Nancy Grace 10/24/08

[TakeNote]

no one said anything about Caylee being comatose.
I simply asked the question, in thinking about the timeline. I want to know where is Caylee. When did she die, and when was she dumped.

ok... from what I got is that Caylee was alive and died in the trunk of the car

 

[PrincessPea]

He's so obviously biased towards the A-team, what use is he? Isn't science supposed to be non-biased???

I totally agree! I just said this same thing last night! Science is supposed to be non-biased!

I have no respect for Kobi. He is on other "crime shows" as an expert and I can't stand to watch him at all. I think this has made him lose his credibility. IMHO

 

[Janis396]

Is it true that anything said to a minister is privelged? I thought that was for confessions only??

 

[galvino]

I am getting SOOOOOO DISGUSTED by these paid talking heads on TV. I lump Kobi in the same catagory as Baden, Henwy Wee, et al (that testified in the Spector case). They are reasonable until they are retained by a defense team. Then, all bets are off and they become mouthpieces for defense spin. Well, I believe All of the afore mentioned 'experts' have blown their credibility to the extent that they now have little left of esteemed career except their availability to speak on TV. Diane Dimond has an interesting article on her website re helicopter lawyers/commentators. Worth a read!

 

[4Siamese]

is KC telling the minister where the body is??????

 

[Boston]

The prosecution has DNA & FBI Lab findings & the defense has Squirrels & Pizza..

Baez & KC are in trouble.....

 

[MD MOMMY]

Is it true that anything said to a minister is privelged? I thought that was for confessions only??

I didn't realize this but from what they are all saying..yes it is priveldged.

 

[Baznme]

I totally agree! I just said this same thing last night! Science is supposed to be non-biased!

I have no respect for Kobi. He is on other "crime shows" as an expert and I can't stand to watch him at all. I think this has made him lose his credibility. IMHO

As well it should!

 

[MD MOMMY]

LP- no doubt Minister is carrying messages.

 

[yosande]

ok... from what I got is that Caylee was alive and died in the trunk of the car

yes, I think they did say that at the beginning of the show, they they thought she was placed alive in the trunk, and died there, decomping for 2.6 days. So my question was could she have been comatose for a time before she died, basically to find out how long she was in the trunk before she was dumped. i think.
how long was she alive in the trunk. Didn't someone say once that it takes up 36 hours to begin to decompose? is that info correct, anyone?

 

[MD MOMMY]

Lp- The family lies? OH REALLY???

 

[panthera]

Is it true that anything said to a minister is privelged? I thought that was for confessions only??

Apparently so. But once the information is passed on to another person it loses it's privilege.

 

[SeriouslySearching]

so could Caylee have lived in a comatose state for many hours before dying?
How does this info match the timeline?

This totally depends on the cause of death. I don't think that Chloroform will prove to be the COD. I think it will be more brutal and lean more towards the injuries Casey described to CA about Z's car accident. Of course, she could have been in a coma from blunt force trauma or other reason.

 

[4Siamese]

I don't care for Jane.

 

[Janis396]

I didn't realize this but from what they are all saying..yes it is priveldged.

I don't know....remember when that minister came forward and told about his conversations with Stacy P last year, where she said she was scared of Drew, that he killed his 3rd wife? He didn't seem to think they were priveleged conversations. ???

 

[kathyn2]

Whats this business about a minister visiting Casey? I missed it? Whats the purpose and what were they saying?

 

[whiteangora]

She actually said Homicide Investigator.....but I wonder if there's any way to verify that after what, 20 years now?

I did a lot of digging about George Anthony's life in Ohio. He was a Detective with the Trumbull Ohio Sheriff Dept for a little over 10 years. I tried contacting the Sheriff to see if he was indeed in homicide but never got any answers. He supposedly had the opportunity to resign before he was to be fired.

 

[SeriouslySearching]

Originally Posted by PrincessPea
I totally agree! I just said this same thing last night! Science is supposed to be non-biased!

I have no respect for Kobi. He is on other "crime shows" as an expert and I can't stand to watch him at all. I think this has made him lose his credibility. IMHO

I never considered him credible BEFORE he joined the defense team.

 

[cfromcanada]

Lp- The family lies? OH REALLY???

I am so relieved to have found this out!!! Otherwise it meant I was nuts!

 

[Janis396]

I did a lot of digging about George Anthony's life in Ohio. He was a Detective with the Trumbull Ohio Sheriff Dept for a little over 10 years. I tried contacting the Sheriff to see if he was indeed in homicide but never got any answers. He supposedly had the opportunity to resign before he was to be fired.

He was fired??? Any idea for what?