From the front page of the Herald-Republican newspaper in Angola, Indiana:
Mongo murders: One year later
By MATT GETTS
[email protected]
MONGO - A year later, and the effects can still be felt.
Terry Anderson, 59, and Darleen Anderson, 57, were found murdered on their property in the 6000 block of C.R. 250N in rural Mongo on Oct. 21, 2005. Darleen Anderson's body was found in the house, and Terry Anderson's was later found in an outbuilding. The victims died of blunt force trauma, according to LaGrange County Coroner Bruce Coney.
Police have not disclosed the weapon that was used to kill the Andersons, or whether the weapon has been recovered.
Their murders are still unsolved, and the case remains an open wound for many involved.
Jim Codling, owner of the Mongo Tavern, now locks the doors of his house at night. Codling also has purchased a dog to protect his family when he's away.
Terry Anderson's daughter, Sherry Musilek, and her husband, Erik, have created a Web site and foundation with the hopes of finding the killer.
For LaGrange County Sheriff Greg Dhaene and the lead investigator in the case, Detective Tad Oakley, the murders are never far from their minds.
You are constantly preoccupied, even in your off time, Dhaene said.
The investigation
It has been two months since anyone has called in with any new tips in the murders, Dhaene said Tuesday, but the investigation remains far from closed.
I am still hopeful there will be an arrest, he said.
We are still encouraging anyone in the community who has information to contact us, contact Crime Stoppers, Dhaene said.
Detectives continue to follow leads in the case, checking and re-checking information.
During the past 12 months, suspects have been looked at from areas including Michigan, Ohio and Florida. Investigators have gone back 30 years into Terry Anderson's life, looking for clues.
The Behavioral Analysis Unit of the Federal Bureau of Investigation has been consulted, and the Mongo murders are now in the bureau's national database. Any similar crime will be compared to the Mongo case by the FBI, with information shared with LaGrange County officials.
A dozen investigators have logged thousands of hours pursuing leads in the case.
It has been a widespread, wide-reaching investigation, Dhaene said.
Dhaene declined to comment on the status of the case.
I don't want to do or say anything that would hinder the course of the investigation, he said. We just don't want to take the chance of doing anything that would compromise (the case).
But the 28-year law enforcement veteran said the last 12 months have been anything but easy.
This has been the single-most difficult case I have been involved in, Dhaene said.
The sheriff cited the serious nature of the crime, the number of potential participants and lack of cooperation from many witnesses.
On Oct. 3, Larry Lee Carpenter, 51, of West Palm Beach, Fla., and formerly of Sturgis, Mich., was sentenced in LaGrange Circuit Court to 150 days in prison and a $100 fine plus court costs on a count of false informing.
Carpenter's sentence will be served after he completes his current term on a drug charge.
Carpenter allegedly provided numerous false, misleading and contradictory statements to sheriff's department and Indiana State Police detectives investigating the murders.
Unfortunately, according to Dhaene, Carpenter's falsehoods have been the rule rather than the exception in this case.
That's been indicative of some of how this investigation has gone, Dhaene said. A number of people have intentionally lied and deceived.
That's what we've faced since almost day one in this case.
The deceptions have forced investigators into wasting time on these false leads, backtracking on interviews and having to re-check statements for accuracy.
In many instances, investigators have been stymied about why the person lied in the first place.
Dhaene said these lies have slowed and hindered the investigation.
Oakley said the department has several theories on the case, but declined to mention any of them specifically.
Remembering
the Andersons
A billboard stands at the intersection of U.S. 20 and S.R. 3, south of Mongo. It asks anyone with information regarding the murders of Terry and Darleen Anderson to contact authorities. The billboard was paid for by the Terry and Darleen Foundation.
According to the foundation's Web site,
www.terryanddarleen.com, The goal of the foundation is to establish a monetary fund that will be used to help the communities that were home to Terry and Darleen. A portion of the fund will be set aside to be used as a reward for information leading the arrest and conviction of those involved.
The Terry and Darleen Anderson Foundation is headquartered in Crestwood, Ill., and is managed by Terry's daughter, Sherry Musilek.
Sherry's husband, Eric Musilek, started the foundation.
(Terry) was my hunting buddy. He was my fishing buddy. We were pretty tight, said Eric Musilek.
A fundraiser for the foundation in the Chicagoland area raised $1,500. Eric Musilek said he looks forward to handing the reward money to whoever provides information leading to the arrest of the killer or killers.
They did not deserve this, he said.
The Web site is filled with pictures and stories about the Andersons, recollections of a man and woman loved by many. Included are photos and pictures of Terry Anderson muskie fishing, and stories of Darleen's shopping habit.
Terry Anderson was a familiar figure at the Mongo Tavern. He'd come in two or three times a week for a soda and a mushroom and swiss burger.
He was a nice guy, Codling said.
A changed Mongo?
One year ago, Mongo was shaken with the news that Terry and Darleen Anderson had been murdered at their home.
Everybody tends to become complacent, Codling said. That (stuff) doesn't happen around here.
While Codling said people in general have become more cautious since the murders, Mongo is still Mongo.
Everybody (still) talks about it, Codling said. But it hasn't changed the town. It's hard to change a town like this.