Judge tosses out charges against father of murdered baby
http://www.thenewsherald.com/stories/012708/loc_20080127002.shtml
LINCOLN PARK Whoever killed 8-day-old Nevaeh Anne Richardson likely will never be brought to justice.
That was the chilling conclusion reached by a Wayne County prosecutor Friday after a judge ruled that there wasn't enough evidence to charge the infant's father with the crime.
"An innocent baby is killed ... and we may never have the killer in custody," said Lora Weingarden, the assistant Wayne County prosecutor who handled the case.
Without mincing words, 25th District Judge David Bajorek blasted police for the way they investigated and presented their case against Christopher Ryan Richardson, 21, of Lincoln Park.
The judge said he "would never have signed the complaint and warrant" charging Richardson with the crime had detectives been more forthcoming about the evidence they had when they initially presented the case to him.
Bajorek said the evidence presented during Friday's preliminary examination was "much different" from what detectives told him when they convinced him to sign the warrant in November charging Richardson with felony murder, first-degree criminal sexual conduct and first-degree child abuse.
The judge said prosecutors had no physical evidence linking Richardson to the crime, and added that several other people had access to the child during the same time period.
While the result of a polygraph test can't legally be admitted as evidence, the interview portion of a polygraph test can be.
Bajorek said that during a polygraph test administered to Richardson, Taylor police Sgt. Michael Anthony spent six hours telling Richardson lies in "an attempt to induce him to make an incriminating statement."
For instance, the judge said, Anthony told Richardson that police had DNA evidence linking him to the crime when they didn't.
Despite those claims, the judge said, Richardson remained steadfast during the six-hour test that he had nothing to do with his daughter's death.
At the end of the test, Bajorek said, Richardson said it's possible his fingernail might have scraped against the baby's anus while he was changing a diaper.
That's the part prosecutors were hoping might link him to the crime as Nevaeh died Nov. 24 from "anal intrusion."
According to police, Richardson and the baby's mother, Cynthia Goscicki, took Nevaeh to Henry Ford Wyandotte Hospital on Nov. 23 after discovering blood coming from the baby's mouth and nose.Employees there noticed additional trauma to the infant's rectum and called police before transferring Nevaeh to Children's Hospital of Michigan in Detroit. The baby died the next day. An autopsy ruled her death a homicide.
An autopsy concluded that the infant died from massive internal bleeding and sepsis, a blood disorder. Before she died, the infant also suffered bruising to her head and ears, as well as injuries to her genital area. Her right eye also was bloodied.
Lincoln Park Police Chief Thomas Karnes said he believes his detectives did everything possible with the limited amount of evidence they had.
Unlike the prosecutor who said she doubts anyone else will ever be charged in this case, the chief said he isn't giving up.
More at link.