OK - Bonnie Beth Lilly, 3, dies from cancerous 17-pound tumor, Comanche County, 3 Jan 2019 *Arrest*

[PayrollNerd]

No. CF-2019-17
LILLY, HENRY CLARENCE III


The Docket has been updated with many lines. Ok, count 1 is 5 years and the others are 13 years consecutively. Then 2 years supervision after release.

OSCN Case Details

 

[Niner]

Thanks a bunch @PayrollNerd ! I shall put this on "my shelf" since Bonnie is still on pending competency.

 

[Niner]

@PayrollNerd -when you have time - can you see what is happening with Bonnie Mills-Lily's case?
Comanche County #CF-2019-17
She was committed in 9/25/23 - so almost a year. TIA!

 

[PayrollNerd]

No. CF-2019-17
BONNIE BETH MILLS-LILLY

Looks like she's been cleared to stand trial. Here's all the listings for her only.



Docket entries:

OSCN Case Details

 

[GoBuckeyes]

They probably won't do any real time. I wonder if the other six kids will stay in their custody.

I hope not.

 

[Niner]

Monday, Sept. 23rd:
*Sounding Docket Hearing (@ 9am CT) – OK – Bonnie Beth Lilly (3 yrs) (Jan. 3, 2018, Lawton; had 17 lb. tumor/cancer) - *Bonnie Beth Mills-Lilly (42/now 47) arrested (1/4/18), charged (1/7/18) & arraigned (12/2/19) with 1st degree manslaughter & not providing medical care to child. Plead not guilty. $60K bond each. Bonded out on 1/10/19. Bond forfeiture (9/27/22) went on the lam. Bond reset to $1M (10/14/22). Comanche County
Trial was set to begin on 9/25/23 for jury selection for Bonnie only but was continued/vacated due to pending competency.
New trial date is now on 10/21/24.
Court hearings from 1/10/19 thru 8/28/23 & Trial Days 1-6 (9/25 to 10/2/23) reference post #207 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...anche-county-3-jan-2019-arrest.412241/page-11
9/25/23 Update: Trial has been vacated/continued due to pending competency.
6/25/24 Docket update: Original transcript & 2 copies of preliminary hearing. Mills-Lilly found competent to stand trial.
9/9/24 Docket update: Court order by Judge Jay Walker-Defendant order to appear in personal for sounding docket hearing on 9/23/24 @ 9am & jury trial set to begin on 10/21/24 @ 9am.
*Henry Clarence Lilly III (49/now 54) arrested (1/4/18), charged (1/7/18) & arraigned (12/2/19) with 1st degree manslaughter & not providing medical care to child. 2/13/24 Trial. Jury found henry guilty of all charges. Sentencing hearing on 4/12/24. Judge Jay Walker sentenced Lilly: 1st degree manslaughter to 5 years, $10K fine/court costs & child abuse charge to 13 years & $10K fine/court costs.

 

[Niner]

Okay - I might have this - but I read the above docket for October 21, 2024 - as Jury Trial starting - BUT!! This article says different. Now I notice behind that Jury Trial is Issue - so maybe JUST a hearing on an "issue" for jury trial??

Big trials coming to Comanche County as trial docket set to begin

The fall season is shaping up to be a busy time of year for judges in Comanche County, as several big trials are scheduled to begin in mid-October through November.

www.kswo.com

Sept. 30, 2024
.....

For defendants facing manslaughter charges, there are only two and they’re both being heard a day apart from each other.​

• In Judge Shepherd’s courtroom on the 30th of October, James Jacobs Junior is charged for the strangulation death of Bobbie Willis back in March of 2021.
• In Judge Walker’s court room on the 31st, a jury will hear the case of Bonnie Beth Mills-Lilly, whose charged with manslaughter and child abuse, for allegedly failing to get her 3-year-old daughter proper medical attention. Her husband was found guilty in February of this year.

So @PayrollNerd - is the article correct in trial starting 10/31/24 instead of what I had 10/21/24?
TIA if you can help!

 

[PayrollNerd]

No. CF-2019-17
BONNIE BETH MILLS-LILLY

These Events are all for her. Both of those dates are listed.


Docket:

OSCN Case Details

 

[Niner]

No. CF-2019-17
BONNIE BETH MILLS-LILLY

These Events are all for her. Both of those dates are listed.
View attachment 534694

Docket:
View attachment 534701

OSCN Case Details

Thanks for this info! So - now I see that the "issue" is her competency....

 

[Niner]

Monday, Oct. 7th:
*Pretrial Conference Hearing (@ 1:30pm CT) – OK – Bonnie Beth Lilly (3 yrs) (Jan. 3, 2018, Lawton; had 17 lb. tumor/cancer) - *Bonnie Beth Mills-Lilly (42/now 47) arrested (1/4/18), charged (1/7/18) & arraigned (12/2/19) with 1st degree manslaughter & not providing medical care to child. Plead not guilty. $60K bond each. Bonded out on 1/10/19. Bond forfeiture (9/27/22) went on the lam. Bond reset to $1M (10/14/22). Comanche County
Trial was set to begin on 9/25/23 for jury selection for Bonnie only but was continued/vacated due to pending competency. Found competent 6/25/24.
New trial date was set to begin on 10/21/24 continued on 10/31/24.
Court hearings from 1/10/19 thru 6/25/24 reference post #266 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...anche-county-3-jan-2019-arrest.412241/page-14
9/9/24 Docket update: Court order by Judge Jay Walker-Defendant order to appear in personal for sounding docket hearing on 9/23/24 @ 9am & jury trial set to begin on 10/21/24 @ 9am.
9/24/24 Update: Sounding Order per Judge Walker. Defendant appears in person & defendant's trial now set to begin on 10/31/24 @ 9am. In the event case is not tried on this docket Defendant is ordered to appear for the next sounding hearing on 1/13/25 @ 9am. Defendant appears for sounding of felony docket & announces ready for trial. Ordered to appear for a pretrial conference hearing on 10/7/24 @ 1:30pm & on 10/21/24 for a Jury trial issue hearing @ 9am. 9/26/24 Docket update: Demand for Jury trial on issue of competency to stand trial on 10/31/24.
*Henry Clarence Lilly III (49/now 54) arrested (1/4/18), charged (1/7/18) & arraigned (12/2/19) with 1st degree manslaughter & not providing medical care to child. 2/13/24 Trial. Jury found Henry guilty of all charges. Sentencing hearing on 4/12/24. Judge Jay Walker sentenced Lilly: 1st degree manslaughter to 5 years, $10K fine/court costs & child abuse charge to 13 years & $10K fine/court costs.

 

[Niner]

Monday, October 21st:
*Jury Trial Issue Hearing (@ 9am CT) – OK – Bonnie Beth Lilly (3 yrs) (Jan. 3, 2018, Lawton; had 17 lb. tumor/cancer) - *Bonnie Beth Mills-Lilly (42/now 47) arrested (1/4/18), charged (1/7/18) & arraigned (12/2/19) with 1st degree manslaughter & not providing medical care to child. Plead not guilty. $60K bond each. Bonded out on 1/10/19. Bond forfeiture (9/27/22) went on the lam. Bond reset to $1M (10/14/22). Comanche County
Trial was set to begin on 9/25/23 for jury selection for Bonnie only but was continued/vacated due to pending competency. Found competent 6/25/24.
New trial date was set to begin on 10/21/24 continued on 10/31/24.
Court hearings from 1/10/19 thru 9/9/24 reference post #270 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...anche-county-3-jan-2019-arrest.412241/page-14
9/24/24 Update: Sounding Order per Judge Walker. Defendant appears in person & defendant's trial now set to begin on 10/31/24 @ 9am. In the event case is not tried on this docket Defendant is ordered to appear for the next sounding hearing on 1/13/25 @ 9am. Defendant appears for sounding of felony docket & announces ready for trial. Ordered to appear for a pretrial conference hearing on 10/7/24 @ 1:30pm & on 10/21/24 for a Jury trial issue hearing @ 9am. 9/26/24 Docket update: Demand for Jury trial on issue of competency to stand trial on 10/31/24.
10/7/24 Update: Next a jury trial issue hearing on 10/21/24 @ 9am.
*Henry Clarence Lilly III (49/now 54) arrested (1/4/18), charged (1/7/18) & arraigned (12/2/19) with 1st degree manslaughter & not providing medical care to child. 2/13/24 Trial. Jury found Henry guilty of all charges. Sentencing hearing on 4/12/24. Judge Jay Walker sentenced Lilly: 1st degree manslaughter to 5 years, $10K fine/court costs & child abuse charge to 13 years & $10K fine/court costs.

 

[Niner]

@PayrollNerd - NO Hurry!! When you have time is there a next hearing date yet? Maybe even a trial date for her. TIA!

 

[Niner]

@PayrollNerd - just checking to see if her trial date IS 10/31/24?? Or?? TIA!

 

[PayrollNerd]

No. CF-2019-17
BONNIE BETH MILLS-LILLY

A couple screen clips from my iPad.

OSCN Case Details

 

[Niner]

Thursday, October 31st:
*Jury Trial Competency Hearing (@ 9am CT) – OK – Bonnie Beth Lilly (3 yrs) (Jan. 3, 2018, Lawton; had 17 lb. tumor/cancer) - *Bonnie Beth Mills-Lilly (42/now 47) arrested (1/4/18), charged (1/7/18) & arraigned (12/2/19) with 1st degree manslaughter & not providing medical care to child. Plead not guilty. $60K bond each. Bonded out on 1/10/19. Bond forfeiture (9/27/22) went on the lam. Bond reset to $1M (10/14/22). Comanche County
Jury Trial Competency hearing set to begin on 10/31/24.
Judge Zwaan presiding.
Court hearings from 1/10/19 thru 9/26/24 reference post #271 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...anche-county-3-jan-2019-arrest.412241/page-14
10/7/24 Update: Next a jury trial issue hearing on 10/21/24 @ 9am. 10/1/24 Docket update: Claim for intercept of tax refund. 10/10/24 Docket update: Transfer Order. Case is transferred to Judge Zwaan for the purpose of jury trial scheduled 10/31/24 @ 9am wherein the defendant has requested a jury trial on the defendant's competency. The transfer Order applies only for the purpose of the scheduled jury trial for competency. This Court will retain jurisdictional for all proceedings post jury competency trial. Court Clerk's certificate of mailing. 10/15/24 Docket update: Motion to endorse additional witnesses/Order by Judge Zwaan re Scott Orth, Psy.D. Subpoena out of County issued via email/State re Dr. Scott Orth. 10/21/24 Docket update: Defendant's witness & exhibit list (competency trial). 10/30/24 Docket updates: Next Jury trial competency hearing on 10/31/24 @ 9am.
*Henry Clarence Lilly III (49/now 54) arrested (1/4/18), charged (1/7/18) & arraigned (12/2/19) with 1st degree manslaughter & not providing medical care to child. 2/13/24 Trial. Jury found henry guilty of all charges. Sentencing hearing on 4/12/24. Judge Jay Walker sentenced Lilly: 1st degree manslaughter to 5 years, $10K fine/court costs & child abuse charge to 13 years & $10K fine/court costs.

 

[Niner]

@PayrollNerd - do not know IF this is an actual trial - if so, does it continue to tomorrow? TIA!

 

[Niner]

I am going to go ahead & post this - I do believe it is a "trial". I also searched - but found nothing.

Friday, November 1st:
*Jury Trial Competency Hearing (Day 2) (@ 9am CT) – OK – Bonnie Beth Lilly (3 yrs) (Jan. 3, 2018, Lawton; had 17 lb. tumor/cancer) - *Bonnie Beth Mills-Lilly (42/now 47) arrested (1/4/18), charged (1/7/18) & arraigned (12/2/19) with 1st degree manslaughter & not providing medical care to child. Plead not guilty. $60K bond each. Bonded out on 1/10/19. Bond forfeiture (9/27/22) went on the lam. Bond reset to $1M (10/14/22). Comanche County
Jury Trial Competency hearing began on 10/31/24.
Judge Zwaan presiding.
Court hearings from 1/10/19 thru 10/30/24 reference post #275 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...anche-county-3-jan-2019-arrest.412241/page-14
10/31/24 Jury trial competency hearing Day 1: ?? no info found. Competency jury trial continues on 11/1/24.
*Henry Clarence Lilly III (49/now 54) arrested (1/4/18), charged (1/7/18) & arraigned (12/2/19) with 1st degree manslaughter & not providing medical care to child. 2/13/24 Trial. Jury found henry guilty of all charges. Sentencing hearing on 4/12/24. Judge Jay Walker sentenced Lilly: 1st degree manslaughter to 5 years, $10K fine/court costs & child abuse charge to 13 years & $10K fine/court costs.

 

[PayrollNerd]

No. CF-2019-17
BONNIE BETH MILLS-LILLY

Here are the latest entries. Nothing on the calendar beyond 10/31.

OSCN Case Details

 

[Niner]

Thank you @PayrollNerd - strange that Count 1 has a conviction, but then it says it is "pending". Weird, if you ask me!
I do not see the Sounding docket hearing for 1/13/25 anymore, but I will put her there just in case she does appear. I shall be back in a few weeks to check her schedule.

Again - THANKS!

 

[Niner]

@PayrollNerd - any new updates for Bonnie? No 1/13/25 Sounding hearing? TIA!