I didn't say your logic was childlike. It seems more like trying to work around the rules with a wink and a nod. Everyone on this thread knows who the person is, and his initials were confirmed by a poster here who appears to be close to the situation (well, closer than most of us anyway). I simply pointed out what has been stated repeatedly by mods (and tricia) regarding "sleuthing" of persons not named POI or suspects; I've never read it to mean we can "sleuth" anyone we wish until they're cleared by the police. That makes no sense, as there are thousands in that area who haven't been cleared and never will be. If those rules don't apply here, then ok. It would certainly make it easier for most of us here if they were applied consistently.