GUILTY HI - Telma Boinville, 51, beaten to death, Oahu, 6 Dec 2017 *Arrests*

New Posts

  • #141
Docket Update - Brown:

688 01/05/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

689 01/05/2023 document purchase Findings of Fact, Conclusions
FOF/COL AND ORDER DENYING DEFENDANT STEPHEN BROWN'S SECOND MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE INTERLOCUTORY APPEAL
Stephen Brown
First Circuit Court 23rd Division
690 01/05/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

691 01/05/2023 document purchase Findings of Fact, Conclusions
FOF/COL AND ORDER DENYING DEFENDANT STEPHEN BROWN'S MOTION FOR CHANGE OF VENUE
Stephen Brown
First Circuit Court 23rd Division
692 01/05/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

693 01/05/2023 document purchase Order Denied
ORDER DENYING DEFENDANT STEPHEN BROWN'S MOTION TO CONTINUE TRIAL WEEK
Stephen Brown
First Circuit Court 23rd Division
694 01/05/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

695 01/05/2023 Minutes
FTR: CTRM 5 9:34 AM CT CONVENED W/OUT PROSPECTIVE JURORS; CASE CALLED AND APPEARANCES WERE ENTERED BY COUNSEL AND DEFENDANT IN CUSTODY. CT NOTED EARLIER DISCUSSION WITH COUNSEL RE JURY PANEL. 9:36 AM PROSPECTIVE JURORS PRESENT; CTS INTRODUCTORY REMARKS. 9:39 AM VOIR DIRE OATH ADMINISTERED. 9:46 AM CT ORDERED THE PROSPECTIVE JURORS THAT ANSWERED "NO" TO THE QUESTIONNAIRE RETURN ON FRIDAY AT 8:30 AM AND WERE EXCUSED. THE PROSPECTIVE JURORS THAT ANSWERED "YES" WERE EXCUSED BY THE CT AND WERE THANKED FOR THEIR SERVICE. 9:49 AM CT IN RECESS. ********** 9:55 AM CASE RECALLED; DEFENDANT NOT PRESENT. CT INFORMED COUNSEL OF CONFLICT WITH SEVERAL PROSPECTIVE JURORS AND ALL AGREED TO EXCUSE. 9:56 AM CT ADJOURNED.
Stephen Brown

DPA Bell, Scott Kamakea
CA Bagasol, William C.
DFT Brown, Stephen
JUDG Somerville , Rowena
CLK Ching, Stefanie


Case Event Schedule
Event Defendant Date Time Room Location Judge Appearance Disposition
Jury Trial Stephen Brown
01/13/2023 08:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Jury Trial Stephen Brown
01/12/2023 08:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Jury Trial Stephen Brown
01/10/2023 10:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Jury Trial Stephen Brown
01/09/2023 08:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Jury Trial Stephen Brown
01/06/2023 08:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Jury Trial Stephen Brown
01/05/2023 08:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena CON-Continued


link: http://jimspss1.courts.state.hi.us:8080/eCourt/ECC/CaseSearch.iface
 
  • #142
Friday, January 6th:
*Trial continues (Day 4) with Jury Selection (@ 8am Hawaiian-Aleutian Time) - HI - Telma Boinville (51) (Dec. 6, 2017, Oahu) – only for *Stephen Brown (23/now 28) arrested (12/13/17), charged & arraigned (12/18/17) with 2nd degree murder, 4 counts kidnapping, 1st degree burglary & criminal property damage. Plead not guilty Bond $1M.
Trial began on 1/3/23 for Brown only with Jury Selection. The prosecutor’s office said they expect the process to last through this week, with opening statements to begin Monday, 1/9/23. But former Attorney General Doug Chin said jury selection may take longer.
Court information from 2/19/18 thru 1/2/23 & Jury Selection Days 1-2 (1/3 to 1/4/23) reference post #139 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...o-death-oahu-6-dec-2017-arrests.359003/page-7
1/5/23 Thursday, Day 3: #688 to #690: Findings of Fact, conclusions. and Order denying defendant Brown's 2nd motion for leave to file interlocutory appeal. #691 & #692: Findings of Fact, conclusions & order denying defendant Browns motion for change of venue. #693 & #694: Order denying defendant Brown's motion to continue trial week. #695: Court convened without prospective jurors; case called & appearances were entered by Counsel & defendant in custody. Court noted earlier discussion with counsel re jury panel. Prospective jurors present. Court's introductory remarks. Voir dire oath administered. Court ordered the prospective jurors that answered "no" to the questionnaire return on Friday, 1/6/23 & were excused. The prospective jurors that answered "yes" were excused by the Court & were thanked for their service. Defendant not present. Court informed Counsel of conflict with several prospective jurors & all agreed to excuse. Court adjourned. Jury selection continues on 1/6/23.
*Hailey Kai Dandurand (20/now 25) – Next Calendar Call hearing on 6/27/23.
 
  • #143
www.hawaiinewsnow.com

Jury selection underway in gruesome North Shore kidnapping, murder

The trial of accused killer and kidnapper Stephen Brown begins this week.
www.hawaiinewsnow.com www.hawaiinewsnow.com

Jan. 6, 2022

HONOLULU (HawaiiNewsNow) - Jury selection is underway in the gruesome 2017 murder of a woman on Oahu’s North Shore.

The trial of accused killer and kidnapper Stephen Brown begins this week.
[.....]
The Honolulu Star-Advertiser reported that 35 people selected for jury duty were “no shows” Tuesday.

Due to this being a high profile case, a large pool of potential jurors was selected and 450 summonses were sent out.
 
  • #144
Brown:

696 01/06/2023 Minutes
FTR: CTRM 5 8:40 AM CT CONVENED W/OUT PROSPECTIVE JURORS PRESENT; CASE CALLED AND APPEARANCES WERE ENTERED BY COUNSEL AND DEFENDANT IN CUSTODY. DEFENSE INFORMED THE CT OF DEFENDANT'S CONCERNS RE PRE-TRIAL PUBLICITY. CT STATED IT WOULD QUESTION THE JURORS IF IT BECOMES AN ISSUE. 8:42 AM PRE-TRIAL JURY SELECTION COMMENCED. 8:50 AM CT IN RECESS. ********** 9:02 AM CT RECONVENED W/OUT PROSPECTIVE JURORS PRESENT; PROSPECTIVE JUROR KEMP INFORMED THE CT OF CONFLICT OF INTEREST AND CANNOT SERVE FOR TRIAL. CT EXCUSED. 9:04 AM CT IN RECESS. ********** 9:10 AM CT RECONVENED W/PROSPECTIVE JURORS PRESENT. 9:15 AM CTS INTRODUCTORY REMARKS; JURY SELECTION COMMENCED. 10:05 AM CT IN RECESS. ********** 10:24 AM CT RECONVENED W/PROSPECTIVE JURORS PRESENT; CONT. OF JURY SELECTION. 11:00 AM PROSPECTIVE JURORS EXCUSED; STATE CHALLENGED 4 JURORS AND PRESENTED ARGUMENT. DEFENSE AGREED WITH ONE BUT OBJECTED TO REMAINING 3. CT MADE ITS FINDINGS AND EXCUSED 3; REPLACEMENT MADE. DEFENSE OBJECTED TO STATE GETTING INTO ISSUES OF ABUSE, MADE ORAL M/MISTRIAL AND PRESENTED ARGUMENT. STATE PRESENTED ARGUMENT. CT MADE ITS FINDINGS, NOTED OBJECTION AND DENIED M/MISTRIAL. 11:13 AM CT IN RECESS. ********** 11:18 AM CT RECONVENED W/PROSPECTIVE JURORS PRESENT; CONT. OF JURY SELECTION. 12:09 PM PROSPECTIVE JURORS EXCUSED FOR LUNCH. 12:11 PM ARGUMENTS HAD BY COUNSEL RE POSSIBLE CHALLENGE. CT MADE ITS FINDINGS AND EXPLAINED SUSTAINED OBJECTION. 12:23 PM CT IN RECESS. ********** 1:15 PM CT RECONVENED W/OUT PROSPECTIVE JURORS PRESENT. CONCERNS RAISED ON RECESS RE PROSPECTIVE JUROR MEDICAL CONDITION. CT EXCUSED. 1:22 PM PROSPECTIVE JURORS PRESENT; CONT. OF JURY SELECTION.
Stephen Brown

DFT Brown, Stephen
DPA Bell, Scott
CA Bagasol, William
JUDG Somerville , Rowena
CLK Ching, Stefanie


Case Event Schedule
Event Defendant Date Time Room Location Judge Appearance Disposition
Jury Trial Stephen Brown
01/13/2023 08:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Jury Trial Stephen Brown
01/12/2023 08:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Jury Trial Stephen Brown
01/10/2023 10:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Jury Trial Stephen Brown
01/09/2023 08:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Jury Trial Stephen Brown
01/06/2023 08:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena CON-Continued

link: http://jimspss1.courts.state.hi.us:8080/eCourt/ECC/CaseSearch.iface
 
  • #145
Monday, January 9th:
*Trial continues (Day 5) with Jury Selection (@ 8:30am Hawaiian-Aleutian Time) - HI - Telma Boinville (51) (Dec. 6, 2017, Oahu) – for *Stephen Brown (23/now 28) arrested (12/13/17), charged & arraigned (12/18/17) with 2nd degree murder, 4 counts kidnapping, 1st degree burglary & criminal property damage. Plead not guilty Bond $1M.
Trial began on 1/3/23 for Brown only with Jury Selection. The prosecutor’s office said they expect the process to last through this week, with opening statements to begin Monday, 1/9/23. But former Attorney General Doug Chin said jury selection may take longer.
Court information from 2/19/18 thru 1/2/23 & Jury Selection Days 1-3 (1/3 to 1/5/23) reference post #142 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...o-death-oahu-6-dec-2017-arrests.359003/page-8
1/6/23 Friday, Jury Selection Day 4: Court said that 35 people selected for jury duty were “no shows” Tuesday, 1/3/23. Due to this being a high profile case, a large pool of potential jurors was selected & 450 summonses were sent out. Court convened without prospective jurors present; case called & appearances were entered by Counsel & defendant in custody. Defense informed the Court of defendant's concerns re pretrial publicity. Court stated it would question the jurors if it becomes an issue. Jury selection commenced. Court in recess. Court reconvened without prospective jurors present; prospective Juror Kemp informed Court of conflict of interest & cannot serve for trial Court excused. Court in recess. Court reconvenes with prospective jurors present. Court introductory remarks; jury selection commenced. Court in recess & prospective jurors present. Jury selection continues. Prospective jurors excused. State challenged 4 jurors & presented argument. Defense agreed with one but objected to remaining 3. Court made its findings & excused 3; replacement made. Defense objected to State getting into issues of abuse, made oral motion for mistrial & presented argument. State presented argument. Court made its findings, noted objection & denied motion for mistrial. Court reconvened with prospective jurors present; jury selection continues. Prospective jurors excused for lunch; Arguments had by Counsel re possible challenge. Court made its findings & explained sustained objection. Court reconvened without prospective jurors present. Concerns raised in recess re prospective juror medical condition.
Jury selection continues on Monday, 1/9/23 @ 8:30am.
*Hailey Kai Dandurand (20/now 25) – Next Calendar Call hearing on 6/27/23. Trial set to begin on 7/10/23.
 
  • #146
  • #147
Case Event Schedule
Event Defendant Date Time Room Location Judge
697 01/09/2023 Minutes
CTRPTR: N. CHEANG 8:48 AM CT CONVENED W/OUT PROSPECTIVE JURORS PRESENT; CASE CALLED AND APPEARANCES WERE ENTERED BY COUNSEL AND DEFENDANT IN CUSTODY. DEFENSE INFORMED THE CT THAT DEFENDANT WOULD ENTER NCP AS TO CT 7. CT COLLOQUY DEFENDANT. IMMIGRATION ADVISEMENT GIVEN. COUNSEL STIPULATED TO FACTUAL BASIS. CT FINDS SUFFICIENT FACTUAL BASIS EXISTS FOR PLEA. DEFENDANT ENTERED NCP IN CT 7. CT FINDS DEFENDANT WAIVED HIS RIGHT TO A TRIAL AND ENTERED HIS PLEA KNOWINGLY, INTELLIGENTLY AND VOLUNTARILY WITH THE UNDERSTANDING OF THE NATURE OF THE CHARGE AND THE CONSEQUENCE OF HIS PLEA, ACCEPTED HIS PLEA AND ADJUDGED HIM GUILTY AS CHARGED IN CT 7. CT SCHEDULED SENTENCING FOR 4/26/23 AT 1:00 PM AND ORDERED DEFENDANT TO COOPERATE IN PREPARING THE PSI REPORT. DEFENSE MADE AN ORAL M/RECONSIDERATION RE EVIDENTIARY PORTION RE CPD MATTERS AND PRESENTED ARGUMENT. STATE PRESENTED ARGUMENT. CT MADE ITS FINDINGS AND WILL EXCLUDE BUT STATE CAN LEAD. 9:00 AM PROSPECTIVE JURORS PRESENT; CONT. OF JURY SELECTION. 9:42 AM JURY EMPANELLED; VERDICT OATH ADMINISTERED. 9:46 AM CT THANKED AND EXCUSED REMAINING PROSPECTIVE JURORS. CTS PRELIMINARY INSTRUCTIONS. 9:52 AM WITNESS EXCLUSIONARY RULE INVOKED. 9:53 AM CT IN RECESS. ********** 10:13 AM CT RECONVENED W/JURY PRESENT. 10:15 AM STATE'S OPENING STATEMENTS. 10:39 AM DEFENSE'S OPENING STATEMENTS. 10:53 AM CT IN RECESS. ********** 10:58 AM CT RECONVENED W/OUT JURY PRESENT. DEFENSE RAISED DEFENDANT'S PRIOR RECORD. DEFENDANT AGREED AS TO TRIAL STRATEGY. STATE PRESENTED ARGUMENTS. CT MADE ITS FINDINGS THAT IT IS DEFENSE'S TACTICAL DECISION AS PART OF TRIAL STRATEGY TO INCLUDE PRIOR CONVICTION WITH DEFENDANT'S CONSENT. CT FURTHER FINDS DEFENDANT KNOWINGLY, INTELLIGENTLY AND VOLUNTARILY WAIVED MIL #1(1) RE EXCLUSION OF PRIOR RECORD AND DEFENSE WDW SAME; ALSO MIL #3(A) RE OTHER WRONGS, CRIMES OR ACTS GRTD. ARGUMENTS HAD RE PHOTO EVIDENCE. CTS FINDINGS MADE AND STATED PREVIOUS RULING STILL STANDS. 11:10 AM JURY PRESENT. 11:11 AM CPL ZACHARY PLEVEL WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 11:15 AM STATE'S EXHIBITS 22-48 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE; STATE'S EXHIBITS 39 & 40 OVER DEFENSE'S OBJECTION. 11:20 AM CROSS EXAMINATION; TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 11:21 AM KAY TOMASA WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 11:35 AM CROSS EXAMINATION. 11:36 AM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 11:37 AM MICHAEL LYNCH WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 11:43 AM STATE'S EXHIBIT 2 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 11:46 AM STATE'S EXHIBITS 49-60 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 11:50 AM STATE'S EXHIBIT 3 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 11:53 AM STATE'S EXHIBITS 61-73 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 11:57 AM STATE'S EXHIBITS 74-85 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 12:00 PM CT IN RECESS. ********** 1:05 PM CT RECONVENED WITH JURY PRESENT. 1:06 PM CONT. OF TESTIMONY OF MICHAEL LYNCH. 1:08 PM STATE'S EXHIBITS 86-101 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 1:13 PM STATE'S EXHIBITS 102-113 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 1:26 PM STATE'S EXHIBITS 114-147 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE; STATE'S EXHIBITS 123, 124, 128-130, 132, 133, 136-139, 143, 144 OVER DEFENSE'S OBJECTION. 1:35 PM STATE'S EXHIBIT 4 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 1:37 PM STATE'S EXHIBITS 148-157 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 1:42 PM STATE'S EXHIBITS 158-167 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 1:45 PM STATE'S EXHIBITS 168-180 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 1:48 PM STATE'S EXHIBITS 181-184 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 1:52 PM STATE'S EXHIBIT 456 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE OVER DEFENSE'S OBJECTION. 1:53 PM STATE'S EXHIBIT 457 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE OVER DEFENSE'S OBJECTION. 1:54 PM STATE'S EXHIBIT 458 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE OVER DEFENSE'S OBJECTION. 1:56 PM STATE'S EXHIBIT 459 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE OVER DEFENSE'S OBJECTION. 1:57 PM STATE'S EXHIBIT 460 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE OVER DEFENSE'S OBJECTION. 1:58 PM STATE'S EXHIBIT 461 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE OVER DEFENSE'S OBJECTION. 2:00 PM STATE'S EXHIBIT 464 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 2:01 PM STATE'S EXHIBIT 468 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 2:02 PM STATE'S EXHIBIT 470 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 2:04 PM STATE'S EXHIBIT 465 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 2:05 PM STATE'S EXHIBIT 469 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 2:09 PM STATE'S EXHIBITS 185-191, 202, 203 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 2:12 PM STATE'S EXHIBITS 192-201, 204 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE OVER DEFENSE'S OBJECTION. 2:22 PM WITNESS ID DEFENDANT. 2:24 PM CT IN RECESS. ********** 2:43 PM CT RECONVENED WITH JURY PRESENT. 2:44 PM CROSS EXAMINATION OF MICHAEL LYNCH. 2:47 PM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 2:49 PM ASTRID CAZANAVE WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 2:55 PM CROSS EXAMINATION. 3:02 PM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 3:03 PM SABINA FOLGOSI WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 3:14 PM CROSS EXAMINATION. 3:15 PM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 3:17 PM WILIAM BELYEU WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 3:23 PM CROSS EXAMINATION; TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 3:24 PM SHANE ATKINS WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 3:36 PM CROSS EXAMINATION. 3:37 PM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 3:38 PM GARRICK BALIGAD WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 3:42 PM STATE'S EXHIBIT 1 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 3:44 PM STATE'S EXHIBITS 205-212 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 3:48 PM STATE'S EXHIBITS 213-227 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 3:53 PM STATE'S EXHIBITS 228-230 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 3:55 PM STATE'S EXHIBITS 231-240 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 4:00 PM STATE'S EXHIBITS 241-250 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE; STATE'S EXHIBIT 249 OVER DEFENSE'S OBJECTION. 4:03 PM STATE'S EXHIBIT 475 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE OVER DEFENSE OBJECTION. 4:05 PM STATE'S EXHIBIT 471 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 4:07 PM STATE'S EXHIBIT 472 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 4:08 PM STATE'S EXHIBIT 473 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 4:10 PM STATE'S EXHIBIT 474 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE.
Stephen Brown

DPA Bell, Scott
CA Bagasol, William
DFT Brown, Stephen
CLK Ching, Stefanie
JUDG

Case Event Schedule
Event Defendant Date Time Room Location Judge Appearance Disposition
Jury Trial Stephen Brown
01/13/2023 08:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Jury Trial Stephen Brown
01/12/2023 08:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Jury Trial Stephen Brown
01/10/2023 10:00:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Jury Trial Stephen Brown
01/09/2023 08:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena CON-Continued


link: http://jimspss1.courts.state.hi.us:8080/eCourt/ECC/CaseSearch.iface
 
Last edited:
  • #148
Tuesday, January 10th:
*Trial continues (Day 2) (@ 10am Hawaiian-Aleutian Time) - HI - Telma Boinville (51) (Dec. 6, 2017, Oahu) – for *Stephen Brown (23/now 28) arrested (12/13/17), charged & arraigned (12/18/17) with 2nd degree murder, 4 counts kidnapping, 1st degree burglary & criminal property damage. Plead not guilty Bond $1M.
Trial began on 1/3/23 for Brown only with Jury Selection & ended 1/9/23. Trial began on 1/9/23.
Court information from 2/19/18 thru 1/2/23 & Jury Selection Days 1-4 (1/3 to 1/6/23) reference post #145 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...o-death-oahu-6-dec-2017-arrests.359003/page-8
1/9/23 Monday, Jury Selection Day 5 & Trial Day 1: #697: Court convened without prospective jurors present; case called & appearances were entered by Counsel & defendant in custody. Defense informed the Court that defendant would enter NCP as to Count 7. Court colloquy defendant. Immigration advisement given. Counsel stipulated to factual basis. Court finds sufficient factual basis exists for plea. Defendant entered NCP in Count 7. Court finds defendant waived his right to a trial & entered his plea knowingly, intelligently & voluntarily with the understanding of the nature of the charge & the consequence of his plea, accept his plea & adjudged him guilty as charged in Court 7. Court scheduled sentencing for 4/26/23 @ 1pm & ordered defendant to cooperate in preparing the PSI report. Defense made an oral motion reconsideration re evidentiary portion re CPD matters & presented argument. State presented argument. Court made its findings & will exclude but State can lead. Prospective jurors present; continue of jury selection. Jury empanelled; verdict oath administered. Court thanked & excused remaining prospective jurors. Courts preliminary instructions. Witness exclusionary rule invoked. Court in recess. Court reconvened with jury present. State's opening statements. Defense's opening statements. Court in recess. Court reconvened without jury present. Defense raised defendant's prior record. Defendant agreed as to trial strategy. State presented arguments. Court made its findings that it is defense's tactical decision as part of trial strategy to include prior conviction with defendants consent. Court further finds defendant knowingly, intelligently & voluntarily waived MIL #1(1) re exclusion of prior record & defense WDW same. Also previous ruling still stands. Jury present. State's witnesses: Cpl. Zachary Plevel. Kay Tomasa. Michael Lynch. Astrid Cazanave. Sabina Folgosi. William Belyeu. Garrick Baligad. State's exhibits marked & received into evidence. Jury selection continues on Tuesday, 1/10/23 @ 10am.
*Hailey Kai Dandurand (20/now 25) – Next Calendar Call hearing on 6/27/23. THERE Trial set to begin on 7/10/23.
 
  • #149
JerseyGirl said:
www.staradvertiser.com

Murder trial begins in brutal 2017 North Shore killing | Honolulu Star-Advertiser

The long-anticipated murder trial of suspect Stephen Brown got underway this morning with Brown’s attorney William Bagasol asserting in court that Brown’s ex-girlfriend Hailey Dandurand — not Brown — is responsible for the slaying of a North Shore woman in December 2017.
www.staradvertiser.com
Click to expand...
Ok, that’s his defense?
I don’t think it’s going to fly with a jury but we will see..

“..Brown’s attorney William Bagasol asserting in court that Brown’s ex-girlfriend Hailey Dandurand — not Brown — is responsible for the slaying of a North Shore woman in December 2017.”
 
  • #150
for Brown:
Count 7 HRS 708-823(1) - Criminal Prop Damage IV-Knowingly damages
Severity: PM - Petty Misdemeanor
Ofs Dt : 12/07/2017
Citation/Arrest #: 17462026-009

Plead No Contest on 1/9/23. Judge takes plea as guilty. Sentencing hearing on 4/26/23 @ 1pm.
 
  • #151
everybodhi said:
Ok, that’s his defense?
I don’t think it’s going to fly with a jury but we will see..

“..Brown’s attorney William Bagasol asserting in court that Brown’s ex-girlfriend Hailey Dandurand — not Brown — is responsible for the slaying of a North Shore woman in December 2017.”
Click to expand...
Both of their defenses are senseless.
News articles point out that Brown LICKED blood from his hand while in police custody, and smiled at news cameras. His co-defendant also smirked & smiled for cameras, and was wearing Telma's earrings while having her debit card in her shirt pocket.
Also in the news: they told the 8 year old daughter, "We killed your mom!"
I don't care what drugs they were on or what relationship issues may or may not have taken place... these two are PURE evil. IMO. I have known plenty of people who use drugs and aren't murderers, many who wouldn't hurt a fly. NO excuse for this.
 
  • #152
www.hawaiinewsnow.com

Opening statements begin in brutal North Shore kidnapping, murder

Telma Boinville was found dead in a North Shore home in 2017.
www.hawaiinewsnow.com www.hawaiinewsnow.com

Jan 9, 2023

HONOLULU (HawaiiNewsNow) - Opening statements began on Monday in the trial of Stephen Brown for the murder of Telma Boinville, who was found dead in a North Shore home in 2017.

The 12-person jury trial started around 10:15 a.m. before First Circuit Court Judge Rowena Somerville.

State Prosecutor Scott Bell started opening arguments, laying out to the jury the events that led up to Boinville’s death, making his case as to why the two suspects — Stephen Brown and Hailey Dandurand — are responsible for her murder.
[.....]
The prosecution told the jury Boinville’s 8-year-old daughter was later able to identify the two suspects — after police took them into custody — as the ones who were in the home when her mom went in to clean the house.
 
  • #153
Case Parties
Seq # Assoc Expn Date Type ID Name / Aliases
698 01/10/2023 document purchase Order
Stephen Brown
First Circuit Court 23rd Division
699 01/10/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

700 01/10/2023 Minutes
CTRPTR: H. HO 9:39 AM CT CONVENED WITH JURY PRESENT; CASE CALLED AND APPEARANCES WERE ENTERED BY COUNSEL AND DEFENDANT IN CUSTODY. (9:39-9:52 MEDIA SET UP) 9:53 AM DANIEL JUSTICE WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 10:02 AM STATE'S EXHIBITS 360-363 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 10:09 AM CROSS EXAMINATION. 10:15 AM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 10:16 AM OFCR AARON EVELAND WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 10:25 AM STATE'S EXHIBITS 251-253 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 10:32 AM STATE'S EXHIBIT 254 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED OVER DEFENSE'S OBJECTION. 10:33 AM WITNESS IDENTIFIED DEFENDANT. 10:34 AM CROSS EXAMINATION. 10:41 AM REDIRECT. 10:42 AM RECROSS; TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 10:44 AM OFCR TAVO TUPOLA WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 10:49 AM CROSS EXAMINATION. 10:50 AM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 10:51 AM MANDA TAN WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 10:54 AM STATE'S EXHIBIT 6 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 10:56 AM STATE'S EXHIBITS 255-271 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 11:02 AM CROSS EXAMINATION. 11:05 AM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED; CT IN RECESS. ********** 11:20 AM CT RECONVENED WITH JURY PRESENT. 11:21 AM OFCR RONALD LOMBARDI WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 11:28 AM CROSS EXAMINATION. 11:29 AM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 11:30 AM SGT. DEREK PA WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 11:35 AM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 11:36 AM DET. ROBERT JONES WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 11:42 AM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 11:45 AM CT IN RECESS. ********** 1:07 PM CT RECONVENED WITH JURY PRESENT. VICTORIA SMITH WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 1:15 PM CROSS EXAMINATION. 1:17 PM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 1:18 PM SGT. CHANCE CORREA WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 1:22 PM STATE'S EXHIBIT 5 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 1:27 PM STATE'S EXHIBIT 272 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 1:35 PM WITNESS IDENTIFIED DEFENDANT. 1:37 PM CROSS EXAMINATION. 1:46 PM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 1:47 PM CPL. BRYCE KIM WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 1:56 PM STATE'S EXHIBIT 463 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 1:57 PM WITNESS IDENTIFIED DEFENDANT. 2:01 PM CROSS EXAMINATION. 2:10 PM CT IN RECESS. ********** 2:16 PM CT RECONVENED W/OUT JURY PRESENT. DEFENSE STATED HE DISCUSSED HIS MIL WITH DEFENDANT AND WITH DEFENDANT'S PERMISSION, WILL OPEN THAT DOOR THAT DEFENDANT WAS UNDER THE INFLUENCE. CT NOTED PREVIOUS OBJECTION AND CONFIRMED THAT DEFENSE NOW INTENDS TO BRING OUT THAT INFORMATION FROM WITNESS. STATE NOTED ANTICIPATED TESTIMONY OF CPL KIM. DEFENSE STATED THEY WOULD INTEND TO BRING INFO THROUGH ANOTHER WITNESS. CT INQUIRED RE WITNESS KIM. COUNSEL STATED HE WAS DONE WITH HIS CROSS. STATE NO REDIRECT. BAILIFF ORDERED TO EXCUSE CPL. KIM. 2:24 PM CT IN RECESS. ********** 2:26 PM CT RECONVENED WITH JURY PRESENT; OFCR AARON OSHIRO WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 2:32 PM WITNESS IDENTIFIED DEFENDANT. 2:43 PM STATE'S EXHIBITS 273-288 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE; STATE'S EXHIBITS 277 & 282 OVER DEFENSE'S OBJECTION. 2:46 PM STATE'S EXHIBITS 289-290 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 2:48 PM STATE'S EXHIBITS 291-294 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 2:49 PM CROSS EXAMINATION. 2:57 PM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 2:59 PM OFCR NAKIA NEWTON WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 3:02 PM WITNESS IDENTIFIED DEFENDANT. 3:04 PM CROSS EXAMINATION. 3:05 PM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 3:06 PM SGT. OSCAR WILLIS WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 3:16 PM STATE'S EXHIBITS 295-298 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 3:18 PM CROSS EXAMINATION. 3:21 PM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 3:23 PM CT ORDERED THE JURY TO RETURN ON THURSDAY AT 8:30 AM FOR FURTHER JURY TRIAL. CT ADJOURNED.
Stephen Brown
DPA Bell, Scott
CA Bagasol, William
DFT Brown, Stephen
JUDG Somerville , Rowena
CLK Ching, Stefanie

701 01/11/2023 Pre-Sent Investigation Ordere
Stephen Brown
First Circuit Court 23rd Division
702 01/11/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown

703 01/11/2023 document purchase No Contest Plea
Stephen Brown
First Circuit Court 23rd Division
704 01/11/2023 document purchase Notice of Electronic Filing
Stephen Brown


Case Event Schedule
Event Defendant Date Time Room Location Judge Appearance Disposition
Jury Trial Stephen Brown
01/13/2023 08:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Jury Trial Stephen Brown
01/12/2023 08:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Jury Trial Stephen Brown
01/10/2023 09:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena CON-Continued

link: http://jimspss1.courts.state.hi.us:8080/eCourt/ECC/CaseSearch.iface
 
  • #154
Thursday, January 12th:
*Trial continues (Day 3) (@ 8:30aam Hawaiian-Aleutian Time) - HI - Telma Boinville (51) (Dec. 6, 2017, Oahu) – for *Stephen Brown (23/now 28) arrested (12/13/17), charged & arraigned (12/18/17) with 2nd degree murder, 4 counts kidnapping, 1st degree burglary & criminal property damage (plead guilty to this charge). Plead not guilty Bond $1M.
Trial began on 1/3/23 for Brown only with Jury Selection & ended 1/9/23. Trial began on 1/9/23.
Count 7 Criminal Prop Damage IV-Knowingly damages; severity: PM - Petty Misdemeanor. Plead No Contest on 1/9/23. Judge takes plea as guilty. Sentencing hearing on 4/26/23 @ 1pm.
Court information from 2/19/18 thru 1/2/23 & Jury Selection Days 1-5 (1/3 to 1/9/23) & Trial Day 1 (1/9/23) reference post #148 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...o-death-oahu-6-dec-2017-arrests.359003/page-8
1/10/23 Tuesday, Trial Day 2: State witnesses: Daniel Justice. Officer Aaron Eveland. Officer Tavo Tupola. Manda Tan. Officer Ronald Lombardi. Sgt. Derek Pa. Detective Robert Jones. Victoria Smith. Sgt. Chance Correa. Cpl. Bryce Kim. Officer Aaron Oshiro. Officer Nakia Newton. Sgt. Oscar Willis. State's exhibits were marked & received into evidence.
Trial continues on Thursday, 1/12/23 @ 8:30am.
*Hailey Kai Dandurand (20/now 25) – Next Calendar Call hearing on 6/27/23. THERE Trial set to begin on 7/10/23.
 
  • #155
Case Parties
Seq # Assoc Expn Date Type ID Name / Aliases
705 01/12/2023 Minutes
CTRPTR: L. KAMALANI-MOE 8:35 AM CT CONVENED W/OUT JURY PRESENT; CASE CALLED AND APPEARANCES WERE ENTERED BY COUNSEL AND DEFENDANT IN CUSTODY. DEFENSE MADE AN ORAL M/MISTRIAL AND PRESENTED ARGUMENT. STATE OBJECTED, DEFERED TO THE CT RE INDIVIDUAL VOIR DIRE OR CURATIVE INSTRUCTION AND PRESENTED ARGUMENT. CTS FINDINGS MADE AND DENIED ORAL M/MISTRIAL. CT FINDS INDIVIDUAL VOIR DIRE NOT NECESSARY BUT WILL GIVE CURATIVE INSTRUCTION. 8:46 AM JURY PRESENT. 8:48 AM CTS CURATIVE INSTRUCTION. 8:49 AM DR. MICHAEL DUNG WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 8:51 AM CT QUALIFIED WITNESS TO TESTIFY AS AN EXPERT IN THE AREA OF INTERNAL MEDICINE. 8:57 AM CROSS EXAMINATION. 8:58 AM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 8:59 AM OFCR CHRISTOPHER YOUNG WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 9:08 AM CROSS EXAMINATION. 9:13 AM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 9:14 AM CPL. DAVID KAAWA WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 9:19 AM STATE'S EXHIBIT 30 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 9:21 AM CROSS EXAMINATION. 9:25 AM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 9:26 AM FGT. KENDRICK TAHARA WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 9:31 AM WITNESS IDENTIFIED DEFENDANT. 9:33 AM CROSS EXAMINATION. 9:40 AM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 9:41 AM OFCR KENT LAREAU WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 9:50 AM STATE'S EXHIBIT 454 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 9:54 AM CT IN RECESS. ********** 10:18 AM CT RECONVENED W/OUT JURY PRESENT. DEFENSE STATED HE WANTED TO RECALL CPL. KAAWA RE STATEMENTS MADE BY DANDURAND. DEFENDANT AFFIRMED. CT FINDS DEFENDANT KNOWINGLY, INTELLIGENTLY AND VOLUNTARILY ACKNOWLEDGED PART OF TRIAL STRATEGY. STATE NOTED ITS POSITION. CT WILL ALLOW AS PART OF DEFENSE'S TRIAL STRATEGY. 10:20 AM JURY PRESENT. 10:22 AM CONT. OF TESTIMONY OF OFCR LAREAU. 10:25 AM REDIRECT. 10:26 AM STATE'S EXHIBI 455 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 10:27 AM CROSS EXAMINATION; TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 10:28 AM RECROSS OF CPL. KAAWA. 10:29 AM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 10:30 AM MACKENZIE OMALZA WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 10:37 AM CROSS EXAMINATION. 10:40 AM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 10:42 AM FRANCES HILL WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 10:50 AM STATE'S EXHIBIT 476 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 10:52 AM CROSS EXAMINATION. 10:59 AM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 11:00 AM OFCR ALLEN-JOHN VERGARA WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 11:02 AM WITNESS IDENTIFIED DEFENDANT. 11:03 AM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 11:04 AM LESLIE MURAKAMI WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 11:09 AM STATE'S EXHIBITS 342-352 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 11:13 AM STATE'S EXHIBIT 466 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 11:15 AM STATE'S EXHIBITS 353-359 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 11:25 AM CROSS EXAMINATION. 11:30 AM REDIRECT. 11:32 AM RECROSS; TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 11:33 AM CT IN RECESS. ********** 12:59 PM CT RECONVENED W/OUT JURY PRESENT. CT INFORMED COUNSEL THAT A SPECTATOR HAD A SIGN ON HER WALKER PERTAINING TO THE DECEDANT WHICH WAS REMOVED BY THE BAILIFF AND UNCERTAIN IF THE JURY SAW IT SO INDIVIDUAL VOIR DIRE WOULD BE NECESSARY. 1:00 PM STATE PLACED ON THE RECORD THAT HE DID NOT SEE ANY SIGNAGE NOR HAS HE DONE ANYTHING TO ENCOURAGE SUCH BEHAVIOR AND HAS ALSO WARNED SEVERAL WITNESSES. CT STATED IT WOULD INDIVIDUALLY VOIR DIRE. 1:03 PM INDIVIDUAL VOIR DIRE COMMENCED. 1:06 PM CT STATED IT CONFISCATED THE SIGNAGE AND WOULD MAKE IT A PART OF THE RECORD. 1:18 PM IN AN ABUNDANCE OF CAUTION, DEFENSE MADE AN ORAL M/MISTRIAL AND PRESENTED ARGUMENTS. STATE OBJECTED AND PRESENTED ARGUMENT. CT MADE ITS FINDINGS AND STATED THE SIGNAGE WAS TAKEN DOWN, INDIVIDUAL VOIR DIRE WAS CONDUCTED AND THEY ALL SAID THEY COULD REMAIN FAIR AND IMPARTIAL AND WERE FURTHER INSTRUCTED NOT TO CONSIDER IF SIGNAGE WAS SEEN AND COULD FOLLOW THE CTS INSTRUCTIONS TO CONSIDER ONLY THE EVIDENCE. CT DENIED THE ORAL M/MISTRIAL AND STATED IT ALSO FURTHER INSTRUCTED THE JURY AS TO ANY POSSIBLE FURTHER SIGNAGE. 1:22 PM CT IN RECESS. ********** 1:27 PM CT RECONVENED W/OUT JURY PRESENT. DEFENSE STATED HE SPOKE WITH WITNESS MURAOKA RE WALMART SURVEILLANCE VIDEO AND REQUESTED TO PLACE DEFENSE'S EXHIBITS INTO EVIDENCE IN LIEU OF VIDEO. STATE NOTED ITS OBJECTIONS WITH TIME STAMPS. CT MADE ITS FINDINGS AND WILL ALLOW. 1:34 PM JURY PRESENT. 1:36 PM CT READ COURTROOM DECORUM ORDER TO EVERYONE IN CTRM. 1:38 PM KAMBRINA MURAOKA WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 1:41 PM STATE'S EXHIBIT 453 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 1:46 PM CROSS EXAMINATION. 1:53 PM DEFENSE'S EXHIBIT K WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 1:56 PM DEFENSE'S EXHIBITS I & J WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 1:57 PM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 1:58 PM OFCR JOSHUA LANDRY WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 2:01 PM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 2:02 PM HIDEKO YOSHIHARA WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 2:06 PM STATE'S EXHIBITS 299 & 300 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 2:09 PM STATE'S EXHIBITS 302-307 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 2:13 PM STATE'S EXHIBITS 308-312 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE OVER DEFENSE'S OBJECTION. 2:14 PM WITNESS IDENTIFIED DEFENDANT. 2:18 PM STATE'S EXHIBITS 313-327 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE OVER DEFENSE'S OBJECTION. 2:23 PM STATE'S EXHIBIT 462 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE OVER DEFENSE'S OBJECTION. 2:26 PM STATE'S EXHIBITS 328-333 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE OVER DEFENSE'S OBJECTION. 2:28 PM STATE'S EXHIBITS 334-335 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE OVER DEFENSE'S OBJECTION. 2:31 PM STATE'S EXHIBITS 336-341 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 2:32 PM CROSS EXAMINATION. 2:46 PM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED; CT IN RECESS. ********** 3:04 PM CT RECONVENED WITH JURY PRESENT. 3:05 PM RICHARD PERRON WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 3:13 PM STATE'S EXHIBITS 364-406 WERE MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 3:26 PM CROSS EXAMINATION. 3:29 PM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 3:30 PM LORI KANESHIRO WAS SWORN IN FOR TESTIMONY. 3:36 PM CT QUALIFIED WITNESS TO TESTIFY AS AN EXPERT IN THE FIELD OF FINGERPRINT COMPARISON IDENTIFICATION. 3:38 PM STATE'S EXHIBIT 573 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 3:43 PM STATE'S EXHIBIT 574 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 3:44 PM STATE'S EXHIBIT 575 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 3:45 PM STATE'S EXHIBIT 576 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 3:47 PM STATE'S EXHIBIT 577 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 3:49 PM STATE'S EXHIBIT 578 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 3:51 PM STATE'S EXHIBIT 579 WAS MARKED AND RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE. 3:54 PM CROSS EXAMINATION. 3:56 PM TESTIMONY CONCLUDED. 3:58 PM CT ORDERED THE JURY TO RETURN TOMORROW AT 8:30 AM FOR FURTHER JURY TRIAL AND TO REPORT IF THEY SEE ANY VISUALS. CT ADJOURNED.
Stephen Brown

DPA Bell, Scott
CA Bagasol, William
DFT Brown, Stephen
JUDG Somerville , Rowena
CLK Ching, Stefanie



Case Event Schedule
Event Defendant Date Time Room Location Judge Appearance Disposition
Jury Trial Stephen Brown
01/13/2023 08:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena

Jury Trial Stephen Brown
01/12/2023 08:30:00 First Circuit 23rd Division PUNCHBOWL Somerville , Rowena CON-Continued

link: http://jimspss1.courts.state.hi.us:8080/eCourt/ECC/CaseSearch.iface
 
  • #156
Friday, January 13th:
*Trial continues (Day 4) (@ 8:30am Hawaiian-Aleutian Time) - HI - Telma Boinville (51) (Dec. 6, 2017, Oahu) – for *Stephen Brown (23/now 28) arrested (12/13/17), charged & arraigned (12/18/17) with 2nd degree murder, 4 counts kidnapping, 1st degree burglary & criminal property damage. Plead not guilty Bond $1M.
Trial began on 1/3/23 for Brown only with Jury Selection & ended 1/9/23. Trial began on 1/9/23.
Count 7 Criminal Prop Damage IV-Knowingly damages; severity: PM - Petty Misdemeanor. Plead No Contest on 1/9/23. Judge takes plea as guilty. Sentencing hearing on 4/26/23 @ 1pm.
Court information from 2/19/18 thru 1/2/23 & Jury Selection Days 1-5 (1/3 to 1/9/23) & Trial Day 1-2 (1/9-1/10) reference post #154 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...o-death-oahu-6-dec-2017-arrests.359003/page-8
1/12/23 Tuesday, Trial Day 3: (#705) Court convened without jury present. Case called & appearances were entered by Counsel & defendant in custody. Defense made an oral motion for mistrial & presented arguments. State objected, deferred to the Court. Individual voie dire or curative instruction & presented argument. Court findings made & denied oral motion for mistrial.
State witnesses: Dr. Michael Dung, expert in the area of internal medicine. Officer Christopher Young. David Kaawa. Sgt. Kendrick Tahara. Office Kent Lareau. Break.
Reconvened without jury present. Defense state he wanted to recall Cpl. Kaawa re statements made by Dandurand. Court will allow as part of defense's trial strategy.
State witnesses: Office Lareau continued. Mackenzie Omalza. Frances Hill. Officer Allen-John Vergara. Leslie Murakami. Lunch break. Court convened without jury. Court informed counsel that a spectator had a sign on her walker pertaining to the decedant which was removed by the bailiff & uncertain if the jury saw it, so individual voir dire would be necessary. State place on record that he did not see any signage nor has he done anything to encourage such behavior & has also warned several witnesses. Court does individually voir dire. Defense made an oral motion for mistrial & presented arguments. State objected & presented argument. Court denied the oral motion for mistrial & stated it also further instructed the jury as to any possible further signage. Defense state he spoke with witness Muraoka re Walmart surveillance video & requested to place defense's exhibits into evidence in lieu of video. State noted its objections with time stamps. Court will allow.
State witnesses: Kambrina Muraoka. Officier Joshua Landry. Hideko Yoshihara. Richard Perron. Lori Kaneshiro, expert in the field of fingerprint comparison identification. Court qualified witness to testify as expert.
State's & defense exhibits were marked & received into evidence. Trial continues on Friday, 1/13/23 @ 8:30am.
*Hailey Kai Dandurand (20/now 25) – Next Calendar Call hearing on 6/27/23. THERE Trial set to begin on 7/10/23.
 
  • #157
  • #158
www.hawaiinewsnow.com

Officer in North Shore murder trial testifies suspect tried to lick blood from hands

The gruesome detail was one of many that came to light Wednesday.
www.hawaiinewsnow.com www.hawaiinewsnow.com

Jan. 13, 2023

HONOLULU (HawaiiNewsNow) - Officers who investigated the brutal North Shore murder of Telma Boinville told jurors Thursday that they found a meat tenderizer next to her body.

The gruesome detail was one of many that came to light as the trial against suspect Stephen Brown continues.
 
  • #159
Hawaii court site is down today until Monday - but got this in my alerts. For Friday's court.

www.hawaiinewsnow.com

Daughter of North Shore murder victim gives chilling testimony of kidnapping by alleged killers

“He came to the truck and grabbed me."
www.hawaiinewsnow.com www.hawaiinewsnow.com

Jan. 13, 2023
HONOLULU (HawaiiNewsNow) - The prosecutor in the trial of Stephen Brown for the 2017 murder of Telma Boinville wrapped up his case Friday with dramatic testimony from the victim’s husband and daughter.

Boinville’s 13-year-old daughter, Makana Boinville Emery, took the stand to tell the chilling story of her kidnapping by the suspected killers. Hawaii News Now is using only her audio to protect her privacy.
[.....]
Boinville’s husband, Kevin Emery, learned what had happened with a phone call.

He rushed to comfort his daughter in an ambulance at the scene.

Emery testified that his daughter described the suspects to him, especially their distinctive hair dyes. Somehow, Emery’s twin brother Ryan found a photo of the couple and texted it to Emery in the ambulance.
[.....]
Brown is denying he killed Boinville.

Earlier Friday, his defense attorney William Bagasol questioned the state DNA expert, holding up a hammer, knife, machete, a meat tenderizer and bat to confirm none had evidence of brown’s DNA.
[.....]
Over the defense’s objections, former Honolulu Medical Examiner Dr. Christopher Happy gave a chilling description of Telma Boinville’s numerous wounds. “Those multiple chop wounds disrupted the brain there so the surface of it was basically destroyed,” Happy said.
[.....]
Wrapping up their case, prosecutors showed surveillance from the Mililani Walmart store. It showed Dandurand buying an untraceable mobile phone, apparently still thinking they would somehow escape the crowd of police and civilians that waited for them outside.
 
  • #160
another article on Friday's trial.

www.khon2.com

Heartbreaking testimony from murdered woman’s daughter

Telma Boinville’s daughter was eight years old and a third-grader at Sunset Elementary School at the time of the murder. The girl told jurors on Friday she was waiting in the truck while Boin…
www.khon2.com www.khon2.com


.....
The prosecutor rested his case at the end of the day. The defense will start calling witnesses on Tuesday, 1/17/23.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Members online

... and 81 more.
Total: 3,353 (members: 82, guests: 3,271)

Online statistics

Members online
82
Guests online
3,271
Total visitors
3,353
Totals may include hidden visitors.

Forum statistics

Threads
632,608
Messages
18,628,939
Members
243,213
Latest member
bleuuu_
Back
Top