and HOW DARE anyone question the great and powerful LWR....THE THIRD
Heeeeeyyyyy...hold up a second here..STOP...REWIND
Jennifer met him at the front door? Either she's psychic or she saw the car. Which would mean he was coming from the wrong direction, and that maybe she went to the front door to see if that WAS his car. And why would she go to the front if she saw him and not the back? What if he WAS coming from the wrong direction, she wasn't expecting him because she knew nothing about him being early that day (he didn't call either), so she went to the front thinking she was mistaken, and wanted a better look at the car to be sure?
So anyway, he says she met him at the FRONT door, he never SET FOOT in the store, but that it took 'tops five minutes' before she opened the back door. Then what was HE doing all that time if he didn't go in the store? Why didn't he go immediately back from where he'd come? Was he standing out in front of the store looking stupid for the time it took her to get to the back door? Maybe they were standing in front of the store discussing/arguing about the reason he was here and hour early and didn't call, let her know ahead of time, nothing.
Is that making any sense or am I reaching WAY too far?
I don't see it as reaching--you are thinking of all possibilities, and that's the kind of thinking that can solve crimes.