VERDICT WATCH FL - Doug Benefield, 58, shot and killed by estranged wife, Manatee County, 27 Sept 2020

[Wishbone]

Thank you!
I'm curious if anything was ever said by Medics or the ER doctor had AB called 911 immediately after shooting DB and not left him lying there and ran to the neighbor who called 911 that his life may have been saved?

Ha ha, if there was information out there saying he could have been saved if she had called I'm sure it would be suppressed like most everything else. Can't make her look bad now can we? JMOO

 

[Wishbone]

Help!
I can't find this online.

I thought I had read that very soon after their first meeting DB took a business trip to Israel.
AB also took a cruise with her mother and girlfriend.
I would like to know if they did this at the same time?
Also I think his trip was within the 13 days between meeting her and marrying her?
tia

He took his trip to Israel a day or two after he met her and I think she went on her cruise after they married. I do remember that he paid for her friend's ticket since she had prepaid for her and her mother's earlier.

 

[Weki]

This is not that complicated imo. It’s a criminal trial. And self-defense is an affirmative defense so the defendant actually has to prove she acted in self-defense by a preponderance of the evidence. She has not done so. Not even close. She’s guilty. Whether she was subjected to manipulation, control etc is irrelevant, honestly. At the moment she shot him, by her own words, he was not threatening her life/great bodily injury. Not even close. She was lying and acting on the stand. Very obvious.

JMO

 

[Izzylizzy]

He took his trip to Israel a day or two after he met her and I think she went on her cruise after they married. I do remember that he paid for her friend's ticket since she had prepaid for her and her mother's earlier.

You never disappoint.
TY

 

[Izzylizzy]

This is not that complicated imo. It’s a criminal trial. And self-defense is an affirmative defense so the defendant actually has to prove she acted in self-defense by a preponderance of the evidence. She has not done so. Not even close. She’s guilty. Whether she was subjected to manipulation, control etc is irrelevant, honestly. At the moment she shot him, by her own words, he was not threatening her life/great bodily injury. Not even close. She was lying and acting on the stand. Very obvious.

JMO

BBM

Thank you!
The internet is filled with accusations of DV "victim shaming" when someone critiques and /or criticizes anything about AB.

 

[turaj]

Ready for trial today...going so fast. Question?? Does AB have any support from family or friends in gallery? I guess her mother is subject to recall but per a rule can be in courtroom and what about her father? I don't know how this will come out but that performance on the stand was something else. I know most consider it an act....but no matter what she is one disturbed woman. I don't think this was planned at all but the whole story makes no sense. DV but inviting him in and being alone?

 

[bobbymkii]

Ready for trial today...going so fast. Question?? Does AB have any support from family or friends in gallery? I guess her mother is subject to recall but per a rule can be in courtroom and what about her father? I don't know how this will come out but that performance on the stand was something else. I know most consider it an act....but no matter what she is one disturbed woman. I don't think this was planned at all but the whole story makes no sense. DV but inviting him in and being alone?

BBM. If I recall correctly her Dad passed away years ago.

 

[nodamselindistress]

Have only seen her mother in the courtroom when she testified. She does have custody of the child, so perhaps that is why? Lots of pictures of them standing on street corners with signs supporing Ashley and the child's sign is something along the lines of Keep my Mommy Free.

Father and mother are divorced. No idea how long. Nothing to indicate he is in the courtroom. My guess would be they are not close.

 

[nodamselindistress]

BBM. If I recall correctly her Dad passed away years ago.

Oh wow, I had not heard that!

 

[Linda7NJ]

Have only seen her mother in the courtroom when she testified. She does have custody of the child, so perhaps that is why? Lots of pictures of them standing on street corners with signs supporing Ashley and the child's sign is something along the lines of Keep my Mommy Free.

Father and mother are divorced. No idea how long. Nothing to indicate he is in the courtroom. My guess would be they are not close.

I think her mother knew. IMO

 

[Wishbone]

Have only seen her mother in the courtroom when she testified. She does have custody of the child, so perhaps that is why? Lots of pictures of them standing on street corners with signs supporing Ashley and the child's sign is something along the lines of Keep my Mommy Free.

Father and mother are divorced. No idea how long. Nothing to indicate he is in the courtroom. My guess would be they are not close.

Not sure, but think mother was subject to being recalled so she wouldn't be present in court. JMO

 

[nodamselindistress]

UGH Dr Ferris is up now. Let the droning on and on begin.

 

[Izzylizzy]

Did I miss the judge's ruling this morning that Ferris can testify and if so were there restrictions?

 

[Izzylizzy]

I read that DB wrote a letter to his friend Trip Cormenwho who was his pastor confessing to his violent acts.
If true was it entered at the trial and is it available to read?

 

[nodamselindistress]

I read that DB wrote a letter to his friend Trip Cormenwho who was his pastor confessing to his violent acts.
If true was it entered at the trial and is it available to read?

Not that I recall. All I know about Doug admitting to certain acts like the gun shot into the ceiling and knocking the dog out came from the custody case.

 

[Izzylizzy]

Not that I recall. All I know about Doug admitting to certain acts like the gun shot into the ceiling and knocking the dog out came from the custody case.

Thanks.
Looks like O'Connell is in for a tough time when she gets to Ferris.

 

[Izzylizzy]

I can't let this go. lol

Last night I listened again to prosecutor O'Donnell's opening statement.
She brought up the unfounded accusation made by AB that DB was poisoning her and her unborn child.
Why didn't she also tell the jury that AB's accusations against DB that he physically/sexually abused their daughter was also unfounded?
Those reprehensible false accusations should give more than pause to the jury when deciding whether to believe AB's claims that she was an abused wife who killed her husband in self-defense.
I don't recall hearing O'Connell bring up AB's false claims of this abuse to her daughter when she examined AB.

 

[Izzylizzy]

Is this the dark haired prosecutor crossing Ferris?
I can't see her.

edit,
Yep the dark haired prosecutor.
She needs to slow down her speech and speak clearly, it comes across as garbled.

 

[nodamselindistress]

Is this the dark haired prosecutor crossing Ferris?
I can't see her.

Yep, they just showed her

 

[Wishbone]

I can't let this go. lol

Last night I listened again to prosecutor O'Donnell's opening statement.
She brought up the unfounded accusation made by AB that DB was poisoning her and her unborn child.
Why didn't she also tell the jury that AB's accusations against DB that he physically/sexually abused their daughter was also unfounded?
Those reprehensible false accusations should give more than pause to the jury when deciding whether to believe AB's claims that she was an abused wife who killed her husband in self-defense.
I don't recall hearing O'Connell bring up AB's false claims of this abuse to her daughter when she examined AB.

All the various unfounded accusations AB made about DB and the fact that she actually left him seem to go against what ferris is saying about what victims of DV actually do unless I'm mistaken.