I thought I was getting a car when I turned 16...thought the little box had the keys in it. It was a matchbox kind of car. I was disappointed, but it wasn't in cruelty, and after the initial eye rolling and "oh come on!" Both brothers really yukked it up, because I should have known that we couldn't afford an extra car for me, but I knew how much time my dad had spent looking for that particular car model - and if he could have he would have given me the real thing.
You know what I don't like is when kids aren't grateful for what they get. I think it was meant funny, not hurtful, but that was the end result. Guess what? We have disappointments in life, sometimes our family disappoints us. He received a gift that was specifically for him, wrapped in something he wishes he could have. All of us have said something we thought was funny, and it fell flat.
There's obviously several people in the family and they are spending the day together and enjoying one another's company. We're seeing 30 seconds of that whole day and making extreme character judgments. He looks healthy, he'll be fine. I don't see cruelty, I see poor judgment.