OH OH - Chillicothe/Middletown Missing/Murdered, Possible Serial Killer

[psyquestor]

How many of these women were shot? Has information about the weapon been released (caliber etc.)? I'm trying to follow along but haven't been able to make my per usual list for comparison.

TIA - sorry to be a bug if this was discussed.

 

[CD82]

How many of these women were shot? Has information about the weapon been released (caliber etc.)? I'm trying to follow along but haven't been able to make my per usual list for comparison.

TIA - sorry to be a bug if this was discussed.

We're waiting to hear about Tiffany's COD right now. Shasta was ruled a suicide for now, but they're investigating it. Timberly was shot in the head. Tameka had a high amount of drugs in her system. The rest are still missing. If the same person is killing these women, I think he is using weapons of opportunity and not anything patterned.

 

[Tillicum]

How many of these women were shot? Has information about the weapon been released (caliber etc.)? I'm trying to follow along but haven't been able to make my per usual list for comparison.

TIA - sorry to be a bug if this was discussed.

Timberly is the only one shot so far. They haven't released COD for Tiffany yet. Shasta drowned and Tameka OD'ed.

 

[CD82]

How many of these women were shot? Has information about the weapon been released (caliber etc.)? I'm trying to follow along but haven't been able to make my per usual list for comparison.

TIA - sorry to be a bug if this was discussed.

Also, no evidence in Timberly's death has been released except the information that they found a bullet, blood, and some "other evidence" in the car McCrary was driving.

 

[Jill1985]

I do as well. For some reason I do not feel like she is linked to the others.

 

[Tillicum]

I do as well. For some reason I do not feel like she is linked to the others.

:welcome6:

 

[nerosleuth]

I just happen to recall that there are three other women from Kentucky that disappeared in 2009 along U.S. Route 23. Two women disappeared from Pike County, Kentucky and one woman disappeared from Boyd County, Kentucky.

The first woman to disappear was 24 year old Crystal Branham Hall from Pikeville, Kentucky on March 1, 2009. Crystal Branham Hall is a mother who had children.

Pikeville is on U.S. Route 23 in Pike County, Kentucky and isn’t far from the Virginia and West Virginia borders.


Crystal Gayle Branham Hall, 24, Pikeville, Kentucky March 1, 2009


http://www.websleuths.com/forums/sh...ayle-Hall-(Branham)-24-Pikeville-1-March-2009


https://www.findthemissing.org/cases/1857


http://www.charleyproject.org/cases/h/hall_crystal.html


The second woman to disappear was 33 year old Nancy Ann Lockard of Turkey Creek, Pike County, Kentucky on June 24, 2009. Nancy Ann Lockard is a mother who had children.

Turkey Creek is near Belfry, Kentucky and Belfry is a small town along the Kentucky-West Virginia border and about 20 miles northeast of Pikeville and U.S. Route 23.


Nancy Ann Lockard, 33, Belfry, Kentucky June 24, 2009


http://www.websleuths.com/forums/sh...Nancy-Ann-Lockard-33-Pike-County-24-June-2009


https://www.findthemissing.org/cases/9669

http://www.charleyproject.org/cases/l/lockard_nancy.html


The third woman to disappear was 25 year old Janet Jolene Stephens Brown of Ashland, Kentucky on October 14, 2009.

Ashland is on U.S. Route 23 in Boyd County, Kentucky and is near the Ohio and West Virginia borders.


Janet Jolene Stephens Brown, 25, Ashland, Kentucky October 14, 2009


http://www.websleuths.com/forums/sh...-Jolene-Brown-Stephens-25-Ashland-14-Oct-2009


https://www.findthemissing.org/en/cases/8206/3/


http://www.charleyproject.org/cases/s/stephens-brown_janet.html

 

[CD82]

I just happen to recall that there are three other women from Kentucky that disappeared in 2009 along U.S. Route 23. Two women disappeared from Pike County, Kentucky and one woman disappeared from Boyd County, Kentucky.

<snipped>
https://www.findthemissing.org/en/cases/8206/3/


http://www.charleyproject.org/cases/s/stephens-brown_janet.html

rsbm

This is starting to turn my stomach.

Now, it could be a very strange coincidence, but there is a thread about a serial killer in Daytona Beach and surrounding areas- mostly prostitutes, drug issues etc.

Here's where it gets weird to me- There has not been a killing since 2008. These Ohio disappearances/murders seem to start right around the same time as the last murder in FL.

Could we have a relocated serial killer here? Truck driver, got a new route? Military? Just someone who up and moved, found a new place to kill since LE was on his trail before?

Here's the link to the WS thread:
http://www.websleuths.com/forums/sh...-County-Daytona-Beach-(Ridgwood-Ave-corridor)

I'd love to hear what everyone thinks.

 

[Tillicum]

rsbm

This is starting to turn my stomach.

Now, it could be a very strange coincidence, but there is a thread about a serial killer in Daytona Beach and surrounding areas- mostly prostitutes, drug issues etc.

Here's where it gets weird to me- There has not been a killing since 2008. These Ohio disappearances/murders seem to start right around the same time as the last murder in FL.

Could we have a relocated serial killer here? Truck driver, got a new route? Military? Just someone who up and moved, found a new place to kill since LE was on his trail before?

Here's the link to the WS thread:
http://www.websleuths.com/forums/sh...-County-Daytona-Beach-(Ridgwood-Ave-corridor)

I'd love to hear what everyone thinks.

I was thinking Florida last night! Possibly stays in Florida from January until April, then comes back here until it gets really cold again? BTW here's something of interest, I'll try to find out if he's still incarcerated. Notice the dates and this is 20 minutes south of Chillicothe. http://www.thetelegramnews.com/Main.asp?SectionID=6&SubSectionID=83&ArticleID=17480

 

[CriminalMinds]

I do as well. For some reason I do not feel like she is linked to the others.

agreed

 

[CriminalMinds]

I was thinking Florida last night! Possibly stays in Florida from January until April, then comes back here until it gets really cold again? BTW here's something of interest, I'll try to find out if he's still incarcerated. Notice the dates and this is 20 minutes south of Chillicothe. http://www.thetelegramnews.com/Main.asp?SectionID=6&SubSectionID=83&ArticleID=17480

http://www.timesjournal.com/news/article_880a6c1e-0071-5cb1-b2c9-34e1a06b72b2.html

 

[CD82]

I was thinking Florida last night! Possibly stays in Florida from January until April, then comes back here until it gets really cold again? BTW here's something of interest, I'll try to find out if he's still incarcerated. Notice the dates and this is 20 minutes south of Chillicothe. http://www.thetelegramnews.com/Main.asp?SectionID=6&SubSectionID=83&ArticleID=17480

Looks like that guy ended up doing a year for another crime. Not sure if he's out or not.

http://www.timesjournal.com/news/article_880a6c1e-0071-5cb1-b2c9-34e1a06b72b2.html

 

[CD82]

http://www.timesjournal.com/news/article_880a6c1e-0071-5cb1-b2c9-34e1a06b72b2.html

Haha....jinx :fence:

 

[CD82]

Doesn't look like too bad of a trip from Columbus to Daytona Beach. Could very well have been a truck route.

 

[Tillicum]

Looks like that guy ended up doing a year for another crime. Not sure if he's out or not.

http://www.timesjournal.com/news/article_880a6c1e-0071-5cb1-b2c9-34e1a06b72b2.html

It said he was currently at Orient, wonder if he was transferred to Chillicothe Corrections for his year.

 

[CriminalMinds]

It's also less than 1.5 miles from the Speedway at the end of Main where Shasta Himelrick was last seen on surveillance video.

https://www.google.com/maps/dir/39....4ce884c05c7e4a4a!2m2!1d-82.949316!2d39.337902

Cause of death was drowning. The amount of drugs in her system were not enough to kill her, and the wounds on her wrists were superficial. I'm not convinced her death wasn't set up to look like a suicide, and I hope it's being investigated in connection with the other murdered and missing.

---

She left the house after receiving a text, and was seen on a surveillance videotape at 3:15 a.m. on Friday at the Speedway gas station at 1136 E. Main St. in Chillicothe.
http://www.dispatch.com/content/sto...nty_deputies_recovering_body_from_Scioto.html

---

Shirley Himelrick said authorities have assured her the case is still open.
"They told us they haven't closed it yet," she said. "They said they are still following up on some things."
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2015/06/03/shasta-himelrick_n_7504672.html

she was trying to hide from someone in that gas station--maybe the person she was trying to end a relationship with? that could be what that text meant---

 

[CD82]

she was trying to hide from someone in that gas station--maybe the person she was trying to end a relationship with? that could be what that text meant---

My theory on her is that she went to that gas station to either withdrawal money (she had recently received an inheritance- I've seen that from many sources) and/or meet up with someone for drugs. Whether the drugs were for her or someone else is also speculation.

 

[CriminalMinds]

Just dumping all my info that I can find sources for now...

Timberly Claytor's ex, Jamil Burgin, says Claytor knew Charlotte Trego, Wanda Lemons, and Tiffany Sayre.

Charlotte Trego's mother, Yvonne Boggs, says her daughter knew Tameka Lynch and Shasta Himelrick.

Boggs also says that Tameka Lynch and Charlotte Trego had visited Brainbridge, OH together in the past. Tameka's body would later be found in a creek near Bainbridge.

Jayme Bowen, Megan Lancaster, and Charlotte Trego all went to the same rehab: Stepping Stone House in Portsmouth, OH.

Holly Logan has had prior arrests for prostitution in the area. Charlotte Trego and Tameka Lynch have both been linked to prostitution by authorities. Megan Lancaster's family has said that she worked in the sex trade. Authorities have said that Wanda Lemons has links to "sex trafficking." Tiffany Sayre's friend says Tiff was a prostitute and was working the night she disappeared. Jennifer Sheperd has had previous prostitution arrests.

Tiffany Sayre's sister claims that Tiffany knew McCrary and had once been assaulted by him, though she was too afraid to report it. In the same article, Charlotte Trego's mother says that McCrary was a "friend" of her daughter.

that's a lot of connecting dots--there must be another common male(dealer/pimp or both combo)(to go along with McCrary), amongst the group to look at--not looking good for him, though

 

[Tillicum]

rsbm

This is starting to turn my stomach.

Now, it could be a very strange coincidence, but there is a thread about a serial killer in Daytona Beach and surrounding areas- mostly prostitutes, drug issues etc.

Here's where it gets weird to me- There has not been a killing since 2008. These Ohio disappearances/murders seem to start right around the same time as the last murder in FL.

Could we have a relocated serial killer here? Truck driver, got a new route? Military? Just someone who up and moved, found a new place to kill since LE was on his trail before?

Here's the link to the WS thread:
http://www.websleuths.com/forums/sh...-County-Daytona-Beach-(Ridgwood-Ave-corridor)

I'd love to hear what everyone thinks.

IMO the perp has to be familiar with the dump sites. They're off back roads and a person wouldn't know they were there unless they'd been there before or knew someone who talked about their location.

 

[CriminalMinds]

http://www.dispatch.com/content/stories/local/2015/06/09/sex-trafficking-sentence.html

--found in one of the girls missing threads