UK - 3 people found dead on the streets of Nottingham 13 June 2023 ‘Arrest’

What did the judge say during sentencing?

Mr Justice Turner started by telling Calocane he would be "detained in a high-security hospital probably for the rest of your life". He said Calocane's "sickening crimes" had shocked the nation and "wrecked the life" of the surviving victims and families.

He described Calocane’s deadly rampage, which ended when he was tasered by police, and then detailed the development of Calocane’s mental illness.

Calocane began to hear voices in his head in 2019, the judge said, becoming convinced he was being spied on by his housemates and MI5. He stopped taking medication because he believed he was not unwell, attacked a police officer trying to arrange a mental health assessment and later disengaged with mental health services.

Mr Justice Turner quoted several assessments of Calocane made by doctors following his arrest, one of whom said he would "never be cured and require long term very cautious management - almost certainly for the rest of his life".

The judge said there had been no evidence to suggest Calocane had been liable to be violent before the onset of his mental illness. And he noted that Calocane was still refusing to take medication prescribed to him.

"You still labour under the strong impression that the voices in your head are real and that you don’t suffer any mental illness whatsoever," he said.

Discussing the type of sentence Calocane should receive, the judge said: "Regardless of the level of personal responsibility, you were and remain dangerous."

He ordered Calocane to stand as sentence was passed, and ordered that he be detained in the high-security Ashworth Hospital under Section 37 of the Mental Health Act, with no timeframe for his release.

 
Footage shows timeline of Nottingham attacks and killer's arrest

Footage released by police has shown the movements of triple killer Valdo Calocane and his subsequent arrest following the Nottingham attacks.

The footage shows Barnaby Webber and Grace O'Malley-Kumar walking home from a night out before Calocane fatally attacked them on 13 June.

Calocane is then seen moving towards where he killed Ian Coates, before stealing his van and driving into three pedestrians in the city centre, all of whom survived but suffered serious injuries.

[Video at link.]

The video of Grace and Barnaby breaks my heart.

Two beautiful young people just enjoying life - both just chatting away on the walk home after partying all night.

Grace really was a hero that night trying to fight Calocane off - as Graces dad so beautifully put ‘she would have never abandoned her friend in danger - that’s just the sort of person she was’
 
Nottingham attacks: attorney general considering killer’s sentence for review
Victoria Prentis to decide whether judges should look at Valdo Calocane’s detention order after families say it is unduly lenient

[…]

A spokesperson for the attorney general, Victoria Prentis, confirmed her office had received a referral arguing the sentence been unduly lenient.

It gives the cabinet minister 28 days from sentencing to review the request and decide whether to refer the case to the court of appeal to decide whether the sentence was appropriate. Only one referral is required to trigger the process.

Webber’s mother, Emma Webber, was critical of the decision by the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) to downgrade the charge from murder.

However, the attorney general’s considerations are unlikely to look at whether the correct charge was pursued in Calocane’s case.

Any person or institution can ask for a sentence to be reviewed if they have reason to think it is unduly lenient.

[…]

 
I definitely think there is a big issue of whether the CPS should have gone for a murder charge rather than the lesser charge of manslaughter, but i don’t think the Attorney General can change that - only refer on for judges to review the sentence.

If the charge had been murder rather than manslaughter the outcome of indefinite detention in a secure hospital rather than prison would probably have been the same.
 


The killer had repeatedly come to the attention of the NHS, police and university officials, with at least eight missed opportunities to stop him.

It previously emerged he had attacked two colleagues at a warehouse in Leicestershire less than six weeks before his rampage.

Today, the BBC revealed the incident had been reported to police but he was never arrested.

Leicestershire Police did not explain why.
 


Attorney General has ordered an independent review into the CPS decision to accept Nottingham triple killer Valdo Calocane's guilty pleas to manslaughter.

The attacker killed nineteen-year-old university students Grace O'Malley Kumar and Barnaby Webber, as well as school caretaker Ian Coates in the early hours of June 13 last year.

The investigation will include examining the CPS decision to accept triple killer Valdo Calocane's guilty pleas to manslaughter on the basis of diminished responsibility, and whether the CPS met its duties to consult with families ahead of accepting pleas.

Attorney General Victoria Prentis said: 'The senseless deaths of Barnaby Webber, Grace O'Malley-Kumar and Ian Coates have horrified the country.

'While nothing will bring their loved ones back, the families understandably want to understand what happened in this
 
I can't believe this has happened again.
_____

Relatives of the victims of last June’s fatal Nottingham knife attacks have expressed their alarm after learning police officers shared graphic details of their loved ones’ injuries over WhatsApp.

A disciplinary hearing held in January was told the message was sent to a group of officers on the app, with one of its members then forwarding it on to his wife and a friend. That officer, PC Matthew Gell, was given a final written warning, while the officer who originally sent the message was reprimanded by management.

 

Mother of Nottingham stabbing victim criticises police officer’s comments​

Open letter says ‘callous and degrading’ police group WhatsApp message caused ‘more trauma than you can imagine’

The mother of one of the Nottingham attack victims has written an open letter to members of a police WhatsApp group in which a message was posted describing her son as being “properly butchered”.

[…]

Webber said she had the “utmost respect” for the emergency services, but added that anyone “who can witness the details of such a horror … and refer to lost children as butchered animals; should seriously consider their position.”

[…]

She said it was her understanding that the officer who wrote the message received a management warning. She said she did not know how many officers were in the group.

The Nottinghamshire police force is being investigated by the police watchdog, the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC), and the College of Policing over its handling of the case.

A force investigation found 11 members of staff viewed material about the case without any legitimate reason for doing so. Three faced disciplinary action but eight were instead handed “performance interventions”.

Speaking directly to the author of the message, Webber said in her letter: “My aim is not to cause undue shame, or to have anyone publicly vilified; there’s no need to add yet more pain; I just hope that by reaching out to educate and explain, my voice might make a difference.

“If you feel able and wish to make contact know that you can and it will be kept fully private. I have written this open letter only because of the actions of your chief constable and her senior leadership team.”

[…]

Webber has previously said she has “lost faith” in Nottinghamshire police’s leadership and called for the chief constable to step aside while allegations of failings are investigated.

She raised concerns after it emerged the son of the force’s boss, Kate Meynell, was among members of the police WhatsApp group in which graphic details were posted about the killings.

In February, Meynell said she had been “horrified” after an unidentified special constable viewed bodycam footage showing the aftermath of the attacks. The officer was sacked in December.

Meanwhile, PC Matthew Gell was given a final written warning after a misconduct hearing in January found he breached confidentiality standards after sharing information about the case in a text message.

Another staff member will also face misconduct proceedings.

[…]

“All hearings relating to police staff misconduct are held in private. It would be inappropriate to comment further due to the ongoing independent investigation by the IOPC and the review by the College of Policing.”

 

Mother of Nottingham stabbing victim criticises police officer’s comments​

Open letter says ‘callous and degrading’ police group WhatsApp message caused ‘more trauma than you can imagine’

The mother of one of the Nottingham attack victims has written an open letter to members of a police WhatsApp group in which a message was posted describing her son as being “properly butchered”.

[…]

Webber said she had the “utmost respect” for the emergency services, but added that anyone “who can witness the details of such a horror … and refer to lost children as butchered animals; should seriously consider their position.”

[…]

She said it was her understanding that the officer who wrote the message received a management warning. She said she did not know how many officers were in the group.

The Nottinghamshire police force is being investigated by the police watchdog, the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC), and the College of Policing over its handling of the case.

A force investigation found 11 members of staff viewed material about the case without any legitimate reason for doing so. Three faced disciplinary action but eight were instead handed “performance interventions”.

Speaking directly to the author of the message, Webber said in her letter: “My aim is not to cause undue shame, or to have anyone publicly vilified; there’s no need to add yet more pain; I just hope that by reaching out to educate and explain, my voice might make a difference.

“If you feel able and wish to make contact know that you can and it will be kept fully private. I have written this open letter only because of the actions of your chief constable and her senior leadership team.”

[…]

Webber has previously said she has “lost faith” in Nottinghamshire police’s leadership and called for the chief constable to step aside while allegations of failings are investigated.

She raised concerns after it emerged the son of the force’s boss, Kate Meynell, was among members of the police WhatsApp group in which graphic details were posted about the killings.

In February, Meynell said she had been “horrified” after an unidentified special constable viewed bodycam footage showing the aftermath of the attacks. The officer was sacked in December.

Meanwhile, PC Matthew Gell was given a final written warning after a misconduct hearing in January found he breached confidentiality standards after sharing information about the case in a text message.

Another staff member will also face misconduct proceedings.

[…]

“All hearings relating to police staff misconduct are held in private. It would be inappropriate to comment further due to the ongoing independent investigation by the IOPC and the review by the College of Policing.”

This makes me so angry, considering all the other cases where officers have been fired or charged for similar offences (not sure I'm allowed to reference those cases here). Well done Mrs Webber for speaking out.
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
183
Guests online
4,259
Total visitors
4,442

Forum statistics

Threads
593,163
Messages
17,981,916
Members
229,044
Latest member
Beckers861
Back
Top