Make Breastfeeding the Law: Gisele

Should there be a worldwide law requiring breastfeeding for 6 months?

  • Yes. Breast is best.

    Votes: 5 2.1%
  • No. I think it should be encouraged but not a law.

    Votes: 116 48.5%
  • Only when men can do it too.

    Votes: 13 5.4%
  • No. Stay out of my business.

    Votes: 118 49.4%

  • Total voters
    239
  • #61
Breast feeding and bottle feeding is viewed so differently in every country and every society. There is something to be said for the benefits of breast feeding, but seriously, it is a personal choice. Not subject to legalization. I doubt Victoria Secret makes a nursing bra...
 
  • #62
While I agree that breast is best, my idea of 'best' isn't the same as those who push breast feeding. It is not 'best' for a baby to starve if mum can't produce enough milk. It is not 'best' for mum to stay off necessary meds that are not compatible with breast feeding.

I voted that while it should be encouraged it should not be required by law.
 
  • #63
Breast feeding and bottle feeding is viewed so differently in every country and every society. There is something to be said for the benefits of breast feeding, but seriously, it is a personal choice. Not subject to legalization. I doubt Victoria Secret makes a nursing bra...

BBM

:floorlaugh:

If they ever do make one, I'm sure Madame Gisele will declare a law that all new mothers must wear it. Encrusted with Swarovski crystals and gold filigree.
 
  • #64
I hope her next pregnancy results in triplets...or more :D
 
  • #65
Breastfeeding should be a choice, not a law. Some women can't for certain reasons already given in post above, so what are we going to do arrest them and make them sit in a cell for 6 months until times up? Gisele just strike the pose and leave the law to the lawmakers.
 
  • #66
This thread is several years old. I wonder giselle has had any more kids. Maybe she's changed her tune.
 
  • #67
  • #68
I think what a woman does with her nipples is her own darn business. This moronic woman still wants the government to govern nipples???

Good luck with that! ...eyeroll


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk 2
 
  • #69
Keep in mind, Gisele also said that childbirth didn't hurt a bit.......not at all.

I would beg to differ..........

Me too!

I had my son in an Army hospital without so much as an aspirin. I begged for something - ANYTHING - but was told there was not time. Then the doctor started to sew me up where I had torn. It felt as if he were doing a patchwork quilt. I kept saying, "Oh, please. Are you done yet?"

Breastfeeding? I didn't, but I did try.

MOO
 
  • #70
I did not nurse my son. But I did nurse my daughter. I was young and not very aware of nursing, my son was also 5 weeks early and not motivated at all.

Some people can't nurse, and others love it so much they just want to express it to the world! I just want people to feed their babies.. Not asking to much.

From bottle to a breastfed baby, I will take breastfeeding any day!! I nursed for a year. But I had an advantage of being home. I doubt I would of stick to it if I had to pump at a job.

The benefits of nursing are so much. Not what the child gets in nutrients, I think formula is just a nutrient. But you save money, and time. I hated cleaning bottles, and preparing the formula. I swear I tried different routines each week.

And I tried breast milk, and it is really good. I tried formula not so good, and I mean like clay tasting. I also tried mix and that was ok.

I just want to say, if you want to nurse, don't give up so soon. Once you get to the 6th week, it is so easy. Thankfully I had a friend who guided me with the courage to keep going.
 
  • #71
So, if I'm getting this right, you should go to jail for not breast feeding, buts is legal to kill a baby while its still in the womb?
Damn, and I thought I was stupid.
 
  • #72
Arghhh I don't think we should open that can of worms...


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk 2
 
  • #73
I only breastfed one baby for six weeks. I did not like it. She woke every two hours wanting to nurse and I was totally exhausted. One of my deliveries was not very painful at all, but the doctor forced a spinal on me at the last. I was refusing and too stupid to assert my rights. The other three were painful from the first labor pain. No one should have to suffer that if they don't want to, and shouldn't feel guilty for not breast feeding.
 
  • #74
I TRIED breast feeding with both my boys, first one I could only feed for 6 weeks and the second was lucky enough to get 12 weeks..

With my first I had no idea how to feed and he tore my nipples to shreds, we had bad latching which equalled bad feeds and ended up with my milk drying up.

With my second son I had the luxury (if you would call it that) of him living in the NICU for his first 4 weeks of life, I pumped every two hours each day for the first 8 weeks until my milk dried up, this time due to stress I put myself under from having a premmie (I though Hunter was going to die at home and it still scares me as he has some complications from being prem)

Does Gisele factor these type of issues into her stupid statement? Probably not... She also would have the luxury of nannies... Seriously some people make me smh!!!
 
  • #75
In the fashion of "Keep your rosaries off of my ovaries" (banner I saw at a DC Pro-Choice rally) my banner will say:

Keep your law of the land off of my mammary glands...

:)

I agree! Do not attempt to regulate women's bodies. Period. What goes in them, what comes out of them and when is entirely a woman's decision. The end.
 
  • #76
I don't think she was advocating a "law". Just overzealous enthusiasm and passion, promoting breast feeding.
 
  • #77
I'm going off on a tangent, and ranting my opinions on this topic, because I think this is much more serious than it seems on the surface.
So, feel free to skip this post.
If I'm crossing lines, mods please snip as needed.

This over-indulged supermodel is smart enough to know exactly that what she is saying. What she suggests is a way of putting more people into the hands of the prison-for-profit system, and, since she thinks it should be world-wide, she's supporting the hells that are prisons in some of the most corrupt political regimes in the world.
For-profit prisons make money from various levels of government based on how many bodies they process and house and, I have no doubt, abusive forced labour of those held prisoner by these trumped up charges. Even the children.
www.globalresearch.ca/the-prison-industry-in-the-united-states-big-busines...
http://www.afscme.org/news/publications/privatization/pdf/AFSCME-Report_Making-A-Killing.pdf
This is the same for-profit industry that pays judges to throw high school kids in jail for being late for school or truant, even when their marks are excellent and they are late because they are working to support themselves. Further, it seems that these systems are often not held publicly accountable.
http://www.jstor.org/discover/10.2307/29768470?uid=2129&uid=2&uid=70&uid=4&sid=21103203150143
This system also pays millions of dollars to judges in kickbacks.
http://variety.com/2013/film/reviews/kids-for-cash-review-1200911791/
The victims of Mark Ciavarella may never recover from the horror of their experience. Including the 10 year old sentenced to two years in detention for accidentally bottoming out his mother's car.
Ciavarella was told to repay $1.2 million in restitution. I wonder how much he was paid for the little boy who killed himself after his release? And he's one of the ones who's been caught. How many have evaded detection or prosecution?
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/w...s-role-in--kidsforcash-kickbacks-8598147.html
And politicians are involved up to their eyebrows.
http://tucsoncitizen.com/cell-out-a...riations-committee-appropriated-by-geo-group/

Sadly, although on its face, it seems ridiculous to jail women for not being able to nurse their children (the women who allow their children to be adopted can't be there for six months, the women who adopt can't nurse them, the women who need certain kinds of medication can't nurse them, women who have to hold down jobs to support their families most often can't nurse them, women who are starving can't nurse their babies--lots of fodder for the prison machine) but I would not put it past politicians and their enablers, both male and female, to put something like this into law if it would put money into their campaign war chests.
Right now laws in the US are being planned in which women can be jailed for having miscarriages because bigots ignorant of the factors involved in carrying a baby to term have decided that any woman who does not carry every pregnancy to term must have deliberately aborted the baby.
http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2013/05/buckhalter-mississippi-stillbirth-manslaughter
This is a logical outcome in a society that sees a woman as a person until she's pregnant and then just sees her as a vessel for a man's seed, even if the man raped her.
http://www.businessinsider.com/rape-victim-sues-state-of-massachusetts-2013-8

I don't see this as a fluffy off hand over-zealous remark made under pressure. All the pressure, that is, of working on a schedule convenient to her with her entourage present to look after both her and her baby. This woman didn't make all her money by being dumb.
I see it as one of many attempts to deny personhood to women as they make the choices needed for themselves and their families. No one should be inserting themselves into the decisions of another person or a family. Such personal, complex decisions should be made solely by the people involved.

To me, it's aggravating that such a nasty comment was made by a celebrity who I now see as just another mean spirited "beauty" who is too selfish to consider the lives other women lead let alone the repercussions of her statements. My bet is that, should there be a public backlash, her PR team will simply issue a stock non-apology in her name while promoting her latest project.

Her comment really bothered me. Not only did it make me consider just what kind of a world it will be by the time my granddaughter is old enough to be injured by such a law, but that it is possible for such a law to be passed.

Please note: I do not believe that the people working in prisons are responsible for the laws that are passed and which they are forced to uphold. The "law-makers" are responsible for the horrors visited on people out of all proportion in relation to the supposed infractions they are accused of committing. Wiping out a conviction is a minor step in righting the wrong (which has happened to many of Ciavarella's victims) . Forcing for-profit prison profiteers to pay for their egregious behaviour out of their own pockets directly to their victims should also be part of the process. And every politician who accepted money from fppps should be forced to publicly apologize to every person injured by their actions. Then they should explain to their supporters why they believe being late for school should result in children never being allowed to attend university or being too stigmatized by convictions to get good jobs. All so someone will make even more money from their sorrow.

Finished ranting.
Back to more seasonal peace, love, and joy.
 
  • #78
The proofs in the pudding Gis


Let's wait and see how smart/well balanced/healthy/happy your kids are as teenagers before we go dictating if Breast. Is Always Best, shall we?

Signed
Failed Breast Feeder.
 
  • #79
  • #80
http://www.boston.com/lifestyle/health/mdmama/Screen Shot 2013-12-11 at 8.27.53 AM.png

This is a truly beautiful photo. To which NO real, normal Mom can possibly relate.

Really, I can't imagine what she was attempting to convey here...

I think a few messages are conveyed here.

1. You can sleep and still get beautiful while breastfeeding, if you have three or four makeup artists working on you.

2. You can go to work and still breastfeed.

3. This is NOT normal women and NOT a normal life, so don't take anything I say seriously, and don't worry if you don't look like I look. Even *I* don't look like I look. SRSLY.

Sigh.

Best-
Herding Cats
 

Staff online

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
128
Guests online
2,961
Total visitors
3,089

Forum statistics

Threads
632,566
Messages
18,628,447
Members
243,196
Latest member
turningstones
Back
Top