JG has denied the D’s request for funding of an expert. That is blatantly unfair and makes for an uneven playing field. The P can have experts at the public’s expense, but the D cannot. Of course there’s no element of bias involved (rolling my eyes). But there’s hope! The Give2 fund that was only just set up is over $6,500 already. The goal is $25,000 and it still has over a month to go!
Abby & Libby - The Delphi Murders - Richard Allen Arrested - #178
- Thread starter Tricia
- Start date
- Status
steeltowngirl
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Mar 2, 2014
- Messages
- 6,521
- Reaction score
- 91,841
Unclear (to me) how they were denied, since there is a standard process. Seems they want additional funding?
Recent filings in Richard Allen murder trial related to evidence, funding for defense
CARROLL COUNTY, Ind. — Before Monday’s Delphi hearing surrounding contempt of court claims were expected to begin at a Fort Wayne court, a series of motions were filed on Sunday by both…
fox59.com
Allen’s defense team is requesting that the court “provide parity” in the investigation and presentation in the upcoming trial to “balance the scales of justice.” This includes the exclusion of certain pieces of evidence since the defense claims they have not had the funds to properly investigate them.
The team is requesting that the defense team be approved for necessary expected expenses for the team to defend Allen within the trial. The team is asking for the state’s prosecutors to pay “out of their personal finances” for investigative services, evidence processing and expert fees.
The defense claims that they have not received any help in funding to obtaining expert assistance to investigate three pieces of evidence within the trial: the bullet found at the crime scene, the digital data collected by law enforcement and Allen’s alleged confession.
“This court should reconsider the denial of funds for defense investigative and expert expenses,” the documents said. “…Alternatively, the court should exclude at trial any testimony or evidence related to the bullet, the digital data, Allen’s purported confession and the cause, manner and timing of death.
“Finally, if denial of the defense’s requests remains, and the state is allowed to proffer testimony on the critical evidence discussed above, the only truly equitable relief would be to order the Carroll County Prosecutor to pay for any expert and investigative services, from this point forward, out of his own personal finances.”
Unclear (to me) how they were denied, since there is a standard process. Seems they want additional funding?
Recent filings in Richard Allen murder trial related to evidence, funding for defense
CARROLL COUNTY, Ind. — Before Monday’s Delphi hearing surrounding contempt of court claims were expected to begin at a Fort Wayne court, a series of motions were filed on Sunday by both…
Allen’s defense team is requesting that the court “provide parity” in the investigation and presentation in the upcoming trial to “balance the scales of justice.” This includes the exclusion of certain pieces of evidence since the defense claims they have not had the funds to properly investigate them.
The team is requesting that the defense team be approved for necessary expected expenses for the team to defend Allen within the trial. The team is asking for the state’s prosecutors to pay “out of their personal finances” for investigative services, evidence processing and expert fees.
The defense claims that they have not received any help in funding to obtaining expert assistance to investigate three pieces of evidence within the trial: the bullet found at the crime scene, the digital data collected by law enforcement and Allen’s alleged confession.
“This court should reconsider the denial of funds for defense investigative and expert expenses,” the documents said. “…Alternatively, the court should exclude at trial any testimony or evidence related to the bullet, the digital data, Allen’s purported confession and the cause, manner and timing of death.
“Finally, if denial of the defense’s requests remains, and the state is allowed to proffer testimony on the critical evidence discussed above, the only truly equitable relief would be to order the Carroll County Prosecutor to pay for any expert and investigative services, from this point forward, out of his own personal finances.”
<modsnip>they really are that pathetic at their job that they are using “lack of funds” for their incompetence. Should they not of checked they could defend RA to the best of their abilities before taking him on as a client?!
How convenient so they should exclude evidence if they can’t afford to investigate it.
It’s absolutely farcical that these are legitimate lawyers.
Last edited by a moderator:
That's was my idea too, they want an "additional funding". But I don't know how it works and how they were denied so I'm not sure. If the judge really had denied any funds for experts for the defense, the defense is right.Unclear (to me) how they were denied, since there is a standard process. Seems they want additional funding?
Recent filings in Richard Allen murder trial related to evidence, funding for defense
CARROLL COUNTY, Ind. — Before Monday’s Delphi hearing surrounding contempt of court claims were expected to begin at a Fort Wayne court, a series of motions were filed on Sunday by both…
Allen’s defense team is requesting that the court “provide parity” in the investigation and presentation in the upcoming trial to “balance the scales of justice.” This includes the exclusion of certain pieces of evidence since the defense claims they have not had the funds to properly investigate them.
The team is requesting that the defense team be approved for necessary expected expenses for the team to defend Allen within the trial. The team is asking for the state’s prosecutors to pay “out of their personal finances” for investigative services, evidence processing and expert fees.
The defense claims that they have not received any help in funding to obtaining expert assistance to investigate three pieces of evidence within the trial: the bullet found at the crime scene, the digital data collected by law enforcement and Allen’s alleged confession.
“This court should reconsider the denial of funds for defense investigative and expert expenses,” the documents said. “…Alternatively, the court should exclude at trial any testimony or evidence related to the bullet, the digital data, Allen’s purported confession and the cause, manner and timing of death.
“Finally, if denial of the defense’s requests remains, and the state is allowed to proffer testimony on the critical evidence discussed above, the only truly equitable relief would be to order the Carroll County Prosecutor to pay for any expert and investigative services, from this point forward, out of his own personal finances.”
Emma Peel
an unexpected turn of events
- Joined
- Aug 26, 2008
- Messages
- 11,174
- Reaction score
- 8,934
As previously discussed such argument misapprehends the proceedings.
The Contempt case is NOT State v RA.
Last edited:
FrostedGlass
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Feb 25, 2017
- Messages
- 5,690
- Reaction score
- 27,339
This filing spells it out in detail for you:
Filed: 3/17/2024 12:46 PM
Carroll Circuit Court
Carroll County, Indiana
MOTION FOR PARITY IN RESOURCES, TO RECONSIDER THE DENIAL OF ANTICIPATED DEFENSE COSTS, OR TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE
AppleTreeGreen
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Jan 26, 2023
- Messages
- 147
- Reaction score
- 1,421
True, I read the State’s response, and the COs could very well be telling the truth.
Delphi murders defendant Richard Allen living in 8x12 prison cell under suicide watch and 24-hour video surveillance
The Westville prison warden provided very specific details about the cell where Allen is living and the accommodations he is offered.www.wthr.com
here are some excerpts :
- Allen is living in the prison’s A-pod, which is a segregated maximum security unit with additional security within the prison. The unit houses felons who have been convicted of serious crimes such as murder and child molestation.
- Allen’s cell is equipped with a surveillance camera that records his activities 24 hours a day.
- The warden assigned Allen to a segregated (individual) cell because the high-profile nature of Allen’s crime involving children places him at a higher risk of retaliation and violence from other inmates. Galipeau said he would be concerned about Allen's safety if he were to place him in the general population of Westville Correctional Facility.
Allen is permitted to shower three times per week, and he is allowed one hour of recreation time outside his cell five times per week.- The defendant is provided three sets of clothing each week. He also has access to the prison commissary and has purchased socks, shoes and shirts, according to the warden.
Each inmate, including Allen, is provided an electronic tablet that allows him to listen to music, watch movies and make phone calls. Those calls can be accessed and monitored by a prison investigator.- Unlike other inmates in the maximum security unit, Allen is permitted to have face-to-face visits with his family.
- When Allen is being transported from his cell to other locations within the prison, he is placed in chains/cuffs around his hands, feet and torso, and is sometimes transported with a restraint chain, which his defense team described as a leash similar to those used to walk a dog.
- Allen has been on “suicide watch” since last fall. The warden testified that Allen’s mental health seemed to decline a few months after he arrived when the defendant “received his legal paperwork.”
- He acknowledged Allen has lost considerable weight since arriving at Westville, but Galipeau said the defendant’s vital signs have remained within a “normal range” and he receives almost daily checkups by the prison’s medical and mental health staff.
According to the ACLU, IDOCwatch.org, IndyStar and Itsgoingdown.org, there are also testimonies, lawsuits and cases centered around former and present inmates who have also alleged to have suffered abuse and neglect at Wabash and Westville prisons that have been denied or rejected, including through legal/court-mandated paperwork in response by the administration and officers at these prisons.
I am not picking a side but I thought it was important to note that.
Torment in Indiana prisons: The abuse, the lawsuit, the death of Phillip Littler
This horror story is unique to Phillip Littler – but not. Kevin ‘Rashid Johnson has told the story again and again, and as a revered artist, he lays bare these atrocities in drawings, exquisite in the pain they reveal, imploring us to listen, feel and act to abolish the existing evil culture...
sfbayview.com
Jailers 'brutalized' a dying man in an Indiana jail. A prosecutor says it wasn't a crime.
An Indiana prosecutor did not pursue criminal charges, but experts who reviewed a jail video say they observed sadistic and criminal behavior.
www.indystar.com
Horrifying Conditions of Confinement at Westville CF — IDOC Watch
Please listen to the interview below with two people currently incarcerated at Westville CF, in which they describe the horrifying conditions of confinement that they and everyone else incarcerated there are being subjected to. One of the main issues they discuss is the water contamination, which is
www.idocwatch.org
He warned Indiana prison officials he would kill a cellmate. And then he did.
Prison mental health care carries its own challenges
www.southbendtribune.com
Support Wabash Valley Prisoners on Hunger Strike!
Several inmates at Wabash Valley Correctional Facility have announced that they have begun a hunger strike to protest their deteriorating conditions. Their immediate demands include: removal from camera monitored cells, relocation from abusive staff, and the cessation of tampering with food and...
itsgoingdown.org
Last edited:
Emma Peel
an unexpected turn of events
- Joined
- Aug 26, 2008
- Messages
- 11,174
- Reaction score
- 8,934
IMO, it's become clear that Judge Gull has handpicked an experienced and strategic public defense team for RA's case. It's very interesting to watch their defense strategy unfold. IMO, at the moment I see only 2 Defense theories; one of them, if successful, would result in a dismissal. JMHO
Last edited:
True, I read the State’s response, and the COs could very well be telling the truth.
According to the ACLU, IDOCwatch.org, IndyStar and Itsgoingdown.org, there are also testimonies, lawsuits and cases centered around former and present inmates who have also alleged to have suffered abuse and neglect at Wabash and Westville prisons that have been denied or rejected, including through legal/court-mandated paperwork in response by the administration and officers at these prisons.
I am not picking a side but I thought it was important to note that.
Torment in Indiana prisons: The abuse, the lawsuit, the death of Phillip Littler
This horror story is unique to Phillip Littler – but not. Kevin ‘Rashid Johnson has told the story again and again, and as a revered artist, he lays bare these atrocities in drawings, exquisite in the pain they reveal, imploring us to listen, feel and act to abolish the existing evil culture...
Jailers 'brutalized' a dying man in an Indiana jail. A prosecutor says it wasn't a crime.
An Indiana prosecutor did not pursue criminal charges, but experts who reviewed a jail video say they observed sadistic and criminal behavior.www.indystar.com
Horrifying Conditions of Confinement at Westville CF — IDOC Watch
Please listen to the interview below with two people currently incarcerated at Westville CF, in which they describe the horrifying conditions of confinement that they and everyone else incarcerated there are being subjected to. One of the main issues they discuss is the water contamination, which is
He warned Indiana prison officials he would kill a cellmate. And then he did.
Prison mental health care carries its own challengeswww.southbendtribune.com
Support Wabash Valley Prisoners on Hunger Strike!
Several inmates at Wabash Valley Correctional Facility have announced that they have begun a hunger strike to protest their deteriorating conditions. Their immediate demands include: removal from camera monitored cells, relocation from abusive staff, and the cessation of tampering with food and...
So RA is not singled out these are conditions alleged in the facilities and not exclusive to RA.
Sounds more like RA is the CO's pet coddled to make sure he goes fit to trial.
Thank you for getting that fact forward by providing the links.
The Defenses exaggerations and cherry picking makes their client even less sympathetic and believable which considering he is detained as the suspect of murdering two young innocents out for a walk on a pleasant day would be hard to do with less “talented” representation.
all imo
Cyber sleuth
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Aug 13, 2015
- Messages
- 920
- Reaction score
- 7,299
Per this filing it looks like the court has paid for defenses legal experts ( bullet forensic experts,This filing spells it out in detail for you:
Filed: 3/17/2024 12:46 PM
Carroll Circuit Court
Carroll County, Indiana
MOTION FOR PARITY IN RESOURCES, TO RECONSIDER THE DENIAL OF ANTICIPATED DEFENSE COSTS, OR TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE
Digital data experts and clinical psychologist )but defense is now requesting additional funds. This is outlined in section 14-16.
Looks like the confession expert and crime
Scene analyst was denied as unnecessary
as funding for hiring additional in-house assistants because they are “drowning” in work.
They have 7 working the case currently.
I don’t think their situation is as dire as they portray nor the denial of additional funding so outrageous. jMO
I wonder if they’ve met with the medical examiner yet.
Gardenista
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Jun 21, 2016
- Messages
- 19,034
- Reaction score
- 157,411
Defense asked for another delay and yesterday the judge said NOPE. Defense asked for a speedy trial and they are getting it.
Good and again shows you the game they are playing. Say one thing but then in the next breath go back on what they originally said.
SCOIN blew it.
AppleTreeGreen
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Jan 26, 2023
- Messages
- 147
- Reaction score
- 1,421
That is a good point and I mean if the defense tries to make that argument, I could see the prosecutor using a rebuttal similar to your comment, IMO
Oculus
The Owls are not what they seem
- Joined
- Sep 5, 2016
- Messages
- 55
- Reaction score
- 302
Let's see then...
Primaries:
Eyes... Nope.
Nose...Nope.
Mouth...Nope.
Secondaries:
Beard....yep.
Wearing a hat....yep.
RA may be the one who did this, but comparing the sketch to his image is not the way to go.
Sketches are sketchy. At best.
Last edited:
- Joined
- Feb 1, 2024
- Messages
- 1,055
- Reaction score
- 7,870
Saying RA does not resemble the sketch is wishful thinking. MOO.
Vaderman
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Jul 26, 2016
- Messages
- 347
- Reaction score
- 3,319
Yeah, seeing the two pictures side-by-side makes makes me think there's less of a resemblance than I initially thought.
FrostedGlass
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Feb 25, 2017
- Messages
- 5,690
- Reaction score
- 27,339
Hair is wrong, too.
His wife said he always kept his hair short since being in the National Guard.
- Status
DNASolves
Staff online
-
WS AdminAdministrator
Online statistics
- Members online
- 92
- Guests online
- 3,221
- Total visitors
- 3,313