TX TX - Cheryl Henry, 22, & Andy Atkinson, 21, Houston, 21 Aug 1990

  • #741
Detective Shorten claimed that the golf club and balls were lined up to point in the direction where Cheryl was, so she'd be found.
If that was true, then why was she covered up with boards?
Detective Shorten seems to think that the reason a knife was used was because it was personal.
I wonder if the thought crossed her mind that guns make noise, and the knife was used because it was less noisy?
 
  • #742
I think if the killer had a gun he could have subdued them from the rear of the car. Then again, it's my belief there was more than one killer.
If you go back and read post # 703 and #708 I explain why imo.
Why would he or they have even gone to the rear of the car first, though? I think all the golf shenanigans were done after their murders.
 
  • #743
Detective Shorten claimed that the golf club and balls were lined up to point in the direction where Cheryl was, so she'd be found.
If that was true, then why was she covered up with boards?
Detective Shorten seems to think that the reason a knife was used was because it was personal.
I wonder if the thought crossed her mind that guns make noise, and the knife was used because it was less noisy?
Right? Sigh. Countless killers use knives when they aren’t personally involved with their victims. EAR used a knife, Charles Ng and Leonard Lake, Dean Corll, Richard Ramirez, etc.
 
  • #744
Rocky1 said:
Do you think it could be possible that Cheryl may have been 200 yards from the car, but Andy was only 100 yards away from the car?

I read that in an article. Let me see if I can find that.... If I remember correctly - the article just said that "Cheryl was found 200 yards from the car, and Andy was 100 yards away from Cheryl.

and re the balloons - would they not have fingerprints on them? Unless of course the killer wore gloves to blow them up, plus DNA on the hole to blow them up.

Anyone seen the injuries to Andy? Was he hit twice in the head? First with a gun as Snoods mentioned & then again with the golf club after he was tied up?
 
  • #745
I didn't think you were being argumentative at all. The more thoughts discussed, the better as far as I am concerned. It's anyone's guess because we just don't know what happened.
I know, we just don’t. We have a few basic facts. I swear sometimes I feel so enmeshed with their murders that I would instantly know if I ever came face to face with the murderer.

Run that f’er down like they did with Richard Rameriz.
 
  • #746
I read that in an article. Let me see if I can find that.... If I remember correctly - the article just said that "Cheryl was found 200 yards from the car, and Andy was 100 yards away from Cheryl.

and re the balloons - would they not have fingerprints on them? Unless of course the killer wore gloves to blow them up, plus DNA on the hole to blow them up.

Anyone seen the injuries to Andy? Was he hit twice in the head? First with a gun as Snoods mentioned & then again with the golf club after he was tied up?
Apologies, my comment about Andy getting hit in the head with a gun was pure speculation. Just trying to figure out how the blood got on his headrest.

I only know of his near decapitation after tied to a tree and he suffered some type of injury while seated in his car.
 
  • #747
Man, I keep going back and forth on that. I have always been one that believes there was only one killer. Singular DNA evidence, previous MO working alone. But he certainly changed his MO from rape to a brutal double murder, right?

Sometimes I think there may have been more than one killer. I think of Channon Christian and Christopher Newsom.

I also think they both could have been controlled with a gun pointed at their heads. Knock Andy in the head with the gun, go around to Cheryl.

Plus the element of surprise when he approached them. Make them both get out of the car at the same time, then tie up Andy the threat first. Cheryl is defenseless. Even if she ran she didn’t stand a chance.
Are we sure that there's only one DNA sample?
Could there be a chance that both wore gloves and the DNA came from just the Seman?
I was on the fence too. That is, until Cheryl's mother said those tracking dogs started tracking from the car. If there was only one killer, and Andy was tied up first the dogs would have tracked past Andy before they found Cheryl. I know I am repeating myself, but I believe one took Cheryl, and the other took Andy in a different direction. IMO, Once Cheryl was found, either LE stopped tracking so the dogs never hit on Andy's scent because they didn't start over back at the car, or LE would have tried to continue tracking away from Cheryl's body to see if they could find out where/how the killer left the woods. My guess is the reason the dogs were running back and forth in that area was because that killer walked out the same way he went in, and the dogs were hitting on both scents in and out. I believe the dogs were tracking ground disturbance and not Cheryl's scent. The reason that Andy's body wasn't tracked from the location where Cheryl's body was found is because he was never near her, imo.
 
  • #748
Apologies, my comment about Andy getting hit in the head with a gun was pure speculation. Just trying to figure out how the blood got on his headrest.

I only know of his near decapitation after tied to a tree and he suffered some type of injury while seated in his car.

Yes, I realize you were just speculating on Andy getting hit by the gun - but it does make sense if only the head rest had blood on it. And you stated earlier - the gold club would be too long to actually hit Andy if he is seated in the car.

I'll have to find that article later on the yards they were found.... too much happening right now in RL! Will be back later.
 
  • #749
Why would he or they have even gone to the rear of the car first, though? I think all the golf shenanigans were done after their murders.
I don't think they went to the rear of the car first. I believe they were ambushed while the seats were reclined.
Post #703 explains my thoughts about the golf club.
I am connecting the golf club to the blood found on the head rest only because I read/heard there was blood on the club.
I think it would be easy to hit someone with a club while standing outside swinging like a lefty. Did I read the rape victim claimed he was left handed?
 
  • #750
You make a good point. Frankly they were both so close together I’ve always questioned why it took them so much longer to find Andy’s body. It wasn’t a huge wild wilderness they were searching.

I get they didn’t want to disturb evidence, but what if Andy was still alive? Why wait until morning?

If the dogs were surely tracking both Andy and Cheryl, why pass up Andy at all? Was he carried from the treetops?
 
  • #751
I don't think they went to the rear of the car first. I believe they were ambushed while the seats were reclined.
Post #703 explains my thoughts about the golf club.
I am connecting the golf club to the blood found on the head rest only because I read/heard there was blood on the club.
I think it would be easy to hit someone with a club while standing outside swinging like a lefty. Did I read the rape victim claimed he was left handed?
Yes, the rape victim says he was left handed. Invaluable information, IMO.
 
  • #752
Why would he or they have even gone to the rear of the car first, though? I think all the golf shenanigans were done after their murders.
Could be, but why would someone stick around a crime scene after murdering two people? They'd be taking a big chance that a cop could drive through there just on routine patrol.
My guess is they had to be covered in blood. I would think the golf clubs would have been too. Finger prints etc, (if he/they didn't wear gloves)
I'm going to try to find where I read the part about the golf clubs and the blood. If I remember right, it mentioned blood on the club and not that it was covered in blood.
 
  • #753
You make a good point. Frankly they were both so close together I’ve always questioned why it took them so much longer to find Andy’s body. It wasn’t a huge wild wilderness they were searching.

I get they didn’t want to disturb evidence, but what if Andy was still alive? Why wait until morning?

If the dogs were surely tracking both Andy and Cheryl, why pass up Andy at all? Was he carried from the treetops?
When cops/dogs track, the cop will walk off to the side a little from where the dog is tracking, just for that reason.... not to disturb footprints or other evidence.
 
  • #754
Bizarre crime stagings are always done after death from the cases I’ve read about. Green River killer (among a few) occasionally did bizarre staging with his deceased victims just to see the reactions from people later.

IMO I doubt he would take the time to stage a bizarre crime scene with two living, screaming victims. We know he stuck around long enough to cover Cheryl’s body in wooden planks he found after she was deceased. Conversely, why take the time to stage beforehand and then perhaps actually get caught murdering people? Either way he is taking a risk. I’m sure he felt much more comfortable after they were deceased.

There were no routine police patrols driving through there that I ever saw. Dark and desolate.
 
  • #755
Bizarre crime stagings are always done after death from the cases I’ve read about. Green River killer (among a few) occasionally did bizarre staging with his deceased victims just to see the reactions from people later.

IMO I doubt he would take the time to stage a bizarre crime scene with two living, screaming victims. We know he stuck around long enough to cover Cheryl’s body in wooden planks he found after she was deceased. Conversely, why take the time to stage beforehand and then perhaps actually get caught murdering people? Either way he is taking a risk. I’m sure he felt much more comfortable after they were deceased.

There were no routine police patrols driving through there that I ever saw. Dark and desolate.
That makes sense, but what about blood being everywhere after the murders? I would think that everything they/he touched would have been covered in blood.
I'm still looking for reference to blood on the golf club.
I've read back to where I mentioned it on page 25 in Feb of 2018. I'm back to page 18 now.
Unrelated, but seeing as we are discussing the wood she was covered in, I did read an article where it states that Cheryl was covered in cedar fence slats.

DNA may help break notorious 'Lover's Lane' murders

I may be wrong, but I'm not convinced that the crime scene was staged at all.
I certainly don't believe Shorten when she claims the golf balls and club were pointing towards Cheryl so she'd be found when her body was covered up with wood.
Where as the balloons were somewhat deflated, I think they may have been there for a while. If they were suspended in the air, hanging with string above Cheryl, they would have had to be filled with Helium rather than air from someone's lungs. If they were all hanging above Cheryl, they would have had to be tied with string or they would have blown away. Maybe not far, but they would have been somewhat scattered. I don't believe that someone would take a bunch of balloons that were not inflated, take string with them, blow them up at the crime scene, tie string to them, just to watch them drop to the ground, but I may be wrong.
I could see if Cheryl and Andy, or the killer(s) had balloons in their vehicle after attending a party that day, but where as they were somewhat deflated, who would ride around for days with balloons floating around in their car for no reason?

I do believe that the 20 dollar bill was left as a message, but could have been a message to Cheryl and not to LE.
 
  • #756
I have found a few links that I thought might be useful to have on the thread.

May 19, 2004. 'Note may hold clues'
Note may hold clues in 'lovers lane' slayings


August 28 1990. 'Ex NC man slain in Texas'
'Officials also found Atkinson's golf club with what appeared to be blood on it....150 yards away. Far enough away that they couldn't see what was happening to each other.'
Star-News - Google News Archive Search


May 19, 2008. 'DNA may help break notorious Lover's Lane murders'
DNA may help break notorious 'Lover's Lane' murders

October 10th, 2010. 'Who is my sister.?'
http://www.prestoimages.com/site/rd3/3_page12622.pdf

December 11, 2010. 'Mysterious Lover's Lane Murderer still at large'
http://www.examiner.com/article/mysterious-lover-s-lane-killer-still-at-large

December 11, 2010. Radio interview with Andy's Dad.
Crime Wire Presents Two Cold Cases
Here's the article that states the golf club had blood on it. It's way back on page 13, post # 244.

Star-News - Google News Archive Search
 
  • #757
I have posted this before but August 23rd was 17 years. 17 years ago my step-sister and her boyfriend were murdered while out on a date and the case remains unsolved. It was been called one of the most horrific crimes in Houston's history yet it remains unsolved. Both of their throats were slit and Cheryl was raped. In 2001 an anonymous letter was sent to HPD which was released in 2004 in hopes it might lead to the killers. Below is the 2004 article since it was the most in depth. I would post a copy of the note but I am not sure how to do it.

Paper: HOUSTON CHRONICLE
Date: WED 12/08/2004
Section: A
Page: 1
Edition: 3 STAR

Police hope note brings answers / Letter was sent to HPD 10 years after '90 slayings on `lovers lane'

By S.K. BARDWELL
Staff
Hoping to reinvigorate their investigation of a 14-year-old homicide case, Houston police have released a handwritten note that may have come from the architect of two of the city's most gruesome slayings.
The letter, postmarked in Houston, was received in March 2001, more than 10 years after Cheryl Henry and Andy Atkinson were stabbed to death as they parked on a secluded cul-de-sac in west Harris County.
"It's the kind of case everyone remembers," Houston police Sgt. Billy Belk said. "It sticks in your mind."
In block letters, the note's sender told investigators, "If you want to know who killed C. Henry and A. Atkinson, it will cost $100,000." The note told investigators to reply in the classifieds section of the March 12, 2001, Houston Chronicle and warned, "a lawyer will be hired to make sure u play straight."
The note was answered, according to instructions. "We do want to know what you know about Henry/Atkinson," the classified ad read. A number was given for the note-sender or a lawyer to contact investigators "with directions on playing straight."
Through the years, police had gotten calls whenever an anniversary or other publicity brings the case back to the public's attention.
The timing of the note, postmarked March 1, 2001, was odd, Belk said, in that it came so long after the slayings, and during a period when the case was getting no publicity. The most recent news story about the case, a 10-year retrospective, had been published Sept. 13, 2000.
Note suppressed
The possibilities the note offered were enticing to investigators sitting at yet another dead end in the case, and Belk said the note was never publicized.
"We kept pretty tight-lipped about it," he said, "to see if we got a response."
They never did.
Today, investigators say, it's a pretty sure bet that whoever sent the note does not intend to contact police again. Belk hopes that by releasing the contents of the note someone may recognize the handwriting, the language or some other scrap of information when it is published.
Cheryl Henry, 22, was home for the summer from classes at Stephen F. Austin State University in Nacogdoches. Andy Atkinson, whose 22nd birthday was only days away, had just moved home after finishing college in North Carolina.
The two left on a date the evening of Aug. 21, 1990, along with Henry's younger sister, Shane, and her escort. The sisters said their goodbyes when the couples left the Bayou Mama club near Westheimer and Gessner late that night.
Neither Henry nor Atkinson returned from their date; their families reported them missing early the next day. On the evening of Aug. 22, a Houston patrol officer spotted Atkinson's car parked on Enclave Round, a then-undeveloped area off the 1300 block of Enclave Parkway that young people often used as a "lovers lane."
Blood in the car appeared fresh. When a computer check of the vehicle's license plate showed it belonged to a missing person, a tracking dog was called to search the nearby heavy woods.
The dog led police to Henry's body about 200 yards away. Her clothes, found nearby, had been cut from her body, probably with the same knife used to slash her throat. Her hands were bound behind her with hemp rope. Her killer had tried to cover her body with boards from a rotting cedar fence.
A bunch of deflated balloons hung Dali-like over a tree limb near Henry's body, having no apparent connection with her death but adding to the surreal quality of the grim scene.
Darkness halted the search for Atkinson. A Houston police officer was posted to stand watch until dawn, when searchers returned and quickly discovered the second body.
Atkinson was found about 100 yards from Henry. He was fully clothed, his hands tied behind him with similar rope. He had been seated with his back against a tree trunk before his throat was slashed. He still had his money and watch.
The young couple had evidently parked to neck, Belk said. The car's front seats were reclined, the engine had been turned off but the key left in the auxiliary position so the music would stay on. Henry's shoes and bag were in the front floorboard.
Suspects cleared
In the first months, investigators chased hundreds of leads. Several potential suspects were identified.
Cheryl Henry's killer had raped her, and left behind DNA. One by one, all the suspects were cleared through DNA comparisons.
Problems within HPD's DNA lab began unfolding in 2002 and ultimately resulted in the lab's closure and the retesting of hundreds of DNA samples, but Belk is confident in the work done on the DNA left by Henry's killer.
That DNA was profiled at the DNA lab founded at Baylor College of Medicine by renowned researcher Dr. C. Thomas Caskey, Belk said. The sample was entered into the state's Combined DNA Indexing System, but a link was never made to any other crime.
The sample from Henry's killer was later sent by HPD to the Texas Department of Public Safety for comparison with DNA from Angel Maturino Resendiz, a convicted rail-riding serial killer. That didn't provide a match either, Belk said.
Last month, Belk and members of Henry's family met with Houston Police Chief Harold Hurtt, who approved the independent retesting of all the DNA samples taken from possible suspects and eliminated through tests done at HPD's lab, Belk said.
He said the case has never gone completely cold.
"We've gotten at least one new lead every year," Belk said, "and I follow up on every one of them."
Noting that most investigators have at least one case they can't let go of, Belk said, "This is mine."
If the case has haunted Belk, it has tortured Barbara Craig, Henry's mother.
"I was always so proud of Cheryl," Craig said recently. "She was the older sister to five other kids. ... The youngest, the twins, were just starting fifth grade that year. Their first day of school was spent at their sister's funeral."
Her daughter's death devastated the family, Craig said. The details made it almost too painful to bear.
"To be killed is horrible," Craig said, "But to be terrorized, tied up, raped ... To think her last moments were of terror, and I wasn't there. Because mothers, you know, that's their job, to make it better."
Several scenarios
Craig said finding the person who killed her daughter and Atkinson is important to the family, although "we try not to base our happiness on whether or not the person is caught."
Atkinson's father could not be reached for comment.
Belk acknowledges the note could be a hoax, but he said it is difficult to see what reward there could be in such a deception. The other possibilities are that the note is from the killer, or from someone who could identify the killer.
The latter would probably be the best news for Belk. In a study published in the Journal of Criminal Justice and Popular Culture in 2002, Seattle University journalism professor Tomas Guillen looked at a half-dozen killers who contacted police or the media before their capture, and concluded that while the killers' missives often helped police link previously unlinked crimes, or proved pivotal in helping convict the offenders once they were caught, they rarely helped identify a killer.
"Although these killers injected themselves into cases, sometimes repeatedly for years, with poems, letters, and telephone calls to investigators or the news media, the communiques did not lead to enough investigative evidence or clues to put an immediate end to a series of slayings," Guillen wrote.
All Belk wants is some foothold he can use to push the case closer to its resolution.
Anyone with information in the case can call Belk at 713-308-3600, or Crime Stoppers at 713-222-TIPS.
...
Houston homicide investigators want to know who wrote them an anonymous letter regarding the 1990 slayings of Cheryl Henry and Andy Atkinson. Their bodies were found near a secluded cul-de-sac in west Harris County. Police got the letter three years ago and are releasing it now in hope that someone with information will come forward.
The letter demanded $100,000 in exchange for the killer’s identity and asked police to respond through the Houston Chronicle’s ``personal column.’’
The letter writer warned that a lawyer would be hired ``to make sure u play straight.’’
This is way back on page 4 post #77.
Snipped by me:

The dog led police to Henry's body about 200 yards away. Her clothes, found nearby, had been cut from her body, probably with the same knife used to slash her throat. Her hands were bound behind her with hemp rope. Her killer had tried to cover her body with boards from a rotting cedar fence.
A bunch of deflated balloons hung Dali-like over a tree limb near Henry's body, having no apparent connection with her death but adding to the surreal quality of the grim scene.

It appears that the cedar fencing was rotting. IMO. I doubt the killer(s) took it from the development, but rather it was in the woods before the murder.
In regards to the balloons. It appears they had no connection with the murders.
 
  • #758
This is from the same link posted above.
According to Sargent John Silva from the HPD, "Atkinsons body was found about 150 yards away.... far enough so they couldn't see what was happening to each other."

Star-News - Google News Archive Search
 
  • #759
Was the $20 dollar bill left as a meassage to Cheryl, here is payment for sex - basically calling her a call girl? Does that mean that she knew the killer and she had spurned his advances? Often times, men that are turned down when a girl likes someone else - they call the girl a “who**”
 
  • #760
Was the $20 dollar bill left as a meassage to Cheryl, here is payment for sex - basically calling her a call girl? Does that mean that she knew the killer and she had spurned his advances? Often times, men that are turned down when a girl likes someone else - they call the girl a “who**”

Good post. That is along the lines of what I was thinking. Of course this would only be in a sick killers twisted mind. Of course I do not know for sure but I do not think the two youngsters would have known there killer. To me he was just looking for people to kill and getting his kicks out of committing the crime and it was his own sick 'joke' that was his amusement.
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
131
Guests online
18,111
Total visitors
18,242

Forum statistics

Threads
633,308
Messages
18,639,453
Members
243,478
Latest member
deweywinchester
Back
Top