raiders444
Active Member
- Joined
- Sep 16, 2017
- Messages
- 109
- Reaction score
- 213
Think I recall reading that elsewhere as well, about the phone left in the car theory. Maybe LE or Gaspo mentioned it.
Ahh okay that makes sense if the source listing JB as the booty call was inaccurate. HOWEVER, I do have one major issue with the facts as you listed them. There is no chance a 20-something year old college male (JB) or female would ever leave his/her cell phone in someone's car overnight. Absolute 0% chance. People today are so addicted and attached to their smart phones, it is literally their life line and connection to the world today and I am sure it was the same way in 2012. I seriously hope LE dove deep into this claim by JB of him being asleep and the phone being in JM's car!
Just reviewed the documents that talk about this, which are pages 109 and 110 in the released documents. A call was made from JB's phone at 4:15 AM, it did not just ping the tower. Also, JB was at the Thrill, but told LE he drove himself home after it closed. Both of those things argue against his phone just passively being in JM's car (though as Webthrush mentioned, there are other possible explanations). Also, though, he wasn't asked about this until March 2013, almost six months later, so his memory of the night might not have been 100% clear.
And again, if what we are told is true, the (male) DNA of the semen MATCHES the DNA on other objects (the rum bottle & pen if I recall correctly) -- that seems to me like pretty much a slam-dunk that not only was a male present at the crime but was likely the killer.
On a side note, I too have never seen the plausibility of MR being the person who made the 911 call.
Ahh okay that makes sense if the source listing JB as the booty call was inaccurate. HOWEVER, I do have one major issue with the facts as you listed them. There is no chance a 20-something year old college male (JB) or female would ever leave his/her cell phone in someone's car overnight. Absolute 0% chance. People today are so addicted and attached to their smart phones, it is literally their life line and connection to the world today and I am sure it was the same way in 2012. I seriously hope LE dove deep into this claim by JB of him being asleep and the phone being in JM's car!
I listened to it last night. It was a good overview of the case, IMO, and yes, a few of the details were wrong.
I had a couple of quibbles myself. The biggest one: I don't think the time of the pocket-dial voicemail is really in dispute anymore. There's never really been an indication that it's wrong at all, but we're past just having a single phone with a time-stamp at this point. LE says they've verified the metadata of the call. If it doesn't make sense that Faith was viciously assaulted in the club by 2 or 3 people and calmly left 45 minutes later, it points to a problem with the transcript, not the time-stamp.
Second, and I've seen it mentioned but never elaborated upon, but what's driving the idea that MR made the 911 call and not KR? Even if one suspects KR, that doesn't make a lot of sense. Is she so overjoyed that her plot succeeded that she handed the phone to MR to do a victory dance in the background? Does MR not question this or think it's weird enough to ever mention again?
<snipped> I have never, however, thought for even one moment that it was MR who made the call, pretending to be KR. I just see no reason why MR would have done it, even if she was asked to, and also can see no reason why she would have been asked to. Just makes no sense at all to me. JMO
I don't think it's impossible that KR would ask MR to make the call, and that MR would then do it. Some people really dislike making phone calls, even to order pizza or something. I think it's especially true of millennials when they're used to texting all day long. I could see it causing someone a lot of anxiety to think of making a 911 call.Even putting the worst construction on it (KR knew she was dead and asked MR to make the call bc she didnt trust her acting abilities), I cant see why she would ask MR to pretend to be her, or why MR would go along with that. You cant even appeal to a mean girl conspiracy there and say MR was in on it (I refuse to take that seriously), since the only reason for MR to make the call is to get her genuine reaction.
I don't think it's impossible that KR would ask MR to make the call, and that MR would then do it. Some people really dislike making phone calls, even to order pizza or something. I think it's especially true of millennials when they're used to texting all day long. I could see it causing someone a lot of anxiety to think of making a 911 call.
I have mentioned before that I've considered if it was MR, mostly just because I had heard the 911 audio and MR's voice on the 20/20 special sounded fairly similar to me.
Just being devil's advocate. At this point I believe the 911 call was made by KR.
Hmmm... I'm doubtful, BUT at least it definitely is (to me) a "new idea" (at least I don't recall ever hearing about this incident or individual before)... don't even know if he's discussable here?, but if so I'd sure be curious to hear more specifics of whatever is known.Just to throw a new idea out there:
What if it was Faith's former neighbor? She was mocking him on Twitter when she heard him and his girlfriend having sex through the walls of her old apartment. He would fit because he used to live near her (which the FBI profile suggested). It would also explain the note. "I'm not stupid" (I know you were making fun of me) "" (You shouldn't have done that) "Jealous" (You just wish it was you that you'd overheard me with). Of course, we don't know if he fits any of the other criteria, or anything else about him. And why he seeks her out this night of all nights, and at 4:30 in the morning, would be a good question.
Thoughts?
Hmmm... I'm doubtful, BUT at least it definitely is (to me) a "new idea" (at least I don't recall ever hearing about this incident or individual before)... don't even know if he's discussable here?, but if so I'd sure be curious to hear more specifics of whatever is known.