PA PA - Philadelphia, WhtFem 40-60, UP17721, upper denture w/D Spizzirri, frontal lobotomy, May'72

[ExitNow]

https://www.dignitymemorial.com/obituaries/greenwich-ct/lucy-greene-10298533

Found Lucy

 

[Goecke]

Two things-
The find a grave page for Dorothy lead me to her father Frank's page, and his obituary. Interestingly, his two daughters (M and M) are listed as surviving him, but there's nothing about Dorothy (or Frank Jr). He died in 1968, so Dorothy would have been alive at the time if she's our Jane Doe. Sadly, if Dorothy and Frank Jr were both institutionalized, the family may have just acted like they didn't exist, which wasn't uncommon for the time period.

The other thing I was wondering was if our Jane Doe's abdominal scar could have been from a hysterectomy (or other sterilization procedure) instead of a c-section. Involuntary sterilization of disabled and/or institutionalized women was quite common at the time due to the eugenics movement.

Hysterectomy and Disability Among U.S. Women - PMC

Hysterectomies are the second most common surgery performed on women in the United States, and most are done for elective reasons. Although women with disabilities appear to have an increased risk of undergoing the procedure, little research has ...

pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

 

[ExitNow]

Marianna Spizzirri (1903-1978) - Find a Grave...

www.findagrave.com

Also, reviewing Census records of 1950, I found a family in Providence, RI. There is a person named Dora 41 y.o. no working and not able to work. She lives with Josephine, who I assume is her mother. There is a tombstone that shows she passed away 1953 and Dora passed away 1954. Hear me out... there is a brother Alfred who is shown to have died in 1952 who also does not work and can't work. Mom also does not work. Speculation, mom is the caretaker of her 2 handicapped adult children. Bedlam hospital was notorious for lobotomies. Marianna, George, and Adolph all work and are also in this home. If mom got sick or passed and could not care for them, it is not too far of a stretch that she may have been sent there and when Wyatt v. Stickney (1971) set standards for mental health, they released her. Family may not have been notified. I can't find an actual death for Alfred or Dora. The region, chain of events and age all line up. I need help rule her out as a possible match.

 

[ExitNow]

Two things-
The find a grave page for Dorothy lead me to her father Frank's page, and his obituary. Interestingly, his two daughters (M and M) are listed as surviving him, but there's nothing about Dorothy (or Frank Jr). He died in 1968, so Dorothy would have been alive at the time if she's our Jane Doe. Sadly, if Dorothy and Frank Jr were both institutionalized, the family may have just acted like they didn't exist, which wasn't uncommon for the time period.

The other thing I was wondering was if our Jane Doe's abdominal scar could have been from a hysterectomy (or other sterilization procedure) instead of a c-section. Involuntary sterilization of disabled and/or institutionalized women was quite common at the time due to the eugenics movement.

Hysterectomy and Disability Among U.S. Women - PMC

Hysterectomies are the second most common surgery performed on women in the United States, and most are done for elective reasons. Although women with disabilities appear to have an increased risk of undergoing the procedure, little research has ...

pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

I really wish we could get a death certificate because PA requires proof of passing before they will search for mental health admission. We meet the 50-year threshold for HIPAA. I would really love to see if Dorothy or Dora were patients and released from there in 1972. Also, your absolutely right about sterilization. Maybe I should submit to PA cold cases with the leads. They would be able to get access to the records. Confirmation will be difficult if they cremated original remains but its worth a try.

 

[Mfleish]

I really wish we could get a death certificate because PA requires proof of passing before they will search for mental health admission. We meet the 50-year threshold for HIPAA. I would really love to see if Dorothy or Dora were patients and released from there in 1972. Also, your absolutely right about sterilization. Maybe I should submit to PA cold cases with the leads. They would be able to get access to the records. Confirmation will be difficult if they cremated original remains but its worth a try.

I believe 1972 death certificates should be released on Ancestry this year. The death certificate is available at the state archives. I believe I have found her in the death index if anyone wants to request the death certificate.

https://www.pa.gov/content/dam/copapwp-pagov/en/phmc/documents/archives/research-online/documents/D-72_T-U-V.pdf

She is located on page 95, under Unknown Female found May 7, 1972.

 

[crcgirl]

Two things-
The find a grave page for Dorothy lead me to her father Frank's page, and his obituary. Interestingly, his two daughters (M and M) are listed as surviving him, but there's nothing about Dorothy (or Frank Jr). He died in 1968, so Dorothy would have been alive at the time if she's our Jane Doe. Sadly, if Dorothy and Frank Jr were both institutionalized, the family may have just acted like they didn't exist, which wasn't uncommon for the time period.

The other thing I was wondering was if our Jane Doe's abdominal scar could have been from a hysterectomy (or other sterilization procedure) instead of a c-section. Involuntary sterilization of disabled and/or institutionalized women was quite common at the time due to the eugenics movement.

Hysterectomy and Disability Among U.S. Women - PMC

Hysterectomies are the second most common surgery performed on women in the United States, and most are done for elective reasons. Although women with disabilities appear to have an increased risk of undergoing the procedure, little research has ...

pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

The coroner noted removal of some reproductive organs but I believe only on one side.

 

[UnlicensedPI]

The ME's office and her nephew are both aware of her likely identity. Last I heard, the ME was trying to see if any records still exist from any of the mental hospitals she stayed in that might help confirm her identification

 

[Goecke]

The coroner noted removal of some reproductive organs but I believe only on one side.

That makes me feel a lot better, if it was only one side it was probably for a legitimate medical reason.

Glad to know that the ME and Dorothy's nephew are aware of this lead. As for Dora, is there a way to confirm she actually is buried at that cemetery? That would be the easiest way to definitively rule her out. The apparent lack of a death certificate is strange, though.

 

[UnlicensedPI]

That makes me feel a lot better, if it was only one side it was probably for a legitimate medical reason.

Glad to know that the ME and Dorothy's nephew are aware of this lead. As for Dora, is there a way to confirm she actually is buried at that cemetery? That would be the easiest way to definitively rule her out. The apparent lack of a death certificate is strange, though.

Deaths- Providence, January 1-9_097 | Rhode Island State Archives Digital Archive

sosri.access.preservica.com