ID - Newborn girl found dead with placenta still attached in safe haven box - October 28, 2024

Clearsky

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 3, 2023
Messages
2,240
Reaction score
3,323
  • #1

BLACKFOOT, Idaho - (KIFI) The Twin Falls Police Department is investigating the death of a newborn girl found in the Safe Haven Baby Box at Grove Creek Medical Center in Blackfoot on October 13.
 
  • #2

BLACKFOOT, Idaho - (KIFI) The Twin Falls Police Department is investigating the death of a newborn girl found in the Safe Haven Baby Box at Grove Creek Medical Center in Blackfoot on October 13.
Grove Creek Medical Center staff responded immediately to the alarm, indicating a baby was in the box," said Monica Kelsey, founder of Safe Haven Baby Boxes. "The medical team removed the infant from the bassinet within a minute. Upon removal, they quickly realized that the infant had passed away long before being placed in the baby box. The Safe Haven Law in Idaho allows for the surrender of an infant who is unharmed and healthy. Therefore, this was not a legal surrender under state law as it does not meet the criteria for Safe Haven surrender
 
  • #3

1732346582227.png


Angela N. Newberry was taken into custody on Thursday and charged with one count of felony failure to report a death to law enforcement, authorities announced.
 
  • #4
  • #5
Charged with failure to report a death rather than with some degree of murder implies that the baby was stillborn, and the mother had no idea what to do and left the body in the baby box. They can generally tell, on autopsy, if a baby has ever taken their first breath.

The most charitable interpretation here is that the baby was stillborn and clearly could not be resuscitated--congenital condition incompatible with life, perhaps, or simply had died a few days before the birth. In that case the mother can only be penalized for failure to report. But if that baby could have been resuscitated had she called for help, she may be in a good deal more trouble than that.
 
  • #6
Charged with failure to report a death rather than with some degree of murder implies that the baby was stillborn, and the mother had no idea what to do and left the body in the baby box. They can generally tell, on autopsy, if a baby has ever taken their first breath.

The most charitable interpretation here is that the baby was stillborn and clearly could not be resuscitated--congenital condition incompatible with life, perhaps, or simply had died a few days before the birth. In that case the mother can only be penalized for failure to report. But if that baby could have been resuscitated had she called for help, she may be in a good deal more trouble than that.
December 5 hearing was continued to December 19. She has retained counsel and is out on bond. I would think the autopsy has been performed by now. Apparently medical staff at the hospital determined that the baby had passed away long before it had been placed there. That poor little thing - it is just so sad.
 
  • #7
December 5 hearing was continued to December 19. She has retained counsel and is out on bond. I would think the autopsy has been performed by now. Apparently medical staff at the hospital determined that the baby had passed away long before it had been placed there. That poor little thing - it is just so sad.
If my surmise that the child was stillborn is correct, then this sounds like a case of poor support for a pregnant woman. It's terrible when they don't get support. It's one of the hardest times in anyone's life, having a baby; a happy time, but a hard time. When it goes bad, it's life-shattering, losing a baby. And she went through it alone. No prenatal care, gave birth outside a hospital--and not the cozy way, with a midwife and family and a hospital on speed-dial. It's honestly just sad. I feel like she just couldn't bring herself to call paramedics and say, "I had a baby, but she's dead."

Maybe I'm more charitable than I should be--the first 24 hours are the most dangerous time of anyone's life, after all--but... I don't know, this just doesn't seem like the sort of situation that calls for anger. If I'm wrong and she's guilty of some kind of manslaughter or even murder, then fine; but man, if not, I hope they don't throw the book at her. She did her best to give that child some sort of a dignified burial, by leaving her in that baby hatch. It's not like she tossed her in a river somewhere, or put her in the trash. If I were the judge, I would give her community service and refer her to counseling plus whatever other help she might need.
 
  • #8
If my surmise that the child was stillborn is correct, then this sounds like a case of poor support for a pregnant woman. It's terrible when they don't get support. It's one of the hardest times in anyone's life, having a baby; a happy time, but a hard time. When it goes bad, it's life-shattering, losing a baby. And she went through it alone. No prenatal care, gave birth outside a hospital--and not the cozy way, with a midwife and family and a hospital on speed-dial. It's honestly just sad. I feel like she just couldn't bring herself to call paramedics and say, "I had a baby, but she's dead."

Maybe I'm more charitable than I should be--the first 24 hours are the most dangerous time of anyone's life, after all--but... I don't know, this just doesn't seem like the sort of situation that calls for anger. If I'm wrong and she's guilty of some kind of manslaughter or even murder, then fine; but man, if not, I hope they don't throw the book at her. She did her best to give that child some sort of a dignified burial, by leaving her in that baby hatch. It's not like she tossed her in a river somewhere, or put her in the trash. If I were the judge, I would give her community service and refer her to counseling plus whatever other help she might need.
I am in complete agreement with you. Unlike Brianna Moore - who snuffed the life out of her newborn and then put her in the trash - this girl placed her baby in the safe haven shelter, which speaks volumes. And, tragically, these are not rare, isolated instances. It's all just so heart-breaking.
 
  • #9
Preliminary Hearing continued to February 20, 2025
 
  • #10
Preliminary Hearing continued again - new date June 5, 2025
 

Staff online

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
129
Guests online
2,508
Total visitors
2,637

Forum statistics

Threads
632,144
Messages
18,622,666
Members
243,034
Latest member
RepresentingTheLBC
Back
Top