Another thing I was just thinking about....when JA called the house asking to speak to NC, if BC was guilty and busy cleaning up the evidence, why not buy himself more time and lie? He could have told her she was in the shower, taking a nap, etc. He could have simply not answered the phone. But as soon as she called him, he seemed to begin searching, calling JA back to ask for CC's #, wanting to know where she worked, etc. But JA never said "um, she was supposed to be at my house this AM".
IF there was even one reported incident of BC yelling at her, pushing her, bruises, anything like that at all, I could understand everyone "knowing" he did it and having gut feelings that he did. I just don't understand why these women were so sure of his guilt immediately. Taking them out of the picture really changes things.
I'm really beginning to believe he could be innocent and CPD didn't want to consider that. The missing person call coming from JA and not BC really put CPD down that path. I just wonder if he had made the call himself...
If he did it, I want him to pay for it, but what if he didn't do it? I can't be convinced yet.