This case is so troubling!
Here's what I can't get past:
1) If MY Dad bought tickets for ME and MY NINE friends to a SOLD OUT, much anticipated concert ... and I drove MY car... the odds of me leaving the concert and my car behind are ZIP - NADA.
2) The only one who could possibly know what Morgan said on that phone call would be one of the friends who stayed inside the concert.
3) No one can even be certain that Morgan actually made that call. The call came from that phone but we don't know that Morgan dialed that number.
4)Morgan was seen outside crying.
5)If Morgan had her phone, her mom and dad said it was very surprising that she would not have called them for a ride...
6) Why would she have called them for a ride when she had her own car?
Now the easy questions:
When I was 20, would I have worried about my safety on a cold, dark October evening in a large city I did not live in? Yes.
If I had my own car, would I have just gotten in it and locked the door? Yes.
Would I have left my purse and phone anywhere willingly? NO.
Would I have handed the keys of my own vehicle over to a gf when I had my purse with me? NO.
Do women that age ever get catty and turn on one another? Yes.
If I went to a concert with a friend that was locked outside, would I have assumed she would have just met up with someone none of us had ever heard of and hitched a ride in a different car when HER CAR WAS THERE and would I just GET IN HER CAR and LEAVE not knowing where she was? NOT IN A MILLION YEARS.
Something doesn't smell right.
Thanks for the post and nice list. I appreciated your input.
It's established that MH didn't drive from Harrisonburg, though it was her car. Many have speculated designated driver. Some have said if they themselves are the DD for their friends they keep the keys. Maybe not so unusual. It's been stated MH did not have her keys, though she did have her purse outside the arena.
Could they have given her keys to her to wait it out? Lots of people are speculating about that and blaming friends for not. Doesn't matter, really, imho. She didn't have them for whatever reason.
As for purse and phone left
willingly, only two scenarios come to mind - leaving a clue to signal abduction or leaving no clue to facilitate running away. I don't know MH, but my read of the consensus is that she didn't simply up and go, if she was of her right mind. Amnesia, though, or some reduced mental acuity from the blow to her head (minor as the scratch/cut may have seemed), ingesting substances (planned or unplanned), or simply having low blood sugar or being severely dehydrated or hypothermic takes all rational thinking and throws it out, even to the point of literally hitchhiking, I fear.
Small point, but the show wasn't sold out, and we don't know if friends reimbursed MH or DH for the tickets or exactly how many of the nine were used (and what happened to the ones that weren't).
Parents probably said she could have called for a ride when they still believed the friends' initial story (I'm presuming) that they left MH's car in Harrisonburg.
What is the source of MH being seen crying outside the arena? I've not seen that. TIA.