OH - Mahoning Co., WhtFem UP4764, 35-48, Apr'92 - Sharon Kedzierski *arrest*

  • #101
Docket Information
Date Description Docket Text
04/18/2023 JE>SEE ATTACHED IMAGE JE> ORDER FOR FORENSIC EXAMINATION (DURKIN) SEE ATTACHED IMAGE


Events
Date/Time Location Type Result Event Judge
04/17/2023 07:00 AM COURTROOM #4 NOTES FOR COURT COMPLETED DURKIN, JOHN M.

05/16/2023 07:00 AM COURTROOM #4 NOTES FOR COURT DURKIN, JOHN M.

05/23/2023 02:00 PM COURTROOM #4 Hearing on continued commitment DURKIN, JOHN M.

link: https://ecourts.mahoningcountyoh.go...DgSJagDca7t2yMnSg7GpwYhIyf7WJt3H4tVSwE*mErm2A
 
  • #102
  • #103
  • #104
  • #105
Tuesday, May 16th:
*Notes for Court Hearing (Sharon’s case) (@ 7am ET) – OH - *Sharon Lynn Kedzierski (43) (reported missing Mar, 1992, found April 9, 1992 @ Universal Truck Mall & Flea Market, Austintown, Mahoning County) – *Samuel William Legg III (23 @ time of crime/49/now 53) arrested & charged (1/2018), indicted (2/14/19) & arraigned (2/26/19) with 3 counts of aggravated murder & 1 count of murder. Plead not guilty. Held without bond. Mahoning County
DNA link.
Court info from 2/26/19 thru 4/15/21 reference post #99 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...-apr92-sharon-kedzierski-arrest.197307/page-5

5/19/21 Update: A recent evaluation indicated there had been no change in Legg’s mental status, and he is unable to understand the nature & objectives of the criminal proceedings against him, is unable to assist in his defense & remains a mentally ill person subject to a court order. Legg will be evaluated again in two years & have another hearing before Durkin. Judge John Durkin ruled Wednesday Legg will remain in Twin Valley Behavioral Healthcare in the Columbus mental hospital. Next hearing Notes for Court on 4/17/23 @ 7am.
4/18/23 Update: Judge’s order for forensic examination. Next Notes for Court hearing on 5/16/23 & hearing on continued commitment on 5/23/23 @ 2pm.
OH - *17 year old woman (Sept. 7, 1997, Medina County) - *Samuel William Legg III (27 @ time of crime/49/now 53) arrested (1/2018), charged & indicted (1/23/19) & arraigned (2/14/19) with 2 counts of rape. Plead not guilty. $1M bond. Medina County
Familial DNA match. Was extradited (Jan. 2018) from Chandler, AZ to Ohio.
Court info from 2/14/19 thru 11/18/21 reference post #99 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...-apr92-sharon-kedzierski-arrest.197307/page-5

11/24/21 Update: Medina County Judge Joyce Kimbler found Legg responsible for two counts of felony rape. However, due to mental illness, Legg is deemed unfit to stand trial, according to court records. Legg will remain committed to a hospital in Columbus for up to 10 years. In appeals
IL - *Julie A. Konkol (39) (found strangled Oct. 23, 1997, behind the abandoned Senter's truck stop in the 43000 block of Old Route 41 in Russell) - *Samuel William Legg III (27 @ time of crime/49/now 53) charged (7/30/20) with 2 counts of 1st degree murder. $3M bond. Lake County
Will eventually be extradited to Illinois to face the charges. The warrants were filed on 7/29/20 when the case was opened. They are for Murder/Intent to Kill/Injure & Murder/Strong Prob Kill/Injure.
Court info from 8/20/20 thru 8/23/21 reference post #99 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...-apr92-sharon-kedzierski-arrest.197307/page-5

OH - *Victoria Jane Collins (27) (found behind the Union 76 truck stop in Lake Township on Dec. 20, 1996) - *Samuel William Legg III (26 @ time of crime/53) indicted & charged (8/20/20) with 2 counts of aggravated murder, murder, 1st degree rape & 1st degree kidnapping. Wood County
Legg's DNA was linked to her death.
Court info from 8/20/20 thru 8/23/21 reference post #99 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...-apr92-sharon-kedzierski-arrest.197307/page-5

3/1/22 Review hearing on competency. 3/3/22: Order: Judgment Entry: This matter before the court this 1st day of March 2022. Ordered that the defendant remains unable to understand the nature & objective of the legal proceedings against him or to assist in his defense & remains a mentally ill person subject to court order. Ordered that further hearings on this matter be scheduled per statue. Ordered that defendant remain in custody of Twin Valley. Ordered that Court's exhibit 1 be placed under seal.
OH - *Angela Marie “Angie” Hicks (14) (disappeared July 21, 1990, found by Midway Mall on Aug. 30, 1990, Elyria, Lorain County) – suspect in ongoing investigation.
Legg (21 @ the time) was Angela’s step father. DNA link to 3 homicides in Ohio & 1 in Illinois.
 
  • #106
  • #107
Docket Information
Date Description Docket Text
04/19/2023 COPIES ISSUED COPIES ISSUED OF 4/18/23 JE TO PARTIES

04/19/2023 REGULAR MAIL POSTAGE FEES Issue Date: 04/19/2023
Service: COPIES OF 4/18/23 JE TO PARTIES
Method: (CP) REGULAR MAIL
LEGG III, SAMUEL
c/o ATTY: LAVELLE, MARK
940 WINDHAM COURT
SUITE 7
BOARDMAN, OH 44512
Tracking No: R001307230

YACOVONE ESQ, MICHAEL J
c/o ATTY: YACOVONE ESQ, MICHAEL J
MAHONING COUNTY PROSECUTOR'S OFFICE
21 W. BOARDMAN STREET
SIXTH FLOOR
YOUNGSTOWN, OH 44503
Tracking No: R001307231

TWIN VALLEY BEHAVIORAL HEALTHCARE
2200 WEST BROAD STREET
COLUMBUS, OH 43223
Tracking No: R001307232

FORENSIC PSYCHIATRIC CENTER OF NORTHEAST OHIO INC
5212 MAHONING AVE
SUITE 317
YOUNGSTOWN, OH 44515
Tracking No: R001307233

04/19/2023 CERTIFIED COPY CERTIFIED COPY OF 4/18/23 JE TO MCJC

05/18/2023 JE>SEE ATTACHED IMAGE JE> WARRANT FOR REMOVAL OF SAMUEL LEGG FOR A CONTINUED COMMITMENT HRG ON 5/23/2023 @ 2:00 PM. (DURKIN) SEE ATTACHED IMAGE

05/18/2023 WARRANT FOR REMOVAL ISSUED TO SH. MAH. CTY WARRANT FOR REMOVAL ISSUED TO SH. MAH. CTY PER 5/18/2023 ENTRY


Events
Date/Time Location Type Result Event Judge
05/16/2023 07:00 AM COURTROOM #4 NOTES FOR COURT DURKIN, JOHN M.

05/23/2023 02:00 PM COURTROOM #4 Hearing on continued commitment DURKIN, JOHN M.

link: https://ecourts.mahoningcountyoh.go...GCLOJSSSpOSZ6G4oRZrLbP2ni04p3KgDfCN1LuDWQALSw
 
  • #108
Tuesday, May 23rd:
*Commitment Hearing (@ 2pm ET) – OH - *Sharon Lynn Kedzierski (43) (reported missing Mar, 1992, found April 9, 1992 @ Universal Truck Mall & Flea Market, Austintown, Mahoning County) – *Samuel William Legg III (23 @ time of crime/49/now 53) arrested & charged (1/2018), indicted (2/14/19) & arraigned (2/26/19) with 3 counts of aggravated murder & 1 count of murder. Plead not guilty. Held without bond.
DNA link.
Court info from 2/26/19 thru 5/19/21 reference post #105 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...-apr92-sharon-kedzierski-arrest.197307/page-6

4/18/23 Update: Judge’s order for forensic examination. Next Notes for Court hearing on 5/16/23 & hearing on continued commitment on 5/23/23 @ 2pm.
5/16/23 Update: Next hearing on continued commitment on 5/23/23.
See post #105 for the other cases.
 
  • #109

May 23, 2023

A truck driver suspected in a 1992 cold case in Austintown was once again deemed incompetent to stand trial.

According to court employees, 53-year-old Samuel Legg was sent back to the Twin Valley Behavioral Health Center in Columbus after once again being deemed incompetent to stand trial.

Legg had previously been deemed incompetent back in 2019, and again in 2021. Court employees tell 21 News Legg will have another evaluative hearing in 2025.
 
  • #110
  • #111
Going thru some oldies...

Docket update:
05/30/2023 JE>SEE ATTACHED IMAGE JE> MATTER CAME ON FOR MANDATORY 2 YEAR REVIEW OF CONTINUED COMMITMENT/COMPETENCY OF DEFT. COURT FINDS DEFT REMAINS UNABLE TO UNDERSTAND NATURE AND OBJECTIVE OF PROCEEDINGS AGINST HIM AND UNABLE TO ASSIST IN HIS DEFENSE. MATTER WILL BE SET FOR FURTHER HRG AS REQUIRED BY STATUE (DURKIN) SEE ATTACHED IMAGE $4.00

06/02/2023 JE> JE> COUNSEL FEES (DURKIN) $8.00

06/06/2023 COPIES ISSUED COPIES ISSUED OF 05/30/23 JE TO PARTIES
$0.80

06/06/2023 REGULAR MAIL POSTAGE FEES Issue Date: 06/06/2023
Service: COPIES OF 05/30/23
Method: (CP) REGULAR MAIL
Cost Per: $0.55
LEGG III, SAMUEL
c/o ATTY: LAVELLE, MARK
940 WINDHAM COURT
SUITE 7
BOARDMAN, OH 44512
Tracking No: R001311968

YACOVONE ESQ, MICHAEL J
c/o ATTY: YACOVONE ESQ, MICHAEL J
MAHONING COUNTY PROSECUTOR'S OFFICE
21 W. BOARDMAN STREET
SIXTH FLOOR
YOUNGSTOWN, OH 44503
Tracking No: R001311969

TWIN VALLEY BEHAVIORAL HEALTHCARE
2200 WEST BROAD STREET
COLUMBUS, OH 43223
Tracking No: R001311970

FORENSIC PSYCHIATRIC CENTER OF NORTHEAST OHIO INC
5212 MAHONING AVE
SUITE 317
YOUNGSTOWN, OH 44515
Tracking No: R001311971
$1.65

06/06/2023 CERTIFIED COPY CERTIFIED COPY OF 05/30/23 JE TO MCSD $1.00

08/18/2023 WARRANT FOR REMOVAL RETURNED & FILED-FEES: WARRANT FOR REMOVAL RETURNED & FILED--RETURNED SAMUEL LEGG III 5-24-23 $706.00

10/24/2023 WARRANT FOR REMOVAL RETURNED & FILED-FEES: WARRANT FOR REMOVAL RETURNED & FILED--RETURNED SAMUEL LEGG III 5-19-23 $718.00


Events
Date/Time Location Type Result Event Judge
05/23/2023 02:00 PM COURTROOM #4 Hearing on continued commitment HEARD DURKIN, JOHN M.

04/21/2025 07:00 AM COURTROOM #4 NOTES FOR COURT DURKIN, JOHN M.

link: https://ecourts.mahoningcountyoh.go...JNbkzDOZbQAskEcGMQEZbDoCtlvRCQGn-JMKtqbD945vA
 
  • #112
Monday, April 21st:
*Notes for Court Hearing (Sharon’s case) (@ 7am ET) – OH - *Sharon Lynn Kedzierski (43) (reported missing Mar, 1992, found April 9, 1992 @ Universal Truck Mall & Flea Market, Austintown, Mahoning County) – *Samuel William Legg III (23 @ time of crime/49/now 55) arrested & charged (1/2018), indicted (2/14/19) & arraigned (2/26/19) with 3 counts of aggravated murder & 1 count of murder. Plead not guilty. Held without bond. Found incompetent to stand trial [5/23/23]. Mahoning County
DNA link.
Judge John Durkin presiding. Prosecutor attorney Paul J Gains, Michael J.Yacovone & Dawn P. Cantalamessa. Defense attorneys Rachel Ceri & Mark Lavaelle.

Court info from 2/26/19 thru 4/18/23 reference post #109 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...-apr92-sharon-kedzierski-arrest.197307/page-6

5/16/23 Update: Next hearing on continued commitment on 5/23/23. 5/23/23 Update: Judge John Durkin said Legg was found incompetent to stand trial. Was sent back to the Twin Valley Behavioral Health Center in Columbus. Another evaluative hearing will be held in 2025.
5/20/23 Docket update: JE-Matter came on for mandatory 2 year review of continued commitment/competency of Dept. Court finds defendant remains unable to understand nature & objective of proceedings against him & unable to assist in his defense. Matter will be set for further hearing as required by statue Durkin.
6/2/23 Docket update: JE-Counsel fees (Durkin). 6/6/23: Regular mail postage to S. Legg, prosecutor Michael J. Yacovone Esq., Twin Valley Behavioral Healthcare & Forensic Psychiastric Center of Northeast Ohio, Inc.
8/18/23 Docket update: Warrant for removal returned & filed for Legg.
10/24/23 Docket update: Warrant for removal returned & filed for Legg. Next notes for court hearing on 4/21/25 @ 7am with Judge John M. Durkin presiding. 4/16/25 Docket update: JE>Order for Forensic examination (Durkin).
OH - *17 year old woman (Sept. 7, 1997, Medina County) - *Samuel William Legg III (27 @ time of crime/49/now 55) arrested (1/2018), charged & indicted (1/23/19) & arraigned (2/14/19) with 2 counts of rape. Plead not guilty. $1M bond. Medina County
Familial DNA match. Was extradited (Jan. 2018) from Chandler, AZ to Ohio.
Judge Joyce V. Kimbler presiding. Defense attorney David C. Sheldon.
Court info from 2/14/19 thru 11/18/21 reference post #105 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...-apr92-sharon-kedzierski-arrest.197307/page-6

11/24/21 Update: Medina County Judge Joyce Kimbler found Legg responsible for two counts of felony rape. However, due to mental illness, Legg is deemed unfit to stand trial, according to court records. Legg will remain committed to a hospital in Columbus for up to 10 years.
7/17/23 Docket updates: Competency hearing journal entry. Cert for Court stenographer's fees. Hearing held. 8/3/23: Warrant for removal returned & filed. 5/13/24 Docket update: Request for Court paid experts and/or expenses. In appeals.
IL - *Julie A. Konkol (39) (found strangled Oct. 23, 1997, behind the abandoned Senter's truck stop in the 43000 block of Old Route 41 in Russell) - *Samuel William Legg III (27 @ time of crime/49/now 55) charged (7/30/20) with 2 counts of 1st degree murder. $3M bond. Lake County
Will eventually be extradited to Illinois to face the charges. The warrants were filed on 7/29/20 when the case was opened. They are for Murder/Intent to Kill/Injure & Murder/Strong Prob Kill/Injure.
Court info from 8/20/20 thru 8/23/21 reference post #105 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...-apr92-sharon-kedzierski-arrest.197307/page-6

OH - *Victoria Jane Collins (27) (last seen Dec. 16 or early Dec. 17, 1996 & found behind the Union 76 truck stop in Lake Township on Dec. 20, 1996) - *Samuel William Legg III (26 @ time of crime/55) indicted & charged (8/20/20) with 2 counts of aggravated murder, murder, 1st degree rape & 1st degree kidnapping. Wood County
Legg's DNA was linked to her death.
Court info from 8/20/20 thru 8/23/21 reference post 105 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...-apr92-sharon-kedzierski-arrest.197307/page-6

3/1/22 Review hearing on competency. 3/3/22: Order: Judgment Entry: This matter before the court this 1st day of March 2022. Ordered that the defendant remains unable to understand the nature & objective of the legal proceedings against him or to assist in his defense & remains a mentally ill person subject to court order. Ordered that further hearings on this matter be scheduled per statue. Ordered that defendant remain in custody of Twin Valley. Ordered that Court's exhibit 1 be placed under seal.
OH - *Angela Marie “Angie” Hicks (14) (disappeared July 21, 1990, found by Midway Mall on Aug. 30, 1990, Elyria, Lorain County) – suspect in ongoing investigation.
Legg (21 @ the time) was Angela’s step father. DNA link to 3 homicides in Ohio & 1 in Illinois.

 
  • #113
  • #114
Looks like he had an earlier hearing date... I see it was on 5/6 - not 5/16 - guess someone typed in the wrong date on the court site.


May 12, 2025
The man accused a committing a murder in Lake Township nearly three decades ago remains incompetent to stand trial.

Wood County Common Pleas Court Judge Matt Reger held a hearing May 6 to determine whether Samuel Legg III is competent to face charges of the murder and rape of 27-year-old Victoria Jane Collins in 1996.

It was determined that Legg, 55, remains a mentally ill person and will remain at Twin Valley Behavioral Healthcare, where he is receiving treatment after first being deemed incompetent in 2021.
[.....]

The next hearing on this matter shall be scheduled per statute, which is a mandatory two-year review.
 
  • #115
I shall go ahead & post this so my notes are up to date. And it looks like he had a hearing on 5/6 for Collins case - so I will keep him on 5/16 for Sharon's cases.

Tuesday, May 6th:
*Hearing (Victoria’s case) (@ 1:30pm ET) – OH - *Sharon Lynn Kedzierski (43) (reported missing Mar, 1992, found April 9, 1992 @ Universal Truck Mall & Flea Market, Austintown, Mahoning County) – *Samuel William Legg III (23 @ time of crime/49/now 55) arrested & charged (1/2018), indicted (2/14/19) & arraigned (2/26/19) with 3 counts of aggravated murder & 1 count of murder. Plead not guilty. Held without bond. Found incompetent to stand trial [5/23/23]. Mahoning County
DNA link.
Judge John Durkin presiding. Prosecutor attorney Paul J Gains, Michael J.Yacovone & Dawn P. Cantalamessa. Defense attorneys Rachel Ceri & Mark Lavaelle.

Court info from 2/26/19 thru 8/18/23 reference post #112 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...-apr92-sharon-kedzierski-arrest.197307/page-6

10/24/23 Docket update: Warrant for removal returned & filed for Legg. Next notes for court hearing on 4/21/25 @ 7am with Judge John M. Durkin presiding. 4/16/25 Docket update: JE>Order for Forensic examination (Durkin).
4/21/25 Update: Notes for court hearing held. Next hearing on 5/16/25 @ 1:30pm.
OH - *17 year old woman (Sept. 7, 1997, Medina County) - *Samuel William Legg III (27 @ time of crime/49/now 55) arrested (1/2018), charged & indicted (1/23/19) & arraigned (2/14/19) with 2 counts of rape. Plead not guilty. $1M bond. Medina County
Familial DNA match. Was extradited (Jan. 2018) from Chandler, AZ to Ohio.
Judge Joyce V. Kimbler presiding. Defense attorney David C. Sheldon.

Court info from 2/14/19 thru 8/3/23 reference post #112 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...-apr92-sharon-kedzierski-arrest.197307/page-6

5/13/24 Docket update: Request for Court paid experts and/or expenses. Case was disposed on 11/18/21. In appeals
IL - *Julie A. Konkol (39) (found strangled Oct. 23, 1997, behind the abandoned Senter's truck stop in the 43000 block of Old Route 41 in Russell) - *Samuel William Legg III (27 @ time of crime/49/now 55) charged (7/30/20) with 2 counts of 1st degree murder. $3M bond. Lake County
Will eventually be extradited to Illinois to face the charges. The warrants were filed on 7/29/20 when the case was opened. They are for Murder/Intent to Kill/Injure & Murder/Strong Prob Kill/Injure.
Court info from 8/20/20 thru 8/23/21 reference post #112 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...-apr92-sharon-kedzierski-arrest.197307/page-6

OH - *Victoria Jane Collins (27) (last seen Dec. 16 or early Dec. 17, 1996 & found behind the Union 76 truck stop in Lake Township on Dec. 20, 1996) - *Samuel William Legg III (26 @ time of crime/55) indicted & charged (8/20/20) with 2 counts of aggravated murder, murder, 1st degree rape & 1st degree kidnapping. Wood County
Legg's DNA was linked to her death.
Court info from 8/20/20 thru 3/1/22 reference post 112 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...-apr92-sharon-kedzierski-arrest.197307/page-6

3/3/22: Order: Judgment Entry: This matter before the court this 1st day of March 2022. Ordered that the defendant remains unable to understand the nature & objective of the legal proceedings against him or to assist in his defense & remains a mentally ill person subject to court order. Ordered that further hearings on this matter be scheduled per statue. Ordered that defendant remain in custody of Twin Valley. Ordered that Court's exhibit 1 be placed under seal. Next hearing on 5/6/25.
5/6/25 Update: Wood County Common Pleas Court Judge Matt Reger held a hearing May 6 to determine whether Samuel Legg III is competent to face charges of the murder & rape of 27-year-old Victoria Jane Collins in 1996. It was determined that Legg, 55, remains a mentally ill person and will remain at Twin Valley Behavioral Healthcare, where he is receiving treatment after first being deemed incompetent in 2021.A hearing to determine his competence is held bi-annually.
OH - *Angela Marie “Angie” Hicks (14) (disappeared July 21, 1990, found by Midway Mall on Aug. 30, 1990, Elyria, Lorain County) – suspect in ongoing investigation.
Legg (21 @ the time) was Angela’s step father. DNA link to 3 homicides in Ohio & 1 in Illinois.
 
  • #116

May 13, 2025

A hearing is scheduled Thursday in Mahoning County Common Pleas Court to determine if Samuel Legg III, labeled a serial killer by the Ohio Attorney General, is competent to stand trial for the 1992 beating death of a woman at an Austintown truck stop.

Judge John Durkin will review a forensic psychiatric report he requested last month for 55-year-old Legg, who is charged with two counts of aggravated murder and murder in connection with the death of Sharon Lynn Kedzierski.
 
  • #117
Events
Date/Time Location Type Result Event Judge
05/15/2025 01:30 PM COURTROOM #4 HEARING DURKIN, JOHN M.

link: Stale Session
 
  • #118
Thursday, May 15th:
*Hearing (Sharon’s case) (@ 1:30pm ET) – OH - *Sharon Lynn Kedzierski (43) (reported missing Mar, 1992, found April 9, 1992 @ Universal Truck Mall & Flea Market, Austintown, Mahoning County) – *Samuel William Legg III (23 @ time of crime/49/now 55) arrested & charged (1/2018), indicted (2/14/19) & arraigned (2/26/19) with 3 counts of aggravated murder & 1 count of murder. Plead not guilty. Held without bond. Found incompetent to stand trial [5/23/23]. Mahoning County
DNA link.
Judge John Durkin presiding. Prosecutor attorney Paul J Gains, Michael J.Yacovone & Dawn P. Cantalamessa. Defense attorneys Rachel Ceri & Mark Lavaelle.

Court info from 2/26/19 thru 8/18/23 reference post #112 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...-apr92-sharon-kedzierski-arrest.197307/page-6

10/24/23 Docket update: Warrant for removal returned & filed for Legg. Next notes for court hearing on 4/21/25 @ 7am with Judge John M. Durkin presiding. 4/16/25 Docket update: JE>Order for Forensic examination (Durkin).
4/21/25 Update: Notes for court hearing held. Next hearing on 5/15/25 @ 1:30pm.
OH - *17 year old woman (Sept. 7, 1997, Medina County) - *Samuel William Legg III (27 @ time of crime/49/now 55) arrested (1/2018), charged & indicted (1/23/19) & arraigned (2/14/19) with 2 counts of rape. Plead not guilty. $1M bond. Medina County
Familial DNA match. Was extradited (Jan. 2018) from Chandler, AZ to Ohio.
Judge Joyce V. Kimbler presiding. Defense attorney David C. Sheldon.

Court info from 2/14/19 thru 8/3/23 reference post #112 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...-apr92-sharon-kedzierski-arrest.197307/page-6

5/13/24 Docket update: Request for Court paid experts and/or expenses. Case was disposed on 11/18/21.
In appeals
IL - *Julie A. Konkol (39) (found strangled Oct. 23, 1997, behind the abandoned Senter's truck stop in the 43000 block of Old Route 41 in Russell) - *Samuel William Legg III (27 @ time of crime/49/now 55) charged (7/30/20) with 2 counts of 1st degree murder. $3M bond. Lake County
Will eventually be extradited to Illinois to face the charges. The warrants were filed on 7/29/20 when the case was opened. They are for Murder/Intent to Kill/Injure & Murder/Strong Prob Kill/Injure.
Court info from 8/20/20 thru 8/23/21 reference post #112 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...-apr92-sharon-kedzierski-arrest.197307/page-6

OH - *Victoria Jane Collins (27) (last seen Dec. 16 or early Dec. 17, 1996 & found behind the Union 76 truck stop in Lake Township on Dec. 20, 1996) - *Samuel William Legg III (26 @ time of crime/55) indicted & charged (8/20/20) with 2 counts of aggravated murder, murder, 1st degree rape & 1st degree kidnapping. Wood County
Legg's DNA was linked to her death.
Judge Matt Reger presiding.

Court info from 8/20/20 thru 3/1/22 reference post 112 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...-apr92-sharon-kedzierski-arrest.197307/page-6

3/3/22: Order: Judgment Entry: This matter before the court this 1st day of March 2022. Ordered that the defendant remains unable to understand the nature & objective of the legal proceedings against him or to assist in his defense & remains a mentally ill person subject to court order. Ordered that further hearings on this matter be scheduled per statue. Ordered that defendant remain in custody of Twin Valley. Ordered that Court's exhibit 1 be placed under seal.
5/6/25 Update: Wood County Common Pleas Court Judge Matt Reger held a hearing May 6 to determine whether Samuel Legg III is competent to face charges of the murder & rape of 27-year-old Victoria Jane Collins in 1996. It was determined that Legg, 55, remains a mentally ill person and will remain at Twin Valley Behavioral Healthcare, where he is receiving treatment after first being deemed incompetent in 2021.A hearing to determine his competence is held bi-annually.
OH - *Angela Marie “Angie” Hicks (14) (disappeared July 21, 1990, found by Midway Mall on Aug. 30, 1990, Elyria, Lorain County) – suspect in ongoing investigation.
Legg (21 @ the time) was Angela’s step father. DNA link to 3 homicides in Ohio & 1 in Illinois.
 
  • #119
No further dates listed - and probably won't be until next year for another competency report.

Docket Information
Date Description Docket Text
05/15/2025 COPIES ISSUED COPIES ISSUED OF 04/16/25 JE
$0.90

05/15/2025 REGULAR MAIL POSTAGE FEES Issue Date: 05/15/2025
Service: COPIES OF 04/16/25 JE
Method: (CP) REGULAR MAIL
Cost Per: $0.64

LEGG III, SAMUEL
c/o ATTY: LAVELLE, MARK
940 WINDHAM COURT
SUITE 7
BOARDMAN, OH 44512
Tracking No: R001373590


FORENSIC PSYCH CTR NE OHIO
EXECUTVE SQR PROFESSIONAL
50 WESTCHESTER DRIVE
YOUNGSTOWN, OH 44515
Tracking No: R001373591


MODARELLI ESQ, ANISSA
c/o ATTY: MODARELLI ESQ, ANISSA
24 W. BOARDMAN STREET
6TH FLOOR
YOUNGSTOWN, OH 44503
Tracking No: R001373592

$1.28
05/15/2025 CERTIFIED COPY CERTIFIED COPY ISSUED OF 04/16/25 JE TO MCJC

link: https://ecourts.mahoningcountyoh.go...ZFImMOdtcKnJoiwZ367EQfuiszH2-K1v6fH2URH7H7erA
 
  • #120

May 16, 2025

Durkin also held a “continued commitment” hearing Thursday for Samuel Legg III, 55, who is being treated in Twin Valley Behavioral Healthcare in Columbus as a result of being charged with a 1992 murder at a former Austintown truck stop. Durkin found Legg not competent to stand trial in Mahoning County Common Pleas Court in 2020.

Thursday’s hearing was held to determine what type of supervision he should have for the next two years. Durkin said the court received a May 1, 2025, report written by Dr. Amanda Conn at the Central Ohio Behavioral Healthcare Center that provided details on Legg’s mental health.

Durkin noted that Legg’s attorney, Mark Lavelle, was present for the hearing, as well as Mahoning County Assistant Prosecutor Anisa Modarelli and others, but Legg refused to appear for the hearing.

The judge said he found that based on the report, Legg has a severe mental illness, “schizoaffective disorder, characterized by substantial deficits in thought, mood, perception and behavior” and he “remains a mentally ill person subject to hospitalization by a court order.”

Legg “represents substantial risks of physical harm to himself and others and he would benefit from and is in need of treatment in a hospital for that mental illness,” Durkin said. He ordered that Legg should remain at the same facility.
 

Staff online

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
79
Guests online
2,654
Total visitors
2,733

Forum statistics

Threads
632,099
Messages
18,621,976
Members
243,019
Latest member
22kimba22
Back
Top