GUILTY MN - America Thayer, 55, beheaded, Shakopee, 28 July 2021 *ARREST* *NG insanity*

[Niner]

I can not access this article. Can someone give a 10% synopsis on this? TIA!

Shakopee beheading case headed toward mental illness verdict

Alexis Saborit is expected to stipulate to the elements of first-degree premeditated murder and present his mental illness defense on Wednesday.

www.kare11.com

All I can see is this:

Shakopee beheading case headed toward mental illness verdict - KARE 11
KARE 11
Alexis Saborit is expected to stipulate to the elements of first-degree premediated murder and present his mental illness defense Wednesday.

 

[Niner]

01/25/2023 Jury Trial (1:30 PM) (Judicial Officer Lennon, Caroline H.)
01/18/2023 Continued to 01/25/2023 - By agreement - Saborit, Alexis

link: https://pa.courts.state.mn.us/CaseDetail.aspx?CaseID=1629139462

 

[savagewoman]

I can not access this article. Can someone give a 10% synopsis on this? TIA!

Shakopee beheading case headed toward mental illness verdict

Alexis Saborit is expected to stipulate to the elements of first-degree premeditated murder and present his mental illness defense on Wednesday.

www.kare11.com

All I can see is this:

Shakopee beheading case headed toward mental illness verdict - KARE 11
KARE 11
Alexis Saborit is expected to stipulate to the elements of first-degree premediated murder and present his mental illness defense Wednesday.

Snippets:
Now, after two psychological evaluations of the defendant, the Scott County Attorney acknowledges the case is headed toward a likely finding of not guilty by reason of mental illness, followed by civil commitment hearings to determine Saborit's future.
https://www.kare11.com/
On Wednesday, court filings indicate Saborit will waive his right to a jury and hold a stipulated facts trial before Judge Caroline Lennon.
In the two-stage trial for defendants using multiple defenses, Lennon would likely find Saborit guilty in the first phase without any witnesses called to testify. But the mental illness stage of the trial, the only person on the state's witness list is Dr. Andrea Lovett of Morningstar Psychological Service.

 

[Niner]

Snippets:
Now, after two psychological evaluations of the defendant, the Scott County Attorney acknowledges the case is headed toward a likely finding of not guilty by reason of mental illness, followed by civil commitment hearings to determine Saborit's future.
Minneapolis St. Paul News, Weather, Traffic, Sports | Minneapolis, Minnesota | kare11.com
On Wednesday, court filings indicate Saborit will waive his right to a jury and hold a stipulated facts trial before Judge Caroline Lennon.
In the two-stage trial for defendants using multiple defenses, Lennon would likely find Saborit guilty in the first phase without any witnesses called to testify. But the mental illness stage of the trial, the only person on the state's witness list is Dr. Andrea Lovett of Morningstar Psychological Service.

Thanks a bunch!!

 

[Niner]

Wednesday, January 25th:
*Bench Trial set to begin (murder) (@ 1:30pm CT) - MN - America Mafalda Thayer (55) (July 27, 2021, Shakopee, beheaded) - *Alexis Saborit (42/now 43) arrested (7/28/21), charged (7/30/21) & indicted (9/17/21) with 1st degree premeditated murder & 2nd degree murder. Plead not guilty by reason of mental illness. $2.5M bond increased (9/17/21) to $4M.
Trial was set to begin on 1/18/23 continued on 1/25/23 as a Bench Trial.
Case info & court info from 7/27/21 to 11/22/22 reference post #79 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...ed-shakopee-28-july-2021-arrest.579397/page-4
12/5/22: #59: Witness list. Next jury trial on 1/18/23. 1/17/23: Request for continuance needing Judicial approval (#60). eService by State. Saborit is expected to stipulate to the elements of first-degree premediated murder & present his mental illness defense Wednesday. After two psychological evaluations of the defendant, the Scott County Attorney acknowledges the case is headed toward a likely finding of not guilty by reason of mental illness, followed by civil commitment hearings to determine Saborit's future. On Wednesday, court filings indicate Saborit will waive his right to a jury & hold a stipulated facts trial before Judge Caroline Lennon. In the two-stage trial for defendants using multiple defenses, Lennon would likely find Saborit guilty in the first phase without any witnesses called to testify. But the mental illness stage of the trial, the only person on the state's witness list is Dr. Andrea Lovett of Morningstar Psychological Service. Bench trial begins on 1/25/23.

 

[Niner]

Judge presented with evidence, exhibits in Saborit murder trial

The man accused of murdering Shakopee resident America Thayer went on trial before a judge Wednesday in Scott County District Court, though he won't likely learn his fate until March.

www.swnewsmedia.com

Jan. 25, 2023
The man accused of murdering Shakopee resident America Thayer went on trial before a judge Wednesday in Scott County District Court, though he won't likely learn his fate until March.
[.....]
In a mostly empty courtroom in Shakopee on Wednesday, Saborit spoke throughout the proceedings with the help of a Spanish language interpreter. He had waived both his right to a jury trial and his right to testify and instead had a "stipulated facts" trial, also called a court trial, in which a judge decides whether a defendant is guilty — not a jury.

District Court Judge Caroline Lennon, who is presiding over the case, was presented with the evidence, exhibits and arguments. Both the defense and the prosecution then agreed to submit written closing arguments to the court. The state’s argument is due Feb. 8, the defense's argument on Feb. 22 and the state’s rebuttal on Mar. 1.

Saborit’s next appearance in court is slated for Mar. 22. That's later than what would be usual in a trial like this, but due to court scheduling conflicts Saborit waived his right to have a judgment issued within seven days after the end of a trial, as required under Minnesota law, to give the court adequate time to make a ruling. The trial had already been delayed from its initial planned Jan. 18 start date after Saborit contracted COVID-19.
[.....]
Saborit underwent psychological tests last summer at the behest of his defense and in October was found competent to stand trial. His plea hearing was held Nov. 22, 2022.

 

[Niner]

Looks like bench trial has been cancelled since the next court date is just a hearing.

Events & Orders of the Court

Date Disposition
01/25/2023 Court Trial (1:30 PM) (Judicial Officer Lennon, Caroline H.)

01/18/2023 Continued to 01/25/2023 - By agreement - Saborit, Alexis
Result: Held On the Record

01/25/2023 Exhibit List Index # 61

01/25/2023
e-Service
State of Minnesota
Served 01/25/2023

01/25/2023
e-Service
Saborit, Alexis
Served 01/25/2023

01/25/2023
e-Service
Saborit, Alexis
Served 01/25/2023

01/25/2023 Hearing Held In-Person

01/25/2023 Order for Release Index # 62 (Judicial Officer: Lennon, Caroline H. )

01/25/2023 Waiver of Jury Trial Index # 63 (Judicial Officer: Lennon, Caroline H. )

01/25/2023 Order for Submissions-Under Advisement Index # 64 (Judicial Officer: Lennon, Caroline H. )

01/25/2023 Request for Interpreter Index # 65

01/25/2023 Exhibit List Index # 66

02/08/2023 Briefs Index # 67

02/08/2023
e-Service
Saborit, Alexis
Served 02/08/2023

02/08/2023
e-Service
Saborit, Alexis
Served 02/08/2023

03/07/2023 Briefs Index # 68

03/07/2023
e-Service
State of Minnesota
Served 03/07/2023

03/07/2023
e-Service
Saborit, Alexis
Served 03/07/2023

03/08/2023 Order for Submissions-Under Advisement Index # 69 (Judicial Officer: Lennon, Caroline H. )

03/08/2023 Correspondence Index # 70

03/13/2023 Briefs Index # 71

03/13/2023
e-Service
Saborit, Alexis
Served 03/13/2023

03/13/2023
e-Service
Saborit, Alexis
Served 03/13/2023

03/13/2023 Taken Under Advisement Index # 72 (Judicial Officer: Lennon, Caroline H. )

03/22/2023 Hearing (2:00 PM) (Judicial Officer Lennon, Caroline H.)

link: https://pa.courts.state.mn.us/CaseDetail.aspx?CaseID=1629139462

 

[Niner]

Wednesday, March 22nd:
*Hearing (@ 2pm CT) - MN - America Mafalda Thayer (55) (July 27, 2021, Shakopee, beheaded) - *Alexis Saborit (42/now 43) arrested (7/28/21), charged (7/30/21) & indicted (9/17/21) with 1st degree premeditated murder & 2nd degree murder. Plead not guilty by reason of mental illness. $2.5M bond increased (9/17/21) to $4M.
Bench Trial began on 1/25/23 & was vacated.
Case info & court info from 7/27/21 to 11/22/22 reference post #85 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...ed-shakopee-28-july-2021-arrest.579397/page-6
1/25/23 Bench Trial Day 1: Saborit spoke throughout the proceedings with the help of a Spanish language interpreter. He had waived both his right to a jury trial & his right to testify & instead had a "stipulated facts" trial, also called a court trial, in which a judge decides whether a defendant is guilty — not a jury. District Court Judge Caroline Lennon, who is presiding over the case, was presented with the evidence, exhibits & arguments. Both the defense & the prosecution then agreed to submit written closing arguments to the court. The state’s argument is due 2/8/23, the defense's argument on 2/22/22 & the state’s rebuttal on 3/1/23. Saborit’s next appearance in court is slated for 3/22/23. That's later than what would be usual in a trial like this, but due to court scheduling conflicts Saborit waived his right to have a judgment issued within seven days after the end of a trial, as required under Minnesota law, to give the court adequate time to make a ruling. Bench trial continues on 3/22/23.
1/18/23 Update: Court trial continued to 1/25/23 by agreement. Held on record. 1/25/23: e-Service (State-1 & Saborit-2). Hearing held in person. Order for Release (#62). Waiver of Jury Trial (#63). Order for submissions-under advisement (#64). Request for interpreter (#65). Exhibit list (#66). 2/8/23: Briefs (#67). e-Service (Saborit-2).
3/7/23: Briefs (#68). e-Service (State-1 & Saborit-1). 3/8/23: Order for submissions-under advisement (#69). Correspondence (#70). 3/13/23: Briefs (#71). e-Service (Saborit-2). Taken under advisement (#72). Next hearing on 3/22/23 @ 2pm.

 

[Niner]

Events & Orders of the Court:

Date Disposition
03/22/2023 CANCELED Hearing (2:00 PM) (Judicial Officer Lennon, Caroline H.)
Other

03/22/2023 Order for Release Index # 73 (Judicial Officer: Lennon, Caroline H. )

03/22/2023 Request for Interpreter Index # 74

05/11/2023 Hearing (1:30 PM) (Judicial Officer Lennon, Caroline H.)

link: https://pa.courts.state.mn.us/CaseDetail.aspx?CaseID=1629139462

 

[Niner]

Thursday, May 11th:
*Hearing (@ 1:30pm CT) - MN - America Mafalda Thayer (55) (July 27, 2021, Shakopee, beheaded) - *Alexis Saborit (42/now 44) arrested (7/28/21), charged (7/30/21) & indicted (9/17/21) with 1st degree premeditated murder & 2nd degree murder. Plead not guilty by reason of mental illness. $2.5M bond increased (9/17/21) to $4M.
Bench Trial began on 1/25/23 & was vacated.
Case info & court info from 7/27/21 to 3/8/23 reference post #88 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...ed-shakopee-28-july-2021-arrest.579397/page-5
3/13/23: Briefs (#71). e-Service (Saborit-2). Taken under advisement (#72). Next hearing on 3/22/23 @ 2pm. 3/22/23 Update: Hearing was cancelled by Judge Caroline H. Lennon. Order for release (#73) by Judge Lennon. Request for interpreter (#74). Next hearing on 5/11/23 @ 1:30pm.

 

[savagewoman]

https://bringmethenews.com/minnesot...uilty-of-beheading-his-girlfriend-in-shakopee

SBM
Scott County judge Caroline Lennon delivered the verdict via a court order, finding Saborit guilty of 1st-degree murder. According to court documents, the judge found "beyond a reasonable doubt" that Saborit killed Thayer with intent and premeditation.

Lennon said in her decision that the nature of the assault — in which Saborit used a dumbbell to initially strike Thayer before turning to the machete — is enough proof to show intent. The judge also pointed out that Saborit showed off the machete to people known to him prior to the murder, which could be a "inference of premeditation."

Saborit previously waived his right to a trial by jury and to a speedy trial. Instead, the judge decided Saborit's fate in a stipulated facts trial. The trial took place in January with closing arguments occurring in February and March, according to court records.

A review hearing is scheduled for June 1. Saborit's 1st-degree murder conviction carries a life sentence. It's likely Saborit won't have any possibility of parole.

 

[Niner]

https://bringmethenews.com/minnesot...uilty-of-beheading-his-girlfriend-in-shakopee

SBM
Scott County judge Caroline Lennon delivered the verdict via a court order, finding Saborit guilty of 1st-degree murder. According to court documents, the judge found "beyond a reasonable doubt" that Saborit killed Thayer with intent and premeditation.

Lennon said in her decision that the nature of the assault — in which Saborit used a dumbbell to initially strike Thayer before turning to the machete — is enough proof to show intent. The judge also pointed out that Saborit showed off the machete to people known to him prior to the murder, which could be a "inference of premeditation."

Saborit previously waived his right to a trial by jury and to a speedy trial. Instead, the judge decided Saborit's fate in a stipulated facts trial. The trial took place in January with closing arguments occurring in February and March, according to court records.

A review hearing is scheduled for June 1. Saborit's 1st-degree murder conviction carries a life sentence. It's likely Saborit won't have any possibility of parole.

Thank you for this!!

I had that trial vacated in my notes. Will change them now! Good know he was found guilty!

 

[Niner]

Upcoming Hearing:
Review Hearing on 06/01/2023 at 1:00 PM

link: Case Search - Minnesota Court Records Online (MCRO)

on this link ^^ you can find the Judge's verdict

 

[imstilla.grandma]

Alexis Saborit, 44, was found guilty in the slaying of America Thayer, 56, in July 2021.

The Minneapolis Star Tribune reports that Saborit struck Thayer with an 8-pound dumbbell while they were in a vehicle near downtown Shakopee, then he decapitated her with a machete.

People in other cars and nearby homes saw the attack. One of them shot a video that appeared to show Saborit pull Thayer's body out of the car into the street then pick up her head by the hair.

Saborit and Thayer were on the way to his court appearance for felony charges alleging that he set fire to their apartment in Shakopee during a confrontation with police and that Saborit attacked Thayer after she told him she wanted to end their relationship.

Saborit fled the scene and disposed of the machete along the way. He was arrested about 1 ½ miles away near the TraveLodge Hotel where he was staying.

County Attorney Ron Hocevar said he was pleased with the verdict, and that he expects Saborit to be sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole.

Minnesota Man Who Beheaded Girlfriend Convicted of First-Degree Murder

A Minnesota man has been convicted of first-degree murder for beheading his girlfriend in front of several witnesses in July 2021.

www.nbcbayarea.com

 

[Niner]

Thursday, June 1st:
*Review Hearing (@ 1pm CT) - MN - America Mafalda Thayer (55) (July 27, 2021, Shakopee, beheaded) - *Alexis Saborit (42/now 44) arrested (7/28/21), charged (7/30/21) & indicted (9/17/21) with 1st degree premeditated murder & 2nd degree murder. Plead not guilty by reason of mental illness. $2.5M bond increased (9/17/21) to $4M.
Bench Trial began on 1/25/23 & ended on 3/22/23 with a guilty verdict.
Case info & court info from 7/27/21 to 3/13/23 reference post #90 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...ed-shakopee-28-july-2021-arrest.579397/page-5
3/22/23 Update: Hearing was cancelled by Judge Caroline H. Lennon. Order for release (#73) by Judge Lennon. Request for interpreter (#74). Next hearing on 5/11/23 @ 1:30pm.
5/11/23 Update: Scott County judge Caroline Lennon delivered the verdict via a court order, finding Saborit guilty of 1st degree murder. According to court documents, the judge found "beyond a reasonable doubt" that Saborit killed Thayer with intent & premeditation. Judge Lennon said in her decision that the nature of the assault — in which Saborit used a dumbbell to initially strike Thayer before turning to the machete — is enough proof to show intent. The judge also pointed out that Saborit showed off the machete to people known to him prior to the murder, which could be a "inference of premeditation." Saborit previously waived his right to a trial by jury & to a speedy trial. Instead, the judge decided Saborit's fate in a stipulated facts trial. The trial took place in January with closing arguments occurring in February & March, according to court records. A review hearing is scheduled for 6/1/23. Saborit's 1st degree murder conviction carries a life sentence. It's likely Saborit won't have any possibility of parole.

 

[Niner]

Docket update:

06/01/2023: Request for Interpreter
Judicial Officer: Lennon, Caroline H.
Party: Defendant Saborit, Alexis
Index #89

06/01/2023: Order for Release
Judicial Officer: Lennon, Caroline H.
Index #88
2 pages

06/01/2023: Hearing Held In-Person
05/31/2023
Notice of Filing of Order
Index #87
1 page

05/31/2023: Order Regarding Visual or Audio Coverage
Judicial Officer: Lennon, Caroline H.
Index #86



Upcoming Hearing:
Court Trial on 06/23/2023 at 8:30 AM

link: Case Search - Minnesota Court Records Online (MCRO)

wondering if this will be his sentencing hearing? On the "Order for Release" - it says Court Trial. Since he has plead guilty - I can not see this going to trial.... ??

 

[Niner]

Friday, June 23rd:
*Sentencing Hearing (@ 8:30am CT) - MN - America Mafalda Thayer (55) (July 27, 2021, Shakopee, beheaded) - *Alexis Saborit (42/now 44) arrested (7/28/21), charged (7/30/21) & indicted (9/17/21) with 1st degree premeditated murder & 2nd degree murder. Plead not guilty by reason of mental illness. $2.5M bond increased (9/17/21) to $4M.
Bench Trial began on 1/25/23 & ended on 3/22/23 with a guilty verdict.
Case info & court info from 7/27/21 to 3/22/23 reference post #95 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...ed-shakopee-28-july-2021-arrest.579397/page-5
5/11/23 Update: Scott County judge Caroline Lennon delivered the verdict via a court order, finding Saborit guilty of 1st degree murder. According to court documents, the judge found "beyond a reasonable doubt" that Saborit killed Thayer with intent & premeditation. Judge Lennon said in her decision that the nature of the assault — in which Saborit used a dumbbell to initially strike Thayer before turning to the machete — is enough proof to show intent. The judge also pointed out that Saborit showed off the machete to people known to him prior to the murder, which could be a "inference of premeditation." Saborit previously waived his right to a trial by jury & to a speedy trial. Instead, the judge decided Saborit's fate in a stipulated facts trial. The trial took place in January with closing arguments occurring in February & March, according to court records. A review hearing is scheduled for 6/1/23. Saborit's 1st degree murder conviction carries a life sentence. It's likely Saborit won't have any possibility of parole.
6/1/23 Update: Hearing held in person. Order for Release Index #88. Request for interpreter (#89). Next sentencing hearing on 6/23/23 @ 8:30am.

 

[Niner]

Minnesota has a new court site - not sure that I am liking it very much - but at least you can actually "see" the documents that are filed unlike before. There were 2 attachments, but I am not posting the link as it has my name on it, so I have typed up "what they say".

Sounds like Saborit is going to be released re Order for Release down below?? Is that how anyone reading here think?

Sentencing has been moved...


Case Events:

06/23/2023 Request for Interpreter
Party: Defendant Saborit, Alexis
Index #93

06/23/2023 Order for Submissions-Under Advisement
Judicial Officer: Lennon, Caroline H.
Index #92
[Exhibit list]

06/23/2023 Exhibit List
Judicial Officer: Lennon, Caroline H.
Index #91

06/23/2023 Order for Release
Judicial Officer: Lennon, Caroline H.
Index #90
[Bail remains as set previously. [me: His bail/bond is $4M]
2) Keep Court & attorney informed of any changes of address & stay in touch. 3) Not leave the State of Minnesota without written court approval. 4) Make all future court appearances with the next being Verdict (sentencing) on 7/18/23 @ 1pm. 5) Not possess or consume Alcoholic beverages, controlled substances not prescribed by a physician. 6) Have no use or possession of firearms & surrender all firearms upon release within 3 hours of release. 7) Have no contact with victim. 10) Remain law abiding. 11) Other: Sign releases.

06/23/2023 Hearing Held In-Person


Upcoming Hearing:
Hearing on 07/18/2023 at 1:00 PM

link: Case Search - Minnesota Court Records Online (MCRO)

 

[Niner]

Tuesday, July 18th:
*Sentencing Hearing (@ 1pm CT) - MN - America Mafalda Thayer (55) (July 27, 2021, Shakopee, beheaded) - *Alexis Saborit (42/now 44) arrested (7/28/21), charged (7/30/21) & indicted (9/17/21) with 1st degree premeditated murder & 2nd degree murder. Plead not guilty by reason of mental illness. $2.5M bond increased (9/17/21) to $4M.
Bench Trial began on 1/25/23 & ended on 3/22/23 with a guilty verdict. Sentencing hearing on 7/18/23.
Case info & court info from 7/27/21 to 5/11/23 reference post #97 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...ed-shakopee-28-july-2021-arrest.579397/page-5
6/1/23 Update: Hearing held in person. Order for Release Index #88. Request for interpreter (#89). Next hearing on 6/23/23 @ 8:30am to determine Saborit’s mental health defense.
6/23/23 Update: Judge Caroline H. Lennon presiding. Hearing held in-person to determine Saborit’s mental health defense. Index #90-Order for Release: [Bail remains as set previously. 2) Keep Court & attorney informed of any changes of address & stay in touch. 3) Not leave the State of Minnesota without written court approval. 4) Make all future court appearances with the next being Verdict (sentencing) on 7/18/23 @ 1pm. 5) Not possess or consume Alcoholic beverages, controlled substances not prescribed by a physician. 6) Have no use or possession of firearms & surrender all firearms upon release within 3 hours of release. 7) Have no contact with victim. 10) Remain law abiding. 11) Other: Sign releases. Index #91-Exhibit list. Index #92: Order for submissions =-under advisement. Index #93: Request for interpreter. Sentencing hearing on 7/18/23 @ 1pm.

 

[Niner]

Alexis Saborit found not guilty by reason of mental illness in girlfriend's beheading

A man who was found guilty of first-degree murder in the first part of a stipulated facts trial after beheading his girlfriend inside a car, dumping her body and fleeing has now been found not guilty by reason of mental illness.

www.cbsnews.com

July 18, 2023

SHAKOPEE, Minn. -- A man who was found guilty of first-degree murder in the first part of a stipulated facts trial after beheading his girlfriend inside a car, dumping her body and fleeing has now been found not guilty by reason of mental illness.

Because Alexis Saborit pleaded not guilty due to mental illness, the trial comprised two phases: one to determine his guilt, and one to determine his "state of mind and resulting culpability," per the court.
[.....]
A judge in May ruled Saborit did indeed commit the killing, but Monday, a judge found him not guilty by reason of mental illness. The judge noted Saborit's medical history includes a traumatic brain injury, "symptoms of mania in conjunction with psychosis" and a "significant history" of non-compliance with prescribed treatments.

Two doctors analyzed Saborit's case and determined he "was suffering from mental illness to the extent that it prevented him from understanding the moral wrongfulness of his actions during the alleged offense."

The judge found "no deficit in the experts' review of the record or the soundness of their analysis," per court documents.
[.....]
Saborit will be held at the Scott County Jail until he can be transferred to a psychiatric care facility.