Back to basics.
I thought I would not have trouble finding a man's shoe with a white stripe across the top. I have not found a shoe of that design in 10 months.
The only shoes/boots that I have seen that are close what appears to be boots iwth a light stripe across the top are boots from Indiana Packers.
I have looked through boots like runners, motorcycling boots, off roading boots, fashion boots with no luck.
As for his being local, many IP employees don't live in Delphi, but commute from other towns like Lafayette, Frankfort, Kokomo. Its a huge employer.