Gilgo Beach LISK Serial Killer, Rex Heuermann, charged with 3 murders, July 2023

[CuriousCricket]

It's so great to see results of these long months of intense investigation. Can't wait for Thursday. Is anyone else wondering about what's going through RH's mind? I think the sheriff said he would catch TV from his cell. So, if the TV has been tuned to the searches -- what was running through his mind? Or was he blindsided with the new court date? It's not like there's really anyone he can talk to. Of course, he's never been able to discuss this area of his life, so maybe it's not a problem for him.

With four murder charges already facing him, does the prospect of more even bother him? It's rewarding for the families who have waited so long, for LE who have worked so long and for the public to have hope this person is out of circulation permanently -- but what goes through a murderer's mind as he watches people discover his darkest secrets?

 

[dotr]

Example- @ 1:00 -roughly -' they could be looking for tools that correspond with marks on body' (dismemberment)

jun 3, 2024 #GilgoBeach #RexHeuermann #CUOMO
Suspected Gilgo Beach serial killer Rex Heuermann is expected to be charged this week with an additional murder. Retired FBI profiler Jim Clemente, "Real Crime Profile" podcast host, joins NewsNation host Chris Cuomo to discuss the possibility of Heuermann being linked to more murders.

 

[Catchinglisk]

Was North Sea the young woman in a trash bag who had a gold pig necklace?

No that is lattingtown Jane doe North Sea was Sandra costilla

 

[Betty P]

I can't find anything from John Ray since soon after his Jan 2024 event.
Has anyone read anything?

No, but I'm sure he's still busy. It's possible LE agreed to investigate all of the information and witnesses Ray provided to them. In exchange, he has to remain out of the media as they conduct their investigations and gather evidence.

Ray is a very experienced attorney and knows what's necessary for prosecution to build a good case prior to an arrest and indictment.

So who do we think realized there was another active serial killer operating on LI first? Who used the others dumping ground to cover their own tracks and/or muddy the waters which ended up confusing James Burke's Keystone Suffolk County cops? What luck for both Heuermann and Bitrolff on that one! Unless...

The LI sex workers would be among the first to know there were other active serial killers on LI. Any John who talks to them would find out. Most Johns wouldn't be curious or make small talk, but a few would.

 

[Vern]

What year was that book published? Did RA fume or delight in macabre photos of his own doing that were wrongly credited to other murderers?

jmo

I doubt it; third review down on Amazon (RBBM):

These very graphic and explicit photos of crimes against bodies come from just one city, Los Angeles and it made me think that hundreds of thousands of similar photos must be in police archives around the world.

And what they say is true, most cities have online archives of their crime scee photos these days judging by a quick google search.

 

[Just K]

No that is lattingtown Jane doe North Sea is Sandra costilla

I was curious as to why the podcast with Josh and Joe didn’t mention “Cherries.” Her case was so similar to Peaches and Karen V. Any ideas.

 

[fidgeypie]

I was curious as to why the podcast with Josh and Joe didn’t mention “Cherries.” Her case was so similar to Peaches and Karen V. Any ideas.

Joe is aware of Cherries we talked about her via email.

 

[CuriousCricket]

You express that so well - I think it’s possible others may be involved somehow but there is one main killer.

Where I think the others are involved is in the swinging scene and sex-worker party scenes that seem to have been prevalent on Long Island at the time. I think the message boards discussed on here so extensively and the knowledge that a swingers (was it a bar?) close to Rex's office brought people to Long Island are proof there was a great deal of interest from numerous people.

However, how many of those would actually even consider crossing that line into murder?

I wonder if some of the murders perhaps lumped into LISK might be straight-forward murders that the killers are lucky got lumped into LISK. Remember after Wayne Williams was arrested in the Atlanta child murders case it came to light that there were missing children actually murdered by their parents but whose cases had been considered possible WW work?

Perhaps some of the victims on LI aren't really LISK victims.

I have hope that with this very active investigation, these will be sorted out.

 

[Izzylizzy]

was curious as to why the podcast with Josh and Joe didn’t mention “Cherries.” Her case was so similar to Peaches and Karen V. Any ideas.

"Cherries"

NY cold case investigator seeks info from Gilgo task force

MAMARONECK, N.Y. (PIX11) – A senior investigator from the Mamaroneck Police Department reached out to the Gilgo Homicides Task Force in Suffolk County this week, asking if murder suspect Rex Heuerm…

pix11.com

 

[Betty P]

Where I think the others are involved is in the swinging scene and sex-worker party scenes that seem to have been prevalent on Long Island at the time. I think the message boards discussed on here so extensively and the knowledge that a swingers (was it a bar?) close to Rex's office brought people to Long Island are proof there was a great deal of interest from numerous people.

However, how many of those would actually even consider crossing that line into murder?

I wonder if some of the murders perhaps lumped into LISK might be straight-forward murders that the killers are lucky got lumped into LISK. Remember after Wayne Williams was arrested in the Atlanta child murders case it came to light that there were missing children actually murdered by their parents but whose cases had been considered possible WW work?

Perhaps some of the victims on LI aren't really LISK victims.

I have hope that with this very active investigation, these will be sorted out.

Of the sex workers who gave tips and info to John Ray, at least 3 of the women told of being at sex party events when they encountered Rex H. JMO, that's enough to seem likely that some of these victims encountered him at those events. One encounter was at the swinger's club "La Trapeze" in Manhattan, not far from Heuermann's office.

Sampling the Delicacies at the Le Trapeze Swingers Club

Not long ago, I sat at a cocktail lounge in the East Village with a realtor friend as she extolled the virtues of Le Trapeze, a swinger’s club in midtown. The experience, she swore, had cured her o…

observer.com

Witness 'SAW Rex Heuermann with sex workers whose remains were found'

Heuermann is charged with first- and second-degree murder in connection with the deaths of three victims, Melissa Barthelemy, Megan Waterman and Amber Costello.

www.dailymail.co.uk

 

[PickleChris]

Of the sex workers who gave tips and info to John Ray, at least 3 of the women told of being at sex party events when they encountered Rex H. JMO, that's enough to seem likely that some of these victims encountered him at those events. One encounter was at the swinger's club "La Trapeze" in Manhattan, not far from Heuermann's office.

Sampling the Delicacies at the Le Trapeze Swingers Club

Not long ago, I sat at a cocktail lounge in the East Village with a realtor friend as she extolled the virtues of Le Trapeze, a swinger’s club in midtown. The experience, she swore, had cured her o…

observer.com

Witness 'SAW Rex Heuermann with sex workers whose remains were found'

Heuermann is charged with first- and second-degree murder in connection with the deaths of three victims, Melissa Barthelemy, Megan Waterman and Amber Costello.

www.dailymail.co.uk

I'm pretty sure if he was going to that place, he was going to the one at the intersection of Wantagh Ave and Hicksville Road in Bethpage. It's changed names quite a few times but is a well known "couples club". Dive down that hole a bit if you like. Used to be called Club Manor. 10 minute drive from his house.

 

[kittythehare]

Ray is okay and on Court TV tonight!

Rex Heuermann returning to court after a renewed search of his home

The new court date comes two weeks after investigators returned to Rex Heuermann’s single-story home in Massapequa Park.

www.courttv.com

wowe, has witness that saw RH with Shannan!!!!

 

[Just K]

"Cherries"

NY cold case investigator seeks info from Gilgo task force

MAMARONECK, N.Y. (PIX11) – A senior investigator from the Mamaroneck Police Department reached out to the Gilgo Homicides Task Force in Suffolk County this week, asking if murder suspect Rex Heuerm…

pix11.com

Thank you! So, in addition to Sandra Costello, there are three other UID females left on the north shore.

 

[Just K]

Thank you! So, in addition to Sandra Costello, there are three other UID females left on the north shore.

Sandra Costilla, is this the correct spelling?

 

[dotr]

Sandra Costilla, is this the correct spelling?

NY - NY- Sandra Costilla, 28, of Queen's, found murdered at the Fish Cove Camp in North Sea, 20 November 1993

2014 https://www.longislandpress.com/2014/07/22/manorville-man-arrested-for-90s-murders-suspected-in-3rd-cold-case/ ''Homicide Squad detectives are also investigating whether Bittrolff killed a third woman, Sandra Costilla, 28, of Queens, whose cause of death resembles Tangredi’s and McNamee’s...

www.websleuths.com

 

[Kudzuu]

Of the sex workers who gave tips and info to John Ray, at least 3 of the women told of being at sex party events when they encountered Rex H. JMO, that's enough to seem likely that some of these victims encountered him at those events. One encounter was at the swinger's club "La Trapeze" in Manhattan, not far from Heuermann's office.

Sampling the Delicacies at the Le Trapeze Swingers Club

Not long ago, I sat at a cocktail lounge in the East Village with a realtor friend as she extolled the virtues of Le Trapeze, a swinger’s club in midtown. The experience, she swore, had cured her o…

observer.com

Witness 'SAW Rex Heuermann with sex workers whose remains were found'

Heuermann is charged with first- and second-degree murder in connection with the deaths of three victims, Melissa Barthelemy, Megan Waterman and Amber Costello.

www.dailymail.co.uk

La Trapeze article is hilarious!!

 

[Just K]

La Trapeze article is hilarious!!

It was very descriptive, informative and disgusting all at the same time.

 

[Betty P]

I'm pretty sure if he was going to that place, he was going to the one at the intersection of Wantagh Ave and Hicksville Road in Bethpage. It's changed names quite a few times but is a well known "couples club". Dive down that hole a bit if you like. Used to be called Club Manor. 10 minute drive from his house.

According to the woman John Ray interviewed, it was the one in Manhattan. Rex and his wife used to go there. They also used to put cards on the bulletin board there when announcing a sex party at their own home.

 

[Luna20]

According to the woman John Ray interviewed, it was the one in Manhattan. Rex and his wife used to go there. They also used to put cards on the bulletin board there when announcing a sex party at their own home.

Rex and his wife went to sex parties?

 

[charminglane]

La Trapeze article is hilarious!!

Thanks for the recommendation!
Tube sock boogie.