Ireland Ireland - Male, 40-60, medal "Good Luck MacGinty'',found drowned,River Lee, Ballincollig, Jul'99

dotr

Well-Known Member
Websleuths Guardian
Joined
Oct 21, 2009
Messages
58,143
Reaction score
174,787
  • #1
rbbm.
Special Report: Complete national policy needed for cold cases
''Mystery surrounds body recovered in Cork in 1999

Good luck McGinty
MscgintyBadgeCorkCase_large.jpg

A body recovered in Ballincollig in 1999 has never been identified despite the recovery of a distinctive medal that said Good Luck MacGinty on it.
One of the greatest advocates for missing people in Ireland, RTÉ reporter Barry Cummins, is adamant that we should never stop looking for answers for those who no longer have a voice.

His heavily-detailed works on behalf of missing people, as well as families whose loved ones have been victims of the worst crimes, can be found on Amazon Kindle, as well as Audible.

Mr Cummins has been instrumental in highlighting the torment among families, as well as giving a voice to those who cannot speak for themselves.

In his book, Without Trace — Ireland’s Missing, Mr Cummins highlights one of Cork’s least-known mysteries, the discovery of a body in Ballincollig in 1999.

“In Co Cork, mystery still surrounds the identity of a man whose body was recovered from the River Lee at Ballincollig, west of Cork city, on July 23, 1999.

"The body was taken from the water by the Cork Fire Brigade, and it was clear that the man had been in the water for some time. His facial features were unrecognisable and it was not possible to get fingerprints due to decomposition.

“Pathologist Dr Margaret Bolster carried out a post-mortem examination, which established that the cause of the man’s death was consistent with drowning. He was aged between 40 and 60, was 5’ 10” tall, of strong build and short hair.

"He was wearing several layers of clothing, including two pairs of trousers, and this led the Gardaí to consider that the man might have been homeless.

“He had no personal documentation but had a number of items of jewellery which still hold out the prospect of him being one day identified.

“He wore a ‘Philip Mercier’ silver watch with a gold face. He had wooden rosary beads and three religious medals. He also had another small horseshoe-type medal which had a distinctive description which read ‘Good Luck MacGinty’.

Detectives checked with every MacGinty they could find, but none of them was a relative of the unidentified man.

While MacGinty may well be the man’s surname, or his mother’s maiden name or the name of another close relative, the Gardaí have also considered the possibility that MacGinty may have been a nickname by which the man was known.

“It is a potentially good clue to the man’s identity, and detectives urge anyone with any knowledge of the name MacGinty to contact them.

DNA has been extracted from the body and filed away if ever a potential family member can be found. Until the case is solved, the unidentified man remains buried at a cemetery in Ballincollig.

“This man must have family and friends somewhere. Someone must know who he is,” says Seán Duggan, one of the firemen who recovered his body from the River Lee. From the terrain surrounding where the Ballincollig man was found, the Cork Fire Service was able to say that the man had entered the water close to where his body was located.”
 
Last edited:
  • #2
Call for cold case units to be set up in every garda area
June 2 2020 rbbm.
“There has been a huge lack of co-ordination in the gardaí to match up or compare evidence when it comes to tracing missing people or matching body parts that have been found.”

He said cold cases could now benefit from advances in DNA testing, online media and social media.

“In many instances, senior gardaí will retire and their unsolved cases will remain there until someone takes it on.

"Garda management needs to push these cases, to assign people in every jurisdiction to take them on, especially now with tools at our disposal such as DNA, online media and social media.”

He said he is a big believer in genealogical websites which, he said, have got a huge bank of DNA profiles.

“I believe we should be able to run cold case DNA through it, to see if we can finally get justice for cold- case victims.

"I would have been relentless about this when I was in the gardaí because it is a huge bank of knowledge sitting there.''

''In his book, Without Trace: Ireland’s Missing, RTÉ reporter Barry Cummins, highlights one of Cork’s least-known mysteries, the discovery of a body in Ballincollig in 1999.''
https://twitter.com/barrycummins12/status/1259168499144044544
 
  • #3
Article dated 13 January 2025
www.irishexaminer.com/news/spotlight/arid-41550049.html

Will we ever solve the mystery of Ireland's unidentified human remains?​

...... SNIP
The recent case of a man exhumed in November from a grave in Bandon, Cork, failed to produce a match, and the DNA profile for him has been forwarded to Interpol.
....... SNIP

The recent exhumation of the remains of an unidentified man in Bandon has so far yielded no success in identifying him.

DNA samples taken from the remains have been sent to Interpol in a bid to solve a 25-year-old mystery.

The man’s remains were reinterred in St Patrick’s cemetery in the town last month, over three weeks after being exhumed on November 5.

DNA samples were harvested and will now be used in an attempt to identify him.

The man’s remains were found in the River Lee at the Lee Fields in July 1999 and were taken from the water by fire officers.

A gravestone marking the grave of the unknown man reads: “Pray for the soul of a man whose name is known to God alone, interred here on the 25th of October 1999.”

When found, he was wearing a Philip Mercier silver watch with a gold face.

Wooden rosary beads and three religious medals were also found on his person, as well as a Good Luck medal in the shape of a horseshoe, on which was etched the name MacGinty.

However, efforts to identify the man failed.

Fingerprints could not be obtained because of the decomposition of the body.

Earlier this year, gardaí made a formal request to the coroner for South Cork, Frank O’Connell, for an exhumation of the body for the purpose of DNA profiling.

Under coronial legislation, exhumations are allowed if a licence is obtained or if an order is made by the minister for justice.

Mr O’Connell made an application to Justice Minister Helen McEntee for the order in recent months and confirmed a licence has been granted.

An exhumation must be carried out under strict conditions, with an environmental health officer present to ensure public health is protected.

The officer also attends the reburial of the remains.

Typically, the area of a graveyard where the exhumation is to take place is sealed off for privacy.
 
Last edited:
  • #4
1742397731997.webp

3782UMIRL - Unidentified Male

3782UMIRL.jpg

Horseshoe-type medal found on the victim.
''Date of Discovery: July 23, 1999
Location of Discovery: River Lee near Ballincollig, Western side of the Lee Fields, Carrigrohane Road, Co Cork
Estimated Date of Death: Unknown
State of Remains: Not recognizable
Cause of Death: Drowning

Physical Description

Estimated Age: 40-60 years old
Race: White
Sex: Male
Height: 5'10"
Weight: Strong build
Hair: Unknown, short hair
Eye Color: Unknown
Distinguishing Marks/Features: Unknown

Identifiers

Dentals: Unknown
Fingerprints: Unavailable
DNA: Unavailable - No DNA profiling

Clothing & Personal Items

Clothing: Several layers of clothing, including two pair of trousers
Jewelry: "Philip Mercier" silver watch.
Additional Personal Items: Wooden rosary beads and three religious medals. Small horseshoe-type medal with "Good Luck MacGinty" inscription.

Circumstances of Discovery

The body was recovered from the River Lee at Ballincollig, west of Cork city, on July 23, 1999. The body was taken from the water by the Cork Fire Brigade, and it was clear that the man had been in the water for some time. His facial features were unrecognizable and it was not possible to get fingerprints due to decomposition. From the terrain surrounding where the Ballincollig man was found, the Cork Fire Service was able to say that the man had entered the water close to where his body was located.
Pathologist Dr Margaret Bolster carried out a post-mortem examination, which established that the cause of the man's death was consistent with drowning. He was aged between 40 and 60, was 5' 10" tall, of strong build and short hair. He was wearing several layers of clothing, including two pairs of trousers, and this led the Garda to consider that the man might have been homeless.
He had no personal documentation but had a number of items of jewellery which still hold out the prospect of him being one day identified. "He wore a 'Philip Mercier' silver watch with a gold face. He had wooden rosary beads and three religious medals. He also had another small horseshoe-type medal which had a distinctive description which read 'Good Luck MacGinty'.
Detectives checked with every MacGinty they could find, but none of them was a relative of the unidentified man. While MacGinty may well be the man's surname, or his mother's maiden name or the name of another close relative, the Garda have also considered the possibility that MacGinty may have been a nickname by which the man was known.It is a potentially good clue to the man's identity, and detectives urge anyone with any knowledge of the name MacGinty to contact them.
DNA has been extracted from the body and filed away if ever a potential family member can be found. Until the case is solved, the unidentified man remains buried at St Patricks Cemetery, Bandon, Co. Cork. Section F, Row 11, Plot 24.''
 
  • #5
I wonder if MacGinty was the name of a racehorse the deceased was associated with, given the horseshoe medallion. There is a McGinty (different spelling) that raced in NZ and Australia; I know from being around that industry a bit as a kid that horses are often given a nickname that doesn't relate to their racing name/registered name at all.
 
  • #6
Doing a search of the horseshoe provides lots of different possibilities. I'm thinking it was meant as a good luck charm.

 
  • #7
I wonder if they ever checked with jewellers. I feel like if I set up an ebay search for the medal, eventually another would turn up with provenance details.
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
55
Guests online
2,506
Total visitors
2,561

Forum statistics

Threads
632,800
Messages
18,631,904
Members
243,294
Latest member
Safeplace07
Back
Top