GUILTY PA - Ellen Robb, 49, beaten to death, Montgomery County, 22 Dec 2006

  • #401
KING OF PRUSSIA, Pa. - January 8, 2007 - A University of Pennsylvania professor was charged Monday in the bludgeoning death of his estranged wife, who told friends she was preparing to divorce him.

Rafael Robb, 56, surrendered to authorities after being charged with first- and third-degree murder and possession of an instrument of crime. His arraignment was scheduled for Monday afternoon.

Robb, an economics professor originally from Israel, had told investigators he was in Philadelphia when his wife Ellen was killed Dec. 22 in the kitchen of their suburban home.

But prosecutors said his alibi did not hold up, and they had pressured him in recent days to prove his innocence.

"Dr. Robb lied to the police about an obvious motive for this murder, his knowledge of his wife's recent plans to divorce him and obtain a significant portion of his wealth," according to the affidavit signed by Upper Merion police Detective David Gershanick.

Rafael Robb was also charged with tampering with evidence and lying to authorities.

Robb had said he took the couple's 12-year-old daughter to school that morning and last saw his wife alive at their Upper Merion Township home before driving to work at about 9:30 a.m. He said he returned home later that day to find his wife's body.

Yet Montgomery County District Attorney Bruce Castor has said the murder scene was staged to look like a burglary. Ellen Robb's face was beaten so badly that Castor said her killer must have hated and specifically targeted her, something authorities wouldn't see in burglary case.

A murder weapon has not been found but investigators believe it was a narrow metal object, such as a crowbar or tire iron.

Authorities now say Rafael Robb killed his wife and allegedly spent about 15 minutes changing out of bloody clothing and staging a burglary before going to his car - bypassing phones in the house - and calling police from his cell phone.

Robb dialed the local 10-digit number for police rather than calling 911.

"We think he erroneously thought the regular police number wasn't taped," Castor said Monday.

In reporting his wife's death, Robb told a 911 dispatcher, "Her head is cracked," indicating that he believed Ellen Robb was beaten. But authorities said Ellen Robb's injuries were so extensive they initially thought she was killed with a shotgun blast to the face.

Ellen Robb, 49, had told family members and others that she had hired a divorce attorney and was expecting $4,000 a month in spousal support after she moved out on Jan. 1, prosecutors said in court papers.

Rafael Robb denied any involvement in the slaying when he was questioned by a reporter outside the courthouse last week, where he was complying with a search warrant for blood and fingerprint samples.

Rafael Robb earned a Ph.D. in economics from the University of California, Los Angeles, in 1981. He has been at Penn for at least four years, according to a resume posted on his university Web site.

Penn officials said earlier that they had arranged for someone else to teach Robb's graduate seminar in game theory this semester. They declined further comment Monday. His lawyer, Francis Genovese, did not immediately return a call for comment Monday morning.
___________________________________________________________________
The above is from local ABC station. See italics added by me. This makes no sense. They now think he committed the murder after he got home, just before he called police??? No, can't be, not at all consistent with evidence of rigor mortis and other facts.
 
  • #402
FactsareFacts said:
So he has already been arraigned then Lisa? And bail was denied?
Yes and he's SHACKLED! Good.
 
  • #403
I think it's just worded incorrectly. Should have been a separate sentence instead of one. IMO
 
  • #404
Hedidit said:
Yes and he's SHACKLED! Good.
So he was arrainged at 2:30 and is now on his way to jail? :behindbar
 
  • #405
Hedidit said:
Yes and he's SHACKLED! Good.
Where did you see that?
 
  • #406
Few minutes ago on Fox 40...breaking news. Hands and feet shackled.
 
  • #407
Bail was denied according to what I heard.

If you go to the cbs3 site there is a link to footage of his pulling up in FG's jeep, his getting out in jeans, blue oxford shirt, same jacket as the one dogwalking, and a greek fisherman's hat, plodding with FG as camera crews walk backward, into the UMPD bldg, wordlessly, and then through a door. But there was no voice-over. Just the footage. Glitch maybe.
 
  • #408
lisafremont said:
Bail was denied according to what I heard.

If you go to the cbs3 site there is a link to footage of his pulling up in FG's jeep, his getting out in jeans, blue oxford shirt, same jacket as the one dogwalking, and a greek fisherman's hat, plodding with FG as camera crews walk backward, into the UMPD bldg, wordlessly, and then through a door. But there was no voice-over. Just the footage. Glitch maybe.
Whoa............that was eerie..........truly reality has set in by now.
 
  • #409
lisafremont said:
Bail was denied according to what I heard.

If you go to the cbs3 site there is a link to footage of his pulling up in FG's jeep, his getting out in jeans, blue oxford shirt, same jacket as the one dogwalking, and a greek fisherman's hat, plodding with FG as camera crews walk backward, into the UMPD bldg, wordlessly, and then through a door. But there was no voice-over. Just the footage. Glitch maybe.
Thanks. I saw it -- didn't matter that there was no voice over. What I saw was a pathetic man getting what he deserved. . .
 
  • #410
Rick Leventhal (I'm watching this again courtesy DVR) said shackled at wrist and ankle, arraigned on first and third degree murder and falsifying evidence
Still no sign of murder weapon or bloody clothes
DA says he has no doubt that the prof. savagely attacked his wife
that he knew she was planning to move out on 1 Jan, get $4000 per mo.
and that he was hiding money overseas
She couldn't go to a party last year she said bec. she had a black eye from him
his alibi is "shaky"
instead of calling police right away
he touched her face, went upstairs
dropped a briefcase in the bedroom
went to his dau's room
then went back to the kitchen
then to the laundry room
then to the garage to his car to get his cellphone
calling the 10-digit non-emergency phone # (hurrah!)
instead of 99
BRUCE CASTOR: There's a phone in his bedroom
There's a phone in the dau's room
There's a telephone in the kitchen.
You pick up one of the phones and you call 911
and you run out of there as fast as you can
You don't wait around for the killer to come beat you over the head
very very strange behavior

RL: But will that behavior be enough to convict? We're expecting
a trial later this year. Professor maintains his innocence
 
  • #411
  • #412
Can someone explain why it is 1st and 3rd degree murder?
 
  • #413
Puzzled me, too. "Falsifying evidence" must mean staging the crime scene.

If anyone finds the arrest warrant and also the search warrant(s), please post!!
 
  • #414
Penn professor charged in wife’s death

By Nancy Phillips

INQUIRER STAFF WRITER

University of Pennsylvania economics professor Rafael Robb has been charged with first-degree murder in connection with the death of his wife, Ellen.

Robb, a bespectacled man with closely cropped salt-and-pepper hair, looked a bit bewildered as he entered the courtroom for his arraignment wearing jeans, sneakers and a blue wool jacket and carrying a black wool cap.

His feet were in shackles and his hands cuffed in front of him and strapped to a leather belt around his waist.

District Justice William Maruszczak asked him to spell his name, and Robb answered in accented English that hinted of his native language of Hebrew.

He sat quietly and betrayed no emotion as the judge read aloud the charges against him. At the close of the brief proceeding, he stood and asked his lawyer, "Where am I going now?" as he was led to Montgomery County prison, where he will be held without bail.

A preliminary hearing will be held some time later this month.

http://www.philly.com/mld/philly/16411211.htm

Wouldn't you think that he and his lawyer would have discussed the details of what was likely to happen prior to his surrender and arraignment? Or is he out of touch or is the lawyer that poor...?
 
  • #415
The TV talking heads should really read here before they start blethering.

I they are confused about the "second divorce". Ellen had filed 13 years ago but didn't complete the job, probably due to Olivia being conceived. I could be wrong, though. Even so, he was with Ellen for about 20 years. He should be financially "over" any prior divorce. Nobody gets spousal support for that long.
 
  • #416
Has there been anymore mentioned about a previous wife?
 
  • #417
Neighbor2 said:
KING OF PRUSSIA, Pa. - January 8, 2007
<snip>
Authorities now say Rafael Robb killed his wife and allegedly spent about 15 minutes changing out of bloody clothing and staging a burglary before going to his car - bypassing phones in the house - and calling police from his cell phone.

Robb dialed the local 10-digit number for police rather than calling 911.

"We think he erroneously thought the regular police number wasn't taped," Castor said Monday.
<snip>
The above is from local ABC station. See italics added by me. This makes no sense. They now think he committed the murder after he got home, just before he called police??? No, can't be, not at all consistent with evidence of rigor mortis and other facts.

I also noticed that but I interpret it differently. I think it says that he killed her, cleaned up, left, returned, staged the scene, then called local police.

That doesn't make sense to me. I think he staged things before he left. He would need to in case someone else showed up!

But note the mention of the speculation that he thought local police # wouldn't be taped! Just as we thought!!
 
  • #418
Hedidit said:
Few minutes ago on Fox 40...breaking news. Hands and feet shackled.

I saw it, too....he was doing the perp walk. Good. :furious:
 
  • #419
luthersmama said:
The TV talking heads should really read here before they start blethering.

I they are confused about the "second divorce". Ellen had filed 13 years ago but didn't complete the job, probably due to Olivia being conceived. I could be wrong, though. Even so, he was with Ellen for about 20 years. He should be financially "over" any prior divorce. Nobody gets spousal support for that long.

He's 56. With her since 36. That still gives him lots of time to have ruined some other poor woman's life.
 
  • #420
luthersmama said:
The TV talking heads should really read here before they start blethering.

I they are confused about the "second divorce". Ellen had filed 13 years ago but didn't complete the job, probably due to Olivia being conceived. I could be wrong, though. Even so, he was with Ellen for about 20 years. He should be financially "over" any prior divorce. Nobody gets spousal support for that long.
That was a new one for me about RR. You are probably correct about it being the second filing for Ellen. I wish someone knew how to reach his family in Isarel for more info on his early years, his mother knowing/not knowing about this murder, siblings etc. Olivia would be key to that information but nobody is going to involve her for media coverage at this time.
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
91
Guests online
3,490
Total visitors
3,581

Forum statistics

Threads
632,649
Messages
18,629,678
Members
243,235
Latest member
MerrillAsh
Back
Top