GUILTY HI - Telma Boinville, 51, beaten to death, Oahu, 6 Dec 2017 *Arrests*

[Niner]

Docket:
336 01/05/2021 Minutes
STATUS CONFERENCE HAD; COUNSEL PRESENT VIA PHONE. STATE NEED ADDTL TIME; DEFENSE DOES NOT OBJ TO CONTINUANCE. DUE TO COVID CONSIDERATIONS, LARGE JURY PANEL ANTICIPATED LATE JUNE/EARLY JULY 2021. ANTICIPATE 1 MONTH TRIAL. CT CONTIUED TRIAL DEADLINES; NEW TRIAL WEEKS 8/9/2021 THROUGH 8/30/2021. CUSTODY TRANSPORT FOR CO-DEFTS; MTN HRGS TO BE HEARD 3/5 (ALL DAY) STARTING AT 8:30AM. TRIAL CALL: 7/27/2021 AT 8:30AM - 4:30PM; PTMD: 3/1/2021 DEFENSE COUNSEL TO SUBMIT WRITTEN WAIVERS OF RULE 48. CT TO DO ORDER CONTINUING.
Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
JUDG Somerville , Rowena
CLK Antolin, Marilyn

337 01/05/2021 document purchase Order Re: Continuance
ORDER CONTINUING THE TRIAL WEEK
Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
First Circuit Court 23rd Division

338 01/05/2021 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand

317 01/15/2021 Minutes
TRIAL CALL 1/15/2021; SAME HRG DATE OF MOTIONS
Stephen Brown

JUDG Somerville , Rowena

318 01/15/2021 Minutes
TRIAL CALL 1/15/2021; SAME HRG DATE OF MOTIONS
Hailey Dandurand

JUDG Somerville , Rowena
319 01/15/2021 Minutes
TRIAL CALL 1/15/2021; (TW: 1/25/2021)
Hailey Dandurand

335 01/15/2021 Minutes
CONTINUED; HRGS CONTINUED TO 3/5/2021 (ALL DAY)
Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand

JUDG Somerville , Rowena
334 01/25/2021 Minutes
CONTINUED; NTW FIRM 8/19/2021 THROUGH 8/30/2021
Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
JUDG Somerville , Rowena


Case Event Schedule
Event Defendant Date Time Room Location Judge Appearance Disposition
Trial Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
08/30/2021 00:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Trial Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
08/16/2021 00:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Trial Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
08/09/2021 00:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Calendar Call Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
07/27/2021 08:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Hearing on Motion Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
03/05/2021 08:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Trial-CANCELLED Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
01/25/2021 00:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Trial=CANCELLED Hailey Dandurand
01/15/2021 00:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena OTH-Other

Hearing on Motion-CANCELLED Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
01/15/2021 08:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Calendar Call-CANCELLED Stephen Brown
01/15/2021 08:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena OTH-Other
Calendar Call-CANCELLED Hailey Dandurand
01/15/2021 08:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena OTH-Other

link: http://jimspss1.courts.state.hi.us:8080/eCourt/ECC/CaseSearch.iface

 

[Niner]

Tried to put this article in Outline - but it is not working...

Former Bend woman charged in Hawaii killing says co-defendant abused her

All I can see is:

The Bend native, and her ex-boyfriend Stephen Brown, are charged with killing Telma Boinville at a North Shore holiday home in late 2017. But as the ...

If anyone can access it - please post about 10% of the article, please? TIA!

They are both due in court on 3/5.

 

[MajorHoople]

from Former Bend woman charged in Hawaii killing says co-defendant abused her

"To many on the island of Oahu, Hailey Kai Dandurand is a glowering figure in baby blue jail clothes, half of a duo accused of one of the more brutal and high-profile killings in Hawaii in recent history.

The Bend native, and her ex-boyfriend Stephen Brown, are charged with killing Telma Boinville at a North Shore holiday home in late 2017. But as the trial date keeps getting pushed back, Dandurand’s defense is trying to have them tried separately, arguing she wasn’t an equal party to the killing and is in fact another victim of her co-defendant, Brown, who has a documented history of violent and coercive relationships with women."

"I was sleeping,” Dandurand wrote in her petition. “He wanted me to wake up. So he slapped me in my face about maybe 15 times."

 

[Niner]

Thanks for that @MajorHoople !

I have their trial beginning 8/9/21 to run thru 8/30/21. And a couple of hearing from now until then.

edited to add - could not access the HI court site this morning - maintenance until Monday morning....

 

[Niner]

Did An Abusive Relationship Lead To A Young Woman's Involvement In A North Shore Murder?

Feb. 28, 2021

Before she became the co-defendant in one of Hawaii’s highest profile murder cases in recent memory, Hailey Dandurand was pursuing a liberal arts degree at Kapiolani Community College after relocating to Oahu in early 2017 from her native Oregon.

In August 2017, she met and started dating 23-year-old Stephen Brown. The relationship soon turned abusive, according to court documents.

Dandurand has said that she suffered repeated attacks by her former boyfriend in the three months leading up to the gruesome and apparently random killing of a 51-year-old Sunset Elementary School substitute teacher — a crime for which they have both been charged.
[.....]
Now, with trial set to begin Aug. 9, the state has agreed not to oppose defense efforts to have the two tried separately.

Dandurand’s defense attorney Barry Sooalo says Dandurand was under the influence of Brown’s abuse at the time of Boinville’s death and did not willingly participate in the alleged murder and kidnapping.
[.....]
Last June, a judge granted Dandurand a restraining order that bars Brown from coming within 100 yards of her for the next decade.
[.....]
Last week Deputy Prosecuting Attorney Kyle Dowd filed a motion to withdraw the state’s original opposition to pleas from both defense teams for separate trials, making a joint trial less likely. The issue is set to be discussed at a hearing on Friday [3/5/21].
[.....]
In general, defendants also often seek separate trials after deciding to become cooperating witnesses for the prosecution.



a lot more in the article.

 

[Niner]

Friday, March 5th:
*Motion Hearing for both (@ 8:30am Hawaiian-Aleutian Time) - HI - Telma Boinville (51) (Dec. 6, 2017, Oahu) – *Stephen Brown (23/now 26) & *Hailey Kai Dandurand (20/now 23) arrested (12/13/17), charged & arraigned (12/18/17) with 2nd degree murder, 2 counts kidnapping & 1st degree burglary. Both plead not guilty. SB bail $1M, KD bail $500K.
Telma’s 8 yr old daughter was found bound & gagged with duct tape.
Trial was set to begin for both on 3/23/20 continued to 5/25/20 moved to 6/22/20 & has been rescheduled for 7/27/20 & has been rescheduled to 10/5/20 & continued to 12/14/20 continued to 1/25/21 & continued to 8/9/21 (thru 8/30/21).
Court information from 2/19/18 thru 8/19/20 reference post #74 here:
HI - Telma Boinville, 51, beaten to death, Oahu, 6 Dec 2017 *Arrests*
8/25/20: Judge Judge has denied the bail reduction for Dandurand. Murder suspects to not get early release due to COVID. Next motions hearing for both on 9/3/20. 8/25/20 Update: Motion for trial continuance-granted. Calendar Call hearing on 9/23/20 was rescheduled to 12/1/20 & trial has been rescheduled to 12/14/20.
9/3/20 Update: Pretrial motions hearing on 10/22/20 for both. Calendar call hearing on 12/1 & trial on 12/14 have been continued. Calendar Call & Motions hearing on 1/15/21 for both & trial now begins on 1/25/21.
10/22/20 Update: Trial for 12/14/20 was cancelled. Next Calendar Call & motion hearings on 1/15/21 for both. 1/5/21 Update: Status conference held. Counsel present via phone. State needs additional time; defense doesn't object to continuance. Due to COVID considerations, large jury panel anticipated late June/early July, 2021. Anticipate a 1 month trial. Court continued trial deadlines; new trial will be 8/9/21 thru 8/30/21. Custody transport for co-defendants. Motion hearings to be heard on 3/5/21 (all day) starting at 8:30am. Trial Calendar Call on 7/27/21 @ 8:30am to 4:30pm. PTMD: 3/1/21 defense counsel to submit written waivers of Rule 48. Court to do order continuing.
2/28/21 Update: The State has agreed not to oppose defense efforts to have the two tried separately. Dandurand’s defense attorney Barry Sooalo says Dandurand was under the influence of Brown’s abuse at the time of Boinville’s death & did not willingly participate in the alleged murder & kidnapping. Last June, a judge granted Dandurand a restraining order that bars Brown from coming within 100 yards of her for the next decade. Last week Deputy Prosecuting Attorney Kyle Dowd filed a motion to withdraw the state’s original opposition to pleas from both defense teams for separate trials, making a joint trial less likely. The issue is set to be discussed at a hearing on Friday, 3/5/21.

 

[Niner]

Okay - this is a bit on the long side - but wanted to get all the docket on here.

for both:

Docket:
348 02/24/2021 document purchase Document
Prosecution's Withdrawal of Prior Pleading and Notice of No Opposition to Defendant Stephen Brown's Motion for Relief from Prejudicial Joinder
Stephen Brown
C&C Honolulu Prosecutors-Felony 11

349 02/24/2021 document purchase Document
Prosecution's Withdrawal of Prior Pleading and Notice of No Opposition to Defendant Hailey Dandurand's Motion for Relief from Prejudicial Joinder
Hailey Dandurand
C&C Honolulu Prosecutors-Felony 11

350 02/24/2021 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand

352 02/28/2021 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Hailey Dandurand

354 02/28/2021 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Hailey Dandurand

355 03/01/2021 document purchase Notice of Adding Parties
Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand

356 03/05/2021 Minutes
CTRPTR: S. HULIHEE 9:08 AM CASE CALLED AND APPEARANCES WERE ENTERED BY COUNSEL AND DEFENDANTS. MR. BREINER ALSO PRESENT AND MADE HIS APPEARANCE ON BEHALF OF THE SURVIVING VICTIMS. CT STATED THE STATE WITHDREW ITS OPPOSITION TO DEFENSES M/PREJUDICIAL JOINDER. STATE CONFIRMED NOTING THEY WOULD ALSO PREFER SEPARATE TRIALS. MR. GOO PRESENTED ARGUMENT. MR. SO'OALO SUBMITTED ON HIS MOTION AND REQUESTED THE CT GRANT SAME. CT NOTED CLAIMS IN BOTH MOTIONS, MADE ITS FINDINGS CITING HRPP RULE 14, STATE V IKIM, STATE V TIMAS. CT POINTED OUT THAT MR. SO'OALO INDICATED ABOUT A YEAR AGO THE PURSUING OF A BATTERED SPOUSE DEFENSE AND TO DATE HAS NOT HIRED THE EXPERTS TO INTERVIEW HIS CLIENT NOR HAS HE FILED THE MOTIONS FOR LITIGATION EXPENSES. NEITHER DEFENSE HAS SET FORTH ANY CLAIM THAT HE OR SHE WILL BE PREVENTED FROM INTRODUCING EVIDENCE THAT WOULD HAVE BEEN ADMISSIBLE IF THEY WERE NOT TRIED ALONGSIDE EACH OTHER. THE IDENTIFICATION OF THE DEFENDANTS BY MINOR HAS NO BEARING ON THIS MOTION. CT FURTHER POINTED OUT THAT A RESTRAINING ORDER WAS TAKEN OUT BY DEFENDANT DANDURAND AGAINST DEFENDANT BROWN 3 YEARS LATER WHILE BOTH IN CUSTODY AND QUESTIONED IF EVEN RELEVANT OR ADMISSIBLE AT TRIAL. CT FURTHER CITES STATE V WALTON WHERE DEFENDANTS ARE NOT ENTITLED TO SEVERANCE MERELY BECAUSE THEIR DEFENSES ARE INCONSISTENT OR HAVE BETTER CHANCE OF ACQUITTAL IN SEPARATE TRIALS. THE PUBLIC INTEREST IN EFFICIENT USE OF JUDICIAL TIME THROUGH A JOINT TRIAL OUTWEIGHS ANY CLAIMED PREJUDICE BY EITHER DEFENDANT. THE CHARGED OFFENSES ARE INEXTRICABLY CONNECTED; THE CASE AGAINST EACH INVOLVES THE SAME PHYSICAL PIECES OF EVIDENCE AND NUMEROUS WITNESSES; ATHE MINOR SHOULD NOT HAVE TO TESTIFY AT TWO TRIALS. SEVERANCE IS NOT OBVIOUSLY IMPERATIVE IN THE INTEREST OF JUSTICE. THE CT HAS BALANCED THE POSSIBLE PREJUDICES CLAIMED BY BOTH DEFENSES AND CONCLUDES THAT THE DEFENDANTS SHOULD BE TRIED JOINTLY. BOTH MOTIONS ARE DENIED W/OUT PREJUDICE. CT TO PREPARE FOF/COL. ARGUMENTS HAD RE M/SUPPRESS ID. CT REQUESTED NO MENTION OF WITNESSES NAME BE DISSEMINATED TO THE PUBLIC AND NO MORE MENTION OF THE POLYGRAPH IS TO BE MADE. STATE REQUESTED THE VICTIM WITNESS ADVOCATE SIT NEAR THE WITNESS. MR. GOO OBJECTED AND PRESENTED ARGUMENT. MR. SO'OALO JOINED IN MR. GOO'S OBJECTION. CT DISAGREED, MADE ITS FINDINGS AND WILL ALLOW THE VICTIM WITNESS ADVOCATE TO SIT IN THE JURY BOX BEHIND MR. DOWD. MR. GOO PRESENTED FURTHER ARGUMENT. STATE SHARED IN THE CTS SENTIMENT AND PRESENTED ARGUMENT. CT WILL ALLOW. DISCUSSION HAD RE STREAMLINING WITNESSES INSTEAD OF RECALLING FOR EACH MOTIONS. COUNSEL IN AGREEMENT. 9:29 AM M.E. PRESENT. MR. GOO STATED WITNESS SITTING SIDEWAYS AND COVERING HER FACE REQUESTED THE WITNESS FACE FRONT PURSUANT TO RIGHT TO CONFRONTATION. MR. DOWD REQUESTED M.E. FACE FRONT AND ANGLE MICROPHONE DOWN TO AVOID LOOKING UP. AFTER QUESTIONING BY THE STATE, MR. DOWD REQUESTED THE CT FIND WITNESS COMPETENT. 9:36 AM VOIR DIRE BY MR. SO'OALO. 9:38 AM VOIR DIRE BY MR. GOO. 9:45 AM CT FINDS MINOR TO BE COMPETENT, NOTED FACTORS MET AND MINOR CAPABLE OF EXPRESSING HERSELF TO BE UNDERSTOOD. 9:46 AM M.E. SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 10:00 AM CROSS EXAMINATION BY MR. GOO. 10:09 AM DEFENDANT BROWN'S EXHIBIT C WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 10:19 AM DEFENDANT BROWN'S EXHIBIT B WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 10:20 AM CT IN RECESS. ********** 10:38 AM CASE RECALLED. CT INFORMED COUNSEL THAT THE MEDIA WAS OUTSIDE AND STATED ITS INTENTION TO INFORM THEM THAT PURSUANT TO SUPREME COURT RULE, WILL NOT ALLOW MINOR TO BE FILMED. MESSRS. DOWD AND MR. SO'OALO HAD NO OBJECTION. MR. GOO OBJECTED TO THE MEDIA BEING PRESENT AT ALL AND PRESENTED ARGUMENT. 10:41 AM MEDIA FROM KHON2 PRESENT. CT ADDRESSED HIM RE CLOSED PROCEEDING ON MINOR. HE ACKNOWLEDGED HIS UNDERSTANDING. 10:47 AM MR. BREINER PRESENT AND INFORMED THE CT AND COUNSEL THAT M.E. IS VERY UPSET AND TERRIFIED AND REQUESTING THE VICTIM WITNESS ADVOCATE BE NEXT TO HER TO HOLD HER HAND. 10:48-10:56 AM OFF RECORD - STATE TO CONFER W/M.E. 10:56 AM MR. DOWD MADE REPRESENTATIONS FROM SPEAKING WITH M.E. AND REQUESTED NEXT WITNESS BE CALLED TO ALLOW ADDITIONAL TIME FOR M.E. TO COMPOSE HERSELF. MR. GOO ARGUED RIGHT TO CONFRONTATION AND QUESTIONED COMPETENCY. MR. SO'OALO AGREED AND OBJECTED TO THE CT DELAYING PROCEEDINGS TO ACCOMMODATE M.E. AND ARGUED THAT COMPETENCY SHOULD BE REVISITED. STATE PRESENTED ARGUMENT. CT AGREED WITH THE STATE NOTING EMOTIONS DO NOT EQUATE TO COMPETENCY AND MADE ITS FINDINGS. MR. GOO NOTED RECORD MADE EARLIER RE HIS OBJECTION BUT REQUESTED TO PROCEED WITH NEXT WITNESS. MR. SO'OALO OBJECTED AS HE DIDN'T GET OPPORTUNITY TO CROSS M.E. YET. CT SUGGESTED BREAK FOR LUNCH UNTIL 1:00 PM. 11:01 AM CT IN RECESS. ********** 1:02 PM CT RECONVENED; CT INFORMED COUNSEL THAT IT REVIEWED THE CIVIL BEAT ARTICLE WHICH WAS BROUGHT TO ITS ATTENTION THIS AM BY STATE. CT RAISED RULES OF PROFESSIONAL CONDUCT 3.6 AND CITED ARTICLE QUOTES AND COMMENTS MADE BY MR. SO'OALO. CT FINDS ALL STATEMENTS TO BE EXTRA JUDICIAL AND MADE KNOWING HE WOULD BE QUOTED AND KNEW IT WOULD BE PREJUDICIAL. CT ORDERED MR. SO'OALO NOT TO MAKE COMMENTS AGAIN OR WILL BE SANCTIONED AND REPORTED TO ODC. THE CT INFORMED THE STATE THEY HAVE THE CTS PERMISSION TO REPORT MR. SO'OALO TO ODC HIMSELF. 1:09 PM CROSS EXAMINATION OF M.E. BY MR. SO'OALO. 1:22 PM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 1:23 PM CT REMINDED COUNSEL THAT MEDIA WAITING OUTSIDE FOR EXTENDED COVERAGE. STATE HAD NO OBJECTION. MESSRS GOO AND SO'OALO OBJECTED. CT NOTED DEFENSE'S OBJECTION AND THAT APPLICATOIN FOR EXTENDED COVERAGE FILED AND GRANTED ACCESS OVER DEFENSE'S OBJECTION. 1:25 PM KEVIN EMERY WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 1:37 PM STATE'S EXHIBIT 1 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE OVER DEFENDANT DANDURAND'S OBJECTION. 1:38 PM CROSS EXAMINATION BY MR. GOO. 1:50 PM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 1:52 PM OFCR AARON EVELAND SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 2:07 PM CROSS EXAMINATION BY MR. GOO. 2:09 PM CROSS EXAMINATION BY MR. SO'OALO. 2:10 PM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. CT IN RECESS. ********** 2:31PM COURT RECONVENED; APPEARANCES MADE BY COUNSEL; DEFT BROWN AND DEFT DANDURAND IN COURTROOM. 2:32 PM DETECTIVE NGUYEN SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 2:36 PM CROSS EXAMINATION BY MR. GOO. 2:41 PM CROSS EXAMINATION BY MR. SO'ALO; NO REDIRECT. 2:43 PM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 2:44 PM LT FUJITANI SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY 2:47 PM WITNESS ID DEFENDANT BROWN, W/O MASK REMOVAL. 2:49 PM WITNESS ID DEFENDANT DANDURAND, W/O MASK REMOVAL. 3:00 PM CROSS EXAMINATION BY MR. GOO. 3:04 PM CROSS EXAMINATION BY MR. SO'OALO; NO REDIRECT. 3:05 PM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. STATE NOTED FOR THE RECORD THAT ITS FINAL WITNESS, CORPORAL KAAWA NOT PRESENT TO TESTIFY. STATE WAS INFORMED THAT CORP KAAWA HAD A HIGH FEVER; NOT FEELING WELL. CT FURTHERED ALL MOTIONS TO MARCH 31, 2021 AT 1PM AND CONTINUE FOR THE REST OF THE AFTERNOON. COUNSEL HAD NO OBJECTION TO THE CONTINUANCE. CUSTODY TRANSPORT WILL BE ORDERED. HRG CONCLUDED; COURT ADJOURNED.
Stephen Brown


Hearings:
Event Defendant Date Time Room Location Judge Appearance Disposition
Trial Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
08/30/2021 00:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Trial Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
08/16/2021 00:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Trial Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
08/09/2021 00:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Calendar Call Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
07/27/2021 08:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Hearing on Motion Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
03/31/2021 13:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Hearing on Motion Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
03/05/2021 08:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

link: http://jimspss1.courts.state.hi.us:8080/eCourt/ECC/CaseSearch.iface

 

[JerseyGirl]

Trial for 2017 North Shore murder moves forward

The murder trial for Stephen Brown and Hailey Dandurand moved forward on Friday, March 5, with the suspects being tried together rather than at separate trials.

The court said the charges against the suspects are connected and involve the same pieces of evidence.

Friday’s hearing also took up the matter of whether to allow testimony for the victim’s daughter.

 

[Niner]

Wednesday, March 31st:
*Motion Hearing for both (@ 1pm Hawaiian-Aleutian Time) - HI - Telma Boinville (51) (Dec. 6, 2017, Oahu) – *Stephen Brown (23/now 26) & *Hailey Kai Dandurand (20/now 23) arrested (12/13/17), charged & arraigned (12/18/17) with 2nd degree murder, 2 counts kidnapping & 1st degree burglary. Both plead not guilty. SB bail $1M, KD bail $500K. Bond reduction denied for HD (8/25/20).
Telma’s 8 yr. old daughter was found bound & gagged with duct tape.
Trial set to begin for both on 8/9/21 (thru 8/30/21)
Court information from 2/19/18 thru 1/5/21 reference post #86 here:
HI - Telma Boinville, 51, beaten to death, Oahu, 6 Dec 2017 *Arrests*
2/28/21 Update: The State has agreed not to oppose defense efforts to have the two tried separately. Dandurand’s defense attorney Barry So’Oalo says Dandurand was under the influence of Brown’s abuse at the time of Boinville’s death & did not willingly participate in the alleged murder & kidnapping. Last June, a judge granted Dandurand a restraining order that bars Brown from coming within 100 yards of her for the next decade. Last week Deputy Prosecuting Attorney Kyle Dowd filed a motion to withdraw the state’s original opposition to pleas from both defense teams for separate trials, making a joint trial less likely. The issue is set to be discussed at a hearing on Friday, 3/5/21.
3/5/21 Update: Appearances by counsel & defendants. Mr. Breiner also present & made his appearance on behalf of the surviving victim. Court stated the State withdrew its opposition to defenses prejudicial joinder. State confirmed noting they would also prefer separate trials. Mr. Goo presented argument. Mr. So'Oalo submitted his motion & requested the Court grant same. Court says both cases against each involves the same physical pieces of evidence & numerous witnesses & the minor should not have to testify at 2 trials. Severance is not obviously imperative in the interest of Justice. Court concludes that the defendants should be tried jointly. Both motions are denied w/out prejudice. Court will allow victim witness advocate to site in the jury box behind Mr. Dowd re State's motion that the victim witness advocate sit near the witness. Arguments re minor to be competent-Court finds minor to be competent. M.E. (minor) sworn in for testimony. Defense's exhibits were marked & received into evidence. Mr. Goo objected to the media being present at all & presented argument. Court will not allow minor to be filmed during her testimony. Mr. Breiner informed the Court & Counsel that M.E. is very upset & terrified & requested the victim witness advocate be next to her to hold her hand. Mr. Goo again questioned competency. Court agreed with the State noting emotions do not equate to competency & made its findings. Court ordered Mr. So'Oalo not to make any comments to media (that were prejudicial) or he will be sanctioned & reported to ODC. Cross exam of M.E. by Mr. So'Oalo. Court informed that media was waiting outside for extended coverage. State had no objection, but defense objected. Court noted defense’s objection & that application for extended covered filed & granted access. Kevin Emery sworn in for testimony. State's exhibit 1 received into evidence over defendant Dandurand's objection. Cross exam by Mr. Goo. Officer Aaron Eveland sworn in for testimony. Cross exam by Mr. Goo & Mr. So'Oalo. Detective Nguyen sworn in for testimony. Cross exam by Mr. Goo & Mr. So'Oalo. No redirect. Lt. Fujitani sworn in for testimony. ID'ed defendant Brown & Dandurand without mask removal. State's final witness: Corporal Kaawa not present to testify as he has a high fever & not feeling well. Court furthered all motions to 3/31/21 @ 1pm. Counsel had no objection to the continuance.
3/7/21 Update: Judge Rowena Somerville agreed that each case had the same evidence & number of witnesses and did not want to subject Boinville's minor daughter--the only witness to the crime-to testify at two trials. Denying State prosecutor's & Dandurand's counsel of 2 separate trials.

 

[Niner]

Case Event Schedule
Event Defendant Date Time Room Location Judge Appearance Disposition
Trial Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
08/30/2021 00:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Trial Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
08/16/2021 00:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Trial Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
08/09/2021 00:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Calendar Call Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
07/27/2021 08:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Hearing on Motion Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
05/06/2021 13:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Hearing on Motion Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
03/31/2021 13:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

link: http://jimspss1.courts.state.hi.us:8080/eCourt/ECC/CaseSearch.iface

 

[Niner]

Oops - forgot to add docket...

357 03/09/2021 document purchase Request for Transcript
EFile Document upload of type Request for Transcript
Hailey Dandurand
C&C Honolulu Prosecuters-CAREER CRIMINAL DIV. 2

358 03/09/2021 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Hailey Dandurand

359 03/12/2021 document purchase Order Denied
ORDER DENYING HAILEY DANDURAND'S MOTION FOR RELIEF FROM PREJUDICIAL JOINDER
Hailey Dandurand
Stephen Brown
First Circuit Court 23rd Division

360 03/12/2021 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Hailey Dandurand
Stephen Brown

361 03/12/2021 document purchase Order Denied
ORDER DENYING STEPHEN BROWN'S MOTION FOR RELIEF FROM PREJUDICAL JOINDER
Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
First Circuit Court 23rd Division

362 03/12/2021 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand

363 03/31/2021 Minutes
CTRPTR: M. BALLESTEROS 1:16 PM CASE CALLED AND APPEARANCES WERE ENTERED BY COUNSEL AND DEFENDANTS IN CUSTODY. 1:18 PM CPL DAVID KAAAWA WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 1:24 PM WITNESS ID DEFENDANT BROWN W/OUT MASK. 1:25 PM WITNESS ID DEFENDANT DANDURAND W/OUT MASK. 1:29 PM CROSS EXAMINATION BY MR. SO'OALO. 1:30 PM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. RE M/SUPPRESS ID, MR. GOO STATED NO WITNESSES AND EXHIBITS B & C ALREADY IN EVIDENCE. RE M/PRECLUDE STMTS BY MINOR, MR. SO'OALO STATED NO WITNESSES. RE M/SUPPRESS EVIDENCE, MR. SO'OALO STATED NO WITNESSES AND PRESENTED ARGUMENT AND REQUESTED THE CT GRANT SAME. STATE PRESENTED ARGUMENT AND REQUESTED THE CT DENY. CT MADE ITS FINDINGS AND DENIED. STATE TO PREPARE FOF/COL. DEADLINE DISCOVERY 6/11/21. RE M/SUPPRESS ID, MR GOO PRESENTED ARGUMENT. STATE PRESENTED ARGUMENT. CT TOOK INTO CONSIDERATION 14 FACTORS SET FORTH IN KANEAIAKALA, MADE ITS FINDINGS AND DENIED. STATE TO PREPARE FOF/COL. RE M/PRECLUDE STMTS BY MINOR, MR. SO'OALO PRESENTED ARGUMENT AND REQUESTED THE CT GRANT SAME. MR. GOO JOINED IN MOTION, PRESENTED ARGUMENT AND REQUESTED THE CT USE HIS PRIOR ARGUMENT RE MINORS COMPETENCY. STATE RESTED ON ITS FILINGS AND PRESENTED ARGUMENT. CT PREVIOUSLY RULED ON MINORS COMPETENCY AND AGAIN FINDS MINOR TO BE COMPETENT. FINDS MADE AND MOTION DENIED. STATE TO PREPARE FOF/COL. RE M/COMPEL, CT INQUIRED RE EXPERT WITNESSES. MR. SO'OALO INFORMED THE CT THAT REQUESTS WERE SUBMITTED BUT NOT FINALIZED YET AND FURTHER UPDATED THE CT. STATE REQUSTED STC IN A MONTH. CT CONTINUED M/COMPEL AND STC FOR 5/9/21 AT 1:00 PM. MR. SO'OALO TO SUBMIT REQUEST FOR EXPERT FEES, ETC. BY THEN. DEFENDANT BROWN WAIVED HIS PRESENCE. DEFENDANT DANDURAND REQUESTED T/B PRESENT. CONCLUDED.
Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand

DPA Dowd, Kyle
CA Goo, Nelson
DFT Brown, Stephen
ATY Sooalo, Barry
DFT Dandurand, Hailey
CLK Ching, Stefanie
JUDG Somerville , Rowena

364 04/01/2021 document purchase Request for Transcript
EFile Document upload of type Request for Transcript
Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
C&C Honolulu Prosecuters-CAREER CRIMINAL DIV. 2

365 04/01/2021 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand

link: http://jimspss1.courts.state.hi.us:8080/eCourt/ECC/CaseSearch.iface

 

[Niner]

Thursday, May 6th:
*Motions Hearing for both (@ 1pm Hawaiian-Aleutian Time) - HI - Telma Boinville (51) (Dec. 6, 2017, Oahu) – *Stephen Brown (23/now 26) & *Hailey Kai Dandurand (20/now 23) arrested (12/13/17), charged & arraigned (12/18/17) with 2nd degree murder, 2 counts kidnapping & 1st degree burglary. Both plead not guilty. SB bail $1M, KD bail $500K. Bond reduction denied for HD (8/25/20).
Telma’s 8 yr. old daughter was found bound & gagged with duct tape.
Trial set to begin for both on 8/9/21 (thru 8/30/21)
Court information from 2/19/18 thru 3/5/21 reference post #89 here:
HI - Telma Boinville, 51, beaten to death, Oahu, 6 Dec 2017 *Arrests*
3/7/21 Update: Judge Rowena Somerville agreed that each case had the same evidence & number of witnesses and did not want to subject Boinville's minor daughter--the only witness to the crime-to testify at two trials. Denying State prosecutor's & Dandurand's counsel of 2 separate trials. Motion hearing for both on 3/31/21.
3/31/21 Update: Present for hearing: Judge Rowena Somerville, DPA Kyle Dowd, CA Nelson Goo, Defendant Brown waived his appearance, attorney Barry So'Oalo, defendant Dandurand. Cpl. David Kaaawa was sworn in for testimony. Witness ID'd defendant Brown w/out mask & also defendant Dandurand. Cross exam by Mr. So'Oalo. Testimony concluded. Re motion to suppress ID, Mr. Goo stated no witnesses & exhibits-already in evidence. Motion to preclude statements by minor, Mr. So'Oalo stated no witnesses & presented argument & request the Court grant same. State presented argument & requested the Court deny. Court made its findings & denied. State to prepare FOF/Col. deadline discovery 6/11/21 & motion to suppress ID, Mr. Goo presented argument & State presented argument. Court took into consideration 14 factors, made its finds & denied. Motion to preclude statements by minor, Mr. So'Oalo presented argument & requested the Court grant same. Mr. Goo joined in motion, presented argument & reqruest the Court use his prior argument re minor's competency. State rested on its filings & presented argument. Court previously ruled on minor's competency & again finds mino to be competent, finds made & motion denied. Motion to compel, Court inquired re expert witnesses. Mr. So'Oalo informed the court that requests were submitted but not finalized yet & further updated the court. State requested STC in a month. Court continued Motion to Compel & set STC for 5/9/21 @ 1pm. Next motions hearing on 5/6/21.

 

[Niner]

366 05/06/2021 document purchase Document
Declaration in Support of Motion to Compel
Stephen Brown
Goo, Nelson W.S.
367 05/06/2021 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

368 05/06/2021 document purchase Findings of Fact, Conclusions
FINDINGS OF FACT, CONCLUSIONS OF LAW, AND ORDER DENYING DEFENDANT STEPHEN BROWN'S MOTION TO SUPPRESS IDENTIFICATION
Stephen Brown
Dowd, Kyle Timothy

369 05/06/2021 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

370 05/06/2021 document purchase Findings of Fact, Conclusions
FINDINGS OF FACT, CONCLUSIONS OF LAW, AND ORDER DENYING DEFENDANT HAILEY DANDURAND'S MOTION TO PRECLUDE STATEMENTS BY MINOR
Hailey Dandurand
Dowd, Kyle Timothy

371 05/06/2021 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Hailey Dandurand

372 05/06/2021 document purchase Findings of Fact, Conclusions
FINDINGS OF FACT, CONCLUSIONS OF LAW, AND ORDER DENYING DEFENDANT HAILEY DANDURAND'S MOTION TO SUPPRESS
Hailey Dandurand
Dowd, Kyle Timothy

373 05/06/2021 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Hailey Dandurand


Hearings:
Event Defendant Date Time Room Location Judge Appearance Disposition
Trial Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
08/30/2021 00:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Trial Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
08/16/2021 00:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Trial Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
08/09/2021 00:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Calendar Call Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
07/27/2021 08:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Hearing on Motion Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
05/06/2021 13:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena


link: http://jimspss1.courts.state.hi.us:8080/eCourt/ECC/CaseSearch.iface

 

[Niner]

Oops - they stuck in another hearing date....

Docket:
374 05/06/2021 Minutes
CT RPTR: B. FAXVOG 1:00-1:15 PM STC CONFERENCE HAD IN CHAMBERS - DISCUSSION RE TRIAL SCHEDULE AND EXPERT WITNESSES/FEES STILL NOT FILED BY MR. SO'OALO. 1:22-1:31 PM CASE CALLED AND APPEARANCES WERE ENTERED BY COUNSEL AND DEFENDANT DANDURAND. DEFENDANT BROWN NOT PRESENT. CT WAIVED DEFENDANT BROWN'S PRESENCE FOR PURPOSES OF THIS HEARING. CT STATED IT WAS IN RECEIPT OF THE M/COMPEL AS WELL AS THE SUPPLEMENT AND DECLARATION. MR. GOO HAD NOTHING FURTHER TO ADD TO HIS MOTION. MESSRS. DOWD AND SO'OALO HAD NOTHING FURTHER TO ADD. CT STATED ON 2/21/20, DEFENDANT DANDURAND FILED M/DETERMINE STATUS STATING SHE WAS INDIGENT AND REQUIRED THE SVCS OF DR. DUKE WAGNER, DR. MINDY MECHANIC, DR. ROBERT GEFFNER AND ATTORNEY JILL SPECTOR RE BATTERED SPOUSE DEFENSE. CT GRANTED THE MOTION AND FILED ORDER ON 4/1/20. ON 4/9/20, DEFENDANT DANDURAND FILED ITS FIRST WITNESS LIST NAMING ABOVE EXPERTS. ON 4/28/20, DEFENDANT BROWN FILED A M/COMPEL A FULL/COMPLETE COPY OF THE EXPERT REPORTS INCLUDING ANY OPINIONS OR CONCLUSIONS. SAID MOTION WAS HEARD AND GRANTED ON 5/20/20 AND THE CT ORDERED MR. SO'OALO TO PROVIDE THE REPORTS AND DOCUMENTS TO COUNSEL W/IN 7 DAYS OF RECEIPT. ON 9/30/20, DEFENDANT BROWN FILED A M/RELIEF FROM PREJUDICIAL JOINDER. ON 1/30/21, DEFENDANT BROWN FILED A M/COMPEL FOR THE REPORTS OF SAID EXPERTS. ON 3/5/21, THE CT HEARD THE M/RELIEF FROM PREJUDICIAL JOINDER AND AFTER BALANCING THE POSSIBLE PREJUDICES CLAIMED BY DEFENDANT DANDURAND, CONCLUDED THAT BOTH DEFENDANTS SHOULD BE TRIED JOINTLY AND DENIED THE MOTION PURSUANT TO TIMAS. THE CT SET A MATERIAL AND INFORMATION DISCLOSURE DEADLINE OF 6/11/21. ON 3/17/21, MR. SO'OALO FILED EX PARTE MOTIONS FOR LITIGATION EXPENSES FOR EXPERT WITNESSES WITH THE 12TH DIVISION. THIS WAS 10 MONTHS AFTER BROWN'S FIRST M/COMPEL WAS GRANTED AND 1 1/2 MONTHS AFTER BROWN'S SECOND M/COMPEL WAS FILED REQUESTING SAME DOCUMENTS. ON THE SAME DAY, THE 12TH DIVISION RETURNED SAME MOTIONS TO MR. SO'OALO INSTRUCTING HIM TO ADD EACH EXPERTS BREAKDOWN OF THEIR ESTIMATED TIME/COST AND A STMT AS TO WHY THEIR TESTIMONY WAS NECESSARY. AS OF THIS MORNING, MR. SO'OALO HAS FAILED TO FOLLOW UP WITH THE 12TH DIVISION RE HIS EX PARTE MOTIONS FOR LITIGATION EXPENSES FOR THE EXPERT WITNESSES. THE CT, HEREBY, GRANTS THE MOTION AND CLARIFIED THE MATERIAL AND INFORMATION DISCLOSURE DEADLINE OF 6/11/21 INCLUDES ANY EXPERT REPOTS, OPINIONS, FINDINGS, WITNESSES, DISCOVERY AND DOCUMENTS. CT INFORMED COUNSEL THAT IF THESE ITEMS ARE NOT TURNED OVER BY THAT DATE, SANCTIONS WILL BE CONSIDERED AND THE PRECLUSION OF EVIDENCE. CT REMINDED COUNSEL THAT TRIAL IS SET FOR 8/9/21 AND GIVEN THE AMOUNT OF JURORS NEEDED FOR THIS TRIAL, WILL NEED TO START PREPARING IN JUNE. THEREFORE, THE 6/11/21 DEADLINE DATE WILL BE STRICTLY ADHERED TO. MR. GOO TO PREPARE ORDER. MESSERS. DOWD AND SO'OALO WAIVED SIGNATURE. CONCLUDED.
Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
DPA Dowd, Kyle
CA Goo, Nelson
ATY Sooalo, Barry
DFT Dandurand, Hailey
JUDG Somerville , Rowena
CLK Ching, Stefanie


Hearings:
Event Defendant Date Time Room Location Judge Appearance Disposition
Trial Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
08/30/2021 00:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Trial Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
08/16/2021 00:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Trial Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
08/09/2021 00:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Calendar Call Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
07/27/2021 08:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Status Conference Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
06/18/2021 13:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Hearing on Motion Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
05/06/2021 13:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

link: http://jimspss1.courts.state.hi.us:8080/eCourt/ECC/CaseSearch.iface

 

[Niner]

Friday, June 19th:
*Status Conference Hearing for both (@ 1:30pm Hawaiian-Aleutian Time) - HI - Telma Boinville (51) (Dec. 6, 2017, Oahu) – *Stephen Brown (23/now 26) & *Hailey Kai Dandurand (20/now 23) arrested (12/13/17), charged & arraigned (12/18/17) with 2nd degree murder, 2 counts kidnapping & 1st degree burglary. Both plead not guilty. SB bail $1M, KD bail $500K. Bond reduction denied for HD (8/25/20).
Telma’s 8 yr. old daughter was found bound & gagged with duct tape.
Trial set to begin for both on 8/9/21 (thru 8/30/21)
Court information from 2/19/18 thru 3/7/21 reference post #92 here:
HI - Telma Boinville, 51, beaten to death, Oahu, 6 Dec 2017 *Arrests*
3/31/21 Update: Present for hearing: Judge Rowena Somerville, DPA Kyle Dowd, CA Nelson Goo, Defendant Brown waived his appearance, attorney Barry So'Oalo, defendant Dandurand. Cpl. David Kaaawa was sworn in for testimony. Witness ID'd defendant Brown w/out mask & also defendant Dandurand. Cross exam by Mr. So'Oalo. Testimony concluded. Re motion to suppress ID, Mr. Goo stated no witnesses & exhibits-already in evidence. Motion to preclude statements by minor, Mr. So'Oalo stated no witnesses & presented argument & request the Court grant same. State presented argument & requested the Court deny. Court made its findings & denied. State to prepare FOF/Col. deadline discovery 6/11/21 & motion to suppress ID, Mr. Goo presented argument & State presented argument. Court took into consideration 14 factors, made its finds & denied. Motion to preclude statements by minor, Mr. So'Oalo presented argument & requested the Court grant same. Mr. Goo joined in motion, presented argument & reqruest the Court use his prior argument re minor's competency. State rested on its filings & presented argument. Court previously ruled on minor's competency & again finds mino to be competent, finds made & motion denied. Motion to compel, Court inquired re expert witnesses. Mr. So'Oalo informed the court that requests were submitted but not finalized yet & further updated the court. State requested STC in a month. Court continued Motion to Compel & set STC for 5/9/21 @ 1pm. Next motions hearing on 5/6/21.
5/6/21: Declaration in Support of Motion to Compel for Brown. Findings of fact, conclusions of law & order denying defendant Brown's motion to suppress identification. Findings of fact, conclusions of law & order denying defendant Dandurand's motion to preclude statements by minor & order denying motion to suppress. Status conference held in chambers; discussion re trial schedule & expert witnesses; fees still not filed by mr. So'Oalo. President counsel for Dandurand, defendant Brown not present. Court waived Browns' presence for purposes of this hearing. Court stated i was in receipt of the Motion to Compel as well as the supplement & declaration. Mr. Goo had nothing further to add to his motion. Dowd & So'Oalo had nothing further to add. Court stated on 2/21/20 Dandurand filed motion to determin status, stating she was indigent & required the services of Dr. Duke wagner, Dr. Mindy Mechanic, Dr. Robert Geffner & attorney Jill Spector re battered spouse defense. Court granted the motion & filed order on 4/1/20. On 4/9/20 Dandurand filed its first witness list naming the above experts. On 4/28/20, Brown filed a motion to compel, a full/complete copy of expert reports including any opions or conclusions. Said motion was heard & granted on 5/20/20 & the Court ordered Mr. So'Oalo to provide the reports & documents to counsel within 7 days of receipt. On 9/30/20, Brown filed a motion for relief from prejudicial joinder. On 1/30/21, Bron filed a motion to compel for the reports of said expert. On 3/5/21, the Court heard the Motion for relief from prejudicial joinder & after balancing the possible prejudices claimed by Dandurand, concluded that both defendants should be tried jointly & denied the motion pursuant to Timas. The court set a material & information disclosure deadline of 6/11/21. On 3/17/21, Mr. So'Oalo filed ex parte motions for litigation expenses for expert witnesses with the 12th division. This was 10 months after rown's first Motion to compel was granted & 1 1/2 months after Brown's 2nd motion to compel was filed requesting same documents. On the same day, the 12th division returned same motions to Mr. So'Oalo instructing him to add each experts breakdown of their estimated time/cost & a statement as to why their testimony was necessary. As of this morning, Mr. So'Oalo has failed to follow up with the 12th division re his ex parte motions for litigation expenses for the expert witnesses. The court, hereby, grants the motion & clarified the material & infomation disclosure deadline of 6/11/21 includes any expert reports, opinions, findings, witnesses, discovery & documents. Court informed counsel that if these items are not turned over by that date, sanctions will be considered & the preclusion of evidence. Court reminded counsel that trial is set for 8/9/21 & given the amount of jurors needed for this trial, will need to start preparing in June. Therefore, the 6/11/21 deadline date will be strictly adhered to. Mr. Goo to prepare order. Mr. Dowd & So'Oalo waived signature. Next status conference hearing on 6/18/21 @ 1:30pm.

 

[Niner]

Docket update - forgot to post some from last month....

375 05/13/2021 document purchase Motion for ___________
Prosecutions Motion to Compel Fingerprint Exemplars and Allow Law Enforcement to Photograph Defendant Stephen Brown
Stephen Brown
C&C Honolulu Prosecuters-CAREER CRIMINAL DIV. 2

376 05/13/2021 document purchase Motion for ___________
Prosecutions Motion to Compel Fingerprint Exemplars and Allow Law Enforcement to Photograph Defendant Hailey Dandurand
Hailey Dandurand
C&C Honolulu Prosecuters-CAREER CRIMINAL DIV. 2

377 05/13/2021 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand

378 05/24/2021 document purchase Order Granted
ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANT STEPHEN BROWN'S MOTION TO COMPEL
Stephen Brown
Goo, Nelson W.S.

379 05/24/2021 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

381 05/27/2021 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Hailey Dandurand

383 06/02/2021 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Hailey Dandurand

384 06/04/2021 Minutes
CTRPTR: S. YOU 9:02-9:18 AM CASE CALLED AND APPEARANCES WERE ENTERED BY COUNSEL AND DEFENDANT DANDURAND IN CUSTODY. DEFENDANT BROWN NOT PRESENT. MR. GOO EXPLAINED WHY. CT WAIVED DEFENDANT BROWN'S PRESENCE FOR PURPOSES OF THIS HEARING. STATE STREAMLINED MOTION AND NOTHING FURTHER TO ADD. MR. GOO OBJECTED AND PRESENTED ARGUMENT. MR. SO'OALO JOINED IN MR. GOO'S ARGUMENT. MR. GOO RAISED PRIOR M/SUPPRESS RE FINGERPRINTS ON LOUVERS. STATE PRESENTED ARGUMENT. CT INQUIRED HOW THE PROCESS WOULD BE STREAMLINED. STATE EXPLAINED REASONING. CT NOTED DUPLICATIVE AND DENIED MOTIONS. MR. GOO TO PREPARE ORDERS. MESSRS. DOWD AND SO'OALO WAIVED SIGNATURE. STC DISCUSSED RE LITIGATION EXPENSES. MR. SO'OALO UPDATED THE CT THAT REPORTS BEING TURNED OVER ON 6/9 AND WILL TURN OVER TO COUNSEL ON 6/10. MR. GOO NOTED POSSIBLE DISCOVERY RE MEDICAL. STATE INFORMED COUNSEL OF RECORDS OF PRIOR MEDICAL EXAMINER (DR. HAPPY), UPDATED THE CT AND POSSIBLE M/COMPEL T/B FILED TO OBTAIN SUCH RECORDS. IF THAT'S THE CASE, M/COMPEL WILL BE HEARD 7/9 AT 8:30 AM, RSDT 7/23. MR. GOO STATED M/SEVER NEEDS TO BE REVISITED ONCE THE DOCUMENTS ARE RECEIVED AND NOTED CLIENT NEEDS MORE TIME. CT REMINDED COUNSEL STC 6/18/21 AT 1:30 PM WILL BE VIA TELEPHONE. CONCLUDED.
Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
DPA Dowd, Kyle Timothy
CA Goo, Nelson W.S.
ATY Sooalo, Barry Lloyd
DFT Dandurand, Hailey
CLK Ching, Stefanie
JUDG Somerville , Rowena

385 06/07/2021 document purchase Order Denied
ORDER DENYING PROSECUTION'S MOTION TO COMPEL FINGERPRINT EXEMPLARS AND TO ALLOW LAW ENFORCEMENT TO PHOTOGRAPH DEFENDANT STEPHEN BROWN
Stephen Brown
Goo, Nelson W.S.

386 06/07/2021 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

Link: http://jimspss1.courts.state.hi.us:8080/eCourt/ECC/CaseSearch.iface


The hearing part does NOT have 7/9/21 as a hearing - but will put it there anyway. I'm going to wait for them to update the court site for the 6/18/21 hearing & then I'll move it to July in my notes.

 

[Niner]

for both:

Docket:
389 06/18/2021 Minutes
STATUS CONFERENCE HAD; COUNSEL PRESENT. CT RCVD MOTION TO COMPEL; HEARING DATE 7/9/2021 AT 8:30AM. PHASE 2 PENDING RPT THAT WILL BE PRODUCED. TRIAL CALL 7/27/2021; TW 8/9/2021 PROBABLY CONTINUED.
Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand

387 06/21/2021 document purchase Motion to Compel Discovery
EFile Document upload of type Motion to Compel Discovery
Stephen Brown
Goo, Nelson W.S.

388 06/21/2021 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

Hearings:
Event Defendant Date Time Room Location Judge Appearance Disposition
Trial Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
08/30/2021 00:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena
Trial Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand

08/16/2021 00:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena
Trial Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand

08/09/2021 00:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena
Calendar Call Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand

07/27/2021 08:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena
Hearing on Motion Hailey Dandurand
Stephen Brown

07/09/2021 08:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena
Status Conference Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand

06/18/2021 13:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

link: http://jimspss1.courts.state.hi.us:8080/eCourt/ECC/CaseSearch.iface

 

[Niner]

Friday, July 9th:
*Motions Hearing for both (@ 8:30am Hawaiian-Aleutian Time) - HI - Telma Boinville (51) (Dec. 6, 2017, Oahu) – *Stephen Brown (23/now 26) & *Hailey Kai Dandurand (20/now 23) arrested (12/13/17), charged & arraigned (12/18/17) with 2nd degree murder, 2 counts kidnapping & 1st degree burglary. Both plead not guilty. SB bail $1M, KD bail $500K. Bond reduction denied for HD (8/25/20).
Telma’s 8 yr. old daughter was found bound & gagged with duct tape.
Trial set to begin for both on 8/9/21 (thru 8/30/21)
Court information from 2/19/18 thru 5/6/21 reference post #95 here:
HI - Telma Boinville, 51, beaten to death, Oahu, 6 Dec 2017 *Arrests*
5/6/21 Update: Next status conference hearing on 6/18/21 @ 1:30pm. 5/13/21 Update: Prosecutions Motion to compel fingerprint exemplars & allow law enforcement to photograph defendant Brown & Dandurand. 5/24/21: Granting defendant Brown's motion to compel. 6/4/21 Update: Case was called & appearances by DPA Kyle Dowd, CA Nelson Goo, attorney Barry So’Oalo & defendant Dandurand. Defendant Brown not present. Mr. Goo explained why. Court waived defendant Brown's presence for purposes of this hearing. State streamlined motion & nothing further to add. Mr. Goo objected & presented argument. Mr. So'Oalo joined in Mr. Goo's argument. Mr. Goo raised prior motion to suppress re fingerprints on Louvers. State presented argument. Court inquired how the process would be streamlined. State explained reasoning. Court noted duplicative & denied motions. Mr. Goo to prepare orders. Attorneys Dowd & So'Oalo waived signature. Mr. So'Oalo updated the court that reports being turned on 6/9 & will turn over to counsel on 6/10. Mr. Goo noted possible discovery re medical. State informed counsel of records of prior medical examiner (Dr. Happy), updated the court & possible motion to compel to be filed to obtain such records. If that's the case, motion to compel will be heard 7/9/21 at 8:30am & RSDT hearing on 7/23/21. Mr. Goo stated motion to sever needs to be revisited once the documents are received & noted client needs more time. Court reminded counsel of status conference hearing on 6/18/21 will be via telephone.
6/18/21 Update: Status conference was held. Court received Motion to Compel will be at motions hearing on 7/9/21. Phase 2 pending report that will be produced. Trial on 8/9/21 will probably be continued.

 

[Niner]

Hearings:
Event Defendant Date Time Room Location Judge Appearance Disposition
Trial Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
08/30/2021 00:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Trial Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
08/16/2021 00:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Trial Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
08/09/2021 00:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Calendar Call Stephen Brown
Hailey Dandurand
07/27/2021 08:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Hearing on Motion Hailey Dandurand
Stephen Brown
07/09/2021 08:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

link: http://jimspss1.courts.state.hi.us:8080/eCourt/ECC/CaseSearch.iface

 

[Niner]

Tuesday, July 27th:
*Calendar Call Hearing for both (@ 8:30am Hawaiian-Aleutian Time) - HI - Telma Boinville (51) (Dec. 6, 2017, Oahu) – *Stephen Brown (23/now 26) & *Hailey Kai Dandurand (20/now 23) arrested (12/13/17), charged & arraigned (12/18/17) with 2nd degree murder, 2 counts kidnapping & 1st degree burglary. Both plead not guilty. SB bail $1M, KD bail $500K. Bond reduction denied for HD (8/25/20).
Telma’s 8 yr. old daughter was found bound & gagged with duct tape.
Trial set to begin for both on 8/9/21 (thru 8/30/21)
Court information from 2/19/18 thru 5/13/21 reference post #98 here:
HI - Telma Boinville, 51, beaten to death, Oahu, 6 Dec 2017 *Arrests*
6/18/21 Update: Status conference was held. Court received Motion to Compel will be at motions hearing on 7/9/21. Phase 2 pending report that will be produced. Trial on 8/9/21 will probably be continued. 7/9/21 Update: Next Calendar Call hearing on 7/27/21.