Mdiicshhaeelr
New Member
- Joined
- Sep 19, 2025
- Messages
- 9
- Reaction score
- 6
“The damn two-for-cent mystery gives me the creeps,” said a detective of the 1929 Isadore Fink murder case.
An “insoluble mystery,” said NY Police Commissioner Edward P. Mulrooney in a 1931 radio interview.
Whether Isadore, Isidore or other, most agree that he was 30. All that he was in his 30s. A few said he was a hopelessly single and friendless bachelor. Others that he was married with children but his family lived on the continent. Even Fink’s surroundings change from source to source. But that he was found murdered in a locked room never changed, nor did the “three blows,” “three reports,” or “three shots.”
Isadore Fink came to New York in 1921 from Galacia. A historical and geographic region spanning southeastern Poland and western Ukraine. His father was a peddler, making meager money. To supplement his income, Fink’s mother worked from home, washing clothes. Fink, too, helped, working with his mom instead of going to school.
His mom died when he was seven. His dad just three years later. Fink continued to work. In his first few years in America, he worked as a shoemaker’s assistant, sharing quarters with shoemaker Max Schwartz at 52 East 126th St.
EAST HARLEM, N.Y.—Fink’s laundry was on the ground floor of a tenement building at 4 east 132nd st. Originally rented as three rooms, he leased out the backroom to elderly Locklin Smith.
Before Fink moved in, the front door was already fixed up with two sturdy locks. After he moved in, he installed a seven-inch long, inch thick bolt. He put iron bars on the front windows and nailed all around the transom window above the front door. In the rear washroom, the small window overlooking the courtyard was always held closed with a lock and caged with bars so close together that even a city rat would think they’re unwelcome. The connecting door between the washroom and Smith’s apartment had three heavy locks, iron bars and a network of cobwebs between it and the ceiling.
This was the locked room where Isadore Fink’s still warm body was found on Saturday, March 9, 1929, at around 10:45 P.M. And it was on Saturdays when Fink would keep the shop open until midnight. But as crime had risen due to the declining economy, and there were laundry rackets going at that time, too, he would only open the door for customers he recognized.
It was just before 10:15 P.M. when Fink returned from making a delivery in the neighborhood, which was unusual for him at such a late hour. He went across the street to the tobacco/newspaper/candy store for a pack of cigarettes, staying for a 15-minute chat. Returning home, the people in the tobacco store watched as Fink let himself in and pulled closed the blinds over the front window.
15 minutes later, Locklin Smith heard heavy heels, the bass of opposing voices, a scream, shots and the thump of dead weight. She ran screaming "Police!” into the tenement hallway and into the street. Arresting the attention of patrolman Albert Kattenborn, who was just a block away.
The laundry locked all around, Kattenborn tried in vain to open the door and window. He went into Smith’s apartment and, again, failed to get into the laundry. Returning to the front door, a small crowd had gathered around another patrolman, Paul Lee.
Taking advantage of the crowd, Kattenborn picked out a small neighborhood newsboy and asked if he would climb through the transom window. After breaking it out with a claw hammer, he sent the boy through and he unlocked the door.
Fink’s still warm body was found by his washtubs. There was a hot iron sitting up on a still burning gas stove and a bundle of unclaimed laundry next to his body. He had two bullet holes in his chest and one through a powder-burned wrist, telling us that he threw his arm up before the first shot was fired. This gives us two shots.
With each entry point so overly-secured, Kattenborn and Lee’s immediate thought was suicide. But with a cursory search, no gun was found. In searching the newsboy, they still came up empty.
When detective William Clark arrived, they searched the body. They found $2 and a “coded” note in Fink’s handwriting. In making a more thorough search of the room, they found $4.75 in the register, but still no weapon.
After the coroner arrived and examined the body, he told the officers that a .38 caliber pistol had been held about two feet from the body. After the examination, an ambulance was called and Fink was taken to Harlem hospital, where he was pronounced dead on arrival.
Early into the next century, Baltimore Physician Assistant Emily Entzi Narcisco, asked if Fink could have locked the door himself, said, “You could run 25 feet if shot in the chest, depending on where the bullet hit. I’ve seen people drive themselves to the emergency department after being shot and then simply run through the door.” But no blood was found anywhere but where Fink’s body lie.
Officers searched at length for the weapon both inside and out but always came up empty. Same as with their search for a secret entrance and prints other than Fink’s. There was no sign of any other in the laundry.
In the following months, officers continued to interview any and all of those whose path crossed Fink’s. The last police report was filed Aug. 15, 1930. In the years since, nothing has come out in the wash.
Isadore Fink was buried in Mount Richmond Cemetery, Staten Island.
A simple solution for the locked door: the third shot.
Officially, the killer’s identity will likely remain unknown now forever. But, whoever they were, once they killed Fink, fled and slammed the door behind them with enough force to cause the bolt lock to slide closed, locking the door.
Was the unclaimed bundle of laundry left by the killer? Did an angry customer return damaged clothes? The wrong clothes? If it was unusual for Fink to make deliveries at such a late hour, was he delivering laundry to someone of higher standing in the neighborhood? Was it all simply just a cover-up from the start? Fink was killed with a .38 caliber. The .38 special was the standard service cartridge for the majority of United States police departments from the '20s through the '90s.
An “insoluble mystery,” said NY Police Commissioner Edward P. Mulrooney in a 1931 radio interview.
Whether Isadore, Isidore or other, most agree that he was 30. All that he was in his 30s. A few said he was a hopelessly single and friendless bachelor. Others that he was married with children but his family lived on the continent. Even Fink’s surroundings change from source to source. But that he was found murdered in a locked room never changed, nor did the “three blows,” “three reports,” or “three shots.”
Isadore Fink came to New York in 1921 from Galacia. A historical and geographic region spanning southeastern Poland and western Ukraine. His father was a peddler, making meager money. To supplement his income, Fink’s mother worked from home, washing clothes. Fink, too, helped, working with his mom instead of going to school.
His mom died when he was seven. His dad just three years later. Fink continued to work. In his first few years in America, he worked as a shoemaker’s assistant, sharing quarters with shoemaker Max Schwartz at 52 East 126th St.
EAST HARLEM, N.Y.—Fink’s laundry was on the ground floor of a tenement building at 4 east 132nd st. Originally rented as three rooms, he leased out the backroom to elderly Locklin Smith.
Before Fink moved in, the front door was already fixed up with two sturdy locks. After he moved in, he installed a seven-inch long, inch thick bolt. He put iron bars on the front windows and nailed all around the transom window above the front door. In the rear washroom, the small window overlooking the courtyard was always held closed with a lock and caged with bars so close together that even a city rat would think they’re unwelcome. The connecting door between the washroom and Smith’s apartment had three heavy locks, iron bars and a network of cobwebs between it and the ceiling.
This was the locked room where Isadore Fink’s still warm body was found on Saturday, March 9, 1929, at around 10:45 P.M. And it was on Saturdays when Fink would keep the shop open until midnight. But as crime had risen due to the declining economy, and there were laundry rackets going at that time, too, he would only open the door for customers he recognized.
It was just before 10:15 P.M. when Fink returned from making a delivery in the neighborhood, which was unusual for him at such a late hour. He went across the street to the tobacco/newspaper/candy store for a pack of cigarettes, staying for a 15-minute chat. Returning home, the people in the tobacco store watched as Fink let himself in and pulled closed the blinds over the front window.
15 minutes later, Locklin Smith heard heavy heels, the bass of opposing voices, a scream, shots and the thump of dead weight. She ran screaming "Police!” into the tenement hallway and into the street. Arresting the attention of patrolman Albert Kattenborn, who was just a block away.
The laundry locked all around, Kattenborn tried in vain to open the door and window. He went into Smith’s apartment and, again, failed to get into the laundry. Returning to the front door, a small crowd had gathered around another patrolman, Paul Lee.
Taking advantage of the crowd, Kattenborn picked out a small neighborhood newsboy and asked if he would climb through the transom window. After breaking it out with a claw hammer, he sent the boy through and he unlocked the door.
Fink’s still warm body was found by his washtubs. There was a hot iron sitting up on a still burning gas stove and a bundle of unclaimed laundry next to his body. He had two bullet holes in his chest and one through a powder-burned wrist, telling us that he threw his arm up before the first shot was fired. This gives us two shots.
With each entry point so overly-secured, Kattenborn and Lee’s immediate thought was suicide. But with a cursory search, no gun was found. In searching the newsboy, they still came up empty.
When detective William Clark arrived, they searched the body. They found $2 and a “coded” note in Fink’s handwriting. In making a more thorough search of the room, they found $4.75 in the register, but still no weapon.
After the coroner arrived and examined the body, he told the officers that a .38 caliber pistol had been held about two feet from the body. After the examination, an ambulance was called and Fink was taken to Harlem hospital, where he was pronounced dead on arrival.
Early into the next century, Baltimore Physician Assistant Emily Entzi Narcisco, asked if Fink could have locked the door himself, said, “You could run 25 feet if shot in the chest, depending on where the bullet hit. I’ve seen people drive themselves to the emergency department after being shot and then simply run through the door.” But no blood was found anywhere but where Fink’s body lie.
Officers searched at length for the weapon both inside and out but always came up empty. Same as with their search for a secret entrance and prints other than Fink’s. There was no sign of any other in the laundry.
In the following months, officers continued to interview any and all of those whose path crossed Fink’s. The last police report was filed Aug. 15, 1930. In the years since, nothing has come out in the wash.
Isadore Fink was buried in Mount Richmond Cemetery, Staten Island.
A simple solution for the locked door: the third shot.
Officially, the killer’s identity will likely remain unknown now forever. But, whoever they were, once they killed Fink, fled and slammed the door behind them with enough force to cause the bolt lock to slide closed, locking the door.
Was the unclaimed bundle of laundry left by the killer? Did an angry customer return damaged clothes? The wrong clothes? If it was unusual for Fink to make deliveries at such a late hour, was he delivering laundry to someone of higher standing in the neighborhood? Was it all simply just a cover-up from the start? Fink was killed with a .38 caliber. The .38 special was the standard service cartridge for the majority of United States police departments from the '20s through the '90s.
Last edited:
