This case is the case that brought me to WS and has fascinated me ever since. I am in awe of all the research and thought that people have put into this and do not claim to have put anywhere near the effort that they have. I've read with interest the discussion of church as target vs. Missy as target and there's a lot of really interesting thought-provoking information and opinions that I hadn't thought about.
Here's where I get stuck when I consider 'church as target': the tactical gear. Please accept my apologies if this has already been hashed out in a prior thread - I've read many of them but not all of them. Standard disclaimer: as usual, MOO.
1. This is a heavy duty disguise for just a burglary. As many have said, there are easier and less cumbersome disguises. Doesn't mean it's not possible that someone really put a lot of thought into a foolproof disguise but it just seems like overkill, especially considering that most burglars are looking for the quick in and out. This disguise appears to me to have the primary focus of covering and distorting almost every aspect of SP's body which seems to be a bit much for a burglary that, if it were real, wouldn't've netted a lot of money/stuff. I mean, I could see it for, say, an armed robbery of a high-end jewelry store - with the added benefit of confusion as to "Why the *bleep* are the cops robbing me?" This leads to my second thought...
2. Tactical gear is not only for protection and disguise. It is, at least in part, for intimidation and fear. Think of seeing an armed line of riot-gear clad police, or seeing a fully geared up SWAT team deploying. For most people, that is scary AF, and that's intentional - get people scared so that they leave/surrender/whatever before any actual action happens. (source = me: I'm a police & fire dispatcher)
The forensic podiatrist mentioned seeing the video of Missy turning her head as if she heard a noise, and someone on Reddit said something like "Can you imagine looking up/around/whatever and seeing that?" (meaning a person in tactical gear) and that really struck me.
If you were out for revenge, and have decided to kill someone, perhaps you might want to make the last minutes of their life absolutely terrifying. If Missy has wronged you in some way, and you are filled with rage (but the cool calculating kind), and you have decided that therefore you must murder Missy, not only do you not want to be identified, but you also decide that her last moments should be filled with complete and utter terror as part of your payback. You don't need her to know who you are, but to know that she is going to die at your hand and there is no escape.
Seeing someone who looks like a police officer about to shoot you? For me, that would be bowel-releasing fear. I'm making myself twitch just trying to imagine it. Or even if you don't see any police logo or identifying information, a person dressed in all black tactical gear? Is this a terrorist? Who is this and why do they have a gun pointed at you and.....? Even scarier if they don't identify themselves as police and don't say anything at all - just loom up in a space where you don't expect anyone else to be, dressed in black, unrecognizable, with a gun pointed at you?
After 18 years at my job, I've seen and heard things I never could have imagined so of course my twisted little brain went to this dark place. It also went to the place of maybe she was still alive after she was shot & that's where the blunt force trauma came into play - wound your enemy & look them in the eye as you bludgeon/stab/whatever them. Okay, I'm going to go watch some happy kitten videos now...
(edited to fix spelling)
I've thought of this many times. Still, when you think about it, any crime where the perp fully conceals themselves is no better or worse than this effort at disguise. The problem is the NATURE of the selection.
John Wayne Gacy actually wore his clown costume while murdering some of his victims. The exterior was the exact opposite of what was going on in the interior. It was an even greater tool of concealment than his costume alone, a kind of "flies to honey" bend on his approach to victims. He told LE, "After all, everybody LOVES clowns." Gacy used the symbol of something
good to do something
bad.
SP has done something similar. SP isn't a SWAT officer. His message isn't SWAT, its POLICE. He's a tactical police officer operating on his own without the company or benefit of a team. No team for SP. He alone is in charge. Here again, he's using the symbol of something
good (law and order) to do something
bad (B&E/burglary). Tactical police are generally thought of as being assigned to bring order out of chaos. The situation is out of control, but not so out of control that it requires SWAT. An officer might even have this equipment in his cruiser's trunk. In a heightened alert situation and acting in concert with his fellow officers, he adds further protection to his standard police uniform. Wearing the uniform sends a message to Joe Civilian, something has gone terribly wrong, there's an environment of heightened danger in the area and
I'm here to manage it. Authority. Obey me. Subjugate yourself to
MY authority. And Joe Civilian does just that. He follows orders.
That's all well and good, but in this case
SP is what's gone wrong with the environment - its just that Joe Civilian (MB) doesn't suspect that. She's more likely thinking, "What the hell is going on? Why is this cop here?" SP has calculated to have her trust him just enough to buy a little time for himself. The decision he makes in those few moments leaves Missy alive or dead, because she's in mental freefall. SP can continue the ruse, stuff her in a closet for "her own protection" and run away - or he can shoot her. He chooses the latter. In a legal sense, premeditation can begin days, months, years before a murder - or it can occur during those decisive seconds when a better choice, the choice to leave Missy alive, was not made.
SP was a
bad guy disguised as a
good guy and Missy bought it long enough for him to make the decision to execute her. Obviously, SP came
prepared to kill someone, perhaps not
for the purpose of killing someone. We can guess what lives inside SP's head, but we can be sure
SP is no good guy. I've said it before, SP brought a gun to a food fight.
Many psychopaths have used similar ruses to mollify the possible terror their presence presented during the moments when their victims were indecisive about the situation in which they found themselves. Bundy, Kemper, Gacy, Ridgeway, Dahmer, etc. all presented themselves as trustworthy. The deadly, effective psychology of conscienceless killers.