For anyone curious about a big picture of the SLAYER RULE in the various US states, here ya go.
In starting to search for WI.'s statutory version of the slayer rule, I got sidetracked w this law review article, w the abstract below:
"The Slayer Rule: An Empirical Examination."
"Abstract
"Elmer Palmer murdered his grandfather. The undisputed motive was money. Thegrandfather’s will included a large gift to Elmer, which the grandfather was poised to eliminate. Elmer acted first. Under the law at the time, Elmer would inherit despite having intentionally killed his grandfather: the existing will controlled. Unfortunately for Elmer, the New York Courtof Appeals announced a new equitable principle: Murderers cannot inherit from their victims.Since this famous decision in 1889, some version of the “slayer rule” has been adopted by nearly every state and lauded by nearly every commentator. Still, important questions about the properscope of the slayer rule remain unanswered. Case law and scholarship identify multiple rationales for the slayer rule, which push in different directions in difficult applications.This study is the first to empirically test key assumptions underlying the slayer rule. Over*a thousand survey respondents answered the question “What’s fair?” or “What would the decedent want?” in twelve different scenarios. Some of the most significant conclusions are that the slayer rule should not apply to assisted suicide, killings in self-defense, or killings due to mental illness. On the other hand, the slayer rule should be expanded beyond murder in some circumstances, suchas elder abuse and neglect. And the slayer rule should be converted from a mandatory rule into a default rule, which testators could opt out of in their wills. Carefully probing what people think about the slayer rule illuminates its many aspects and points toward needed reforms."
(Article is 43 pages long, so I doubt ^ 1 page quote would violate the 10% copyright ToS here)
BTW, I thought Websleuths had threads on Elmer Palmer's murder of his grandfather mentioned in the abstract, but I did not find them.
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
