GUILTY South Africa - Jayde Panayiotou, 28, Port Elizabeth, 21 April 2015

  • #661
I'm not quite there yet but just wanted to add the following:

The following are all from XX of Thereza Botha.

TP wants a copy of all the notes Botha made when drawing up her report. She says it a lot but will do so.
TP says there was never any direct communication between CP & Trompie.
Botha responds that TP is missing the plot

TP asks Botha to describe Cherise Swanepoel's house.
"Theres a rd & gate".
Are you being sarcastic?
"I visited it 2yrs ago, can't recall."

The last response below has now taken 1st place as the best quote from the trial.

PD asks Botha is she is a mathematician.
"No".
Are you a psychologist?
"No. I'm not a Gynaecologist either"


When she said this, I nearly fell off my chair. I just loved this witness. She wasn’t at all uncomfortable or intimidated about testifying in court.

See you all tomorrow.
 
  • #662
Thanks for updates, :cheers::cheers:
 
  • #663
Thank you for the updates JJ andTortoise.
 
  • #664
Yes, thanks all for the updates!! :yourock:
 
  • #665
I'm still chuckling about the gynaecologist answer she gave. And telling Price yesterday he wasn't following the plot.

Not following the plot? I think he lost the plot long ago.
 
  • #666
  • #667
Court is in session. Samir September is sworn in

September works @ NMMU in admin dept. He therefore has access to student's records & was subpoenaed for certain info.

The info pertains to alleged hitman Sinethemba Nemembe (SN)

This relates to Sinethemba Nemembe. SS now explains how student info is recorded and stored

https://twitter.com/KathrynReporter
 
  • #668
A copy of Nemembe's ID is placed on screen. Attorney Peter Daubermann (PD) objects. Says it's not correct that NMMU was served a subpoena

He says subpoena was served on a certain employee & not the uni or the witness before court. SN's right to privacy was therefore breached

Prosecutor Marius Stander (MS) asks to consult with the IO before responding

The witness stands down while MS addresses court. Agrees the subpoena was addressed to a Beverly. The Uni said her superior would testify

https://twitter.com/KathrynReporter
 
  • #669
MS says many have testified even if subpoena wasn't in their name.
Judge Chetty says objection is an invasion of privacy

[The trial that keeps on giving. Something different every day]

Chetty allows September to continue

[The defence can't take a trick]

September says he verified all the info himself.
How did NMMU come into poss of ID doc?
"Attached to student's application form"

The last time SN changed anything on his student profile was on 14 Apr 2015. He did so via the online system, using his secret pin

https://twitter.com/KathrynReporter
 
  • #670
The first entry was made in 2009. SN was issued with a sick certificate on 27 July 2015.

We look at the cellphone number SN entered on 14 Apr 2015 (Just days before Jayde's murder)

MS has no further questions. There is no re-examination.

https://twitter.com/KathrynReporter

What was all that about?
 
  • #671
MS is preparing to call his last witness for the state. IO Kanna Swanepoel

[Hopefully this means that CP will follow Swanepoel]

A copy of the original SD card on which the sting video was recorded is at court. Previously a witness said the card was recorded over

https://twitter.com/KathrynReporter

Very long delay and then break for morning at approx. 11.15.
 
  • #672
  • #673
SD card used to record sting to feature in Court. Turns out it was placed in evidence bag after sting and not opened since

next witness Samier September (SS) from
@NMMU4U administration. He was asked to supply records on a certain student
This relates to Sinethemba Nemembe. SS now explains how student info is recorded and stored
Nemembe's ID is shown in court (his first name is actually Emmanuel) Daubermann objects....
Daubermann wants to see the subpoena given to NMMU he says it is directed to a particular person from student records.
Daubermann says she is the only one who should produce the records, the University was not served with papers
Daubermann brings up his clients right to privacy as witness did not have right to access info and it is therefore unlawful

Stander asks for brief adjournement to consult with Investigating Officer (IO)
Journo's are now discussing Nemembe, his name has been spelled differently throughout trial and also other indictements

Stander says witness should stand down for now. He explains papers served on individual at NMMU.
Stander says when they asked her for an affidavit, NMMU informed them that her superior will furnish them with one
MTN also sent someone else to testify. He says documents he is dealing with was made available by person served with papers
Stander not sure who is invading Nemembe's privacy. Daubermann rejects this.

Judge overrules objection.
Witness is back in court. SS says they get ID from student when they apply for studies

Stander points to a date on student records: 14 April 2015. SS says it represents last time changes were made to record
(Sick note has date 19/6/15-27/7/15) student updated his cell number via online service on 14 April '15
Stander has no further questions. He brings up two State witnesses who were never crossed by defence
Daubermann no further questions (depending on last witness) Stander says IO Kanna Swanepoel will be called as last witness

Price tells Judge he only got SDcard (with sting) yesterday and they need time. Stander asks to adjourn till 11am
Court adjourns till Monday due to some logistical issues.

https://twitter.com/alzammer


State Prosecutor Marius Stander calls his next witness, Samire September
September is employed at the NMMU as Manager at student records
September was subpoenaed for information pertaining to Sinethemba Nemembe
Daubermann objects about the nature of the subpoena, saying that the person it was served to is supposed to provide info
Stander requests a short adjournment so he can consult the investigating officer on this matter
Court back in session, Stander asks that his witness stands down for now as he discusses subpoena
Stander: when we asked her for an affidavit, NMMU informed us that her superior will furnish us with one
Stander does not agree that the info is an invasion of privacy, Daubermann disagrees
Judge Chetty over rules the objection
September is called in again
Stander goes through documentation of Nemembe
Stander goes to date listed on document, 14 April 2015 and asks the significance of date listed
September states it refers to the day that a change has been made to the students profile
Stander has no further questions, Defence has no questions. September is excused

Price brings up 2 evidence bags,one with the original dvd cut of the secret recording and the original SD card it came from

Stander says Swanepoel will be his last witness, depending on how his cross examination goes
Court is adjourned until 11:15. State and Defence need to go over things
there has been a struggle to find a device that can read the SD card with the secret recording. It is very old
Court is adjourned until 9:30 on Monday

https://twitter.com/RNEWSZA



So it's good news. Yipee! If the original SD card was not recorded over it crushes the defence's lame and pathetic argument that the recording could have been tampered with.

Sealed in an evidence bag since it was cut on DVD, and opened in court both parties present. How's that for a chain of custody.

Better get used to the samp CP!
 
  • #674
  • #675
Will we see live streaming of the defence case in Panayiotou, following the vanBreda SCA ruling I wonder.

I'm not sure I want to see Price in action to be honest, it's enough reading what's reported in the tweets.

They might say the media application needs to be in place at the start of the trial, or will it be just a case of setting up the cameras from here on in and court having to deal with any objections?
 
  • #676
[FONT=&quot]The state is expected to close its case early next week as the prosecution’s final witness in the sensational Panayiotou murder trial takes the stand.[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot]Yesterday, Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University’s Samir September confirmed in the Port Elizabeth High Court that the cellphone number which suspected hitman Sinethemba Nemembe allegedly used at the time of the murder was the same as the number he had listed on the university’s data base.

(More to read at) http://www.heraldlive.co.za/news/2017/06/24/panayiotou-state-call-final-witness/?platform=hootsuite
[/FONT]
 
  • #677
As this trial has been proceeding over a very long period, I’ve endeavoured to pull the whole story together in summary form for our benefit as well as for any newcomers.

The abduction and murder of Jayde was meant to look like a robbery, and according to the State's case, followed several earlier failed attempts. The State asserts that CP was drowning in debt, which included outstanding payments on his vehicle, R2.2 million for a Lovemore Heights property and more than R500 000 on his Stellen Glen Home. The State believes CP was forced into further debt to keep his wife Jayde and his mistress, Chanelle Coutts, happy and that is why he allegedly decided to have his wife killed.

In September 2014, CP approached Luthando (“Thando”) Siyoni and asked him to source a hitman/shooter to kill someone. At that time, the name of the person was not discussed but TS eventually came to learn that it was CP’s wife, Jayde.

in February 2015, Siyoni approached Sizwezakhe ("Sizwe") Vumazonke who agreed to kill her.

In early April, Vumazonke told Siyoni that he needed to rent a vehicle in order to execute the plan. Vumazonke rented a vehicle on 9 April but was unaware that the car was equipped with a tracker device.

On 4 April, Vumazonke approached his cousin, Sinethemba Nemembe, to assist in the abduction and murder. Three unsuccessful attempts to abduct Jayde took place before 21 April.

Jayde disappeared at 6:30am on 21 April. A massive search commenced and that evening police found an abandoned Mazda 323 believed to have been used in the abduction.

The following morning, the crew of a helicopter that was participating in the search noticed an object in an isolated area near a township in Uitenhage. Further investigation by members on the ground led to the recovery of her body in the area spotted from the helicopter.

Captain Willie Mayi was tipped off by a police informant about a businessman who had allegedly orchestrated the murder of his wife. After being given the names of Siyoni and his girlfriend, Babalwa Breakfast, Mayi took them in for questioning. He said Breakfast spilt the beans on her boyfriend, giving him enough ammunition to arrest Siyoni.

Unbeknownst to CP, Siyoni was arrested on 28 April. As soon as he was arrested, he identified CP as the mastermind and Vumazonke as the shooter and agreed to cooperate with the police. CP was arrested the following day.

Vumazonke was arrested on 3 May. At that time, he was out on parole for theft and illegal possession of a stolen firearm and ammunition. He subsequently died of suspected poisoning whilst in prison.

Cellphone and GPS data showed that on 15 April Zolani Sibeko had made an early morning call to Vumazonke which had been logged on the Linton Grange tower. Following the call, the GPS data showed the vehicle immediately accelerating and turning into Deacon Street, which is where the entrance is to the townhouse complex from where Jayde was abducted. Cellphone tower plotting placed Sibeko with alleged hitmen Vumazonke and Nemembe when they circled Jayde’s route to work. Sibeko was allegedly present again outside Jayde’s home the following day, when the planned kidnapping was aborted because the kidnappers could not trace her. Stander said he would rely on Sibeko’s cellphone billing and the tracking report of the alleged hit vehicle to prove the charges against Sibeko who is yet to put forward a version.

Stander said the State had two cellphone experts who would testify before the report compiled by data analyst Thereza Botha was submitted. He said, when looking at the cellphone records between April 1 and April 30, 2015, there were 163 calls made between Sibeko and Vandala and a further 89 calls between him and Vumazonke.

You can read Swanepoel’s sworn affidavit dated 18 May 2015 here. It's 18 pages long.
 
  • #678
I'd hate for you all to be bored so here are 3 further affidavits all relating to CP's first application for bail. They're all different and worth reading.

CP’s affidavit sworn 15 May 2015 can be found here.

Swanepoel’s affidavit in reply sworn 18 May 2015 can be found here .

CP’s affidavit sworn 20 May 2015 in reply to Swanepoel’s above affidavit can be found here.
 
  • #679
Stander has in more exhibits into court records. It is an affidavit which deals with cell records of OK Grocer and landline

Daubermann objects to this affidavit on same grounds he objected to the others. He wants to place it on record

https://twitter.com/alzammer
 
  • #680
A bit of a change in proceedings. MS first wants to call Organised Crime's WO Shane Bosch (Bosch) to the stand. He also testified in the twt

Bosch is sworn in. MS asks if deceased suspected triggerman Sizwe Vumazonke (SV) was in custody in Dec 2014. "He was arrested for robbery"

He was then released on 23 Jan 2015, after just serving a month.

Bosch was asked to ascertain who a specific landline belonged to. "I phoned the number & reached a (car rental)company"

https://twitter.com/KathrynReporter
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
80
Guests online
2,446
Total visitors
2,526

Forum statistics

Threads
632,760
Messages
18,631,375
Members
243,285
Latest member
shhhe
Back
Top