southcitymom
Well-Known Member
My own son is 11, he has never uttered those words. He's never even said he hated me or his dad. He will go as far as "you are so mean" but always qualifies it by saying "sometimes" ROFL
If those words ever came out of his mouth, I honestly don't know how I would react...I would be stunned beyond belief!!! I would want him immediately evaluated. Making an appointment would be out of the question. I would take it seriously same as if he ever threatened to harm himself.
All these people that admit to their own children saying such things, do they consider themselves a permissive parent? I just can't wrap my head around the total lack of respect in some homes.
I wanted to add...it's a MUTUAL RESPECT in my home. It goes both ways, I would never say such things either, not in anger nor even in jest.
I do hear what you're saying, but I think talk like this must be taken in context. I have heard little boys (and girls) in play say, "I am going to kill so and so!"
Last year, my 1st grade son was joking around in the lunchroom and said to the ceiling, "I am going to kill someone with this (plastic) knife." Another little boy thought he said it to him and hit my son. They were both referred to the principal's office, where my son was lectured ad nauseum about zero-tolerance, as well he should have been. We followed up with consequences at home. My son doesn't have a violent bone in his body (no violent screens in his life and my husband and I don't even spank) - he's always in character club and on honor roll - but he's a little boy trying on language and testing limits.
Is he murderous and in need of counseling? No. He just needs to learn what's appropriate. If he said something like that at school in conjunction with other aggressive, antisocial words and behaviors, I would seek counseling. But that one incident didn't worry me a bit.
Both my boys have said they hated me before. Inside it cracks me up and I actually am glad they feel safe enough to get that angry with me. It's just the worst word for anger that they know and it's taboo - very powerful and provocative to them and many children. I give them consequences for such language because they need to learn better ways to express their anger, but I'm not impressed by it and I don't lose any sleep over it. Not all kids says, "I hate you" to Mom and Dad, but plenty do - enough that it is a normal phase.
Last week, my youngest son (6) was asked by his Tae Kwon Do instructor where he would go if he could go any place in the world and he replied, "to the center of the earth so that he could die in the hot boiling lava and go to heaven." The instructor didn't really know what to do with that and moved on. Is my youngest son in need of counseling for suicidal ideation? Nope - he's very intrigued by death right now and he wants to check out Heaven, but if you discuss that with him, he'll tell you in no uncertain terms that he'd take the next bus back home to me once he was finished up there. He is a child with a child's imagination. He is also well-behaved, making good grades, etc...etc...
Anyway, I share these stories not to drone on about my sons' freaky behaviors, but just to say so much of this depends on the child. Children say and do strange things in early and middle childhood and, IMHO, not every murder or suicide "threat" is an immediate red flag to send a kid to a shrink.