Madeleine McCann: German prisoner identified as suspect #27

[C.greek]

There have to be credible doubts in relation to the girls disappearance and CB's role in it.

Yes but this is not one

 

[Zuleika]

We have discussed this as well in the past, trying to identify the lookalike pal.
But come on now...are you seriously presenting here credible doubts about the identification?

You brought up CT again referring to tabloids . Are you seriously suggesting she's 100% certain it was CB ....not his lookalike ...and even if she is , CB 's a known thief and yes he might well have been scouting around for somewhere to rob ,it doesn't follow that he abducted MBM but left behind all the family personal belongings although I can understand he wouldn't want incriminating evidence found in his possession were he to be apprehended at a later date .

 

[Zuleika]

We have discussed this as well in the past, trying to identify the lookalike pal.
But come on now...are you seriously presenting here credible doubts about the identification?

You brought up CT again referring to tabloids . Are you seriously suggesting she's 100% certain it was CB ....not his lookalike ...and even if she is , CB 's a known thief and yes he might well have been scouting around for somewhere to rob ,it doesn't follow that he abducted MBM but left behind all the family personal belongings although I can understand he wouldn't want incriminating evidence found in his possession were he to be apprehended at a later date .

 

[C.greek]

There have to be credible doubts in relation to the girls disappearance and CB's role in it.

Yes but this is not one

You brought up CT again referring to tabloids . Are you seriously suggesting she's 100% certain it was CB ....not his lookalike ...and even if she is , CB 's a known thief and yes he might well have been scouting around for somewhere to rob ,it doesn't follow that he abducted MBM but left behind all the family personal belongings although I can understand he wouldn't want incriminating evidence found in his possession were he to be apprehended at a later date .

There is a lot of circumstantial evidence that make BKA be certain CB did it. His lookalike pal's phone(who I believe the police and investigative forces have identified) did not ping close to the apartment, and most possibly his lookalike pal did not share chats with other pedophiles pertaining to MM, and his lookalike pal did not *confess while drunk that he knows what happened to MM, and his lookalike pal might not be a convicted pedophile nor a convicted rapist.

 

[Lilly b]

There have to be credible doubts in relation to the girls disappearance and CB's role in it.

Glad you think so, don't know why your on here, unless you know that it was someone else, and then, please share

 

[Zuleika]

Yes but this is not one

There is a lot of circumstantial evidence that make BKA be certain CB did it. His lookalike pal's phone(who I believe the police and investigative forces have identified) did not ping close to the apartment, and most possibly his lookalike pal did not share chats with other pedophiles pertaining to MM, and his lookalike pal did not *confess while drunk that he knows what happened to MM, and his lookalike pal might not be a convicted pedophile nor a convicted rapist.

" Confessing while drunk he knew what happened to MM " is way off him confessing to abducting and murdering her don't you think ?

,

 

[RichardKimble]

Glad you think so, don't know why your on here, unless you know that it was someone else, and then, please share

So only those that don't doubt CB is the one are allowed on here, are you the owner ?

 

[mrjitty]

What I find more interesting that raking over the embers of the PJ investigation, is where BKA find themselves if CB did get clean away that night.

What could link him to the crime, and prove what crime was committed, so long as they don't have a body?

I am increasingly convinced the core purpose of HCW's summer appeal was to find the body.

Without a body, prosecution is going to be extremely difficult for reasons we have talked about endlessly.

 

[RichardKimble]

Yes but this is not one

There is a lot of circumstantial evidence that make BKA be certain CB did it. His lookalike pal's phone(who I believe the police and investigative forces have identified) did not ping close to the apartment, and most possibly his lookalike pal did not share chats with other pedophiles pertaining to MM, and his lookalike pal did not *confess while drunk that he knows what happened to MM, and his lookalike pal might not be a convicted pedophile nor a convicted rapist.

What is this lot of circumstantial, lets see, a phone which was possibly registered to CB was used 2 hrs prior to any reports of a missing child, he has history of sex crimes, according to an assistant commissioner to the met, cast your net wide enough and there are these type of people in any parish or words to that effect., any more ?

 

[Lilly b]

" Confessing while drunk he knew what happened to MM " is way off him confessing to abducting and murdering her don't you think ?

,

Depends, if he new what happened to her, and was nothing to do with him, any decent person would report it, wouldn't you say?

 

[RichardKimble]

Depends, if he new what happened to her, and was nothing to do with him, any decent person would report it, wouldn't you say?

Can one be decent and have paedo tendencies or like his mate be a people trafficker.

 

[RichardKimble]

What I find more interesting that raking over the embers of the PJ investigation, is where BKA find themselves if CB did get clean away that night.

What could link him to the crime, and prove what crime was committed, so long as they don't have a body?

I am increasingly convinced the core purpose of HCW's summer appeal was to find the body.

Without a body, prosecution is going to be extremely difficult for reasons we have talked about endlessly.

13+ years after the fact what are the chances , Claudia Lawrence ,Suzi Lamplugh both grown women missing in the uk, both presumed murdered.

 

[Zuleika]

Depends, if he new what happened to her, and was nothing to do with him, any decent person would report it, wouldn't you say?

He isn't a decent person tho is he? He does appear to brag tho , even if what he says isn't true .

 

[tedtink]

He isn't a decent person tho is he? He does appear to brag tho , even if what he says isn't true .

Do you not think he may have gone into a little more detail than 'I know what happened to her'?
Do you think if CB had just said that, HB would have just shrugged it off without asking CB to expand on that statement?
You think that HB couldn't just have put that in an email to OG, no, they flew out to Greece, swept the Hotel for bugs, allegedly - Lot more to HB's testimony IMO.

 

[C.greek]

What I find more interesting that raking over the embers of the PJ investigation, is where BKA find themselves if CB did get clean away that night.

What could link him to the crime, and prove what crime was committed, so long as they don't have a body?

I am increasingly convinced the core purpose of HCW's summer appeal was to find the body.

Without a body, prosecution is going to be extremely difficult for reasons we have talked about endlessly.

What makes you think the appeal was to find the body? What if she was put in the ocean? Unless they have intelligence that she was buried.

I increasingly think they want to charge him with other violent crimes so as to establish a MO before they proceed with circumstantial evidence to charge him with MM's murder.

 

[Anxala]

Glad you think so, don't know why your on here, unless you know that it was someone else, and then, please share

To be fair, Lilly, that's not really fair.

Anyone who's followed the case from the off has to constantly balance the historical elements of the case with the claims of this current investigation. And sometimes, the two just don't sit at all well together. It's perfectly reasonable to question what are sometimes presented on here as 'truths' but are, in fact, really just perspectives.

In the absence of knowing what the BKA is sitting upon, I personally remain very much on the fence as far as CB's involvement is concerned. That's not me claiming he's innocent or anything or denying his involvement or suggesting I know better than you and others on here, just me waiting for something from the BKA investigation that fits, sits and makes 'historical' sense to me.

 

[SuperdadV8]

Not directly linked to the MM case, but i can remember long discussions earlier about a possible motive and that paedophiles do not have to be murderers, just because they are producing child . Even FF stated, that just because CB has a peadophile past and criminal record, nothing points out to the assumption, that he could be a psychopath and murderer.

Well, looks like as if these horrible things do happen! Even in highly frequented areas....

Horrifying moment girl, five, is seized by 'paedophile and his male lover' in Russia | Daily Mail Online

 

[Denis R Tandib]

But by that reasoning how does one account for any movement after the fact. No one saw CB, the descriptions of the two men seen carrying children doesn't tie in with CB ,one is all but discounted by £12 million of tax payers money, its like it didn't happen .

I imagine that if you abduct a child, you would want to do so without being seen or caught. Perhaps whoever took MM from 5A was successful in this regard.

BTW, read through the statements of the Smith family again, especially Aoife’s and then cross reference it with the Malaga footage of CB from a few weeks beforehand ... I see a slim man with brown hair! Tannerman could easily be CB in a wig ... we know he liked dress-ups.

In my mind, it’s impossible to rule Tannerman and Smithman or many other scenarios in or out.

 

[Denis R Tandib]

What is the question? and allow me to say that it is not only MY opinion about the PJ'S handling of the investigation...

It’s okay, Chiatos already answered it.

 

[Denis R Tandib]

Glad you think so, don't know why your on here, unless you know that it was someone else, and then, please share

Unless proven BARD there are doubts. At this stage we don’t know what BKA have so IMO it’s probably best not assume that CB is guilty of the MM crime.