VA - Johnny Depp's defamation case against ex Amber Heard, who countersued #8

[gloomy]

I use to collect it and I’ve not seen any phones.

I think it's possible there was a phone. But in the UK trial she said it was an old fashioned mint green and cream phone. Imo a mint green phone does not go with the décor in that house. It just sounds like a straight up lie. Also I just googled the mansion and it was built in 1985 so maybe they kept a mint green phone even if the décor was updated? I don't know if I believe that. MOO

Edit - I mentioned all the above because why didn't she say it was a mint green phone during this trial? Maybe because it's a lie.

 

[wasnt_me]

For some reason I was thinking the mystery phone was over by the higher bar with the stools

Probably because you know it would have to be on a wall accessible by his right hand if he was choking her on the bar with his left.

 

[Ray_of_hope]

DH watched the end of the blonde man testifying and screamed like he was watching a football game: "Yeah! He clipped her (EB's) wings." He was watching EB ask him if he wanted 15 minutes of fame on television and he had a great comeback stating that he was being logical after he turned EB's statement around to HER wanting this case for HER 15 minutes...

 

[neesaki]

If the jurors even care about this, I hope they look at them and easily figure it out like others did.

ETA -- but wait. Aren't they incoming to Stephen Deuter's phone?

What difference does it make if they are in 2017 after the divorce?

Didn’t Rottenborg say the ones from JD were identified as “him” ?

 

[makayla]

Regarding the emails that were supposedly sent by JD and mentioned in cross today, I think there will be a lot of discussion tonight on YouTube from some of the lawyers who go live at night … it certainly deserves scrutiny for authenticity, so hopefully someone with expertise in that area can resolve this issue.

 

[Ray_of_hope]

publishing next demonstrative.

Photo of alleged bruise beneath eye - he is teaching us how to read the metadata about what was altered on the photo. editing program or app was used on it.

Side view of same alleged bruise - an editing application was used.

Did you see AH scribbling furiously while he was testifying? She thought it was a class, lol.

 

[MimosaMornings]

I think it's possible there was a phone. But in the UK trial she said it was an old fashioned mint green and cream phone. Imo a mint green phone does not go with the décor in that house. It just sounds like a straight up lie. Also I just googled the mansion and it was built in 1985 so maybe they kept a mint green phone even if the décor was updated? I don't know if I believe that. MOO

A mint green/cream Bakelite phone that hangs on a wall? With a rotary dial?

 

[neesaki]

I just know that after watching the AH attorneys, and some of their “experts”… especially Dr. Spiegal, I don’t have faith in them to be fully ethical.

 

[Observe_dont_Absorb]

I am a bit out of kilter as just catching up on the court recordings from earlier today.

Something has stood out - when JD is giving his testimony about AH fighting with her sister Witney (or attacking her?), I noticed that EB is sitting giving a staring shaming face and vigourously shaking her head.

I feel this is grossly inappropriate behaviour for a legal person to conduct themselves in such a manner in court and also appears to be intimidation. Is this normal in courts? I think it's terrifying and wrong.

 

[gloomy]

A mint green/cream Bakelite phone that hangs on a wall? With a rotary dial?

AH did not mention the detail of the phone, just that it was old fashioned and mint green.

It's on page 26.
pdf of her UK testimony

 

[Warwick7]

because they are LOL

Facts suck when a lie is faced with them. They are working overtime to try to a) keep testimony about the color edits out and b) discredit the expert by not allowing him to complete an answer.

Bam!

 

[MimosaMornings]

Did you see AH scribbling furiously while he was testifying? She thought it was a class, lol.

Scribbling....perhaps....
“Out, damned spot!”
JMO

 

[wasnt_me]

Didn’t Rottenborg say the ones from JD were identified as “him” ?

I thought they said it was SD's phone, but I think I'm mistaken. I think it was JD's phone these came from. So, if it's incoming, it should have been FROM SD. Sorry. I was confused, I think, which means the lawyer was wrong and JD was right.

 

[PatLaurel]

She said the phone was on the wall opposite the clock. That it was out of view when Ben took pictures of the damage.

This is where she alleges the mounted antique phone was:
View attachment 345980

And she said the phone was mounted next to the fridge. There's no fridge on that side of the bar, just a wall.
She also stated JD was on the lower level, where there is a kitchen, a bar and a ping pong table. The kitchen is not on the same floor as the bar.

MOO JMO

 

[whitelilac]

I personally think that EB is going to be very relieved when this is over, and will never want to cross paths with AH again.
I think she has been blindsided on occasion by the exposed lies, and the dishonesty of her client.

 

[wasnt_me]

AH did not mention the detail of the phone, just that it was old fashioned and mint green.

It's on page 26.
pdf of her UK testimony

In her statement, she did not say it. In the trial, she did say details of the phone.

" Yes, I believe so. After that moment, or after those moments,
20 he was so angry he punched the wall a few times. He was
21 screaming at me and he had me by the neck. I moved away when
22 he started hitting the hall. He was punching the wall. He
23 got carried away in that moment. He saw the phone, the
24 receiver of the phone. It was a like a mint green and cream
25 Bakelite sort of heavy plastic mounted phone on the wall"

https://www.nickwallis.com/_files/ugd/5df505_41e9f60e9fcc4598918326ea6069ecd6.pdf

Page 11 of the PDF

 

[wasnt_me]

And she said the phone was mounted next to the fridge. There's no fridge on that side of the bar, just a wall.
She also stated JD was on the lower level, where there is a kitchen, a bar and a ping pong table. The kitchen is not on the same floor as the bar.

MOO JMO

Oh, now the thing was in the kitchen? Really?

ETA, that's right. I went back to the UK testimony, and she does say that it was in the kitchen when she was choking her.

In her deposition for the USA trial, she does say kitchen

https://www.fairfaxcounty.gov/circuit/sites/circuit/files/assets/documents/pdf/high-profile/depp%20v%20heard/cl-2019-2911-foreign-subp-prep-raquel-pennington-8-22-2019.pdf

page 22.

Did she say on the stand then that this was at the bar? When does she move it to the bar?

 

[JujuColumbo]

It’s been an astounding day for team JD!!! Didn’t watch any so I have a question, did the guy from TMZ basically admit that the video and tips came from team AH?

 

[Breathe]

At the end of today, the Judge said that after the witnesses tomorrow, AH's team will address the counterclaim. Is AH's team calling more witnesses? I thought they rested their case. Help please. TIA

 

[ZoriahNZ]

Oh, now the thing was in the kitchen? Really?

ETA, that's right. I went back to the UK testimony, and she does say that it was in the kitchen when she was choking her. Now, in the USA trial, it was the bar? Why didn't this come up in the trial?

Here's a picture of the kitchen. She's still lying, in my opinion. There was no mounted phone.



The Gold Coast mansion where Johnny Depp's finger was severed is for sale