Search results

I am still here, I made a Facebook page at the 16th anniversary of her death, I will be posting police records, and any other files or information I have there. I would like this to be in the public eye. I apologize for falling off of the face of the Earth...

Please be advised, there may be individuals trying to dispute me on details, I need to keep my identity hidden. Hopefully I can get a hold of a mod to confirm my identity. Everything I have posted is objective and closest to the truth that I can gather, my identity is probably easy to guess...

Greetings, I apologize for the hiatus but I am still here, I have been busy with my personal and professional life, but I am still invested in this case. I recently found a website called "FamilyTreeNow.com", I did a search on "Holly Carruthers", and her address history showed up, all the...

Brian Shaffer's disappearance feels close to my heart, as Randy Shaffer offered a $8,000 dollar reward to any information leading to Holly Metzger-Carruthers location. It is a damn shame that Randy Shaffer passed away without getting answers to his son's mystery disappearance. Here are some...

Here is Holly's obituary, I want her remembered as a good person, I'm writing her story as I have time, time is scarce on my weekends due to work, but I have most of my information on the woman she was with compiled together. The next step is figuring out how to upload the interview. But as I...

There's so much more to this case, Holly was with a woman the night she went missing, which, once I get home, I am going to summarize my information on this individual, and post the audio recording of this woman being interviewed by law enforcement officials after Holly's death, also her...

I want to state briefly before I post this first part of my summary, that Holly had mental health issues and substance abuse issues she struggled with, her death was a result of drowning, but not officially declared accidental or purposely by homicide, the case remained open until 2014, until it...

There was also white residue determined to be sleeping medication in her vehicle, and a cane in her car. It was believed that she used the cane, but this is false, she did not need a cane nor was she injured or had the cane before she left her home that night.

I have the coroner's examination, I have the toxicology reports, Holly was under the influence of prescription medication like Seroquel, I need to double check but I believe it was Seroquel. I need to acquire the case files again, my copies were banged up pretty bad from how often I read them...

Hey there Armchair-Reader, I think we could could could collaborate together, as I do not have much experience in this, I am trying to figure out what happened to Holly Metzger-Carruthers as she has long been forgotten. It would be nice to be in communication with someone in the same state as me...

Thank you dotr, I am actively pursuing this, and have access to information not known to public, I am planning on sharing information with the Ws community, hopefully other input will help me bring justice to Holly.

That is a great idea, I was wondering if I should reach out, or if maybe next year on the ten year anniversary of her death reach out to news sources. I don't want her forgotten, there's so many loose ends in the investigation. I wish Ashland County Sheriff's Department or Holmes County...

Woah. I never really thought of it that way, this is very true. I just can't get over that if she WAS from Ohio, then why hasn't anyone come forward, it breaks my heart that she was forgotten.

A news article was posted with a new sketch of Jane Doe. http://www.newsnet5.com/news/state/new-sketch-released-of-unidentified-woman-shawn-grate-allegedly-confessed-to-killing-in-marion

It's sad to see that Holly is forgotten after nine years, to those who are still wondering the cause of death was confirmed as drowning but foul play was not ruled out, due to the circumstances of the case, there was never a TRUE suspect. I am asking on how to bring attention to Holly, I don't...

Hello all, I am here on Websleuths because of my interest in true crime, and Holly Metzger Carruthers, she went missing back in December 17, 2007, she was found deceased on March 19, 2008. After the funeral for Holly, the media attention on her case disappeared, everyone stopped asking...