Meredith Kercher murdered-Amanda Knox appeals conviction #12

Status
Not open for further replies.
  • #501
  • #502
Are you surprised that the people who have been harassed by Mignini might have contacted the CPJ? They interviewed all the "plaintiffs". It seems as though they all had contact with the organization. What exactly is your opinion regarding Preston? That he tells them what to do and they do it? That the organization has no integrity? Sfarzo seems to be the centerpiece of the complaint if you ask me.

Hearing that yet another group from the US wants to dictate how things are done in Italy doesn't surprise me. That it is not taken seriously by many doesn't surprise me. If a group in the US wants to tell US journalists what to do, that's fine with me. If a group in the US wants to tell people in other countries what to do, I'm bewildered. Mostly, I want to know what those US journalist would have to say if Italians told them what to do.
 
  • #503
  • #504
  • #505
  • #506
Hearing that yet another group from the US wants to dictate how things are done in Italy doesn't surprise me. That it is not taken seriously by many doesn't surprise me. If a group in the US wants to tell US journalists what to do, that's fine with me. If a group in the US wants to tell people in other countries what to do, I'm bewildered. Mostly, I want to know what those US journalist would have to say if Italians told them what to do.

It seems you're trying to come up with any random reason to discredit a group of people whose whole reason for existence is to protect certain people from harm. The fact that the CPJ is based in the US is a very weak reason to be offended when their actions are under such good intentions.
 
  • #507
It seems you're trying to come up with any random reason to discredit a group of people whose whole reason for existence is to protect certain people from harm. The fact that the CPJ is based in the US is a very weak reason to be offended when their actions are under such good intentions.

Laws in the US are different from many other countries. If people like Preston don't like Italian laws, he should stay out of Italy. We know that novelist Doug Preston injected himself into an ongoing serial murder investigation in a foreign country because he wanted a juicy story to help his career. He slid up to an Italian journalist who had connections to police. The prosecutors office decided that Preston was interfering with the investigation, and indeed became suspicious of Preston's activities and knowledge of the investigation. As a result, Preston was detained and questioned for something like 5 hours. This so tremendously upset Preston that he left the country, and has not stopped talking about it since that event years ago.

Are we supposed to think that this now means that journalists are not at liberty to report facts and news in Italy? Of course not. Are we supposed to think that journalists can say whatever they want, true or false, about public figures? Again, of course not. I think it means that novelists should not interfere with a police investigation.

I'd like to know what Preston thought would happen when he injected himself into a murder investigation. Did he think that because he was a novelist, the police would take him into their fold and treat him like an investigator? Was he upset that he was considered to be interfering? What exactly is his complaint? I view him as a guy with an agenda who conveniently attached himself to Knox to further his cause - and career as a novelist.
 
  • #508
Has an admin stated this?

Linking to Blocked URLs

"If, when posting a link to another site, the address is replaced by asterisks ****** in your post, this means it is a blocked site and should not be linked or posted here in any way. We understand that many do not know a site is blocked until they attempt to post the address. So,please delete your post if you inadvertently post a blocked site, or contact the forum moderator for assistance. Remember, if you cannot link to the source, you cannot copy any information from that site in your post. There are various reasons for blocking certain sites and attempts to circumvent these blocks by altering the link to bypass the censor will be met with zero tolerance and a potential permanent ban."

Rules Etiquette & Information - Websleuths Crime Sleuthing Community
 
  • #509
  • #510
Laws in the US are different from many other countries. If people like Preston don't like Italian laws, he should stay out of Italy. We know that novelist Doug Preston injected himself into an ongoing serial murder investigation in a foreign country because he wanted a juicy story to help his career. He slid up to an Italian journalist who had connections to police. The prosecutors office decided that Preston was interfering with the investigation, and indeed became suspicious of Preston's activities and knowledge of the investigation. As a result, Preston was detained and questioned for something like 5 hours. This so tremendously upset Preston that he left the country, and has not stopped talking about it since that event years ago.

Are we supposed to think that this now means that journalists are not at liberty to report facts and news in Italy? Of course not. Are we supposed to think that journalists can say whatever they want, true or false, about public figures? Again, of course not. I think it means that novelists should not interfere with a police investigation.

I'd like to know what Preston thought would happen when he injected himself into a murder investigation. Did he think that because he was a novelist, the police would take him into their fold and treat him like an investigator? Was he upset that he was considered to be interfering? What exactly is his complaint? I view him as a guy with an agenda who conveniently attached himself to Knox to further his cause - and career as a novelist.

You can take Preston out of the equation if you don't believe his version of what happened. There are still several other reporters mentioned in the CPJ's open letter. This isn't just about Preston, though you seem intent on making it solely about him.
 
  • #511
  • #512
Works for me
Yes, I reposted it. You may have copied it from another post, in which case it would be abbreviated and not linkable.
 
  • #513
Yes, I reposted it. You may have copied it from another post, in which case it would be abbreviated for the rest of us.

Are my links ok then? Did I do something wrong? No asterisks came up for me
 
  • #514
Are my links ok then? Did I do something wrong? No asterisks came up for me
they seem to be fine except copyright issues. I did edit one down to 10%, and if the other one is quoting more than 10% from the linked site, please take a minute to cut it down to no more than 10% copied from another site.
Gracias.
 
  • #515
they seem to be fine except copyright issues. I did edit one down to 10%, and if the other one is quoting more than 10% from the linked site, please take a minute to cut it down to no more than 10% copied from another site.
Gracias.

Great thanks :)

ooops is past the time to edit :( if you can then i can repost in different posts
 
  • #516
In video 5 above, around 3-4 minutes, Mgnini says he knew instantly that it was a staged breakin because the front door was fully intact.

He said if the door hadn't been, he'd consider it a breakin. That's illogical. It's illogical to think a burglar will only gain entry through a front door. So I guess even if the balcony had been broken into, he wouldn't have believed it because the front door was intact.
 
  • #517
It's neat though to see Frank in the videos! :rocker:

So, TJMK is run by Peter Quennell? (6:15 in the video). Is HE the machine?
 
  • #518
It's neat though to see Frank in the videos! :rocker:

So, TJMK is run by Peter Quennell? (6:15 in the video). Is HE the machine?

Yikes sorry I have not had time to look at all of them which one is it?
 
  • #519
I'm in video 5, where they are talking about bloggers and blogging wars. It was about 6:15.

Allusunz, i'm seriously and in earnest advising that you just go with what Jbean said and ignore everything else about the link you put on the board. Jbean said it was okay, but for the amount of citing you did. So you're fine. Don't worry about it.
 
  • #520
Status
Not open for further replies.

Staff online

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
158
Guests online
1,407
Total visitors
1,565

Forum statistics

Threads
632,450
Messages
18,626,853
Members
243,158
Latest member
bcallred
Back
Top