Georgia Man Accused of Holding Wife Captive for 30 Years—The Truth Was Very Different

mccrackenpostonjr

Verified Criminal Defense Attorney
Joined
May 21, 2025
Messages
1
Reaction score
9
  • #1
Hello everyone! My name is McCracken Poston Jr. and I’m a criminal defense lawyer in Georgia and Tennessee. Several of my cases have been on shows you may have watched, forensic files, A&E’s American Justice, and NPR Snap Judgment. Most recently you may have heard about another one of my cases on last summer’s number one Apple podcast, “Noble”.

I wanted to share a case I was personally involved in that has stuck with me for decades. In 1999, I defended a man named Alvin Ridley in Ringgold, Georgia. He had lived a quiet, highly private life with his wife, Virginia, who had epilepsy and agoraphobia. When she died at home, he was later arrested and charged with murder—accused of having held her captive for nearly 30 years.

The evidence didn’t support the charge. In fact, after gaining access to Alvin’s home, I discovered a massive collection of Virginia’s handwritten writings—over 15,000 pages—detailing their private but loving life together. These writings were crucial in his acquittal.

What makes this case even more important to revisit: Alvin was diagnosed with autism at age 79, more than two decades after the trial. His diagnosis changed everything about how people understood his behavior—his silence, his routines, even his lawsuits.

I’ve written a book about the case and recently did a Reddit AMA that’s now approaching one million views. The AMA covers behind-the-scenes details, including how a suitcase of evidence released cockroaches into the courtroom mid-trial.

If this case interests you, here’s the AMA:

I’d love to answer questions, if I can.
McP



Happy to answer any questions here too. Thanks for reading.
 
  • #2
I remember watching this on Dateline or one of those shows. Very interesting case.
 
  • #3
cockroaches n the courtroom!
 
  • #4
I remember this case. I never believed that he was guilty.
 
  • #5
Hello everyone! My name is McCracken Poston Jr. and I’m a criminal defense lawyer in Georgia and Tennessee. Several of my cases have been on shows you may have watched, forensic files, A&E’s American Justice, and NPR Snap Judgment. Most recently you may have heard about another one of my cases on last summer’s number one Apple podcast, “Noble”.

I wanted to share a case I was personally involved in that has stuck with me for decades. In 1999, I defended a man named Alvin Ridley in Ringgold, Georgia. He had lived a quiet, highly private life with his wife, Virginia, who had epilepsy and agoraphobia. When she died at home, he was later arrested and charged with murder—accused of having held her captive for nearly 30 years.

The evidence didn’t support the charge. In fact, after gaining access to Alvin’s home, I discovered a massive collection of Virginia’s handwritten writings—over 15,000 pages—detailing their private but loving life together. These writings were crucial in his acquittal.

What makes this case even more important to revisit: Alvin was diagnosed with autism at age 79, more than two decades after the trial. His diagnosis changed everything about how people understood his behavior—his silence, his routines, even his lawsuits.

I’ve written a book about the case and recently did a Reddit AMA that’s now approaching one million views. The AMA covers behind-the-scenes details, including how a suitcase of evidence released cockroaches into the courtroom mid-trial.

If this case interests you, here’s the AMA:

I’d love to answer questions, if I can.
McP



Happy to answer any questions here too. Thanks for reading.
You totally responded to me about Alvin recently on a different site!
I think I specifically commented about how I found it odd (as a woman with autism personally) that he drove past other places to a payphone.
Thanks for your work. Defense attorneys are absolutely crucial to our nation.
 
  • #6
I figured all along that he was probably autistic, and she may have been too.
 
  • #7
Wow. What a great person. Certainly God is going to bless you when you reach the pearly gates. We, as a country, talk so badly about lawyers, but you are one who set a terrific example, of fairly representing him, taking care of some of his many needs, and getting a fair and remarkable acquittal. Thank from my heart for the work you do, and may God bless you, as he most certainly will. MOO. Katt
 
  • #8
I remember watching this on Dateline or one of those shows. Very interesting case.
I think, I saw it on Medical Detectives in Ger, already several times. Interesting to hear more!
 

Staff online

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
151
Guests online
2,236
Total visitors
2,387

Forum statistics

Threads
632,501
Messages
18,627,678
Members
243,171
Latest member
neckdeepinstories
Back
Top