MN - One dead after Minneapolis shooting involving immigration agents, US media report, January 24, 2026

  • #1,281

Trump repeats claim Alex Pretti should not have been carrying a gun​

Even though Trump came to Iowa to try and shift focus away from the fallout in Minneapolis, he's asked several times about it.

Facing questions on a stop off before the rally in Des Moines, the US president repeated his claim that Alex Pretti should not have carried a gun.

He added:


I'm sorry, what now? Alex was legally permitted to carry a handgun under Minnesota Law, so Trump saying he shouldn't have been carrying a gun but also insisting on Second Amendment rights is LUDICROUS. So everyone has the right to carry, but you shouldn't carry when law enforcement show up, how confusing and contradicting and an absolute grasp in trying to justify incompetence by the officers involved. jmo.

Just want to highlight this part from your link.

"Trump ..... But all of us-hey, look, bottom line, everybody in this room, we view that as a very unfortunate incident."
 
  • #1,282
  • #1,283
My theory is many are unqualified, J6’ers, proud boys, 3 percenters, white supremacists, militia and failed military trigger happy goons

Wouldn't it really really be intersting just how their recruitment, interviewing and selecting happens?
 
  • #1,284
  • #1,285
  • #1,286
I think the gun laws are governed by the states? Not the federal govt, and not the president.
At least, that is what I understand from the varying gun laws between the states.

imo
It's a general federal right to bear arms, but what exactly that means, what the permitting or licensing requirements are, and if specific guns or ammo or quantities of ammo may be purchased varies by state.

I am not a resident of MN, but my best inference from this case is that a visible handgun can be carried by an adult, but you need a permit to conceal carry. It's also possible that you need a permit for a handgun, and an extra endorsement on the permit to hide the gun on your body.

It seems more peaceful when people like Alex are hiding the gun, but a bad actor hiding a gun is definitely worse than a bad actor displaying a gun. At least it can be seen when they are reaching for it.

MOO
 
  • #1,287
Noem stated it in her interview with Fox: https://www.cnn.com/2026/01/25/politics/trump-officials-shifting-rhetoric-alex-pretti

That is legitimately the only source (Noem/DHS) I can find of these claims. The police chief in Minneapolis said he was carrying legally - also in the linked article.

I will point out two lies from Noem she said in the same interview as claiming he had no id:
  • Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem claimed Pretti “attacked” officers, an assertion echoed by FBI Director Kash Patel, but no footage available as of Sunday afternoon shows Pretti committing any attack.
  • Noem claimed Pretti was “brandishing” a gun, but no available footage shows Pretti even holding a weapon in his hand at the scene; a concealed gun appeared to be taken from his waistband area by a federal agent moments before he was shot.

Are you actually saying that Noem is the only source of "no ID" ????
 
  • #1,288
 
  • #1,289
Wouldn't it really really be intersting just how their recruitment, interviewing and selecting happens?

With regard to this case, Alex Pretti, it is interesting to hear about the sloppy hiring process. Because the ICE altercations with the public sure seem sloppy and brutal.

A journalist applied for an ICE job. She is an anti-ICE journalist. She explained how the recruitment process worked for her. She was offered a job with ICE despite having submitted none of the 'required' paperwork. (Obviously, she declined the job.)

It is a very interesting read, considering the killings of both Renee and Alex.

imo


“DHS probably has no idea whether ICE offered me a job, which is kind of the point of the article: they have no idea what they’re doing,” she told the Guardian.

 
  • #1,290
A few hours after federal agents fatally shot Alex Pretti in front of a Minneapolis donut shop, snowy footsteps, exploded tear gas and flash bang canisters and crumpled police tape littered the street where he died.

To casual observers, it was a mess. To the Minnesota professionals whose job it is to secure officer-involved crime scenes and collect evidence when someone is killed, it was an emergency.

The third emergency, in fact, in less than three weeks involving a breakdown of basic law enforcement procedures and coordination needed to investigate and restore a traumatized community’s sense of accountability and trust.
The evidence tug-o-war in Alex Pretti killing and why it matters
 
  • #1,291
Are you actually saying that Noem is the only source of "no ID" ????
He was leaving his shift. People in hospitals and almost every large workplace display at the very least work badges, and usually need them to get through doors, pick up prints at copiers, park their cars, etc.

MOO
 
  • #1,292
Are you actually saying that Noem is the only source of "no ID" ????
Can you find a source other than Noem and other DHS spokespeople? Personally, I cannot.
 
  • #1,293
Notice sent to congressional officials from U.S. Customs and Border Protection with details on fatal shooting of protester Alex Pretti says two federal immigration officials discharged their weapons, both Glocks. During the struggle, a Border Patrol yelled, "He’s got a gun!" multiple times. There's no mention of Pretti brandishing his gun prior to the shooting. Minutes before, at 9 a.m., a CBP officer was confronted by two female civilians blowing whistles. The women were ordered to move out of the Minneapolis roadway, but did not move. Pretti was pronounced dead at 9:32 a.m



 
  • #1,294
Humans are strange.

I have a funny feeling that changing "anti ICE protester" to "Pro Life protester" and..... a certain number of people would be dialing the prudence component of legal weapons carrying waaaay up.

Some of those same humans who now cry "murder" could well be crying "FAFO" regarding a pro lifer's decision to carry a weapon to a protest. Others would be "shocked and appalled" at the lack of personal responsibility.

Of course, others would strongly deny any personal bias and claim that human behavior is restricted solely to the humans on the other side.....
IMO
What they are protesting for or against is just noise or an attempt at distraction. In my mind it is neither here nor there- its just an attempt to deflect and redirect. The protesters have a right to be doing what they are doing per the LAW. Period. No matter who they are.

I support ICE - but not when they operate outside their parameters, use unnecessary force and kill someone - aka do not operate within the LAW - they need to be investigated and charges brought. Just like any other LE they need to follow the LAW.

I cannot imagine standing on a sidewalk in my town and have anyone push me over from behind purposely for no reason. I would call the police and file charges. Esp if it was a police officer that randomly pushed me over. If it happened in my house, it would be called domestic abuse and I would also file charges bc its not just appalling it is against the LAW. And that is just for starters.

This is not a Netflix series we are discussing or a fun debate to score points - its real life - there is a real dead man, a promising life cut short, a family left behind and so much collateral damage done. And for no reason - what happened was wrong and a big error in judgement. It needs to be investigated and charges brought imo.

There are mistakes made in any profession and there are bad apples in any profession. I think what we are seeing is the result of some bad apples being told to "unleash the hounds" by their superiors bc they have immunity ( which they don't). An investigation will hopefully get to the bottom of it.

To take and smear a victim or blame them or insinuate they are dead bc they should have stayed home, etc - How far have we fallen as a society to think any of this is okay.

JUST MY OPINION
 
  • #1,295
  • #1,296
Notice sent to congressional officials from U.S. Customs and Border Protection with details on fatal shooting of protester Alex Pretti says two federal immigration officials discharged their weapons, both Glocks. During the struggle, a Border Patrol yelled, "He’s got a gun!" multiple times. There's no mention of Pretti brandishing his gun prior to the shooting. Minutes before, at 9 a.m., a CBP officer was confronted by two female civilians blowing whistles. The women were ordered to move out of the Minneapolis roadway, but did not move. Pretti was pronounced dead at 9:32 a.m



Reminder: he was shot multiple times
 
  • #1,297
Thinking (haunted) nonstop about this catastrophic tragedy, the killing of Alex Pretti, and the previous catastrophic tragedy, the killing of Renee Macklin Good, and working hard to stay on focus and filter my thoughts through a true-crime framework, I think I've settled on some elements to consider.

I have to believe I'm not the only person here who, in the hours after Ms. Good was killed, feared such a shooting would happen again. Then it did. Now I'm waiting for the next one; I can't not.

IMO, pattern of criminal conduct may pertain here. These next few elements pertaining to pattern of criminal conduct are just my opinions/observations.

In both cases, agents believed themselves to be engaged in confontation with ordinary citizens.

In both cases, agents were not communicating with each other or the victims in a cohesive, consistent manner.

In both cases, de-escalation efforts were not undertaken by agents.

In both cases, weapons were quickly drawn and fired, resulting in near-immediate deaths.

In both cases, citizens with medical credentials were denied access to the victims.

In both cases, agents quickly vacated the scene.

I think there are other elements in both shootings that are indicative of a pattern of criminal conduct, but to start here is enough to raise my question, which is: Did the institution that employed, trained and deployed these agents in fact create the pattern of criminal conduct? If so, how does that institution face justice?
 
  • #1,298
I certainly dont see it that way. ICE has requested that Minneapolis police assist with crowd control in these situations. The Mayor wont allow it. They aren't asking MPD to help them with the immigration arrests, just to keep the peace. Isn't that a police department's job? Neither one of these fatal shootings would have happened if police had been on scene to help with crowd control.

Was there a problem with crowd control? Do you have a link that suggests the crowd was rowdy? From what I see, it was several groups of citizens exercising their right to protest. Where does crowd control come in and how does it prevent an agent from tackling a man to the ground and shooting him in the back multiple times despite neutralizing any potential threat?

MOO.
 
  • #1,299
He was leaving his shift. People in hospitals and almost every large workplace display at the very least work badges, and usually need them to get through doors, pick up prints at copiers, park their cars, etc.

MOO
I have no doubt there was a lanyard with a picture ID somewhere on his person.

jmo
 
  • #1,300
I have to believe I'm not the only person here who, in the hours after Ms. Good was killed, feared such a shooting would happen again. Then it did. Now I'm waiting for the next one; I can't not.

I was thinking the same thing the other day. How many more US citizens are going to be killed by ICE?

In Renee's and Alex's cases, they didn't even get 'thoughts and prayers' from the administration.

imo
 

Guardians Monthly Goal

Staff online

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
152
Guests online
1,825
Total visitors
1,977

Forum statistics

Threads
638,831
Messages
18,733,811
Members
244,541
Latest member
Kiffie77
Back
Top