OH - Pike Co - 8 in Rhoden Family Murdered - 4 Wagner Family Members Arrested #89

  • #1,061
I moved to OH some years ago. I'm a native of another state and metro area that is different from OH. Ohio, JMO, has more government corruption (all states have a little), it's government is not "open", IOW it's difficult to access information about legislative operations, budgets, laws, elected officials, crime, criminals, etc. It has large, powerful political machines and a flawed system of choosing, electing and appointing judges at nearly all levels. There isn't much public oversight and few "guardrails".

Here's a recent article you can read that might give you a better idea of some problems facing the judiciary, albeit this article discusses those relating to gerrymandering. Overall, the concern is that Ohio courts are not always accountable to the public.


I hope this helps.

There have also been problems with branches of government involved in other aspects of investigating and prosecuting crimes. My previous posts had some links to concerns with the Ohio AG, who tried to drop the prosecutions of the 4 Wagners.
Every single state and metro government in the United States of America are not transparent, are difficult to research, have large powerful political machines, flawed judiciary systems, and are certainly not accountable to the public. Lord, our own Federal government lacks transparency and accountability. What made you think state and local governments wouldn't follow suit?

These problems aren't new, nor will they change constantly reading and posting about them..

Again, your original post was very condensending towards Ohioans when the problems are universal throughout America, and have been since the founding of this country.
 
  • #1,062
The Death Penalty for Billy is reinstated. His defense may appeal if possible.


]01/22/2026***CERTIFIED COPY OF COURT OF APPEALS DECISION AND JUDGMENT ENTRY - THE TRIAL COURT'S JUDGMENT THAT DISMISSED THE DEATH-PENALTY SPECIFICATIONS IS REVERSED AND THIS MATTER IS REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT WITH INSTRUCTIONS TO REINSTATE THE DEATH-PENALTY SPECIFICATIONS[/td]

Trying to get a copy of the decision with details by the higher court. If so, I will post it.
 
Last edited:
  • #1,063
Here's the docket update on his Appeal case #2024CA000931
Case Status: Closed

Docket information
Date Docket Text
01/22/2026 DECISION AND JUDGMENT ENTRY - THE TRIAL COURT'S JUDGMENT THAT DISMISSED THE DEATH-PENALTY SPECIFICATIONS IS REVERSED AND THIS MATTER IS REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT WITH INSTRUCTIONS TO REINSTATE THE DEATH-PENALTY SPECIFICATIONS
COPIES FILED EMAILED AND MAILED TO COUNSEL, COPY RETURNED TO COURT OF APPEALS, CERTIFIED COPY FILED IN TRIAL CASE
01/22/2026 REGULAR MAIL ISSUED
Issue Date: 01/22/2026
Service: REGULAR MAIL
Method: REGULAR MAIL ISSUED

ANGELA R CANEPA
MAILING ADDRESS
SPECIAL PROSECUTOR
C/O PUBLIC SAFETY DEPARTMENT
1970 W BROAD ST., 5TH FLOOR
COLUMBUS, OH 43223
Tracking Number: 000012073

STEVEN L TAYLOR
MAILING ADDRESS
ATTORNEY AT LAW
196 E STATE ST
SUITE 200
COLUMBUS, OH 43215
Tracking Number: 000012074

SETH L GILBERT
MAILING ADDRESS
ATTORNEY AT LAW
196 E STATE ST
SUITE 200
COLUMBUS, OH 43215
Tracking Number: 000012075

KORT W GATTERDAM
MAILING ADDRESS
CARPENTER LIPPS LLP
280 PLAZA, SUITE 1300
280 NORTH HIGH STREET
COLUMBUS, OH 43215
Tracking Number: 000012076

MARK C COLLINS
MAILING ADDRESS
MARK C COLLINS CO LPA
150 EAST MOUND STREET
SUITE 308
COLUMBUS, OH 43215
Tracking Number: 000012077

THOMAS F HAYES
MAILING ADDRESS
ATTORNEY AT LAW
65 S LIVINGSTON AVE
COLUMBUS, OH 43215
Tracking Number: 000012078

link: https://cpcourt.pikecounty.oh.gov/e...f4bqec67dV-6hyFcaQXyDjja*vZawNzhbw12Bz6tsJHMA
 
  • #1,064
Here's the docket update on his Appeal case #2024CA000931
Case Status: Closed

Docket information
Date Docket Text
01/22/2026 DECISION AND JUDGMENT ENTRY - THE TRIAL COURT'S JUDGMENT THAT DISMISSED THE DEATH-PENALTY SPECIFICATIONS IS REVERSED AND THIS MATTER IS REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT WITH INSTRUCTIONS TO REINSTATE THE DEATH-PENALTY SPECIFICATIONS
COPIES FILED EMAILED AND MAILED TO COUNSEL, COPY RETURNED TO COURT OF APPEALS, CERTIFIED COPY FILED IN TRIAL CASE
01/22/2026 REGULAR MAIL ISSUED
Issue Date: 01/22/2026
Service: REGULAR MAIL
Method: REGULAR MAIL ISSUED

ANGELA R CANEPA
MAILING ADDRESS
SPECIAL PROSECUTOR
C/O PUBLIC SAFETY DEPARTMENT
1970 W BROAD ST., 5TH FLOOR
COLUMBUS, OH 43223
Tracking Number: 000012073

STEVEN L TAYLOR
MAILING ADDRESS
ATTORNEY AT LAW
196 E STATE ST
SUITE 200
COLUMBUS, OH 43215
Tracking Number: 000012074

SETH L GILBERT
MAILING ADDRESS
ATTORNEY AT LAW
196 E STATE ST
SUITE 200
COLUMBUS, OH 43215
Tracking Number: 000012075

KORT W GATTERDAM
MAILING ADDRESS
CARPENTER LIPPS LLP
280 PLAZA, SUITE 1300
280 NORTH HIGH STREET
COLUMBUS, OH 43215
Tracking Number: 000012076

MARK C COLLINS
MAILING ADDRESS
MARK C COLLINS CO LPA
150 EAST MOUND STREET
SUITE 308
COLUMBUS, OH 43215
Tracking Number: 000012077

THOMAS F HAYES
MAILING ADDRESS
ATTORNEY AT LAW
65 S LIVINGSTON AVE
COLUMBUS, OH 43215
Tracking Number: 000012078

link: https://cpcourt.pikecounty.oh.gov/e...f4bqec67dV-6hyFcaQXyDjja*vZawNzhbw12Bz6tsJHMA
Thank you both! This is very good news. Justice for the Rhoden & Gilley families!
 
  • #1,065
Thank you both! This is very good news. Justice for the Rhoden & Gilley families!

I did check the "Events" nothing yet - but will my eye open for next hearing date! :)
 
  • #1,066
It is insane that this case hasn't been completely resolved yet. Almost ten years.
 
  • #1,067
The Death Penalty for Billy is reinstated. His defense may appeal if possible.


]01/22/2026***CERTIFIED COPY OF COURT OF APPEALS DECISION AND JUDGMENT ENTRY - THE TRIAL COURT'S JUDGMENT THAT DISMISSED THE DEATH-PENALTY SPECIFICATIONS IS REVERSED AND THIS MATTER IS REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT WITH INSTRUCTIONS TO REINSTATE THE DEATH-PENALTY SPECIFICATIONS[/td]

Trying to get a copy of the decision with details by the higher court. If so, I will post it.
This is good news! Maybe there will be accountability yet in this case! IMO
 
  • #1,068
  • #1,069
  • #1,070
This is the written decision from the Higher Court on Billy's DP specifications, to be reinstated.
 

Attachments

  • #1,071
  • #1,072
Thanks, CO!
I would hope that an appeal to Hein's decision on JW and AW cases would result in the same. I'm assuming his decisions are up for appeal also??????
 
  • #1,073
I would hope that an appeal to Hein's decision on JW and AW cases would result in the same. I'm assuming his decisions are up for appeal also??????
There is an appeal on Both JW and AW sentencing. I am not sure if theirs has to be decided and finalized before Billy's trial can begin. At least if the DP reversal stands it would put more pressure on JW to testify in Billy's case I would think. I am not sure hat the Judge would ever hand down the DP to Billy.

I believe the jury in Ohio and most states recommend the sentence in a capital murder case, but the judge does have the final say. I think it has to be a unanimous decision of the jury for DP or it will be life in prison, but the judge could rule otherwise. I could be wrong about all of that, have only researched it a little.

I feel like whatever decisions are handed down there will be more appeals rolling in.
 
Last edited:
  • #1,074
Here are the latest updates for Angela & Jake

Angela - Appeal

Docket
Date Docket Text
01/09/2026 MERIT BRIEF OF APPELLEE ANGELA WAGNER FILED
COPIES FILED RETD TO COUNSEL, 4 MAILED TO COURT OF APPEALS

01/22/2026 REPLY BRIEF OF PLAINTIFF-APPELLANT STATE OF OHIO FILED
COPIES FILED RETD TO COUNSEL BY EMAIL, 4 MAILED TO COURT OF APPEALS


Jake - Appeal #2025CA000935

Docket
Date Docket Text
12/17/2025 MOTION TO WITHDRAW AS CO-COUNSEL FILED
Attorney: GOODPASTER, CASSANDRA

12/29/2025 MAGISTRATE'S ORDER - ATTORNEY CASSANDRA GOODPASTER IS GRANTED LEAVE TO WITHDRAW AS CO-COUNSEL; ATTORNEY KATHLEEN EVANS REMAINS OF RECORD TO REPRESENT APPELLEE
COPIES FILED EMAILED TO COUNSEL, 4 MAILED TO COURT OF APPEALS


Jake - Appeal #2025CA000939

Docket
Date Docket Text
12/17/2025 MOTION TO WITHDRAW AS CO-COUNSEL FILED
Attorney: GOODPASTER, CASSANDRA

12/29/2025 MAGISTRATE'S ORDER - ATTORNEY CASSANDRA GOODPASTER IS GRANTED LEAVE TO WITHDRAW AS CO-COUNSEL; ATTORNEY KATHLEEN EVANS REMAINS OF RECORD TO REPRESENT APPELLEE
COPIES FILED EMAILED TO COUNSEL, 4 MAILED TO COURT OF APPEALS

link: https://cpcourt.pikecounty.oh.gov/eservices/search.page.3.2?x=hZzEUpWvSUeZMcgnaR5cww
 
  • #1,075
Monday, February 9th:
*Status Conference Hearing (@ 12pm ET) – OH – Pike County 8 people dead: Christopher Rhoden, Sr. (40), his ex-wife, Dana Manley Rhoden (37), their three children, Clarence “Frankie” Rhoden (20), Christopher Jr. (16), Hanna Mae (19); Frankie’s fiancée, Hannah Hazel Gilley (20), Christopher Rhoden Sr.’s brother, Kenneth Rhoden (44), & a cousin, Gary Rhoden (37). Hanna Rhoden’s baby girl (5 days old), another baby (6 mos.) and a young child (3) were unharmed. (April 21-22, 2016, Pebbles) - *George Washington “Billy” Wagner III (47/now 54) (name changed [11/5/86] from William Emmanuel) [Jake’s father] indicted (11/12/18), arrested (11/13/18), charged (11/15/18) & arraigned (12/4/18) with 8 counts of aggravated murder, [Dismissed 11/27/24: (plus gun specifications on each)], (plus gun specifications on each), 1 count of 1st degree conspiracy, 4 counts of 1st degree aggravated burglary, 1 count of 5th degree unlawful possession of dangerous ordnance, 3 counts of 3rd degree evidence tampering, 1 count of 5th degree forgery, 1 count of 5th degree unauthorized use of computer or telecommunications, 1 count of 4th degree interception of wire, oral or electronic communication, 1 count of 4th degree obstructing justice & 1 count of 1st degree engaging in a pattern of corrupt activity. Plead not guilty. Held without bond. DA will seek the DP. Was permanently moved (9/13/24) to the Pickaway County Jail in Circleville. Pike County
Appeal case #2024CA000931 State of Ohio vs. Wagner, III, George Washington. Case Status: Open File Date 12/2/24. Action: Court of Appeals. Case closed on 1/22/26.
Presiding Judge Jonathan P. Hein. Prosecutors Angela R. Canepa, Seth L. Gilbert & Steven L. Taylor. Defense attorneys Mark C. Collins, Kort Gatterdam & Thomas F. Hayes.

Court of Appeals from 1/10/25 to 6/12/25 Docket reference post #928 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...ner-family-members-arrested-89.732618/page-47

6/20/25 Docket update: Application & entry to broadcast, televise, record or photograph proceedings.
Appeal Case #2024CA000932 State of Ohio vs. Wagner, III, George Washington. Court of Appeals. Case Status: Open on 12/9/24. Action: Court of Appeals. Case dismissed on 2/14/25.

Court of Appeals from 1/3/25 to 2/14/25 reference post #928 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...ner-family-members-arrested-89.732618/page-47

Trial was set to begin on 1/6/25 was postponed & no further dates.
Presiding Judge Jonathan P. Hein replaced (on 5/29/24) Judge R. Alan Corbin [health reasons]. Prosecutor Angela R. Canepa & defense attorneys Mark C. Collins & Thomas F, Hayes.

Case & court information from 12/4/18 thru 6/25/25 reference post #928 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...ner-family-members-arrested-89.732618/page-47

7/22/25 Docket update: Judgment entry CANCELLING proceedings set for 7/25/25 filed. Next pretrial hearing on 8/22/25 @ 10am. 8/19/25 Docket update: Judgment entry Cancelling proceedings set for 8/22/25 filed. 10/8/25 Docket update: Motion, entry & certification for appointed counsel fees.
1/22/26 Docket update: *Certified copy of Court of Appeals Decision & Judgment entry: The trial court's judgment that dismissed the death penalty specifications is reversed & this matter is remanded to trial court with instructions to reinstate the death penalty specifications.
1/22/26 Docket updates: Appeal case #2024CA000931/Case Status: Closed. Decision & Judgment entry: The Trial Court's judgment that dismissed the death penalty specifications is reversed & this matter is remanded to Trial Court with instructions to reinstate the death penalty specifications. Copies filed, emailed & mailed to Counsel, copy returned to Court of Appeals, Certified copy filed in trial case. Regular mail issued to: Angela A. Canepa, Special Prosecutor, attorneys Steven L. Taylor, Seth L. Gilbert, Thomas F. Hayes & Kort W. Gafferdam of Carpenter Lipps, LLP, Mark C. Collins of Mark C. Collins Co., LPA. See post #1070, page 54, thread #89 for document.
1/23/26 Docket updates: Notice of hearing sent to all required parties. Next status conference hearing on 2/9/26 @ 12pm. warrant for removal from Pickaway County Jail on 2/9/26 @ 12pm.
*George Washington Wagner IV (27/now 34) – Guilty of all charges on 11/30/22 & sentenced on 12/19/22 to 8 Life sentences without the possibility of parole to run consecutively for the murders plus 121 years on other charges. Appeal filed 1/26/23. Last update 7/23/25. Had oral arguments hearing re appeals on 4/17/25. Appeals court has 60 days for decision.
*Angela Jo Wagner (48/now 55) – 9/10/21: Plead guilty to a plea deal to Counts 9 thru 22; Counts 1-8 were dismissed. Sentenced on 1/3/25 to 9 years for complicity & 3 years for tampering; 18 months for electronic interception; corrupt activity 9 years prison. Also gets 12 years for firearms specs. All different charges all add up to 30 years. Minor charges run concurrently to major charges to get to 30 years, minus 6 years 6 weeks already spent in jail. Wagner will have no appeal right.
*Edward Jacob “Jake” Wagner (26/now 33) – Plead guilty (4/22/21) to all charges & will testify at the trials & sentenced on 1/3/25 to 8 life terms for aggravated murder. Max sentences for other charges including conspiracy for murder, aggravated burglary, corrupt acts. Instead, he is giving Wagner 32 years, with chance for parole after that. More detail: 12 years on the gun charges for Wagner, 20 years (concurrent) for the eight aggravated murders.
*Rita Jo Newcomb (65/now 72) – Motion hearing on 12/2/19 entered a plea of guilty to all charges. Will testify at the trials. Sentenced on 1/3/25 to no additional jail time & 5 years of supervision & up to $750 in fines.
*Fredericka Carol Wagner (76/now 83) – 6/26/19: Charges were dismissed without prejudice.
 

Guardians Monthly Goal

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
99
Guests online
3,271
Total visitors
3,370

Forum statistics

Threads
640,574
Messages
18,761,709
Members
244,690
Latest member
moreLegion
Back
Top