PA PA - Mary Ann Bagenstose, 25, West Willow, 5 June 1984

New Posts

Trackergd said:
I had a few moments today to take a look at Google Maps. The two wooded areas along Goods Run, the Shiprock Woods Nature Preserve and the wooded area between Radcliff Road and 272 all should be the focus of a forensic ground search after a good hard frost to kill the green vegetation. They are all areas of opportunity to hide remains.
Click to expand...

It blows my mind that a search has yet to be done specifically in the Park Reserve Area.
 
MadMcGoo said:
Mary Ann Bagenstose – The Charley Project

Mary Ann Bagenstose
mary_ann_bagenstose_1.jpg
mary_ann_bagenstose_2.jpg
bagenstose_mary3.jpg
bagenstose_mary4.jpg

Mary circa 1984
  • Missing Since: 06/05/1984
  • Missing From: West Willow, Pennsylvania
  • Classification: Endangered Missing
  • Sex: Female
  • Race: White
  • Date of Birth: 09/28/1958 (61)
  • Age: 25 years old
  • Height and Weight: 5'5, 125 pounds
  • Clothing/Jewelry Description: A black t-shirt, blue jeans and brown sandals.
  • Distinguishing Characteristics: Caucasian female. Blonde hair. Mary limps slightly and has to wear a lift in one shoe due to injuries sustained in a car accident.
Details of Disappearance
Mary was last seen at her home on west Willow Street in West Willow, Pennsylvania on June 5, 1984. Her estranged husband, Jere, went to pick her up to look at a car she was thinking of buying, but when he arrived Mary wasn't ready to go yet; she was still putting her makeup on. Her husband took their two-year-old son to nearby Long's Park and when they returned in the early afternoon, she was gone.

Jere said he found a note on the kitchen table from Mary, saying the car wouldn't start and she was going to walk to a local Turkey Hill Minit Market, three-quarters of a mile away. Clerks at the store, who knew her because she visited frequently, don't remember seeing her there that day, and Jere threw out the note before anyone else saw it. She has never been heard from again. None of her personal belongings disappeared with her.

Mary and Jere were in the process of a divorce in 1984 and Jere was living with his parents on Edgehill Drive, but he remained in regular contact with Mary. She disappeared the day before a custody hearing over their child. Foul play is suspected in her case, as it's uncharacteristic of her to leave without warning.

Investigating Agency
Source Information
Updated 2 times since October 12, 2004. Last updated July 20, 2020; two pictures added, details of disappearance updated.
Click to expand...
While this claims Jere lived with his mother on Edgehill Drive. This newpaper article Mary Ann Bagenstose, Missing 6 years, since June 5, 1984 - Newspapers.com
from 1990 claims that Jere was living in the house. He remarried in 1991 to Theresa Whitman. In a 2007 obituary for Jere's mother Miriam it lists Jere and Theresa as preceding her in death and they were from Willow Street. Still living in the home he shared with Mary Ann. I also agree with a previous comment that the note that Mary Ann supposedly left the Jere threw out should have easily been found in the trash. It is quite suspicious.
 
MadMcGoo said:
Mary Ann Bagenstose – The Charley Project

Mary Ann Bagenstose
mary_ann_bagenstose_1.jpg
mary_ann_bagenstose_2.jpg
bagenstose_mary3.jpg
bagenstose_mary4.jpg

Mary circa 1984
  • Missing Since: 06/05/1984
  • Missing From: West Willow, Pennsylvania
  • Classification: Endangered Missing
  • Sex: Female
  • Race: White
  • Date of Birth: 09/28/1958 (61)
  • Age: 25 years old
  • Height and Weight: 5'5, 125 pounds
  • Clothing/Jewelry Description: A black t-shirt, blue jeans and brown sandals.
  • Distinguishing Characteristics: Caucasian female. Blonde hair. Mary limps slightly and has to wear a lift in one shoe due to injuries sustained in a car accident.
Details of Disappearance
Mary was last seen at her home on west Willow Street in West Willow, Pennsylvania on June 5, 1984. Her estranged husband, Jere, went to pick her up to look at a car she was thinking of buying, but when he arrived Mary wasn't ready to go yet; she was still putting her makeup on. Her husband took their two-year-old son to nearby Long's Park and when they returned in the early afternoon, she was gone.

Jere said he found a note on the kitchen table from Mary, saying the car wouldn't start and she was going to walk to a local Turkey Hill Minit Market, three-quarters of a mile away. Clerks at the store, who knew her because she visited frequently, don't remember seeing her there that day, and Jere threw out the note before anyone else saw it. She has never been heard from again. None of her personal belongings disappeared with her.

Mary and Jere were in the process of a divorce in 1984 and Jere was living with his parents on Edgehill Drive, but he remained in regular contact with Mary. She disappeared the day before a custody hearing over their child. Foul play is suspected in her case, as it's uncharacteristic of her to leave without warning.

Investigating Agency
Source Information
Updated 2 times since October 12, 2004. Last updated July 20, 2020; two pictures added, details of disappearance updated.
Click to expand...
While this claims Jere lived with his mother on Edgehill Drive. This newpaper article Mary Ann Bagenstose, Missing 6 years, since June 5, 1984 - Newspapers.com
from 1990 claims that Jere was living in the house. He remarried in 1991 to Theresa Whitman. In a 2007 obituary for Jere's mother Miriam it lists Jere and Theresa as preceding her in death and they were from Willow Street. Still living in the home he shared with Mary Ann. I also agree with a previous comment that the note that Mary Ann supposedly left the Jere threw out should have easily been found in the trash. It is quite suspicious.
 
So she vanishes a day before a custody hearing and is last seen by her estranged ex, who is also the father of said child? And all we have to go on is his bizarre story which no one can verify? There are way too many cases like this.

Bumping for Mary. She is not forgotten <3
 
1663685011138.jpeg
1663684990316.jpeg
On Tuesday, several State Police vehicles were spotted outside the residence, located at 167 West Willow Road. A spokesperson confirmed their presence there was part of an investigation, but would provide no further details.

Bagenstose, who was 26 at the time of her disappearance, was last seen by her estranged husband, Jere Bagenstose, on the morning she disappeared, the missing persons cold case website the Charley Project said.

Jere Bagenstose told police he visited the home frequently despite their estrangement. He was living with his parents at the time of Mary Ann Bagenstose's disappearance, the Charley Project said.

On the morning of Mary Ann Bagenstose's disappearance, Jere Bagenstose said he was there to take her and the couple's 2-year-old son to look at a new car.

When he arrived, Jere Bagenstose told police, Mary Ann Bagenstose was not yet ready to leave, so he took their son to Long's Park to feed ducks.

When he returned later that day, he said, he found a note from Mary Ann Bagenstose stating she was walking to a nearby Turkey Hill store after discovering her car wouldn't start.

The Turkey Hill is located roughly a mile from the home.
Clerks at the store, who knew her because she visited frequently, don't remember seeing her there that day, and Jere Bagenstose later told police he threw out the note, which was never recovered, according to the Charley Project.

None of Mary Ann Bagenstose's personal belongings disappeared with her, and her family said it would be extremely out of character for her to leave without her son or without informing relatives, the Charley Project said.

Her mother, Geraldine Engonforo, reported her missing two days later, police said.
www.fox43.com

State Police search Willow Street home where woman went missing in 1984

Mary Ann Bagenstose was last seen at the home on West Willow Road on June 5, 1984. State Police vehicles were spotted outside the residence Tuesday morning.
www.fox43.com www.fox43.com
 
lancaster.crimewatchpa.com

NEWS POST: Charges Filed in Killing of Maryann Bagenstose in 1984

The Lancaster County District Attorney’s Office and Pennsylvania State Police have filed charges regarding the 1984 murder of 25-year-old Maryann Bagenstose in Pequea Township.Pennsylvania State Police Troopers Chadwick Roberts and Brian...
lancaster.crimewatchpa.com lancaster.crimewatchpa.com

picture of husband….
 

Husband charged with homicide in Pennsylvania cold-case of estranged wife who disappeared 38 years ago​

Investigators say handwriting analysis and other evidence led to the arrest of Jere Bagenstose, 68, of Lancaster County. Maryann Bagenstose has never been located​

www.phillyvoice.com

Husband charged with homicide in Pennsylvania cold-case of estranged wife who disappeared 38 years ago

Investigators say handwriting analysis and other evidence led to the arrest of Jere Bagenstose, 68, of Lancaster County. Maryann Bagenstose has never been located
www.phillyvoice.com www.phillyvoice.com
 
Hopefully he will give up the location of her remains. Sad that it took this long. Jail is not going to to be kind to him in his aged condition. Perhaps they will offer him a slightly nicer living condition if he gives up her location.
 
SOLVED!! COLD CASE - 1984 - MISSING 25-YEAR-OLD MARY ANN BAGENSTOSE - PEQUEA TOWNSHIP - LANCASTER COUNTY UPDATE: Estranged husband charged with killing Maryann Bagenstose nearly 40 years ago! Estranged husband charged with killing Maryann Bagenstose nearly 40 years ago [video, update] Pennsylvania State Police Troop... Source: Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers Case Status: Closed

Sourced via CRIMEWATCH®: Missing Persons

Just jumping in here, sorry for not reading the whole thread. Why is this case closed. Is her body found?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Pennysmom1
CO CO- Mary Bernadette Brubaker, 32, Boulder, 1 Dec 1996
Replies
2
Views
81
Caring1
Caring1
D
WA WA- Mary Ann Daniels, 33, disabled, found murdered @ home, Everett, 1 Feb., 1989, DNA- Joseph Andrew Jacquez, *Arrested in Nevada, 2025*
Replies
5
Views
411
dotr
D
R
CANADA Canada - Ian David MacKeigan, 20, Halifax, Nova Scotia, 22 Oct 1984
Replies
0
Views
74
renaebri
R
spartanx
SC SC - Ernest LaGrande Vereen, 72, Garden City Beach, Horry County - 10 Oct 1984
Replies
2
Views
115
Pennysmom1
Pennysmom1
M
VA The Homicide or Suicide of Mary Ford Christian, 1946
Replies
16
Views
472
merrysee
M

Members online

... and 127 more.
Total: 6,495 (members: 128, guests: 6,367)

Online statistics

Members online
128
Guests online
6,367
Total visitors
6,495
Totals may include hidden visitors.

Forum statistics

Threads
621,348
Messages
18,431,266
Members
239,572
Latest member
Beepboopsafari
Back
Top