1.jpg
423UFFL.jpg
423UFFL4.jpg
423UFFL3.jpg

Seffner (Hillsborough County) Jane Doe
Basic Statistics:

- Found on December 30, 1982 in an orange grove in Seffner, Hillsborough County, Florida
- Skeletal remains at time of discovery
- 35-45 (or 35-50) years of age at death, estimated
- White female
- Height estimated at 5'2" - 5'4" (62 in - 64 in)
- Weight unknown
- Hair and eye color unknown

Clothing:
- Blue jeans and panties (near body)

Unique Features:
- Old fracture of left cheek and surgical wire under right eye

Dental Records:
- Full upper dentures
- Periapical abscess on tooth #29
- Teeth #23, #24, #25, #26 have noted decay with periapical abscesses
- Tooth #22 evulsed perimortem (extracted forcibly at or near the time of death)
- Tooth #31 recent extraction healing

Identifiers:
- Dentals are available (see Dental Records).
- Fingerprints are unavailable due to decomposition.
- DNA is available.

DoeNetwork: 423UFFL
NamUs: The National Missing and Unidentified Persons System (NamUs)
 
  • #2
  • #3
  • #4

This is Gertrude Menacher Gertrude Marianne Menacher – The Charley Project

"Menacher was last known to be with her boyfriend, Charles Gibson, her daughter, Angela DeLawder, and DeLawder's boyfriend, Ivan Gutierrez. They all disappeared from Hallandale, Florida on the same day, March 7, 1981..." They were all known to be heavily involved in the Miami drug scene; their car was found at Miami airport.

It's a bit under four hours from Menacher's home to Seffner: Google Maps
 
  • #5
  • #6
She is also listed on Florida's UID database, but as of Asian descent, age range 45-50.

Florida Unidentified Decedants Database
Huh, interesting. I forgot about FLUIDDB for a bit there. That changes the situation a bit, doesn't it? Surprised that conclusion isn't at least given a mention on NamUs.


I think it's possible, but at the same time, I'm not too confident. I think her pictures bear a passing resemblance to the USF reconstruction, but it differs wildly from the other reconstruction, especially in the nose area (that bulbous nose seems quite distinctive?) Not saying it's impossible, I'm just on the fence about it.
 
  • #7
Added November 9, 2021
smaller UP212 (2).png
 
  • #8
"Body found in orange grove," Tampa Tribune, 31 December 1982, 2B.
<modsnip>
The grove where the body was found was north of U.S. Highway 92 and south of Interstate 4, between Kingsway Avenue and MacIntosh Road, said sheriff's Maj. John Cacciatore.

The skeleton was clad in blue jeans, a blue belt with white buckle, white tube socks with green stripes, blue tennis shoes and a blue button-down collar shirt, Cacciatore said.

The woman had stood about 4 feet 10 inches, had a full upper dental plate and had a metallic surgical wire attached to the cheekbone, Cacciatore said.

Authorities could not determine cause of death and estimated the body had been there between 6 and 18 months.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #9
Ina Arnall missing from OK May 1981. She was driving to Tulsa to see her daughter. Her car was found at the Tulsa airport. She was 46 at the time she went missing. UID estimate is 35-50.

News article says PMI could be 6-18 months.

Ina is described as 4’11” - 5’2” (90-110 lbs)
Brown hair and Hazel eyes.

Interesting that one of the recons shows her right eye a little far to the right. This appears the same in Ina’s photo.

Also, Ina had full upper dentures Same as UID.

1673125005548.jpeg
1673125325354.jpeg

1673125379041.jpeg


 
  • #10
One exclusion
55924D8E-37D5-4636-AA75-C628EA17FBBA.jpeg
 
  • #11
Ina Arnall missing from OK May 1981. She was driving to Tulsa to see her daughter. Her car was found at the Tulsa airport. She was 46 at the time she went missing. UID estimate is 35-50.

News article says PMI could be 6-18 months.

Ina is described as 4’11” - 5’2” (90-110 lbs)
Brown hair and Hazel eyes.

Interesting that one of the recons shows her right eye a little far to the right. This appears the same in Ina’s photo.

Also, Ina had full upper dentures Same as UID.

View attachment 393613View attachment 393616
View attachment 393617

I came to suggest Ina Arnall but I see you did it hehe.
 
  • #12
  • #13
I have submitted Ina as a potential match to Seffner JD.
 
  • #14
Ina Arnall is now excluded from being UP212, Seffner FL Jane Doe. I will also cross post in Ina’s thread. I received word back from Hillsborough ME today. Response below. Sure wish more exclusions were this quick.

I was able to compare Ms. Ina’s MP13768 to UP212. Both the missing person and unidentified person have DNA profiles uploaded into national databases and I can confirm these cases have been excluded as a possible match. Thank you for the submission, and Happy New Year to you and yours as well!
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
128
Guests online
2,811
Total visitors
2,939

Forum statistics

Threads
632,679
Messages
18,630,368
Members
243,248
Latest member
nonameneeded777
Back
Top