Carruthers, Chester
Case date: 1981Town: Harrison
On 08/13/76, Caruthers' mother reported her son had been missing for two weeks. On 05/13/81, human remains were discovered behind a residence off Route 35 in Harrison, Maine. They were later identified as Caruthers.
Unsolved Homicide Unit | Maine State Police
The investigation into the murder of Chester Carruthers was old when it arrived on Peter Herring’s desk.
Carruthers, a 15-year-old Harrison boy, had disappeared in 1976, but his body wasn’t found until 1981, when a neighbor’s pet dog arrived home carrying a skull. Carruthers had been shot once in the head shortly after his disappearance, his body left in the woods a quarter-mile from his house.
Herring, then a homicide investigator with the Maine State Police, was charged with trying to uncover the long, cold trail of the killer. Herring tracked down a suspect, but could never pull together enough evidence to make an arrest and be sure of a conviction.
Excerpt from Detectives shake the dust from unsolved murder cases